I just don’t know about Begovic. I think some of the excitement I’ve seen is way overboard - are people just getting giddy because we haven’t had any signings in a couple of weeks?
Better than what we have in Isted & AMB probably. But doesn’t scream promotion goalkeeper at me. This feels more like a “NJ at Stoke” signing than it does “NJ at Luton” signing.
Hope I’m wrong if it does happen.
Begovic was long gone by the time Jones joined Stoke in 2019. He was with Chelsea in 2015.
Think Callum means he wasn't the type of signing he would make at Stoke, not that he did sign him for Stoke.
On a side note, really surprised it's been 9 years since he signed for Chelsea, I remember that and would have said it was more 2017/2018.
Yea this exactly.
One of Stoke fans’ big criticisms of Jones was that he overpaid for players who were on the decline. Very easy to make the argument that Begovic is in danger of falling into that category.
I'm less concerned about signing a 37 year old with a long career behind him to play in goal than any other position. Surely Begovic is an improvement in quality. Bring it on.
Can get three years out of him if he's kept himself in shape. A good goalkeeper can earn promotion as much as a goalscorer.
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
I wonder if a deal for Isted or AMB has fallen through as Davies looked set to sign when we had 3 keepers.
Davies was offered a new deal nothing to do with us
That's the point.
If we wont have 4 keepers on the books, but had a deal in place for Davies until he u-turned, then either Begovic takes us over our salary budget and Davies which makes signing a 4h keeper an issue, or deal for a keeper to leave fell through.
Begovic feels a bit like Ben Foster at Wrexham, might do for a season, but not sure he's at an age or skill level still to contend in the league above.
A 1 year deal, with a an option of another, may make sense from both a coaching of other keepers and to ensure he is still as good as we need him to be...
He was literally contending in the league above a few weeks ago.
In any case, if he gets us up and out of this miserable league in the coming season, then it won't matter.
Especially as while they didn't want him as their first choice next season, QPR still wanted him to stay. He's not someone being bombed out of QPR.
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
I still find it a bit surprising that so early on we brought in a new No 2 keeper, when we still had 2 keepers on our books. Yes players can get injured, but I don't think anyone would mind either AMB or Isted as the No 2, so long as the main keeper was a clear step up from them.
If they think Mannion has a greater ceiling than either of the other two, and we didn't secure an outright no.1 in the budget, then having Mannion in early to assess and develop makes sense.
Normally a club would have 3 keepers so if AMB and Isted aren't of the standard you always had to sign 2 and ship 1. If you don't land the no.1 for the budget you have available and the options out there are no better than Mannion pro rata'd to salary, then perhaps that's the hand you've been dealt and you have to get on with it.
Also having Mannion in the door means we can say to the potential keepers that we aren't desperate, but we would love them to join this promotion push. That might help bring expectations down re:salary and you can bill it as an opportunity to further develop as a coach.
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
That's what I hope my "after" pic will look like. He appears to be my goal weight.
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
I wonder if a deal for Isted or AMB has fallen through as Davies looked set to sign when we had 3 keepers.
Davies was offered a new deal nothing to do with us
Not quite…..Davies failed a medical with us, then re-signed with Sheff
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
I wonder if a deal for Isted or AMB has fallen through as Davies looked set to sign when we had 3 keepers.
Davies was offered a new deal nothing to do with us
Not quite…..Davies failed a medical with us, then re-signed with Sheff
I am assuming we have raised the bar on our medicals then, previously just being able to draw breath got you through ...
I just don’t know about Begovic. I think some of the excitement I’ve seen is way overboard - are people just getting giddy because we haven’t had any signings in a couple of weeks?
Better than what we have in Isted & AMB probably. But doesn’t scream promotion goalkeeper at me. This feels more like a “NJ at Stoke” signing than it does “NJ at Luton” signing.
Hope I’m wrong if it does happen.
Begovic was long gone by the time Jones joined Stoke in 2019. He was with Chelsea in 2015.
Think Callum means he wasn't the type of signing he would make at Stoke, not that he did sign him for Stoke.
On a side note, really surprised it's been 9 years since he signed for Chelsea, I remember that and would have said it was more 2017/2018.
Yea this exactly.
One of Stoke fans’ big criticisms of Jones was that he overpaid for players who were on the decline. Very easy to make the argument that Begovic is in danger of falling into that category.
I mean surely it's a fact that Begovic currently is on the decline. We're just hoping that for one more season he can still do a job in League One.
Obviously it's more difficult to say 'legs gone' with goalkeepers than outfield players. But it is a risk.
I wouldn't mind it, hopefully he takes a big pay cut to mitigate the risk a bit.
Keep up, I heard from a very close source but was a while ago, that he's not interested in playing full time anymore, age etc. He was looking for a number 2/3 keeper role...
By all accounts he wasn't going to be first choice at QPR anymore, so that doesn't hold up
Keep up, I heard from a very close source but was a while ago, that he's not interested in playing full time anymore, age etc. He was looking for a number 2/3 keeper role...
By all accounts he wasn't going to be first choice at QPR anymore, so that doesn't hold up
I bet 3rd choice in the prem would mean more money than 2nd choice at QPR. Could be what he is supposedly looking for
Keep up, I heard from a very close source but was a while ago, that he's not interested in playing full time anymore, age etc. He was looking for a number 2/3 keeper role...
By all accounts he wasn't going to be first choice at QPR anymore, so that doesn't hold up
I bet 3rd choice in the prem would mean more money than 2nd choice at QPR. Could be what he is supposedly looking for
IWas it confirmed that he counts as home grown based on how long he's been in the country? If not I can't imagine a PL team would bother.
Keep up, I heard from a very close source but was a while ago, that he's not interested in playing full time anymore, age etc. He was looking for a number 2/3 keeper role...
By all accounts he wasn't going to be first choice at QPR anymore, so that doesn't hold up
Sorry for passing on info, I will tell the member of his family they are wrong
Does anyone know or heard anything about this Begovic rumour?
Another day, same 'joke'.
Another day pages of repetitive posts, all repeating what others have already said, with almost next to no substance or foundation.
This is the rumours thread, not confirmed signing thread. Obviously it's going to be full of ongoing discussions about a goalkeeper as that is the position we need most.
Begovic is interest is correct, but not close from what I have been told. One of the keepers needs to go first, they don't want to be left with an inflated GK department. As I have been told, no offer has been made, but was given a tour.
Does anyone know or heard anything about this Begovic rumour?
Another day, same 'joke'.
Another day pages of repetitive posts, all repeating what others have already said, with almost next to no substance or foundation.
But they are at least discussing our transfers, rather than making inane childish comments, that add zero to the thread and seem simply designed to irritate. There's a joke thread if you want to try and be funny.
Comments
One of Stoke fans’ big criticisms of Jones was that he overpaid for players who were on the decline. Very easy to make the argument that Begovic is in danger of falling into that category.
Wide.
A good goalkeeper can earn promotion as much as a goalscorer.
Normally a club would have 3 keepers so if AMB and Isted aren't of the standard you always had to sign 2 and ship 1. If you don't land the no.1 for the budget you have available and the options out there are no better than Mannion pro rata'd to salary, then perhaps that's the hand you've been dealt and you have to get on with it.
Also having Mannion in the door means we can say to the potential keepers that we aren't desperate, but we would love them to join this promotion push. That might help bring expectations down re:salary and you can bill it as an opportunity to further develop as a coach.
No pun intended. Honestly.
Obviously it's more difficult to say 'legs gone' with goalkeepers than outfield players. But it is a risk.
I wouldn't mind it, hopefully he takes a big pay cut to mitigate the risk a bit.
Oh bugger.
There's a joke thread if you want to try and be funny.