I would guess it's more so with how Oxford are better than us than location surely.
Disappointing this, truth be told I am surprised we landed Conor Coventry. Expect we will have this same issue signing other players
Coventry we probably won out on because of location, West Ham player wouldn't have to relocate or anything to play for us. I'd rather we didn't have another Kirk situation where we sign a player for a substantial fee and they never settle.
Partly location I would imagine but also position in the League doesn't help. They are top 6 & we aren't far off the relegation places.
This is what happens when you dont plan properly in the summer & say "but we can always strengthen in January". I see those chickens coming home as it's getting close to roosting time.
My bet is a panic buy or another (dud) loanee.
Edit
And I see Godwin as a panic buy in this case. And to think people thought Stockon was a "one season wonder" last year.
Jones is struggling with being a regular CB at the moment.
He's been our only reliable CB most of the time this season tbf
I agree, but his current form is a bit worrying. Most of the time he looks ok, as he’s ’no nonsense’, but when mistakes creep in he looks very fallible. Over the last ten games Hector has been the better option, but he’s out now.
I'm hoping Gillesphey will help whoever plays alongside him to perform better. It’ll be Jones that gets the nod over Ness and Thomas in a back four I suspect, and Ness will probably get the nod over Thomas in a back three. Another injury or two and we’ll struggle. I doubt they’ll bring in another CB now, but I think they should. Zak and Deji aren’t ready imho, although if we get into a position where we’re safe they might consider playing one of them to gain some experience? Deji is back from his Bromley loan I think.
I think the mistakes he's made will be less when he plays with better defenders. Hector is too slow/casual IMHO
And yet he was in a back four that won the Championship title a couple of years back.
He made four appearances that season.
And what did they say about him at Fulham... "He's been one of the team's most error-prone defenders." Link.
Fair enough Chunsey, didn’t know that. I’m sure I read when we signed him that he was a regular.
Apologies.
He reminds me of Naby slightly. On his day, very good, but can make you nervous watching him.
Chunsey ?
Yeh come on Grumpy get with it, same as for Leuthy, Elfy and Jimmy (Seed) yours Chasey 😉
Jones is struggling with being a regular CB at the moment.
He's been our only reliable CB most of the time this season tbf
I agree, but his current form is a bit worrying. Most of the time he looks ok, as he’s ’no nonsense’, but when mistakes creep in he looks very fallible. Over the last ten games Hector has been the better option, but he’s out now.
I'm hoping Gillesphey will help whoever plays alongside him to perform better. It’ll be Jones that gets the nod over Ness and Thomas in a back four I suspect, and Ness will probably get the nod over Thomas in a back three. Another injury or two and we’ll struggle. I doubt they’ll bring in another CB now, but I think they should. Zak and Deji aren’t ready imho, although if we get into a position where we’re safe they might consider playing one of them to gain some experience? Deji is back from his Bromley loan I think.
I think the mistakes he's made will be less when he plays with better defenders. Hector is too slow/casual IMHO
And yet he was in a back four that won the Championship title a couple of years back.
He made four appearances that season.
And what did they say about him at Fulham... "He's been one of the team's most error-prone defenders." Link.
Fair enough Chunsey, didn’t know that. I’m sure I read when we signed him that he was a regular.
Apologies.
He reminds me of Naby slightly. On his day, very good, but can make you nervous watching him.
Chunsey ?
Yeh come on Grumpy get with it, same as for Leuthy, Elfy and Jimmy (Seed) yours Chasey 😉
I doubt you do much of that at your time of life
I bet I could still give you a run for your money 😉
Jones is struggling with being a regular CB at the moment.
He's been our only reliable CB most of the time this season tbf
I agree, but his current form is a bit worrying. Most of the time he looks ok, as he’s ’no nonsense’, but when mistakes creep in he looks very fallible. Over the last ten games Hector has been the better option, but he’s out now.
I'm hoping Gillesphey will help whoever plays alongside him to perform better. It’ll be Jones that gets the nod over Ness and Thomas in a back four I suspect, and Ness will probably get the nod over Thomas in a back three. Another injury or two and we’ll struggle. I doubt they’ll bring in another CB now, but I think they should. Zak and Deji aren’t ready imho, although if we get into a position where we’re safe they might consider playing one of them to gain some experience? Deji is back from his Bromley loan I think.
I think the mistakes he's made will be less when he plays with better defenders. Hector is too slow/casual IMHO
And yet he was in a back four that won the Championship title a couple of years back.
He made four appearances that season.
And what did they say about him at Fulham... "He's been one of the team's most error-prone defenders." Link.
Fair enough Chunsey, didn’t know that. I’m sure I read when we signed him that he was a regular.
Apologies.
He reminds me of Naby slightly. On his day, very good, but can make you nervous watching him.
Chunsey ?
Yeh come on Grumpy get with it, same as for Leuthy, Elfy and Jimmy (Seed) yours Chasey 😉
I doubt you do much of that at your time of life
I bet I could still give you a run for your money 😉
Not in this heat mate, we'd be flat out after we put our trainers on.
Been a slightly frustrating window but can't really blame the club this time. JCH playing silly buggers & Goodwin not wanting to move. Can't really do much more.
Either way, it's a target we have missed out on and we are going to start to look desperate if we approach another striker, don't want us signing players for the sake of it.
I got the impression Goodwin was only happening because of the result of JCH not going through.
Jones is struggling with being a regular CB at the moment.
He's been our only reliable CB most of the time this season tbf
I agree, but his current form is a bit worrying. Most of the time he looks ok, as he’s ’no nonsense’, but when mistakes creep in he looks very fallible. Over the last ten games Hector has been the better option, but he’s out now.
I'm hoping Gillesphey will help whoever plays alongside him to perform better. It’ll be Jones that gets the nod over Ness and Thomas in a back four I suspect, and Ness will probably get the nod over Thomas in a back three. Another injury or two and we’ll struggle. I doubt they’ll bring in another CB now, but I think they should. Zak and Deji aren’t ready imho, although if we get into a position where we’re safe they might consider playing one of them to gain some experience? Deji is back from his Bromley loan I think.
I think the mistakes he's made will be less when he plays with better defenders. Hector is too slow/casual IMHO
And yet he was in a back four that won the Championship title a couple of years back.
He made four appearances that season.
And what did they say about him at Fulham... "He's been one of the team's most error-prone defenders." Link.
Fair enough Chunsey, didn’t know that. I’m sure I read when we signed him that he was a regular.
Apologies.
He reminds me of Naby slightly. On his day, very good, but can make you nervous watching him.
400k is bonkers btw, he has 6 goals, I've watched them all and only one of them was good against Blackpool. I know there's probably more to his game but that's a crazy fee. On that basis Miles is worth at least 3-5 million surely?
As a punt a decent signing but 400k is a big wad on a player who I would see as a development player alongside Kanu
Either way, it's a target we have missed out on and we are going to start to look desperate if we approach another striker, don't want us signing players for the sake of it.
I got the impression Goodwin was only happening because of the result of JCH not going through.
Be interesting to see who we target next.
For this reason I wouldn't be mega disappointed with a loan. Then properly target a striker for the summer, get them in before preseason.
Can we stop using this thread to discuss whether or not Oxford is more appealing to live in than London please and get back on track to discussing George Dobson
Either way, it's a target we have missed out on and we are going to start to look desperate if we approach another striker, don't want us signing players for the sake of it.
I got the impression Goodwin was only happening because of the result of JCH not going through.
Be interesting to see who we target next.
For this reason I wouldn't be mega disappointed with a loan. Then properly target a striker for the summer, get them in before preseason.
I would be disappointed with a loan.
Some might call that unreasonable... But if anything has been unreasonable, it's this season.
400k is bonkers btw, he has 6 goals, I've watched them all and only one of them was good against Blackpool. I know there's probably more to his game but that's a crazy fee. On that basis Miles is worth at least 3-5 million surely?
As a punt a decent signing but 400k is a big wad on a player who I would see as a development player alongside Kanu
But this is why we need to stop judging forwards on goals scored. Look at their form this year with him and without him. He improves his side when he is playing.
We have May to get us 20 goals, we need another to get us 10/15 and get others involved and give them more goals and opportunities.
Good on Goodwin I suppose for not just going to the highest salary. See, not every player does that, despite what you read on here.
Now we're dropping down to who was 3rd on our list (or lower). Can't help but feel a bit glum about that.
I take your point regards salary, but if taking into account relocating costs and all that goes with it he could well be substantially better off on a lower salary.
Can we stop using this thread to discuss whether or not Oxford is more appealing to live in than London please and get back on track to discussing George Dobson
Can we stop using this thread to discuss whether or not Oxford is more appealing to live in than London please and get back on track to discussing George Dobson
Agree re Dobson...oh and would prefer to live in Oxford meself...🙄
Good on Goodwin I suppose for not just going to the highest salary. See, not every player does that, despite what you read on here.
Now we're dropping down to who was 3rd on our list (or lower). Can't help but feel a bit glum about that.
I take your point regards salary, but if taking into account relocating costs and all that goes with it he could well be substantially better off on a lower salary.
Could well be. But at 21 years old I doubt he's asked his accountant to crunch the numbers on that. Likely wants to stay near his family/mates.
Can we stop using this thread to discuss whether or not Oxford is more appealing to live in than London please and get back on track to discussing George Dobson
Agree re Dobson...oh and would prefer to live in Oxford meself...🙄
Comments
Coventry we probably won out on because of location, West Ham player wouldn't have to relocate or anything to play for us. I'd rather we didn't have another Kirk situation where we sign a player for a substantial fee and they never settle.
This is what happens when you dont plan properly in the summer & say "but we can always strengthen in January". I see those chickens coming home as it's getting close to roosting time.
My bet is a panic buy or another (dud) loanee.
Edit
And I see Godwin as a panic buy in this case. And to think people thought Stockon was a "one season wonder" last year.
I doubt you do much of that at your time of life
Oxford and the surrounding area is a lovely place to live.
That's that
Not in this heat mate, we'd be flat out after we put our trainers on.
Now we're dropping down to who was 3rd on our list (or lower). Can't help but feel a bit glum about that.
I got the impression Goodwin was only happening because of the result of JCH not going through.
Be interesting to see who we target next.
400k is bonkers btw, he has 6 goals, I've watched them all and only one of them was good against Blackpool. I know there's probably more to his game but that's a crazy fee. On that basis Miles is worth at least 3-5 million surely?
As a punt a decent signing but 400k is a big wad on a player who I would see as a development player alongside Kanu
Some might call that unreasonable... But if anything has been unreasonable, it's this season.
We have May to get us 20 goals, we need another to get us 10/15 and get others involved and give them more goals and opportunities.
I take your point regards salary, but if taking into account relocating costs and all that goes with it he could well be substantially better off on a lower salary.
He's accepted a transfer to Hungary.