From all the comments/moans about signing "youngsters" it's a good job we didn't sign Erling Haaland then as he's only 23...would have been a meltdown.
I mean if we can't get Ladapo, the next best thing is no-one getting him I suppose
Hold -on there's always the Free agent market.......and by waiting till after the deadline their negotiating position is even weaker ..so we can get them cheaper.
Agreed. Blindly accept whatever players are signed.
Said absolutely nobody ..... but anyway, the alternative is what? I mean, what do you do when you've already pissed your pants?
I’ve only seen people asking perfectly valid questions of the signings we’re making. If you’re happy with it then good for you, but ‘not those signings’ is really not an unreasonable thing to say if you think the quality of players isn’t good enough to get us promoted, is it?
I can't say I've seen any of them play much - a bit like everyone else on this thread. Apart from the Udinese lad. I've been following all of his games for a while now.
going against the grain of course but I actually think the window has been pretty good ( yes a lack of experience ) but I’d say the player level has been pretty good , once we get Fraser , Camara & Leaburn fit with these others players we’ll be sweet.
I think this window has actually been ok relative to previous. The problem is it’s been completely dwarfed by our expectations at the start. That’s partly a comms issue
From all the comments/moans about signing "youngsters" it's a good job we didn't sign Erling Haaland then as he's only 23...would have been a meltdown.
Yeah that's the one, Charlton life would of gone into meltdown if we signed Erling Haaland
There is no question that the club is now focusing on youth, even with incomings, loans or permanent. The phrase you win nothing with youth players, might well be true but it's worth looking at fees paid in the last few years and the wages that accompanies those signings. It's also worth looking at squads that achieved promotion in this modern era. I'm sure that someone on here has the stats for both Bowyer and Chris Powell's squad but I don't believe that either of those squads had the same age average age. There is one standout in both those squads though, they both goalscorers, Powell's squad had two, which is why, in my opinion they won the league, Bowyers team had one, which I believe is why they made the playoffs and not the top two. Whatever signings we bring in we must have a threat in the forward line and because of the injury to Leaburn and the slow reaction to not only replacing him, but bringing in an experienced striker, we have yet to start the season and the owners are now having to play catch up.
From all the comments/moans about signing "youngsters" it's a good job we didn't sign Erling Haaland then as he's only 23...would have been a meltdown.
There's a difference between a 23 year old that has probably played well over 100 top flight games by the age of 23 and someone who has played a handful of games in the lower leagues
all these double names in the squad, the Watsons, the Taylors & Campbells reminds me of the time we had two Kocs - one was that Turkish lad with the unfortunate first name & the other was Lyle Taylor
Would it not be best to actually see these new signings play for us before we make a decision on how good this window has been...no I do not know CM or any of the others 🥴
It blows my mind… why are we signing kids on loan, we when enough kids of our own already in the team!!!
Where are the tried and tested league one senior players who are able to help us push on..
Alfie May must be thinking what the help have I joined!!
But our kids aren't good enough. I have no doubt that Anderson, Asiimwe and Ness will get better, but are they top seven good enough?
Are our youngsters good enough to play in academies for Man City and the Italian top flight?
i haven't seen any of our new signings play (or remember them) but they are older than our youngsters that are currently playing and all come from top flight clubs.
Agreed. Blindly accept whatever players are signed.
Said absolutely nobody ..... but anyway, the alternative is what? I mean, what do you do when you've already pissed your pants?
I’ve only seen people asking perfectly valid questions of the signings we’re making. If you’re happy with it then good for you, but ‘not those signings’ is really not an unreasonable thing to say if you think the quality of players isn’t good enough to get us promoted, is it?
I can't say I've seen any of them play much - a bit like everyone else on this thread. Apart from the Udinese lad. I've been following all of his games for a while now.
Big fan of the Irish league?
Massive fan. My knowledge of Irish football is second only to my knowledge of Italian youth football.
From all the comments/moans about signing "youngsters" it's a good job we didn't sign Erling Haaland then as he's only 23...would have been a meltdown.
There's a difference between a 23 year old that has probably played well over 100 top flight games by the age of 23 and someone who has played a handful of games in the lower leagues
Yes that's true enough. Think I'm just getting worn down by all the negativity. We just need to see what happens on the pitch before passing judgement.
From all the comments/moans about signing "youngsters" it's a good job we didn't sign Erling Haaland then as he's only 23...would have been a meltdown.
He was so unproven before he went to City as well. A real gamble for City and complete comparable to us signing players on loan that have barely played a senior game.
As it stands we can play 2 full XI's without fielding an injured player, which is a step forwards at least.
Isted
Jones Hector Thomas
Asiimwe Dobson Anderson Edun
T. Campbell May Blackett-Taylor
Maynard-Brewer
Elerewe Abankwu Ness
T.Watson Taylor L.Watson Kirk C.Campbell Kanu Jaiyesimi
Yes, the second XI is even more shite than the already shite first XI, but at least we have the bodies, and that's without the new Striker, Camara, Fraser, Leaburn, McGrandles and Aneke (stop sniggering at the back) in it.
343 with wingers cutting in to shoot and wing backs overlapping is the way forwards!
Agreed. Blindly accept whatever players are signed.
Said absolutely nobody ..... but anyway, the alternative is what? I mean, what do you do when you've already pissed your pants?
I’ve only seen people asking perfectly valid questions of the signings we’re making. If you’re happy with it then good for you, but ‘not those signings’ is really not an unreasonable thing to say if you think the quality of players isn’t good enough to get us promoted, is it?
I can't say I've seen any of them play much - a bit like everyone else on this thread. Apart from the Udinese lad. I've been following all of his games for a while now.
Big fan of the Irish league?
Massive fan. My knowledge of Irish football is second only to my knowledge of Italian youth football.
As it stands we can play 2 full XI's without fielding an injured player, which is a step forwards at least.
Isted
Jones Hector Thomas
Asiimwe Dobson Anderson Edun
T. Campbell May Blackett-Taylor
Maynard-Brewer
Elerewe Abankwu Ness
T.Watson Taylor L.Watson Kirk C.Campbell Kanu Jaiyesimi
Yes, the second XI is even more shite than the already shite first XI, but at least we have the bodies, and that's without the new Striker, Camara, Fraser, Leaburn, McGrandles and Aneke (stop sniggering at the back) in it.
343 with wingers cutting in to shoot and wing backs overlapping is the way forwards!
Glad that was edited, just seeing two Kirks in a team made me shudder.
Comments
There's a difference between a 23 year old that has probably played well over 100 top flight games by the age of 23 and someone who has played a handful of games in the lower leagues
i haven't seen any of our new signings play (or remember them) but they are older than our youngsters that are currently playing and all come from top flight clubs.
Avanti!
‘Sign a striker’
*Club signs Bonne*
What’s the problem?
C.Campbell Kanu Jaiyesimi
343 with wingers cutting in to shoot and wing backs overlapping is the way forwards!
Hark at her!