Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

January Transfer Window - Jan 2023 (Deadline Day starts page 112)

1100101103105106173

Comments

  • Kirk and Stockley off the books will help a lot. Especially if we can get them done today and get in a replacement or two by tomorrow night
  • Would rather Kilkenny over Morgan every day of the week in midfield 
    Morgan's performance on Saturday was baffling. 50% brilliant. 50% terrible
    Change Saturday for his entire Charlton career and you have summed him up perfectly
  • Dazzler21 said:
    mendonca said:
    Payne, Morgan, Kilkenny, Henry....all quite similar in physical stature.
     Are they?

    Payne 5ft 5" - Short & Stocky
    Kilkenny 5ft 7" Short and Slim
    Henry 5ft 9" Average and Average
    Morgan 5ft 11" Average and Slim

    You've got half a foot's difference between the lot and when it comes to their footballing style they're all different too. 

    All very different players.
    (I can't speak for Kilkenny's play style yet).

    And height doesn't ALWAYS equate to physical style anyway - Dobson is tall but not particularly "big" (by football standards) and still mixes it up effectively. Andy Hughes was not a monster physically but loved a scrap.

    A lack of height could potentially be a hindrance at set pieces but that's where our own defence and forwards need to step up anyway.
  • sam3110 said:
    Kirk and Stockley off the books will help a lot. Especially if we can get them done today and get in a replacement or two by tomorrow night
    Only if they are permanent deals. Stockley has another 18 months left and Kirk 2 and half years to go.

    These long contracts given out are coming back to hit Sandgaard in the pocket 
  • edited January 2023
    Great Stockley to Fleetwood, now watch him score a hat trick on the 11th Feb!! 🤷‍♂️
  • shirty5 said:
    sam3110 said:
    Kirk and Stockley off the books will help a lot. Especially if we can get them done today and get in a replacement or two by tomorrow night
    Only if they are permanent deals. Stockley has another 18 months left and Kirk 2 and half years to go.

    These long contracts given out are coming back to hit Sandgaard in the pocket 
    And Kirk is a loan to Burton

    https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-winger-charlie-kirk-expected-to-make-loan-move-away-before-deadline/
  • Expect DJ to follow Kirk and Stockley out the door today as well then .... sounds like a good clear out by Holden and not carrying any passengers. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • Expect DJ to follow Kirk and Stockley out the door today as well then .... sounds like a good clear out by Holden and not carrying any passengers. 
    Great if they all went none good enough for what hopefully will be a better season and promotion push next year
    hopefully the loans with view to perms
  • Assuming that link on players salaries, shared the other day, was correct, off loading Kirk with save £5k a week, not sure where Stockley was on it, but woulda thought he'd be on around the same
  • Gribbo said:
    Assuming that link on players salaries, shared the other day, was correct, off loading Kirk with save £5k a week, not sure where Stockley was on it, but woulda thought he'd be on around the same
    It only saves 5k a week if Burton pay all of it...
  • Hopefully Kilkeeny can put his foot in unliked skippy Fraser and Morgan
  • Scoham said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    All well and good getting Kirk off the books but there has to be a replacement for him lined up otherwise we're very light wide for a side that wants to play 433. 
    Not convinced we’ll get a winger in, Campbell is Kirk’s replacement.

    That’s not a bad thing, he clearly has potential to do well at this level and looks a better fit for a Holden side. We need pace and energy on the wings, Kirk’s a low tempo player suited to a possession side.
    He's a 19 year old kid. I wouldn't want to play him every week if JRS or CBT got injured. We NEED more cover than that.
    I'd agree with you if we weren't a league one club losing £8 million per year.

    We're really not going to sign another winger in those circumstances, particularly when you see Campbell looks promising. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • Bit alarming with our injury record
  • With a name like his and an injury record like ours you just know how this is going to play out.


  • If Stockley goes, on loan or permanent, we will need another striker, we only have two plus Aneke. I am not counting Kanu, as I do not think he is ready. If Kirk and/or DJ goes, we should be OK with Campbell. Payne could always play wide if need be or Clare

  • Chunes said:
    It's mad that we've got so many players in some positions that we're having to trim the squad and yet we only had one senior left-back at the start of the season. 
    It's a madness that if, all rumours are true, we are having a complete overall in the January window, Chunes. Look at our wide players, apart from Campbell, losing anyone of them is a bonus, Blackett Taylor, DJ and Kirk would not get in a top six side. 
  • Just seen an Inside Football article saying that there is interest in Lyle Taylor from un- named clubs. His contract is up in June. Looks like a bit of a desperation in the piece- either the Nott. F. placed it to create interest because they want to move him on(which there was a piece in Dec that suggested that), or his agent because he wants to go and nobody is enquiring.
  • Dazzler21 said:
    mendonca said:
    Payne, Morgan, Kilkenny, Henry....all quite similar in physical stature.
     Are they?

    Payne 5ft 5" - Short & Stocky
    Kilkenny 5ft 7" Short and Slim
    Henry 5ft 9" Average and Average
    Morgan 5ft 11" Average and Slim

    You've got half a foot's difference between the lot and when it comes to their footballing style they're all different too. 

    All very different players.
    (I can't speak for Kilkenny's play style yet).

    Crikes you must be bored searching each player's height :)My point was indeed related to how they each lack a physical presence in midfield. 
  • Scoham said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    All well and good getting Kirk off the books but there has to be a replacement for him lined up otherwise we're very light wide for a side that wants to play 433. 
    Not convinced we’ll get a winger in, Campbell is Kirk’s replacement.

    That’s not a bad thing, he clearly has potential to do well at this level and looks a better fit for a Holden side. We need pace and energy on the wings, Kirk’s a low tempo player suited to a possession side.
    He's a 19 year old kid. I wouldn't want to play him every week if JRS or CBT got injured. We NEED more cover than that.
    Captain Clayden is still here.. 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!