In terms of taking the knee it’s very simple for me - we have a team of many backgrounds, colours, cultures and races. They all want to take the knee and if that’s what the squad want to do to support their own players then that should be good enough for the fans.
By booing them you are basically saying you are turning your backs on a squad decision that they have all made together.
This isn’t dirty scummy Millwall. This is Charlton and if someone wants to boo the knee and show themselves to be a dirty stinking racist - then I won’t be comfortable taking my mixed raced family to the game.
Not a classic to watch, but a solid start to the season - pretty clear that the defence is as strong as last year, if not stronger, and the midfield looked so much more full of energy, really looking forward to seeing how that develops. With those two bits in place it looks like we will be better able to impose ourselves on teams this year. We do rely on the three up front to do it on their own more than I would like, they did show glimpses but clearly we need another winger, which will add creativity and allow Washington and Stockley to rotate up front. We are close and seem to be heading in very much the right direction, so I am pleased to get out of a game against a Wednesday team which will be strong this year with a point
Just watching the highlights demonstrates that we certainly created decent chances. Albie Morgan's first "miss" is forgivable. The ball came across at quite a pace and some way in front of him, so he was always stretching for it. The second miss, where he blazed it high and wide was dreadful. His shooting technique looks poor and he must have had plenty of practice/coaching so I suspect its a temperament thing; he lacks composure.
The Morgan miss was a lot like the Stephens miss against Wednesday in 2011.
I thought from watching on Sky, that we were good, Clare and Dobson add something we’ve missed for a while; having a mobile midfield will make the team better. Is Albie ready for prime time? Not sure, think Kirk if he joins will help him as it won’t all be on him to pick a pass.
as for booing the knee, I understand British history and heritage, and still find it unacceptable to boo.
Not much to say other than Sheffield Wednesday’s free kick right at the very end where they rolled it across the half way line before the whistle blew for full time was so beautifully Charlton.
Absolutely. Brainless decision.
At that point, with time already run out, the only thing any team should do is pump it straight in the box and see if you can get a miracle before the whistle goes. When he passed it square I thought “what a dunce - that’s the sort of thing we’d do”
In terms of taking the knee it’s very simple for me - we have a team of many backgrounds, colours, cultures and races. They all want to take the knee and if that’s what the squad want to do to support their own players then that should be good enough for the fans.
By booing them you are basically saying you are turning your backs on a squad decision that they have all made together.
This isn’t dirty scummy Millwall. This is Charlton and if someone wants to boo the knee and show themselves to be a dirty stinking racist - then I won’t be comfortable taking my mixed raced family to the game.
TTK will be going on forever.
And therein lies the rub.
When does it stop ? 6 months time ? 6 years time ? Or will kids be asking their parents in 2121 why do players kneel down before the start of a match.
That is my problem with it. I dont boo when it is done but I do ask when does a gesture become obsolete or "of its time". You may say never.....or when people understand that racism is wrong, but that is never going to happen as in society you will always have racists, bigots, extremists etc.
Just watching the highlights demonstrates that we certainly created decent chances. Albie Morgan's first "miss" is forgivable. The ball came across at quite a pace and some way in front of him, so he was always stretching for it. The second miss, where he blazed it high and wide was dreadful. His shooting technique looks poor and he must have had plenty of practice/coaching so I suspect its a temperament thing; he lacks composure.
I think Albie looked a step up from last season (has done all pre season). I believe if he keeps getting himself in those positions it will come. I think he is a little over emotional in shooting positions as he was properly beating himself up when he missed. I think once he gets one or two he will calm down. Was such an interesting battle between him and Bannan.
He can pass a ball with such composure, he just needs to calm himself and have that same composure in-front of goal. It will come.
Apart from the game. I'm glad to be back at The Valley. Glad the fans are back. Glad that I've got a club to come back to. Apart from booing the knee and the Addams Family song - the atmosphere was great! Overall, a good day. Sounds like I was a bit 'glad all over' . . . (oh dear me).
even game but what is it with managers putting players on for 2 minutes? ok, so clayden has his debut but we needed him on with 15 to go - it was important not to lose but it seemed such an obvious sub
Was there a stand up for Seb Lewis chant around the 18th minute , that’s what I think I heard and stood up for, don’t think there was anything on the big screen .
In terms of taking the knee it’s very simple for me - we have a team of many backgrounds, colours, cultures and races. They all want to take the knee and if that’s what the squad want to do to support their own players then that should be good enough for the fans.
By booing them you are basically saying you are turning your backs on a squad decision that they have all made together.
This isn’t dirty scummy Millwall. This is Charlton and if someone wants to boo the knee and show themselves to be a dirty stinking racist - then I won’t be comfortable taking my mixed raced family to the game.
TTK will be going on forever.
And therein lies the rub.
When does it stop ? 6 months time ? 6 years time ? Or will kids be asking their parents in 2121 why do players kneel down before the start of a match.
That is my problem with it. I dont boo when it is done but I do ask when does a gesture become obsolete or "of its time". You may say never.....or when people understand that racism is wrong, but that is never going to happen as in society you will always have racists, bigots, extremists etc.
Players shake hands before a game. I believe this is a gesture with the "sword" hand to highlight the lack of weapons and therefore confirm trust / friendship. (The sword bit may be urban myth!).
But I have no problem with this "of its time" gesture and wouldn't boo a player for shaking hands. In fact the opposite - or is it compulsory?.
Taking the knee might eventually become a symbolic ritual before a game to indicate "We're all in this together. Class, race, income etc shouldn't count". Is there anything wrong with that?
It wouldn't be such a bad idea if kids were obliged to drop to one knee for a few seconds before a game even if they didn't really understand it.
Now that’s all out the way, I’ll talk about the game. I will not be replying to anyone regarding these sections above.
—
In terms of the team, I thought we looked solid and
Great post. There are the usual divisions on this site with familiar names seemingly looking for a scrap unfortunately, so it’s good to hear a voice of reason. Not replying to provocation is the best policy.
I think we need to be playing 4-4-2 but we need at least one more capable striker if we are to compete for promotion. Washington can't play the left winger in a 4-3-3 either, so we need someone else. In the meantime I would play Clayden in a 4-4-2 with Conor alongside Jayden. That might have been enough yesterday.
Will be interesting to see what the formation and tactics are if Stocklely comes off/ is unavailable for selection. Probably will revert to 4-4-2 with Washington and another striker up front.
Was there a stand up for Seb Lewis chant around the 18th minute , that’s what I think I heard and stood up for, don’t think there was anything on the big screen .
It was great: To be back. To see fellow Charlton fans. To see the glory of the Beautiful Valley. To keep a clean sheet. To not lose. To get off the mark points wise.
It wasn’t great: To have no Red Red Robin. To see a poor game. To be two points behind target.
It was a good decision by Mr Adkins to make Stockley captain.
Morgan was poor imo and he should have 100% hit the target especially the second one. He needs to do so much better. Personally would have taken him off for Davison and let him chase flick on/Harry the defence etc. As they looked tired.
End of the day its a point against a recently relegated team and certainly a foundation to build on.
Comments
We do rely on the three up front to do it on their own more than I would like, they did show glimpses but clearly we need another winger, which will add creativity and allow Washington and Stockley to rotate up front.
We are close and seem to be heading in very much the right direction, so I am pleased to get out of a game against a Wednesday team which will be strong this year with a point
as for booing the knee, I understand British history and heritage, and still find it unacceptable to boo.
When he passed it square I thought “what a dunce - that’s the sort of thing we’d do”
When does it stop ? 6 months time ? 6 years time ? Or will kids be asking their parents in 2121 why do players kneel down before the start of a match.
That is my problem with it. I dont boo when it is done but I do ask when does a gesture become obsolete or "of its time". You may say never.....or when people understand that racism is wrong, but that is never going to happen as in society you will always have racists, bigots, extremists etc.
He can pass a ball with such composure, he just needs to calm himself and have that same composure in-front of goal. It will come.
Yeah, probably.
But I have no problem with this "of its time" gesture and wouldn't boo a player for shaking hands. In fact the opposite - or is it compulsory?.
Taking the knee might eventually become a symbolic ritual before a game to indicate "We're all in this together. Class, race, income etc shouldn't count". Is there anything wrong with that?
It wouldn't be such a bad idea if kids were obliged to drop to one knee for a few seconds before a game even if they didn't really understand it.
Will be interesting to see what the formation and tactics are if Stocklely comes off/ is unavailable for selection. Probably will revert to 4-4-2 with Washington and another striker up front.
We go again
To be back.
To see fellow Charlton fans.
To see the glory of the Beautiful Valley.
To keep a clean sheet.
To not lose.
To get off the mark points wise.
It wasn’t great:
To have no Red Red Robin.
To see a poor game.
To be two points behind target.
It was a good decision by Mr Adkins to make Stockley captain.
End of the day its a point against a recently relegated team and certainly a foundation to build on.
Onwards and upwards.