I know we’ve made more than one offer for Josh Sims and he’s rejected them as we low-balled him.
I’m sure if the offers were good enough he’d already be with us.
Make what you want of that and TS transfer strategy…
Do you know this for certain ? And how do you know what him and his agent are asking for isnt excessive ?!
it came straight from the horses mouth (SMT) via another fan. Probably about a month ago and I don’t know how much he asked for or what we offered, but he said it was multiple offers made.
I did lot say before as was told in confidence but since he’s now referred to it elsewhere I might as well share.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I know we’ve made more than one offer for Josh Sims and he’s rejected them as we low-balled him.
I’m sure if the offers were good enough he’d already be with us.
Make what you want of that and TS transfer strategy…
Do you know this for certain ? And how do you know what him and his agent are asking for isnt excessive ?!
it came straight from the horses mouth (SMT) via another fan. Probably about a month ago and I don’t know how much he asked for or what we offered, but he said it was multiple offers made.
I did lot say before as was told in confidence but since he’s now referred to it elsewhere I might as well share.
Fair enough mate thanks for sharing wonder if we moved on completely now with CBT signing or if we hope to get him close to the end of the window still
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
Last season we were paying the "left over dregs", Watson, Gunter, Bogle and Maddison about 5kish a week!! Dobson was rumoured to be on over 5 at Sunderland, I can't imagine he took a massive pay cut?
I don't believe we are offering 3k a week to first team players. I would imagine Stockley, Kirk and MacGillivray are all on "decent" money?
I know we’ve made more than one offer for Josh Sims and he’s rejected them as we low-balled him.
I’m sure if the offers were good enough he’d already be with us.
Make what you want of that and TS transfer strategy…
Do you know this for certain ? And how do you know what him and his agent are asking for isnt excessive ?!
it came straight from the horses mouth (SMT) via another fan. Probably about a month ago and I don’t know how much he asked for or what we offered, but he said it was multiple offers made.
I did lot say before as was told in confidence but since he’s now referred to it elsewhere I might as well share.
It would make sense but I have to question if Sims is asking for more money than anyone is willing to pay and that’s why he doesn’t yet have a club.
He/his agent have probably seen or heard the supposed figures flying around at Ipswich etc and want a slice of it. I doubt he’s impressed by the prospect of dropping down from the 10-15k p/w he was probably on at Southampton.
He’s going to have to lower his demands to get a deal. Whether that’s here or elsewhere.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
I know we’ve made more than one offer for Josh Sims and he’s rejected them as we low-balled him.
I’m sure if the offers were good enough he’d already be with us.
Make what you want of that and TS transfer strategy…
Says everything we need to know about this disaster of a window.
Depends how much Sims and his agent want. He’s been with Southampton for a while, so presume he was on a decent wage. Maybe one higher than a League 1 side are prepared to pay. I doubt Doncaster were paying his full wage last season.
He’s been a free agent for a month and no one else has signed him up either, so not unlikely that his demands are too high for several clubs, not just us.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
Why do you think we are signing the likes of Dobson, Clare and Taylor. None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap. Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I’m not 100% as who knows which websites are true or not these days, but I’ve seen a few say Bannan is on £27k at Wednesday. I know that’s a follow on from a Championship contract, but it’s obscene, and ridiculous they didn’t have a relegation clause to decrease that wage.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I’m not 100% as who knows which websites are true or not these days, but I’ve seen a few say Bannan is on £27k at Wednesday. I know that’s a follow on from a Championship contract, but it’s obscene, and ridiculous they didn’t have a relegation clause to decrease that wage.
Even stranger he only signed a new contract in February when they were headed for the drop
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
Why do you think we are signing the likes of Dobson, Clare and Taylor. None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap. Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
Yeah, and I'm sure Kirk, Stockley and McGillivray (and Famewo) are on peanuts...
I think we're offering higher wages to players that the club think are worth it. But I do think that it's very possible that the powers that be have a definition of "worth it" that is more restrictive than it needs to be.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
Why do you think we are signing the likes of Dobson, Clare and Taylor. None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap. Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
Yeah, and I'm sure Kirk, Stockley and McGillivray (and Famewo) are on peanuts...
I think we're offering higher wages to players that the club think are worth it. But I do think that it's very possible that the powers that be have a definition of "worth it" that is more restrictive than it needs to be.
The transfer window closes soon. We shall then find out if we are offering decent wages or not. Be prepared to be disappointed and spend another year in league one.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I’m not 100% as who knows which websites are true or not these days, but I’ve seen a few say Bannan is on £27k at Wednesday. I know that’s a follow on from a Championship contract, but it’s obscene, and ridiculous they didn’t have a relegation clause to decrease that wage.
If Charlton had a player on £27k when we were relegated, he'd have been pushed out in the summer, no doubting. That sounds like our first 11 budget! On the point, how come Wendies are able to come out of a transfer embargo and be throwing contracts left right and centre. We on the other hand are stable Stanley's and are missing out on pretty much everyone. I can't believe we haven't wanted any of the players that, Ipswich, Wigan, Wednesday etc have been signing, so the only reason for signing has to be the wages AND confidence in their prospects.
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I’m not 100% as who knows which websites are true or not these days, but I’ve seen a few say Bannan is on £27k at Wednesday. I know that’s a follow on from a Championship contract, but it’s obscene, and ridiculous they didn’t have a relegation clause to decrease that wage.
Even stranger he only signed a new contract in February when they were headed for the drop
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
Why do you think we are signing the likes of Dobson, Clare and Taylor. None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap. Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
Yeah, and I'm sure Kirk, Stockley and McGillivray (and Famewo) are on peanuts...
I think we're offering higher wages to players that the club think are worth it. But I do think that it's very possible that the powers that be have a definition of "worth it" that is more restrictive than it needs to be.
The transfer window closes soon. We shall then find out if we are offering decent wages or not. Be prepared to be disappointed and spend another year in league one.
As things stand I'll bite your hand off to spend another year in League 1 !!!
"Tonight's main story. Charlton Athletic have once again signed nobody. We'll have all the latest from our special correspondent Louis Mendez. Later, in other news, today in Afghanistan..."
When you hear of players earning 15k per week in league one that is ridiculous. 10k per week is still way too much. But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion. That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets. If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
True, but we don't know what the offer is or what was being asked. For all we know we ARE offering (for example) Sims 5-6k (which I seem to think is around what Stockley is on) but he's holding out for 10+.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
Why do you think we are signing the likes of Dobson, Clare and Taylor. None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap. Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
Yeah, and I'm sure Kirk, Stockley and McGillivray (and Famewo) are on peanuts...
I think we're offering higher wages to players that the club think are worth it. But I do think that it's very possible that the powers that be have a definition of "worth it" that is more restrictive than it needs to be.
The transfer window closes soon. We shall then find out if we are offering decent wages or not. Be prepared to be disappointed and spend another year in league one.
I take the fact that you think we will be in L1 next season as positive!
Comments
I did lot say before as was told in confidence but since he’s now referred to it elsewhere I might as well share.
10k per week is still way too much.
But if you are serious about getting promotion then I believe 5k should be offered to the players you think are good enough to get you promotion.
That's easy for me to say as it's not my money but if your top offer is 3k as I've been told it is then you are going to miss out on your top targets.
If that means we miss out on promotion then it's a false economy in the long-term.
I don't believe we are offering 3k a week to first team players. I would imagine Stockley, Kirk and MacGillivray are all on "decent" money?
He/his agent have probably seen or heard the supposed figures flying around at Ipswich etc and want a slice of it. I doubt he’s impressed by the prospect of dropping down from the 10-15k p/w he was probably on at Southampton.
He’s going to have to lower his demands to get a deal. Whether that’s here or elsewhere.
3k sounds very very low and I genuinely can't see people like Gallen or Adkins going along with that knowing they're wasting their time.
I'm also far from convinced that Kirk would move all the way down at a time of personal loss for the sake of 3k.
None of these will get us promotion but they come cheap.
Adkins keeps refering to sticking to a budget and what with we are signing I believe it's too low
I think we're offering higher wages to players that the club think are worth it. But I do think that it's very possible that the powers that be have a definition of "worth it" that is more restrictive than it needs to be.
We shall then find out if we are offering decent wages or not.
Be prepared to be disappointed and spend another year in league one.
"Tonight's main story. Charlton Athletic have once again signed nobody. We'll have all the latest from our special correspondent Louis Mendez. Later, in other news, today in Afghanistan..."