I would be a lot happier if NA acknowledged that Davison was not good enough in his loans last season, but has somehow kicked on since then. Otherwise it looks like desperation brought on by lack of success in recruiting a new striker.
You honestly think they'd give up three weeks before the window closes and just throw the towel in? Not to mention the free market after that if he was so desperate
No I don't. But there may be a loss of confidence that a successful outcome can be achieved, given the limits of the club's current circumstances.
Is that not basically the same thing? If anything it's media manipulation to tell other clubs we don't need a striker but may still sign one if they're going to be fair on price.
I would be a lot happier if NA acknowledged that Davison was not good enough in his loans last season, but has somehow kicked on since then. Otherwise it looks like desperation brought on by lack of success in recruiting a new striker.
You honestly think they'd give up three weeks before the window closes and just throw the towel in? Not to mention the free market after that if he was so desperate
No I don't. But there may be a loss of confidence that a successful outcome can be achieved, given the limits of the club's current circumstances.
Is that not basically the same thing? If anything it's media manipulation to tell other clubs we don't need a striker but may still sign one if they're going to be fair on price.
Two different possibilities: 1. We give up. Davison is our man. 2. We're gonna keep trying, but frankly it doesn't look hopeful as things stand, so we may have to make do with Davison.
I'm suggesting that no.2 MIGHT be the case.
Haha, those days are gone, maybe last season...If he plays it will be purely on merit
Mullin League 2 top scorer - 4th choice - oNe SeaSoN WoNdER, LeAgUe 2 StAnDaRd, nOt PrOvEn tHoUgH.
Davison League 2 3 goal scorer - 4th choice - Fair enough give the lad a chance, clearly seen something.
* I have no problem with Davison being used by the way, and no way is he the Aneke replacement, Stockley back up. Fully expect a prem loanee fwd to come in, but, context.
I would be a lot happier if NA acknowledged that Davison was not good enough in his loans last season, but has somehow kicked on since then. Otherwise it looks like desperation brought on by lack of success in recruiting a new striker.
You honestly think they'd give up three weeks before the window closes and just throw the towel in? Not to mention the free market after that if he was so desperate
No I don't. But there may be a loss of confidence that a successful outcome can be achieved, given the limits of the club's current circumstances.
Is that not basically the same thing? If anything it's media manipulation to tell other clubs we don't need a striker but may still sign one if they're going to be fair on price.
Two different possibilities: 1. We give up. Davison is our man. 2. We're gonna keep trying, but frankly it doesn't look hopeful as things stand, so we may have to make do with Davison.
I would be a lot happier if NA acknowledged that Davison was not good enough in his loans last season, but has somehow kicked on since then. Otherwise it looks like desperation brought on by lack of success in recruiting a new striker.
You honestly think they'd give up three weeks before the window closes and just throw the towel in? Not to mention the free market after that if he was so desperate
No I don't. But there may be a loss of confidence that a successful outcome can be achieved, given the limits of the club's current circumstances.
Is that not basically the same thing? If anything it's media manipulation to tell other clubs we don't need a striker but may still sign one if they're going to be fair on price.
Two different possibilities: 1. We give up. Davison is our man. 2. We're gonna keep trying, but frankly it doesn't look hopeful as things stand, so we may have to make do with Davison.
I'm suggesting that no.2 MIGHT be the case.
Haha, those days are gone, maybe last season...If he plays it will be purely on merit
I really dont understand how Paul Mullin hasnt signed for someone yet
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
Davison had a couple of decent games in the championship for us. He's fast and strong with a good finish, don't see any issue with him being one of our options this season
Thought Adkins explanation of the transfer situation was very good. We're going to give it go this season, but not jeopardise the stability that we've got now.
I really dont understand how Paul Mullin hasnt signed for someone yet
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
I'd guess there's been Champ interest and a handful of L2 players have jumped straight up already so probably a case of waiting on them, championship clubs XYZ don't get their fancy backup striker signing, then it's "hi Paul!"
And I guess from his point of view... Be Charlton's backup striker on 3k a week for 2 years or be QPR's for 7k a week.
Just seen a video from a pre season match between Portsmouth and Bristol city where Portsmouth had to borrow a City player, who then scored, as they were short for players. This was only 2 days ago. Think we're in a much better situation than many.
I really dont understand how Paul Mullin hasnt signed for someone yet
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
I’m guessing it’s because he has a few options and is biding his time for the best deal.
Davison had a couple of decent games in the championship for us. He's fast and strong with a good finish, don't see any issue with him being one of our options this season
I really dont understand how Paul Mullin hasnt signed for someone yet
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
For that matter where is Mullin training at the moment? At least Tucker is still a Gillingham player so can do a normal pre season with them
Davison had a couple of decent games in the championship for us. He's fast and strong with a good finish, don't see any issue with him being one of our options this season
He has 1 goal for us on what basis is that a decent finish?
Just seen a video from a pre season match between Portsmouth and Bristol city where Portsmouth had to borrow a City player, who then scored, as they were short for players. This was only 2 days ago. Think we're in a much better situation than many.
They had about 7 trialists as well. They are well behind us but there is still a lot of waiting going on.
Just seen a video from a pre season match between Portsmouth and Bristol city where Portsmouth had to borrow a City player, who then scored, as they were short for players. This was only 2 days ago. Think we're in a much better situation than many.
That’s unbelievable really. How embarrassing for Pompey. Surely taking along a few of their kids and putting them in would have been preferable. Unless Cowley was trying to make a point to the owner.
Davison had a couple of decent games in the championship for us. He's fast and strong with a good finish, don't see any issue with him being one of our options this season
He has 1 goal for us on what basis is that a decent finish?
I meant in general, not in the handful of appearances he's had for us
I really dont understand how Paul Mullin hasnt signed for someone yet
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
For that matter where is Mullin training at the moment? At least Tucker is still a Gillingham player so can do a normal pre season with them
That's the issue isn't it, last season we had a number of players that didn't do preseason anywhere. I think Gunter did with Reading but a lot of the others didn't. Yet only Ronnie gets a pass.
This season even if 1 or 2 are 2 or 3 weeks behind hopefully we won't have to throw them straight in and they can catch up quite quickly.
Bowyer threw young players under the bus = Charlton life melt down
adkins praises young striker in public = Charlton life meltdown
Davison was used by bowyer two years ago when he wasn’t ready and he didn’t let himself down. He didn’t cover himself in glory on loan but the loan may have turned a boy into a man. I would be happy to have him in the squad and playing in cup games over a premiership loan or a one season wonder like mullin.
A few overreactions here re Davison. I'd love him to do really well this season.
Stockley is our main man so I'd be happy enough with Davison getting some minutes here and there and maybe a PL loan as another option up top. I don't think it's a priority area anyway, we desperately do need these wingers that everyone keeps talking about though.
Rather see players come through the academy, the fans will give them both more time and encouragement rather than buying a player in the hope he settles, fits into the style of play hits the ground running all the old b******s that normally comes out.
Cannot get my head round the idea that 'We haven't signed anyone for a few days. We are never going to sign anyone ever again and are therefore doomed.'
A few overreactions here re Davison. I'd love him to do really well this season.
Stockley is our main man so I'd be happy enough with Davison getting some minutes here and there and maybe a PL loan as another option up top. I don't think it's a priority area anyway, we desperately do need these wingers that everyone keeps talking about though.
everybody wants him to do well but you can have reservations about if he is good enough. I hope he proves me wrong and is in double figures by Christmas
Comments
Davison League 2 3 goal scorer - 4th choice - Fair enough give the lad a chance, clearly seen something.
* I have no problem with Davison being used by the way, and no way is he the Aneke replacement, Stockley back up. Fully expect a prem loanee fwd to come in, but, context.
😬😬😬
The bloke has had one decent season in LEAGUE TWO - He surely shouldn't have this much weight over League One teams, especially if there are some bigger teams after him
https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-chief-nigel-adkins-gives-his-reaction-to-rotherham-managers-transfer-window-claim/
Also believe he will use the young players well and not before they are ready.
He knows exactly what he is saying and to whom he is saying it.
I'd guess there's been Champ interest and a handful of L2 players have jumped straight up already so probably a case of waiting on them, championship clubs XYZ don't get their fancy backup striker signing, then it's "hi Paul!"
And I guess from his point of view... Be Charlton's backup striker on 3k a week for 2 years or be QPR's for 7k a week.
This season even if 1 or 2 are 2 or 3 weeks behind hopefully we won't have to throw them straight in and they can catch up quite quickly.
adkins praises young striker in public = Charlton life meltdown
Davison was used by bowyer two years ago when he wasn’t ready and he didn’t let himself down. He didn’t cover himself in glory on loan but the loan may have turned a boy into a man. I would be happy to have him in the squad and playing in cup games over a premiership loan or a one season wonder like mullin.
Stockley is our main man so I'd be happy enough with Davison getting some minutes here and there and maybe a PL loan as another option up top.
I don't think it's a priority area anyway, we desperately do need these wingers that everyone keeps talking about though.
Last March, Scoham posted a link to a good interview with Davison. Before writing the player off, perhaps some people might want to read it?