Honestly think Maddison signing in the first place was a bit of Bows thinking that he could be the one to finally get more out of him. Alas it hasn't really worked out that way.
Hope there's a couple of wingers/AMs on their way to give a target man like Stockley some service
Maddison has to have fallen out big time with Bowyer - a fall out that can’t be repaired - and given what happened at Peterborough, where the manager there washed his hands of him, it is likely the issue is to do with Maddison - that said, I imagine that if you fall out with Bowyer, it’s very difficult to get back on an equal footing with him
But if we lose Maddison and Williams, and don’t replace them today, that’s very poor on the part of the club
I agree with much of that ...... although there's 6 hours left, evidently irons in the fire, plenty of twists and turns still to come.
Remember, our signing of a player may be dependent of the selling club signing a replacement first.
They might not be saying it "out loud" but a clearance fire sale like this (especially if few/no inbound) does feel oddly like a writing off of the season and hoping we drift along to a midtable finish with the real business to be done in summer.
Seems to conflict a bit with TS' "go-getter" persona unless he's reluctant to throw money at short term gain and sees it as a trimming exercise.
Fantastic business if we can get Maddison out the door. Purely because it's clear to me he won't play much if at all under Bowyer(rightly or wrongly). He'll be on a decent wage, so if we can get him out & get 1 or 2 others in, then it's good business
Sounds like we're relying on frees, loans and cheap moves.
Thought this was a brand new era?
How do you offer mega transfers, yet can only offer a pittance of a wage?
By not using all your wage budget on over 30s and buying young players?
I don't expect an over night revolution but I can't be the only one slightly disappointed if there are no foundations payed?
It looks, from the transfers that have happened this season, that we have gambled on going up this season. We can all second guess on what the plan is, but you can't suggest any of our signings are forward looking?
If Bowyer and Gallen sign players then decide halfway through a season they’re not good enough let’s get rid, then so be it, everything else is instant these days. Fully trust their judgment here, positive since TS, that sufficient bodies will be in before deadline.
I fully agree. However I can see why there is a counter argument and fans asking why did we sign them in the 1st place. That is a debate for tomorrow. Let's hope we have some good targets still lined up today. I think the deal with Exeter may not be dead in the water just yet
agreed, but a clear in would be nice too. We need to start rebuilding the squad with permanent signings on long contracts not loans and short term deals.
And if the cap is removed at the end of the season we're in a difficult position to get better players in.
Sounds like we're relying on frees, loans and cheap moves.
Thought this was a brand new era?
How do you offer mega transfers, yet can only offer a pittance of a wage?
Why are we shipping all our players out when you can't get better with the wage cap?
This x 100. Madness getting rid of all the experienced creative players & then bringing in inexperienced youngsters whi haven't proven that they can cut it.
Looks like Bowyer wants a team of Steve Browns & Steve Gritts and not Claus Jensons & Paulo De Canios.
neither Williams or Maddison are a great loss imo
Is that because they're not talented or because our manager can't/won't manage them?
Neither of those things imo. Williams was surplus in the summer but triggered his own option and Maddison I'm guessing we took a gamble on his attitude and application and not paid off
I said earlier on in this thread today that I'm sad to see JW go, and I hoped we would have got a perm in first to replace him. Now looks as though Madison going as well, so creative players going and no sign, to me, of anyone else coming in except the Gunners lad! We do seem to going down the route again of " We tried to get some players in but couldn't get them over the line", I hope I'm wrong!
Yes I was thinking the same,the alarm bells are beginning to ring. Let’s hope there is a more structured plan in place now.🤞🤞🤞
Maddison has to have fallen out big time with Bowyer - a fall out that can’t be repaired - and given what happened at Peterborough, where the manager there washed his hands of him, it is likely the issue is to do with Maddison - that said, I imagine that if you fall out with Bowyer, it’s very difficult to get back on an equal footing with him
But if we lose Maddison and Williams, and don’t replace them today, that’s very poor on the part of the club
Curbs was no different as a Manager... Didnt he get rid of Shaun Newton in less than favourable circumstances?
Bowyer certainly isnt some revolutionary Manager that gets rid of players at the first sign of a disagreement
Curbs also drummed out Greg Shields, Scot Parker was banished to the stiffs for wanting his move to Chel$ki. Jason Euell too was excluded for ages before finally being forgiven.
Bowyer isn't the messiah, he can be criticised. Right now it looks like he's ditched some of our most creative players because they don't fit into his new negative gameplan we've seen since last January.
I hope he does well, but I simply cannot see us getting promoted when he goes on about stability and then brings in players and sells them on months later.
Maddison has to have fallen out big time with Bowyer - a fall out that can’t be repaired - and given what happened at Peterborough, where the manager there washed his hands of him, it is likely the issue is to do with Maddison - that said, I imagine that if you fall out with Bowyer, it’s very difficult to get back on an equal footing with him
But if we lose Maddison and Williams, and don’t replace them today, that’s very poor on the part of the club
Curbs was no different as a Manager... Didnt he get rid of Shaun Newton in less than favourable circumstances?
Bowyer certainly isnt some revolutionary Manager that gets rid of players at the first sign of a disagreement
Curbs also drummed out Greg Shields, Scot Parker was banished to the stiffs for wanting his move to Chel$ki. Jason Euell too was excluded for ages before finally being forgiven.
Greg Shields was a tidy player - why did Curbs drum him out ?
Not that I want to piss on anybody's chips i'd like to see us sign Randall too but a mate of mine who supports Exeter reckons it's to replace Nicky Law who's just gone to the MLS as a player-coach, just passing on what he told me. Still hope we can sign Randall but I don't see it happening unless we're prepared to up our offer.
"Marry in haste, repent at leisure" as the old proverbs says.
Circumstances (two weeks to build a squad after sociopath owners and years of neglect) left Bowyer and Gallen grabbing whoever was available for a quick walk up the aisle.
Now they've had to co-habit with them for a few months they are taking the chance to divorce a few.
Comments
Hope there's a couple of wingers/AMs on their way to give a target man like Stockley some service
Remember, our signing of a player may be dependent of the selling club signing a replacement first.
Seems to conflict a bit with TS' "go-getter" persona unless he's reluctant to throw money at short term gain and sees it as a trimming exercise.
I don't expect an over night revolution but I can't be the only one slightly disappointed if there are no foundations payed?
It looks, from the transfers that have happened this season, that we have gambled on going up this season. We can all second guess on what the plan is, but you can't suggest any of our signings are forward looking?
However I can see why there is a counter argument and fans asking why did we sign them in the 1st place. That is a debate for tomorrow.
Let's hope we have some good targets still lined up today.
I think the deal with Exeter may not be dead in the water just yet
Williams was surplus in the summer but triggered his own option and Maddison I'm guessing we took a gamble on his attitude and application and not paid off
It's a really sad sign for me that Bowyer hasn't and won't ever be able to manage difficult players. It's known he holds grudges too.
I am disappointed.
Jason Euell too was excluded for ages before finally being forgiven.
Bowyer isn't the messiah, he can be criticised. Right now it looks like he's ditched some of our most creative players because they don't fit into his new negative gameplan we've seen since last January.
I hope he does well, but I simply cannot see us getting promoted when he goes on about stability and then brings in players and sells them on months later.
I hope the photo copier still on.
Circumstances (two weeks to build a squad after sociopath owners and years of neglect) left Bowyer and Gallen grabbing whoever was available for a quick walk up the aisle.
Now they've had to co-habit with them for a few months they are taking the chance to divorce a few.