Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

The 2017 Summer Transfer Rumours Thread (Deadline Day from page 264)

1146147149151152296

Comments

  • When fit we're looking at:

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi JFC

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, Crofts, Fosu, Watt, Novak


    Not sure where Wright fits in if we signed him, and it's plainly clear we need another winger.
  • Scoham said:

    I simply dont understand the need to shift Ceballos when by keeping him we dont need anymore Midfielders... I dont think we even need to worry about signing Reeves and/or Wright because of the depth we've got in the centre.

    Concentrate on using the Teixeira | Ajose | Vetokele freed up money to get a Left-Back in, get that Right-Back as cover for Chris Solly and despite Dillon Phillips now improving from the earlier games we need a damned Goalkeeper!! - I said it a few weeks ago but this season is EXACTLY the same as last, we've signed a handful (three) players who'll get the fans excited and think that change is afoot and now we've started to dither in the Transfer Market and we'll still be waiting for targets to join after the Bristol Rovers game!!

    We are still crying out for another box to box midfielder. Kashi gives us still and quality but dont think he brings that box to box player like Wright.
    Surely JFC is that man?
    One option but what if he gets injured? apart from Kashi centre mid is the same as from when Robinson come in and I felt this area was along with the missing 10 was one of the reason we struggled.

    Whenever i think of successful Charlton teams it has been built around a strong energetic centre midfield.
    Not sure if it's good enough myself but at the moment I'd say Kashi and Crofts are the options as holding midfielders with JFC and Aribo as the box to box CMs.
    Plus Jackson and a couple of the kids. Really don't think CM is a priority at the moment when compared to full backs and wide players given KR's formation. And a GK of course.

    The other thing is with the likes of Wright KR will also be looking to improve the squad - so may see him as an upgrade on Crofts and ship Crofts or another out.
  • Da Silva, a GK and a winger, i'd be happy with. If we keep Novak and Watt I can't see Roland sanctioning another striker. Especially as we play 1 up top.
  • Rob Green told he can leave Leeds. Too expensive for us? I imagine he'll get a gig in The Championship or as a Premier League backup somewhere though.
  • When fit we're looking at:

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi JFC

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, Crofts, Fosu, Watt, Novak


    Not sure where Wright fits in if we signed him, and it's plainly clear we need another winger.

    That's a pretty strong team. If the players in it stayed fit - don't laugh - anything other than a top 6 finish would be totally unacceptable
  • “Tex has gone to St Truiden – we’re two separate things so that came off my wage bill,” he added.

    Hold on, doesn't Roland pretend he doesn't / didn't own STTV?

    That was back when he had two Belgian sides - his girlfriend owned STVV, but since he sold Standard he has taken control of her/it/them.
  • Rob Green told he can leave Leeds. Too expensive for us? I imagine he'll get a gig in The Championship or as a Premier League backup somewhere though.

    Probably not worth a flag but if there was a 'dislike' button I'd be hitting it. The perennial disappointment and the John Lewis of the Goalkeeper Union - looks good, likes to be compared to others, is always considered but never really saves you anything.
  • When fit we're looking at:

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi JFC

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, Crofts, Fosu, Watt, Novak


    Not sure where Wright fits in if we signed him, and it's plainly clear we need another winger.

    That's a pretty strong team. If the players in it stayed fit - don't laugh - anything other than a top 6 finish would be totally unacceptable
    It is pretty strong and if they're all fit you'd have to think that side would be in the top 2, as i can't see too many stronger sides.

    However that side is a couple of injuries away from being mid-table nobodies. If any 2-3 from Kashi, Holmes, Marshall and Magennis got injured, we'd struggle big time.
  • edited July 2017

    When fit we're looking at:

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi JFC

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, Crofts, Fosu, Watt, Novak


    Not sure where Wright fits in if we signed him, and it's plainly clear we need another winger.

    For what it's worth you could argue that against tougher opposition or away from home Robinson might opt for something like...

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi

    JFC Wright
    Marshall Holmes

    Magennis

    With Marshall and Holmes playing wide. That side wouldn't be too bad.
  • I don't think Bauer will be starting. If our goal is promotion then he's not good enough.
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited July 2017


    J.Steele (Contract ends in 2018)

    Solly Pearce Bauer DaSilva

    Kashi Crofts

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, JFC, Fosu, KAG, Novak


    Fosu should be able to play RM as he is a Right footed Left Winger?

    Also you can see I have put Steele in, he's gotta be worth a look in to see if he is available?
  • I see the squad as something like this:
    New GK
    Solly, Konsa, Pearce, New LB
    Kashi, JFC
    Marshall, New 10, Holmes
    Magennis

    2nd XI:
    Phillips
    Barnes, Bauer, Lennon, Page
    Crofts, Aribo
    Fosu, Clarke, New Winger
    Novak

    I don't think we need another RB as we have Konsa, Barnes and Charles-Cook all capable of covering there. If Solly was out, I would start Konsa RB and bring Bauer into the starting team.

    I don't get the need for Wright but we have 100% made a bid from him. As a 'DM', we have Kashi, Crofts and then possibly Dijksteel. As the more box to box midfielder, we have JFC, Aribo and then possibly even Jackson or Lapslie. I really think with 4 senior CM's, 1 youngster who broke in last year and then another 2 looking to break in this season, it would be a waste of money signing another one.

    The only reason we might want Wright is if we don't sign another number 10, and Aribo backs up Clarke in that position. But again, would be a total waste of time IMO as we should leave Wright, leave Aribo as a CM and keep Ceballos.

    GK and LB are clearly the priority. I wouldn't mind another attacking midfielder/winger and thought Stewart would be worth a one year deal.

    If we got Martin, Da Silva and Stewart, we wouldn't really be spending a penny and still leaves us to get rid of Sarr. I wouldn't mind getting rid of Watt and bringing in another striker though.


  • Pearce to me is the only definite CB. The other position is open, which leaves quite a choice Bauer, Konsa, Sarr (if he stays), Lennon
  • I see the squad as something like this:
    New GK
    Solly, Konsa, Pearce, New LB
    Kashi, JFC
    Marshall, New 10, Holmes
    Magennis

    2nd XI:
    Phillips
    Barnes, Bauer, Lennon, Page
    Crofts, Aribo
    Fosu, Clarke, New Winger
    Novak

    I don't think we need another RB as we have Konsa, Barnes and Charles-Cook all capable of covering there. If Solly was out, I would start Konsa RB and bring Bauer into the starting team.

    I don't get the need for Wright but we have 100% made a bid from him. As a 'DM', we have Kashi, Crofts and then possibly Dijksteel. As the more box to box midfielder, we have JFC, Aribo and then possibly even Jackson or Lapslie. I really think with 4 senior CM's, 1 youngster who broke in last year and then another 2 looking to break in this season, it would be a waste of money signing another one.

    The only reason we might want Wright is if we don't sign another number 10, and Aribo backs up Clarke in that position. But again, would be a total waste of time IMO as we should leave Wright, leave Aribo as a CM and keep Ceballos.

    GK and LB are clearly the priority. I wouldn't mind another attacking midfielder/winger and thought Stewart would be worth a one year deal.

    If we got Martin, Da Silva and Stewart, we wouldn't really be spending a penny and still leaves us to get rid of Sarr. I wouldn't mind getting rid of Watt and bringing in another striker though.


    There is actually another reason. We just want to p**s off Gillingham - and Paul Scally in particular - even more.
  • I see the squad as something like this:
    New GK
    Solly, Konsa, Pearce, New LB
    Kashi, JFC
    Marshall, New 10, Holmes
    Magennis

    2nd XI:
    Phillips
    Barnes, Bauer, Lennon, Page
    Crofts, Aribo
    Fosu, Clarke, New Winger
    Novak

    I don't think we need another RB as we have Konsa, Barnes and Charles-Cook all capable of covering there. If Solly was out, I would start Konsa RB and bring Bauer into the starting team.

    I don't get the need for Wright but we have 100% made a bid from him. As a 'DM', we have Kashi, Crofts and then possibly Dijksteel. As the more box to box midfielder, we have JFC, Aribo and then possibly even Jackson or Lapslie. I really think with 4 senior CM's, 1 youngster who broke in last year and then another 2 looking to break in this season, it would be a waste of money signing another one.

    The only reason we might want Wright is if we don't sign another number 10, and Aribo backs up Clarke in that position. But again, would be a total waste of time IMO as we should leave Wright, leave Aribo as a CM and keep Ceballos.

    GK and LB are clearly the priority. I wouldn't mind another attacking midfielder/winger and thought Stewart would be worth a one year deal.

    If we got Martin, Da Silva and Stewart, we wouldn't really be spending a penny and still leaves us to get rid of Sarr. I wouldn't mind getting rid of Watt and bringing in another striker though.


    There is actually another reason. We just want to p**s off Gillingham - and Paul Scally in particular - even more.
    to be fair, it might quite nice for RD and co to piss a club off that's not their own!
  • Pearce to me is the only definite CB. The other position is open, which leaves quite a choice Bauer, Konsa, Sarr (if he stays), Lennon

    I agree, but I have always seen a left/right combination meaning either Bauer/Konsa to partner either Pearce/Lennon.
  • “Tex has gone to St Truiden – we’re two separate things so that came off my wage bill,” he added.

    Hold on, doesn't Roland pretend he doesn't / didn't own STTV?

    That was while he owned Standard Liege. I believe he subsequently took public control of Sint-Truiden again, although he has since sold a share of it.
  • When fit we're looking at:

    New keeper

    Solly Pearce Bauer new left back

    Kashi JFC

    Marshall Clarke Holmes

    Magennis

    Subs: Phillips, Konsa, Aribo, Crofts, Fosu, Watt, Novak


    Not sure where Wright fits in if we signed him, and it's plainly clear we need another winger.

    That's a pretty strong team. If the players in it stayed fit - don't laugh - anything other than a top 6 finish would be totally unacceptable
    It is pretty strong and if they're all fit you'd have to think that side would be in the top 2, as i can't see too many stronger sides.

    However that side is a couple of injuries away from being mid-table nobodies. If any 2-3 from Kashi, Holmes, Marshall and Magennis got injured, we'd struggle big time.
    That's no different to pretty much every other league one side.
  • KR says only two definite starters. I'm assuming that's Holmes and Pearce.
  • Sponsored links:


  • At this moment in time, Phillips, Solly, Pearce, Kashi, Marshall, Holmes and Magennis must surely be definite starters.
  • At this moment in time, Phillips, Solly, Pearce, Kashi, Marshall, Holmes and Magennis must surely be definite starters.

    Can you include Holmes seeing he has only been involved in one Pre-Season game?

    He really need to get his match fitness up to be considered a starter surely
  • At this moment in time, Phillips, Solly, Pearce, Kashi, Marshall, Holmes and Magennis must surely be definite starters.

    Yeah agree with that, and so probably does KR himself. Guess he can't say that though, as players might get complacent.
  • Pearce to me is the only definite CB. The other position is open, which leaves quite a choice Bauer, Konsa, Sarr (if he stays), Lennon

    I agree, but I have always seen a left/right combination meaning either Bauer/Konsa to partner either Pearce/Lennon.
    Agreed in terms of the combination, but Pearce to me is the only leader/organiser amongst the CBs. That was one of the many mistakes of the transfer decisions 2 years ago, having a first choice pairing of Sarr and Bauer, both new to the country and both very inexperienced was a crazy decision.

    One of the many strengths of the Powell promotion team was the number of leaders in it. Our 3 CBs, Taylor, Morrison and Cort were all strong personalities
    Yeah I completely agree with you regarding Pearce. I see it that Bauer/Konsa are competing to partner him. I do believe that Diarra started that season at CB with Bauer though, Sarr was mainly a back up.

    Yeah we are certainly heavily reliant on Pearce's leadership at the back, luckily I do believe he is up to it.
  • Watt seems to be missing from this discussion.
  • sam3110 said:

    colthe3rd said:

    Please can we see some more of people's preferred teams/lineups?

    Sure

    Neuer
    Ramos, Boateng, Chiellini
    Alves Verratti Nainggolan Alaba
    Messi Lewandowski Ronaldo

    De Gea, Azpilicueta, Thiago Silva, Pogba, Modric, Suarez, Neymar
    That team would get slaughtered in League One!!... No Bonucci?
  • sam3110 said:

    colthe3rd said:

    Please can we see some more of people's preferred teams/lineups?

    Sure

    Neuer
    Ramos, Boateng, Chiellini
    Alves Verratti Nainggolan Alaba
    Messi Lewandowski Ronaldo

    De Gea, Azpilicueta, Thiago Silva, Pogba, Modric, Suarez, Neymar
    That team would get slaughtered in League One!!... No Bonucci?
    Toas up between him and Silva for the place on the bench.

    Tbh I'd actually love to have Buffon, Chiellini, Bonucci, Barzagli as the back line, but can't be too greedy
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!