I think he'll get one more game . If we don't win that then it's bye bye and deservedly so just for that first half formation ( Whatever it was ) and performance alone.
I am just so sick of us being so soft in defence, has been the case for multiple coaches now, who have been unable or unwilling to focus on defence.
If Holden is destined to be shown the door soon then I really hope we try to break the cycle, send the cheap assistants back to the academy to continue to learn, bring in a more old school manager who is not looking to be best mates with the players and who is willing to focus on defending, winning over playing the "right way".
He should be under pressure but he's Methven's man so he isn't. Tactically he seems to be getting so much wrong and the constant changes of formation can't help the team be organised in defence
If I'm Rowell or the only a minority investor in no way involved in the day to day Methven, I look at that, I look at the wages on the books and the fees spent this summer, and I don't know how I can keep Holden, even if I hired him in the first place.
As SD Addick, I would have Holden gone tonight. He's way out of his depth. Apart from seeming like a good guy, I can't identify a strength he brings as a manager.
If I'm Rowell or the only a minority investor in no way involved in the day to day Methven, I look at that, I look at the wages on the books and the fees spent this summer, and I don't know how I can keep Holden, even if I hired him in the first place.
As SD Addick, I would have Holden gone tonight. He's way out of his depth. Apart from seeming like a good guy, I can't identify a strength he brings as a manager.
We’ll get shot of him. Then we’ll appoint someone to shore it up and get us to mid table. Same as we do every season. Nothing changes. Except one day it won’t work. Once I supported a club with ambition.
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four thought so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Scapegoat? Happy with how that first half played out?
Holden got it totally wrong and we were lucky to still be in the game at half time.
The reason we're in the league position we are is because we're stuck relying on kids waiting for those perfect players that don't exist.
Last 3 seasons we've started poorly, it's recruitment every single time. Why do other clubs manage to get a squad together ready for August but never us?
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four thought so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Scapegoat? Happy with how that first half played out?
Holden got it totally wrong and we were lucky to still be in the game at half time.
The reason we're in the league position we are is because we're stuck relying on kids waiting for those perfect players that don't exist.
Last 3 seasons we've started poorly, it's recruitment every single time. Why do other clubs manage to get a squad together ready for August but never us?
If you don’t have the players, you set up to be hard to beat.
By contrast, we are consistently opened up and counter attacked with ease.
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four thought so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Scapegoat? Happy with how that first half played out?
Holden got it totally wrong and we were lucky to still be in the game at half time.
The reason we're in the league position we are is because we're stuck relying on kids waiting for those perfect players that don't exist.
Last 3 seasons we've started poorly, it's recruitment every single time. Why do other clubs manage to get a squad together ready for August but never us?
Last two seasons you are 100% spot on. This season has been a bit different because of the take over and they have a week to turn this around. However, I suspect that this time next week, you will be 100% right over 3 seasons
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four though so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Bullshit. You saying you'd be happy if Charlie walked through the door got rid of every single one of our players and replaced them with the port vale team? They beat us with a far worse team on an individual basis because they are properly coached to a system that works for them. Holden is out of excuses as far as I'm concerned.
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four though so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Bullshit. You saying you'd be happy if Charlie walked through the door got rid of every single one of our players and replaced them with the port vale team? They beat us with a far worse team on an individual basis because they are properly coached to a system that works for them. Holden is out of excuses as far as I'm concerned.
We had 5 players under the age of 22 starting today.
Players can be worse and win with experience. We have zero because we haven't recruited any leaders.
The thing I'm really concerned about with him is he just clearly doesn't know how to put a defence together. It doesn't matter how good your attackers are if you keep conceding, promotion squads are built on strong defences. Going back to last season Holden's teams seem to make the same mistakes over and over and he doesn't know how to fix it. I was willing to give him time to change the shape to one he was more comfortable with but the defence looks even more lost playing 3 at the back and he's given up on it repeatedly. Countless different formations and overplaying kids. Sure he could do with more players but he also couldn't be doing much worse with what he's got. I honestly feel like if we got a top quality right back, creative midfielder, centre back and striker in tomorrow not that much would change and that does worry me
If we were still making occasional errors during games it would be excusable with a young and unbalanced squad. But we're making the same mistakes over and over with no alternative plan.
The squad is not great but it's not as bad as results suggest.
Easy scapegoat to ignore what is happening upstairs.
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four though so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
Bullshit. You saying you'd be happy if Charlie walked through the door got rid of every single one of our players and replaced them with the port vale team? They beat us with a far worse team on an individual basis because they are properly coached to a system that works for them. Holden is out of excuses as far as I'm concerned.
We had 5 players under the age of 21 starting today.
Players can be worse and win with experience. We have zero because we haven't recruited any leaders.
That was a Holden choice though… as evidenced by the fact that Elerewe and Ness were hooked by half time.
Good: he realised it was wrong and changed it
Bad: the fact he got it so desperately wrong in the first place
Comments
If Holden is destined to be shown the door soon then I really hope we try to break the cycle, send the cheap assistants back to the academy to continue to learn, bring in a more old school manager who is not looking to be best mates with the players and who is willing to focus on defending, winning over playing the "right way".
Yes he's doing poorly, but the main issues is our squad building and recruitment this summer.
Friends with the gang of four though so will be interesting to see how quickly they turn on him to save their own skin.
As SD Addick, I would have Holden gone tonight. He's way out of his depth. Apart from seeming like a good guy, I can't identify a strength he brings as a manager.
Holden Out for me.
Holden got it totally wrong and we were lucky to still be in the game at half time.
Last 3 seasons we've started poorly, it's recruitment every single time. Why do other clubs manage to get a squad together ready for August but never us?
The bloke compared Salford to South London ffs, nothing but empty soundbites.
By contrast, we are consistently opened up and counter attacked with ease.
.
Players can be worse and win with experience. We have zero because we haven't recruited any leaders.
Chris wilder
&
Darren moore
The squad is not great but it's not as bad as results suggest.
Good: he realised it was wrong and changed it
Bad: the fact he got it so desperately wrong in the first place