Charlton v Port Vale - Post Match Views
Comments
-
First half decent.
Second half crap
No atmosphere
Boring as.6 -
The idea of Botaka is beautiful: sent on as sub: sprinting across the pitch from dug-out to corner flag, the quickest acceleration we have seen since the estimable Paul Williams, snapping at the heels of the unsuspecting defender.
Botaka didn't win that ball in the corner. Nor the pass on his right-wing. His tip-taps fell short, tentative and intercepted. We were trapped in the second half, retreating against another third-division team, on the back foot. Miles away from the imploring Covered End.
Was it Hanlan who was set free? Ball at feet, all defenders left behind, only the keeper to beat. One-on-one inside the box - and instead of a shot, he passes to Ajose three yards out. He's offside!
That is simply stupid.
It's the Sparrows Lane coaching for you. Meanwhile, Magennis, injured playing for his country last weekend, had leaped high at an another over-hit cross, arched his back – and powered a header beyond the keeper. Yann Kermorgant would applaud that superb goal.
Foley and Fox? Basic, schoolboy errors. Passes sent astray. Here and there. Weak and dull. Clearances from Pearce and Bauer are shanked and skied. Crofts and Ulvestadt: utterly anonymous. It's a throw-in to our opponents...
Ricky Holmes is the only man in our squad with zip, fire, and energy: gamble and guts. Penetrating, probing, rushing forward; clever and quick.
We already miss him. Thank God that Port Vale are even worse than Charlton.
4 -
I haven't got a lot to add but I've been so uninspired by what I've seen so far this season that I've only made one posting since August and I thought that I really ought to write something or it may appear that I've given up on us. So, for what they're worth, here are my thoughts on the Port Vale game.
1. It was good to see Nicky Ajose with a bit more spring in his step at last. Long may that continue. We've seen him miss a few like the one he took today so it was great that he stuck it away so coolly. Hopefully a great boost to his confidence.
2. Josh Magennis is looking a little too good for us. He leads the line better than anyone we've had since Yann, always gives 100% and has kept up a reasonable (if not spectacular) scoring rate. I wouldn't be surprised if he is already in the sights of some Championship clubs, particularly as he has put in some excellent performances for Northern Ireland lately.
3. Overall Morgan Fox had his best game for ages - he reverted to type in the second half but for the first 45 minutes looked superb.
4. This was another game which showed how poor this division is. Port Vale, like many teams we've played this season, were reasonably well drilled and had one or two useful players but were nevertheless not very good. Even with the players we have at the moment, we should be doing so much better in League 1 than we are. Slade's negativity and our lack of midfield drive have been our undoing. Crofts and, sadly, Jackson too are just not good enough now even at this level.
5. It was very sad to see the sparse crowd today. Less than ten years ago we were established in the Premier League with a full stadium and some great players. It's hard to believe now that we were ever that good.24 -
I get where @Off_it is coming from. I feel the same. You can't turn emotions on and off like a switch. At the moment, I feel deflated with all things relating to Charlton. The management, the discord, the turnover of both managers and players make it hard to make a connection. It doesn't mean that I give up supporting Charlton as I hope that things improve in the near future. I just hope that there is not more damage to come from this regime.Nadou said:
Because the idea of being a supporter is to have fun and to care if your team wins or loses. If you don't care, you might get more pleasure elsewhere. Or do you just enjoy posting that you don't care?Off_it said:10 -
This breaks my heart.Redmidland said:Nearly 9000 my backside, here is a picture taken at 3:15 this afternoon-:
10 -
I've never had a problem with Foley playing right back. That is his position. What we have to look at now is champions form to get into the play offs. Today's set up won't give us that IMO but it is a start. How we do on Tuesday will be telling. We have to have our best players on the pitch which means Tex and we have to have Ba on the bench! At least until the window when things can be done.1
-
I agree with your report entirely, but found it a little verbose. Could you cut to the chase next time?Nicholas said:First half decent.
Second half crap
No atmosphere
Boring as.13 -
Said this last week. It's a complete waste of a squad space, especially when we usually have 2 other centre backs on the bench anyway.seth plum said:It is farcical to put tex on the bench by the way, it seems clear he won't play a league game for us. Even with no prospect of coming on, a player like Aribo (because he is a midfielder) should have been named amongst the substitutes.
I don't blame Nugent by the way.
I also can't believe that no one (as far as i'm aware) ever asked Slade to clarify Tex's situation. Perhaps a journo can ask the new guy when he's appointed if we're actually allowed to play him.2 -
That second goal shows the service Ajose's been lacking all season - it's how he scored a lot of his goals for Swindon last season.ForeverAddickted said:Highlights (well the goals): http://www.skysports.com/football/charlton-vs-port-vale/358869
3 -
Tend to agree with this and I would add Port Vale were shocking, absolutely nothing going forward. This is a poor league quality wise and our position is in it is pretty disgraceful really for a club who, in the regimes mind, are in a healthy state.Nicholas said:First half decent.
Second half crap
No atmosphere
Boring as.2 -
Sponsored links:
-
The strangest part of yesterday for me was just before half-time I went for a piss.
Three of us were standing there doing what comes naturally when we heard a faint cheer, we looked at one another and said that it couldn't be a goal as it was not a big enough cheer.
I then walked back to my seat in the upper North only to hear the bloke on the tannoy announce Ajose had scored.
That has got to be the quietest goal celebration i have heard at the valley in years, official attendance nearly nine thousand my arse2 -
Can I just add that the ref was an absolute arse.7
-
Sounds like one big arse fest yesterday.2
-
Did anyone else think the ref was awful.1
-
Chippycafc said:
Did anyone else think the ref was awful.
Agreed on both countsHartleypete said:Can I just add that the ref was an absolute arse.
0 -
Yup, totally awfulHartleypete said:Can I just add that the ref was an absolute arse.
0 -
Not from the roll of the eyes that Allen gave on the C5 goals programme.soapboxsam said:Mad Dog it is then, to be our next manager.
Good to see Ajose tuck the second goal away.
Curbs said that the owners need to consider the type of manager they want. Unfortunately, the type of manager they want is the one that accepts the shit sandwich served up for lunch & then to force them to accept the responsibility for that lunch when the results are bad & the diners complain or stop frequenting the establishment.
Like they said on the Goals show, what manager would take the job ? Even those managers unemployed would think twice.4 -
My first game for a year since Rotherham at home. I usually go with the old man 5/6 times a year, but just lost interest in the regimes direction. However I just missed going with the old boy as he is not getting any younger. The football wasn't great as expected, but was happy to share a drink and and pie, and have a tipple of brandy during the game.
Now to the game itself..
Magennis is a unit, but I think he was taking care of his hamstring as all I've heard previously is that the guy doesn't stop running. Fox was poor prior to setting up the 2 goals, however if he can hug the touch line in the final third he can ping in a great cross, the full backs definitely pushed up, Foley even with a shout for a pen. Bauer must of loved yesterday, easiest days wages he got, the guy just plays the quintessential CB role so well. He was a rash all over their CF, he must have thought 'just FO will you!!!' Midfield not great as everyone says each week. JJ I thought played OK, will probably be better off playing at home than away when the oppo will naturally attack more...IMO
Will go again in about a month's time1 -
Very good First Half, 2ND half was OK. Worst Saturday attendance for a home league fixture for over 21 years.
0 -
Redmidland said:
Nearly 9000 my backside, here is a picture taken at 3:15 this afternoon-:
At every home match the continuing legacy of Duchatalet and Meire is there for all to see. The longer it goes on, the fewer will come back.
1 -
Sponsored links:
-
The league is pony and we should be doing better , I still believe we can make the play offs
How sorry does the empty Valley look , sell the club you muppets
0% Top two ......... 25% 3rd-6th ......... 50% 7th-12th ......... 24.5% 13th-20th .......0.5% relegation4 -
Momentarily you probably thought I was getting the drinks in......blackpool72 said:The strangest part of yesterday for me was just before half-time I went for a piss.
Three of us were standing there doing what comes naturally when we heard a faint cheer, we looked at one another and said that it couldn't be a goal as it was not a big enough cheer.
I then walked back to my seat in the upper North only to hear the bloke on the tannoy announce Ajose had scored.
That has got to be the quietest goal celebration i have heard at the valley in years, official attendance nearly nine thousand my arse0 -
No, that would have been a huge cheerElfsborgAddick said:
Momentarily you probably thought I was getting the drinks in......blackpool72 said:The strangest part of yesterday for me was just before half-time I went for a piss.
Three of us were standing there doing what comes naturally when we heard a faint cheer, we looked at one another and said that it couldn't be a goal as it was not a big enough cheer.
I then walked back to my seat in the upper North only to hear the bloke on the tannoy announce Ajose had scored.
That has got to be the quietest goal celebration i have heard at the valley in years, official attendance nearly nine thousand my arse1 -
vff said:soapboxsam said:
Like they said on the Goals show, what manager would take the job ? Even those managers unemployed would think twice.
If i was unemployed i'd bite their hand off.
3 years money for 4-5 months work if you're lucky to last that long. And reputation not damaged too much as everyone knows the owner and CEO are complete morons.0 -
This is exactly what I was thinking while listening. I am very much against the notion of we win just for turning up, or because we've been in the Premier League relatively recently and we're playing the likes of Port Vale of AFC Wimbledon or Fleetwood Town that we should start 1-0. But I did expect that there would be days when we weren't brilliant, but where we'd get a couple goals or nick a 1-0 just because we have more talent in our side than most. And that really hasn't happened with maybe the exception of Chesterfield.seth plum said:PWR.
I feel more cheerful than usual, but I won't confuse cheerful with hopeful.
Today was almost the kind of run of the mill victory that I have been expecting to see every game this season, which you don't need telling we haven't been getting.
Port Vale were yet another honest team with some limitations, however they gave it a bit of a go in the second half and I though represented their club well as players. The Port Vale fans were loyal behind their team, and they joined in the silence impeccably, but Charlton were better and deserved the win. As an addendum Clive detailed three Port Vale players who fell in the Great War before our unveiling ceremony by Sam's statue which was a fine addition to a tasteful and moving ceremony before the match.
Anyway back to the game.
Did I notice much different? Well we wanted to keep the ball deep to draw Vale on and create extra space behind them to exploit which was a bit new (was almost a disaster on one occasion) and when there were crossing opportunities a midfield player, most notably Jackson would bomb into the area as extra confusion and an extra option which was good, and the Magennis/Ajose partnership was more successful than usual because they played closer together.
To me it was, and is, something to be laid at Slade's doorstep, as it felt that, despite this team's limitations, he had them playing well within themselves. Not just saying that because of today's result, but in general it's been incredibly unfortunate that our excellent defense hasn't kept clean sheets at key times, or our strong attack hasn't been able to nick goals.2 -
Fox was excellent, few passes went astray. Foley I thought wold be our week link but looked ok.Viewfinder said:
Foley and Fox? Basic, schoolboy errors. Passes sent astray. Here and there. Weak and dull. Clearances from Pearce and Bauer are shanked and skied. Crofts and Ulvestadt: utterly anonymous. It's a throw-in to our opponents...
Pearce and Bauer were excellent. Bauer shanked one clearance. It happens. Cofts and Ulvestadt were ok, worked hard.2 -
And one that has a top 6 budgie.Nug said:
Tend to agree with this and I would add Port Vale were shocking, absolutely nothing going forward. This is a poor league quality wise and our position is in it is pretty disgraceful really for a club who, in the regimes mind, are in a healthy state.Nicholas said:First half decent.
Second half crap
No atmosphere
Boring as.
( How I'd love to hear it's going "cheep"!)
2 -
Posting after going out straight after the game to see "Fantastic Creatures" (good film). Enjoyed the game - end to end at times, both teams wanting it - even Vale didn't give up with minutes to go. Atmosphere flat because of the lack of people and never been the same since most of the upper North moved to the lower.
Thought main difference since Slade went was players looking more interested and closing down quicker. 2nd half, we were pushing up and not sitting quite so deep but that caused it's own problems. Thought all the team played quite well even Foley although he is better at R/B not in the mid-field.
Moaned a lot about Ajose's touch and then he scored a great goal... Think we should be higher up the table. Hate the singing "we are going down" - why? Who wants us to? Going down won't make RD sell us any quicker - if anything he'll hang on even longer... I want Charlton to do the best they can and, unrealistically , win every game not go down...3 -
I enjoyed the game and don't think that Vale were as bad as some have made out. They played the ball well out from the back and attacked down both wings. They were unlucky on a couple of occasions and could have scored. Having said that I thought we were the better team and took two chances well and with a bit of luck could have scored more.
Attended ceremony behind stand with my son and a bit surprised at the low numbers, but when I saw the size of the crowd it was apparent why. Oh how I wish their tenure was over so the crowd would return. I am sure it would be worth another 10 points by season end.2 -
Did we win that game because Slade had got the chop ?
We were certainly more positive, more attacking and that was without our best player Ricky Holmes, who has been one of only 2 creative threats this season.
I'm thinking that we've been so easy to stop, because our only tactic was give it to Holmes or lump it to Magennis.
No Holmes, meant we moved the ball around more. Fox got forward more, as did Ulvestad & Crofts & Ajose looked more lively and happier.
We started slowly, but picked up well & it was a thoroughly deserved win. I enjoyed it.
Oh and a special mention for Morgan Fox, who probably played his best game.
He had 2 assists and chested away a goal bound shot. I'll nominate Morgan as MOM because of this, although Magennis & Bauer possibly played better overall, but without the assists.
I was also very pleased for Josh. It's about time one of his headers hit the net.
Pearce battled manfully, Lookman looked good. Foley was ok, as was Crofts. Crofts had a good shot saved.
Jackson and the sub Botaka were anonymous.
Ajose was the most lively he's been & looked happier.
So a better all round display without Slade. Coincidence ? It might be, but I doubt it.5
