The only question we should be asking at this late stage is how much compo will we get? I find it distressing for the game that a club can produce a player and he can walk at 19 after playing for a quarter of a year! I think it will reflect badly on Poyet, although the turmoil within the club will be some mitigation I'm sure he will use. I think he is a great player but he may ultimately lack Shelvey's class- and I wasn't talking about playing ability there- but Shelvey is class in that respect too IMO.
The only question we should be asking at this late stage is how much compo will we get? I find it distressing for the game that a club can produce a player and he can walk at 19 after playing for a quarter of a year! I think it will reflect badly on Poyet, although the turmoil within the club will be some mitigation I'm sure he will use. I think he is a great player but he may ultimately lack Shelvey's class- and I wasn't talking about playing ability there- but Shelvey is class in that respect too IMO.
I agree. I think Diego will depart. I will wish him well but I do think that it will leave a bad taste in not showing any loyalty or respect to Charlton. Jonjo will always be respected for his actions prior to leaving.
The only question we should be asking at this late stage is how much compo will we get? I find it distressing for the game that a club can produce a player and he can walk at 19 after playing for a quarter of a year! I think it will reflect badly on Poyet, although the turmoil within the club will be some mitigation I'm sure he will use. I think he is a great player but he may ultimately lack Shelvey's class- and I wasn't talking about playing ability there- but Shelvey is class in that respect too IMO.
Compensation is already set at 400k. Agreed between PL and all the Football League clubs although we were one of a few to vote against the proposals at the time.
How can it reflect badly on Poyet? He was forced to sit and watch and not be picked for months and months because The Spivs could not afford the wage increase that a couple of first team appearances would have triggered. Thankfully RD had no such qualms and Powell was allowed to pick Diego straight away. A plus point for RD there. If the takeover had not have happened its likely Diego would be walking away this summer without having made a single first team appearance.
We know that Powell would always pick what he considered to be the best team regardless of what pressure the owner put on him, so I believe the decision to play Poyet when he did was based purely on who else was available. ie Stephens going.
I don't boo any ex players, but there is a select list of those I will clap - Bent, Lisbie, Shelvey, Jenkinson would all get heartfelt applause from me if they turned up at the Valley with an opposing team. Poyet, if he left now would not! He could do what Shelvey did at the very least!
Why would he stay? He may feel that the CAFC he would have been loyal to no longer exists. It's very very disappointing but the 'word' about the network and treatment of both managers and players will be widespread in football circles. Our brand is tainted.
The fans who voted for him to be player of the year and forked out money for Valley gold, the club that nutured his talent and gave him his chance at a perfectly reasonable age. Lots of reasons - although greed and lack of gratitude are not.
Agreed muttley It hasn't held Shelvey back.he should give something back to the club for his development like Shelvey did. He shouldn't be desperate for money and he knows his got a good career before him. That said RD shouldn't piss about with his contract offer or we are going to lose a good transfer fee it would be nice to see him play for us at least one more season though. Come on Diego sign up you can't lose fella.
I don't boo any ex players, but there is a select list of those I will clap - Bent, Lisbie, Shelvey, Jenkinson would all get heartfelt applause from me if they turned up at the Valley with an opposing team. Poyet, if he left now would not! He could do what Shelvey did at the very least!
I have got to say I think he will go. Riga's departure has blown our last chance of retaining him.
We have been hearing about his apparent departure ever since he joined the academy. I remember reading that Gus placed him at Charlton because it meant he could continue with his education uninterrupted and that he was going to joined Arsenal at 17 .Fortunately that didn't happen.
On the subject of them working together. I think it is plausible he could follow his father. Last season when the rumours about a possible move were floated it seemed strange to me because Diego had not made his first team debut . I hadn't appreciated then that this was probably more about contractual issues than playing two youngsters Cousins and Poyet in the same team.
The way I have interpreted the father and son working together scenario , it was around Diego making progress in an academy set up on his own . Now he might be considered a more established player I think Gus would view it differently.
He has already fixed himself up with a premiership team - of that I am sure. Only waiting for contract to expire in June. What a classless way to start your career.
He has already fixed himself up with a premiership team - of that I am sure. Only waiting for contract to expire in June. What a classless way to start your career.
I'm sure he'd have loved to have signed an extended contract last year He may have suffered an injury ,loss of form last season and be on the football slag heap That didn't happen and he's played well and rewards us by helping us stay up Now he can maximise for himself his potential earnings at this point , the route he chooses may not be the best one but he has to do what he/his advisers consider is in his best interests I'm sorry but I'm with him , when he's 40 and got no job who's gonna help pay those bills , they do keep coming after you've stopped earning , look at Freddie Flintoff making a comeback in 20/20 for Lancashire , it will be because his sundries need paying not for the love of the game Good luck to Diego whatever route he chooses , hopefully he'll stay at this arm of the Belgian circus
good comment oohaah… I want Diego to stay I really do, I've enjoyed watching him develop with the rest of the academy lads over the past 4 years, however,, if he does go then good luck to him, the club should not be 'churlish' about it, because in reality it should reflect on the inability of there previous regime in not securing his talent earlier on and even then I suspect his knowledgable father has been advising him rather well in these matters Good Luck Diegs hope you stay though
He has already fixed himself up with a premiership team - of that I am sure. Only waiting for contract to expire in June. What a classless way to start your career.
Very one eyed supporters type view. I doubt you trouble yourself much with the dozen or so players that get released every year. The way any club can prevent players walking away out of contract is to put them under contract. Don't attempt to do that after he demonstrates his value is several times what we can pay him. We played poker badly. The player will reflect that we left our options open so we could bin him in a few weeks if he didn't make the grade. If he leaves now he's not being classless. People that criticise him for doing so are showing a ridiculous lack of empathy.
As a long term valley gold subscriber I'd be disappointed if we piss away the best prospect that has come out of the academy since Parker. But, the fault is with the club not having him tied down in 2013. I cannot believe that experts watching him play last year couldn't see that there was a player there that would be championship quality, at least.
He has already fixed himself up with a premiership team - of that I am sure. Only waiting for contract to expire in June. What a classless way to start your career.
What Shelvey did was a magnificent gesture towards the club, but I really don't understand why we'd expect other players to do the same. We've had at least three different boards/owners in Poyet's time at the club and are now part of an international syndicate. We might like to think that any money gained from him signing a contract extension would go into the club coffers but there's no guarantee of that. We have a chairman that is in it to make money; Diego Poyet plays football to make money. Why should he do something with the aim of making a multi-millionaire even richer? Whilst I expect that Diego is pretty well heeled compared to your average teenager, his personal finances are nowhere near the Duchâtelet league. Poyet has got to do what's best for him, not what's best for a Belgian tycoon or for anyone else. I personally hope he signs a new contract, but not so that Charlton's owners can pick a few crumbs up off the table, but because he genuinely wants to play for us.
Comments
How can it reflect badly on Poyet? He was forced to sit and watch and not be picked for months and months because The Spivs could not afford the wage increase that a couple of first team appearances would have triggered. Thankfully RD had no such qualms and Powell was allowed to pick Diego straight away. A plus point for RD there. If the takeover had not have happened its likely Diego would be walking away this summer without having made a single first team appearance.
I have got to say I think he will go. Riga's departure has blown our last chance of retaining him.
We have been hearing about his apparent departure ever since he joined the academy. I remember reading that Gus placed him at Charlton because it meant he could continue with his education uninterrupted and that he was going to joined Arsenal at 17 .Fortunately that didn't happen.
On the subject of them working together. I think it is plausible he could follow his father. Last season when the rumours about a possible move were floated it seemed strange to me because Diego had not made his first team debut . I hadn't appreciated then that this was probably more about contractual issues than playing two youngsters Cousins and Poyet in the same team.
The way I have interpreted the father and son working together scenario , it was around Diego making progress in an academy set up on his own . Now he might be considered a more established player I think Gus would view it differently.
He may have suffered an injury ,loss of form last season and be on the football slag heap
That didn't happen and he's played well and rewards us by helping us stay up
Now he can maximise for himself his potential earnings at this point , the route he chooses may not be the best one but he has to do what he/his advisers consider is in his best interests
I'm sorry but I'm with him , when he's 40 and got no job who's gonna help pay those bills , they do keep coming after you've stopped earning , look at Freddie Flintoff making a comeback in 20/20 for Lancashire , it will be because his sundries need paying not for the love of the game
Good luck to Diego whatever route he chooses , hopefully he'll stay at this arm of the Belgian circus
As a long term valley gold subscriber I'd be disappointed if we piss away the best prospect that has come out of the academy since Parker. But, the fault is with the club not having him tied down in 2013. I cannot believe that experts watching him play last year couldn't see that there was a player there that would be championship quality, at least.