Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

*** Harvey Knibbs signs - 4 year deal ***

12346»

Comments

  • fenlandaddick
    fenlandaddick Posts: 1,784
    On the stream just heard the trainer telling him to run harder in the post match warm down. So don't worry all is well.
  • charltonbob
    charltonbob Posts: 8,288
    On the stream just heard the trainer telling him to run harder in the post match warm down. So don't worry all is well.
    Lazy fucker, get rid !
  • To_Be_Franck
    To_Be_Franck Posts: 1,095
    Thought he was anonymous in the game today. Not really getting the hype 
  • closet_addick
    closet_addick Posts: 181
    Good read and very encouraging, especially the part about playing as an 8.

    I wonder if Jones has signed Knibbs to play with Coventry in midfield as that box to box player while Coventry covers, and has other plans for the 10? Knibbs played as a central midfielder almost every game last season, was mainly used as an attacking midfielder prior to that in 23/24:


    Some of that is an artifact of how transfermrkt tracks positions.  Reading played a lot of 433 formations.  Knibbs played in the midfield 3 so was listed as a central midfielder but he was midfielder who played the most forward positionally and had the freedom to drift centrally in attack with the other midfielders covering.  It was kind of like a hybrid of an attacking midfielder and a central midfielder.

    It will be interesting to see if Jones uses him in the Berry AM role from last year or if we will see a more fluid midfield formation this year
    True, he did play on the right hand side of a midfield 3, his heat map and line ups show that. 

    I'd quite like to see us play a 433, Coventry in that defensive role and then Knibbs on the right and Donley on the left if we pull that move off (wishful thinking) on a side note, Coventry's heat map BTW, my word, some player.




    Conor "Forrest Gump" Coventry 
  • SuedeAdidas
    SuedeAdidas Posts: 7,760
    Good read and very encouraging, especially the part about playing as an 8.

    I wonder if Jones has signed Knibbs to play with Coventry in midfield as that box to box player while Coventry covers, and has other plans for the 10? Knibbs played as a central midfielder almost every game last season, was mainly used as an attacking midfielder prior to that in 23/24:


    Some of that is an artifact of how transfermrkt tracks positions.  Reading played a lot of 433 formations.  Knibbs played in the midfield 3 so was listed as a central midfielder but he was midfielder who played the most forward positionally and had the freedom to drift centrally in attack with the other midfielders covering.  It was kind of like a hybrid of an attacking midfielder and a central midfielder.

    It will be interesting to see if Jones uses him in the Berry AM role from last year or if we will see a more fluid midfield formation this year
    True, he did play on the right hand side of a midfield 3, his heat map and line ups show that. 

    I'd quite like to see us play a 433, Coventry in that defensive role and then Knibbs on the right and Donley on the left if we pull that move off (wishful thinking) on a side note, Coventry's heat map BTW, my word, some player.




    Did anyone notice Conor going for those two pisses?
  • fattmatt
    fattmatt Posts: 586
    Quality reporting from the Beeb. 
  • soapy_jones
    soapy_jones Posts: 21,398
    fattmatt said:
    Quality reporting from the Beeb. 
    NEVER EVER given a shit about us, so why would the BBC check our name is spelt properly before publishing?
  • wolfgang
    wolfgang Posts: 407
    fattmatt said:
    Quality reporting from the Beeb. 
    NEVER EVER given a shit about us, so why would the BBC check our name is spelt properly before publishing?
    John Reith must be turning in his grave.
  • sammy391
    sammy391 Posts: 3,791
    Yet to see anything to get excited or inspired about! 
    Know he hasn’t had a preseason, but doesn’t come across a player who will effect our season a great deal

  • Sponsored links:



  • Laddick01
    Laddick01 Posts: 6,440
    sammy391 said:
    Yet to see anything to get excited or inspired about! 
    Know he hasn’t had a preseason, but doesn’t come across a player who will effect our season a great deal
    Has scored our only league goal of the season and barely been involved. 

    I’ll judge him once he’s had a proper run in the team
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,462
    sammy391 said:
    Yet to see anything to get excited or inspired about! 
    Know he hasn’t had a preseason, but doesn’t come across a player who will effect our season a great deal
    Not sure what you were expecting him to be, but everything said about him has made it clear he's a goalscoring midfielder who works hard and presses well, not a skilful playmaker to run the game and spray killer passes around.
  • North Lower Neil
    North Lower Neil Posts: 22,997
    He's played the equivalent of one and half matches so far.  

    Reminds me of people worrying Alfie May was a dud when he didn't score in his first couple of games.

    Kelman, Knibbs, Rankin-Costello all had comments on here deciding they look rubbish.  They might be good, they might not turn out great, but give people a chance, and definitely more than a couple of games FFS.
  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 16,565
    Find it difficult to fathom how professional players can get so unfit in a matter of weeks. Expecting a lot more to come from his Knibbs. 
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,747
    Thought he pressed well on a handful of occasions when it was 0-0, but difficult match for him to effect proceedings given the ball was bypassing him a lot. 
  • Find it difficult to fathom how professional players can get so unfit in a matter of weeks. Expecting a lot more to come from his Knibbs. 
    Hes not unfit, only in comparison to other professional footballers is he perhaps not there yet. Being fit and being match sharp are completely different things
  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 16,565
    Find it difficult to fathom how professional players can get so unfit in a matter of weeks. Expecting a lot more to come from his Knibbs. 
    Hes not unfit, only in comparison to other professional footballers is he perhaps not there yet. Being fit and being match sharp are completely different things
    He was puffing and blowing after five minutes v Stevenage. Looked well unfit to me. 
  • Find it difficult to fathom how professional players can get so unfit in a matter of weeks. Expecting a lot more to come from his Knibbs. 
    Hes not unfit, only in comparison to other professional footballers is he perhaps not there yet. Being fit and being match sharp are completely different things
    He was puffing and blowing after five minutes v Stevenage. Looked well unfit to me. 
    So two games ago after having no preseason. I’d like to see you do better 
  • Siv_in_Norfolk
    Siv_in_Norfolk Posts: 4,061
    Find it difficult to fathom how professional players can get so unfit in a matter of weeks. Expecting a lot more to come from his Knibbs. 
    Hes not unfit, only in comparison to other professional footballers is he perhaps not there yet. Being fit and being match sharp are completely different things
    He was puffing and blowing after five minutes v Stevenage. Looked well unfit to me. 
    So two games ago after having no preseason. I’d like to see you do better 
    Hello, mate. I know you are going through a lot at the moment. We (everyone who read what's up, am sure) are all wishing the best for you and yours.

    I think your stress is leading you to post a bit spikily on here. 
  • stoneroses19
    stoneroses19 Posts: 7,254
    Best in the league for tackles per 90 minutes. 



  • Sponsored links:



  • Best in the league for tackles per 90 minutes. 


    Impressive given he's only played about 150 minutes all season.
  • CAFCsayer
    CAFCsayer Posts: 10,242
    Very unlucky that we seem to have signed prime Gerrard in the same position 
  • SporadicAddick
    SporadicAddick Posts: 6,906
    wolfgang said:
    fattmatt said:
    Quality reporting from the Beeb. 
    NEVER EVER given a shit about us, so why would the BBC check our name is spelt properly before publishing?
    John Reith must be turning in his grave.
    Was he a Charlton fan?
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,466
    According to the new Football Manager Knibbs is eligible for Jamaica. They could genuinely field half a team of Addicks at this point
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,400
    Knibbs will get his chance, and what a bloody luxury for us btw.

    Two seasons ago, Dobson gets injured, and we may as well not show up. Now if one of our midfield are unfit, Knibbs in waiting. 

    Still excited about him as I am Kelman, have full faith they will do well here in the end.