Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
John Robinson selling play off final shirt
Comments
-
Well he knows that £300 wouldn’t do it so he obviously knows the ballpark. If he doesnt want to say, he could have done it a little more politely.North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?2 -
Maybe he wants to keep his powder dry. Why should he be expected to answer such a question just because someone has asked?stop_shouting said:
Well he knows that £300 wouldn’t do it so he obviously knows the ballpark. If he doesnt want to say, he could have done it a little more politely.North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?0 -
It's like anything really, not what it's worth but what people are prepared to pay for it.stop_shouting said:
Well he knows that £300 wouldn’t do it so he obviously knows the ballpark. If he doesnt want to say, he could have done it a little more politely.North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?
A good idea would be if the team from Wembley clubbed together then Robbo gave it to the museum.
All would be happy.
Either way, John Robinson, you're the man.0 -
Dont answer it in the first place then...itll take a fair chunk more than 300 notes, but the reply came across a bit wanky considerkng it was a genuine enquiryStig said:
Maybe he wants to keep his powder dry. Why should he be expected to answer such a question just because someone has asked?stop_shouting said:
Well he knows that £300 wouldn’t do it so he obviously knows the ballpark. If he doesnt want to say, he could have done it a little more politely.North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?2 -
It was a fair an honest answer. £300 won't touch the sides. There was nothing wanky about it.2
-
Itd be closer with an extra zero on the end, but i dont think the one word "no" answer, and "no thanks" to expanding on it was really waranted. It was clearly just an inquisitive question3
-
Never post on a message board when you have had a drink
3 -
0 -
Shame he’s put the wrong year on the play off winners plaque 🤦♂️Talal said:4 -
Sponsored links:
-
I am guessing more than £300.13
-
What about putting a fund together for either the medals or shirts for the museum. It doesn’t have to be specific to Charlton Life as it’s for all Charlton fans. A bit like they do with a piece of art that should stay in a UK gallery.2
-
And taken them out of their boxes although he may still have those.oohaahmortimer said:
Shame he’s put the wrong year on the play off winners plaque 🤦♂️Talal said:0 -
The playoff date on the medal doesn’t match the plaque.Henry Irving said:
And taken them out of their boxes although he may still have those.oohaahmortimer said:
Shame he’s put the wrong year on the play off winners plaque 🤦♂️Talal said:0 -
Yes, but JR has probably had that done himself.Redrobo said:
The playoff date on the medal doesn’t match the plaque.Henry Irving said:
And taken them out of their boxes although he may still have those.oohaahmortimer said:
Shame he’s put the wrong year on the play off winners plaque 🤦♂️Talal said:
These actually look like the pitch presentation medals.
Players got two medals in 2000. One a big shinny one on a colourful ribbon to wear around their neck which looks better on TV and a smaller, more traditional medal in a presentation box. Will have a look to see if we have photos of Clive's medals.
We also have Shaun Newton's presentation medal from 2000 in the museum plus a spare that Chris Parkes found in a drawer at the training ground years later and gave to us that we let kids wear for photos in the museum.1 -
Interested in the shirt if anyone can put me in contact with him?0
-
was there ever a view on here of value?I was thinking £3k - £4k but may be way over?0
-
I think it is so completely unique and individual that a value is almost impossible. It will just be whatever a reasonably wealthy fan is prepared to pay in the day and could range fairly significantly I imagine.1
-
Probably why it should be publicly auctioned.1
-
Sponsored links:
-
I’m no expert but I’d guess you could get the play off shirt for £1500 at the most .SporadicAddick said:was there ever a view on here of value?I was thinking £3k - £4k but may be way over?2 -
Apparently it’s a secret that only certain posters are allowed to know 😀SporadicAddick said:was there ever a view on here of value?I was thinking £3k - £4k but may be way over?3 -
Personally i think he'd be mad to sell them via the channels he's going through at the moment. If he sold them at a club dinner event or 'an evening with' event or something like that i think he'd make far more.
There would likely be wealthy fans who go to that type of event who probably don't even know he's selling them.2 -
Agreed, an auction at a club dinnerChris_from_Sidcup said:Personally i think he'd be mad to sell them via the channels he's going through at the moment. If he sold them at a club dinner event or 'an evening with' event or something like that i think he'd make far more.
There would likely be wealthy fans who go to that type of event who probably don't even know he's selling them.0 -
Would be a bit of a bargain, in my opinion.Bedsaddick said:
I’m no expert but I’d guess you could get the play off shirt for £1500 at the most .SporadicAddick said:was there ever a view on here of value?I was thinking £3k - £4k but may be way over?
Dobson's shirt from the United game last season went for 700 quid which shows what an auction can do.0 -
No one ‘knows’ but it is pretty obvious that £300 or whatever amount was asked, is not going to be the price.valleynick66 said:
Apparently it’s a secret that only certain posters are allowed to know 😀SporadicAddick said:was there ever a view on here of value?I was thinking £3k - £4k but may be way over?3 -
Well it looks like a real Charlton supporter living out there has got his hands on the shirt & it was delivered personally.
Good man.
He seems delighted not only to have the shirt but to have met his hero.
Everyones a winner 🤩♥️5 -
Jonny R was always my son Rory's favorite player so to have the opportunity to meet him in person over a few beers and buy his playoff final shirt could not be passed by . . . could do with Jonny in our current Team . . . !!!KBslittlesis said:Well it looks like a real Charlton supporter living out there has got his hands on the shirt & it was delivered personally.
Good man.
He seems delighted not only to have the shirt but to have met his hero.
Everyones a winner 🤩♥️2 -
Auction is always a good place to go - especially one of these charity dinners where the wine is flowing.
One of my investors went to a charity dinner for our chairman's foundation - where all kinds of sporting memorabilia was going. He got pissed and paid £10k for a pair of Usain Bolts running spikes. His wife went bat shit at him when he rolled in at 5am holding a half eaten kebab, steaming drunk, with a pair of running shoes hanging by the laces round his neck.4 -
Ouch!!DamoNorthStand said:Auction is always a good place to go - especially one of these charity dinners where the wine is flowing.
One of my investors went to a charity dinner for our chairman's foundation - where all kinds of sporting memorabilia was going. He got pissed and paid £10k for a pair of Usain Bolts running spikes. His wife went bat shit at him when he rolled in at 5am holding a half eaten kebab, steaming drunk, with a pair of running shoes hanging by the laces round his neck.
These went for £900
2
