Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
John Robinson selling play off final shirt
Comments
-
-
Agreed.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It must be so hard watching footballers from that era sit back and watch the money thrown at the absolute shite playing in league one.KBslittlesis said:It’s a fairly recent phenomenon that footballers are rich and stay rich.
Most of those who played in our early prem days still have to hold down a job to pay the bills.
Whilst it’s very sad he has to part with things we, as fans, think are beyond value. I completely understand why he chooses to.
C’est la vie.
And probably why Brownie is so hard on them on comms.
I don’t blame him one bit tbh.3 -
These things don’t always mean as much to players as fans think they do. If players want to make a few quid from what they have good luck to them. Don't automatically mean they are on the breadline, might want a new kitchen and see something like this a small a way of eating into the costs.
Don’t agree with ‘buying’ them and then telling them to keep em. If you want to give someone money then just write them a cheque.8 -
Does the museum have the funds to buy it? If not could we not have a Charlton Life whip round? I'd rather see it in the museum for all to enjoy.6
-
We have three shirts from that PO Final. Mendonca's , Brown's (both on loan) and a signed no.18 which we assume was a spare.LargeAddick said:Does the museum have the funds to buy it? If not could we not have a Charlton Life whip round? I'd rather see it in the museum for all to enjoy.
We'd love to have another but we have to balance what we spend on what funds/income we have.
Agree with AFKA that players often see these items in a different way to fans.
But regardless it is his to do with as he wishes.
We're contacting him to offer help with valuation.2 -
I wonder if Michael Gray would like to flog his, I'd be interested in buying it
11 -
Robbo is a Charlton legend.1
-
3 seems a decent number of playoff shirts, I imagine there a shirts from other important games which would add more to the "Charlton story".Henry Irving said:
We have three shirts from that PO Final. Mendonca's , Brown's (both on loan) and a signed no.18 which we assume was a spare.LargeAddick said:Does the museum have the funds to buy it? If not could we not have a Charlton Life whip round? I'd rather see it in the museum for all to enjoy.
We'd love to have another but we have to balance what we spend on what funds/income we have.
Agree with AFKA that players often see these items in a different way to fans.
But regardless it is his to do with as he wishes.
We're contacting him to offer help with valuation.
Players do a accumulate a lot of memorabilia, with all the shirt swapping. I imagine Robbo has some decent ones from his Welsh career.1 -
'Fast buck' is pretty shitty tbh. The saddest part is its not substantial money either.sillav nitram said:
I don’t think I’ve said anything of the kind, I said, I obviously I don’t know the reason.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It’s bizarre you’d suggest the possibility of there being anything untoward in his decision to sell what must be very important items.sillav nitram said:
It’s bizarre that you should think it so? Do you not hold sentiment and memory as a value?shine166 said:
Bizarresillav nitram said:Seems quite sad that he's selling something so memorable, both to him, his teammates and fans alike.
Obviously I don't know the reason but I hope its not to make a fast buck as IMHO it devalues the whole experience.
It’s amazing how some can turn everything into an argument, seeing things that are not there?
That Play Off final holds much emotional sentiment for me and I cherish the fact that I was there to witness one of the best games of football that involved our club and I’m ever likely to see, how often can we say that?I’ve still got a lot of memorabilia of that day and wouldn’t throw it out, the sentiment is important to me but clearly not others it seems.
Even though the players may not of been boyhood Charlton fans I would have thought the game would have emotional sentiment for them too but perhaps not.2 -
Sponsored links:
-
Oh please get off yer high horse and do one.shine166 said:
'Fast buck' is pretty shitty tbh. The saddest part is its not substantial money either.sillav nitram said:
I don’t think I’ve said anything of the kind, I said, I obviously I don’t know the reason.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It’s bizarre you’d suggest the possibility of there being anything untoward in his decision to sell what must be very important items.sillav nitram said:
It’s bizarre that you should think it so? Do you not hold sentiment and memory as a value?shine166 said:
Bizarresillav nitram said:Seems quite sad that he's selling something so memorable, both to him, his teammates and fans alike.
Obviously I don't know the reason but I hope its not to make a fast buck as IMHO it devalues the whole experience.
It’s amazing how some can turn everything into an argument, seeing things that are not there?
That Play Off final holds much emotional sentiment for me and I cherish the fact that I was there to witness one of the best games of football that involved our club and I’m ever likely to see, how often can we say that?I’ve still got a lot of memorabilia of that day and wouldn’t throw it out, the sentiment is important to me but clearly not others it seems.
Even though the players may not of been boyhood Charlton fans I would have thought the game would have emotional sentiment for them too but perhaps not.0 -
Why can't you just admit you made a shitty comment and you "do one". Fool.sillav nitram said:
Oh please get off yer high horse and do one.shine166 said:
'Fast buck' is pretty shitty tbh. The saddest part is its not substantial money either.sillav nitram said:
I don’t think I’ve said anything of the kind, I said, I obviously I don’t know the reason.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It’s bizarre you’d suggest the possibility of there being anything untoward in his decision to sell what must be very important items.sillav nitram said:
It’s bizarre that you should think it so? Do you not hold sentiment and memory as a value?shine166 said:
Bizarresillav nitram said:Seems quite sad that he's selling something so memorable, both to him, his teammates and fans alike.
Obviously I don't know the reason but I hope its not to make a fast buck as IMHO it devalues the whole experience.
It’s amazing how some can turn everything into an argument, seeing things that are not there?
That Play Off final holds much emotional sentiment for me and I cherish the fact that I was there to witness one of the best games of football that involved our club and I’m ever likely to see, how often can we say that?I’ve still got a lot of memorabilia of that day and wouldn’t throw it out, the sentiment is important to me but clearly not others it seems.
Even though the players may not of been boyhood Charlton fans I would have thought the game would have emotional sentiment for them too but perhaps not.4 -
No idea what he would be looking at for it, but Id potentially be interested in the play-off one0
-
Goes without saying that you have to join in, that's you all over.Off_it said:
Why can't you just admit you made a shitty comment and you "do one". Fool.sillav nitram said:
Oh please get off yer high horse and do one.shine166 said:
'Fast buck' is pretty shitty tbh. The saddest part is its not substantial money either.sillav nitram said:
I don’t think I’ve said anything of the kind, I said, I obviously I don’t know the reason.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It’s bizarre you’d suggest the possibility of there being anything untoward in his decision to sell what must be very important items.sillav nitram said:
It’s bizarre that you should think it so? Do you not hold sentiment and memory as a value?shine166 said:
Bizarresillav nitram said:Seems quite sad that he's selling something so memorable, both to him, his teammates and fans alike.
Obviously I don't know the reason but I hope its not to make a fast buck as IMHO it devalues the whole experience.
It’s amazing how some can turn everything into an argument, seeing things that are not there?
That Play Off final holds much emotional sentiment for me and I cherish the fact that I was there to witness one of the best games of football that involved our club and I’m ever likely to see, how often can we say that?I’ve still got a lot of memorabilia of that day and wouldn’t throw it out, the sentiment is important to me but clearly not others it seems.
Even though the players may not of been boyhood Charlton fans I would have thought the game would have emotional sentiment for them too but perhaps not.
2 -
If you say so mate. I was already involved in the thread, but if you say so. (*smiles and laughs)sillav nitram said:
Goes without saying that you have to join in, that's you all over.Off_it said:
Why can't you just admit you made a shitty comment and you "do one". Fool.sillav nitram said:
Oh please get off yer high horse and do one.shine166 said:
'Fast buck' is pretty shitty tbh. The saddest part is its not substantial money either.sillav nitram said:
I don’t think I’ve said anything of the kind, I said, I obviously I don’t know the reason.Stu_of_Kunming said:
It’s bizarre you’d suggest the possibility of there being anything untoward in his decision to sell what must be very important items.sillav nitram said:
It’s bizarre that you should think it so? Do you not hold sentiment and memory as a value?shine166 said:
Bizarresillav nitram said:Seems quite sad that he's selling something so memorable, both to him, his teammates and fans alike.
Obviously I don't know the reason but I hope its not to make a fast buck as IMHO it devalues the whole experience.
It’s amazing how some can turn everything into an argument, seeing things that are not there?
That Play Off final holds much emotional sentiment for me and I cherish the fact that I was there to witness one of the best games of football that involved our club and I’m ever likely to see, how often can we say that?I’ve still got a lot of memorabilia of that day and wouldn’t throw it out, the sentiment is important to me but clearly not others it seems.
Even though the players may not of been boyhood Charlton fans I would have thought the game would have emotional sentiment for them too but perhaps not.0 -
I don’t know if it’s because too many people have responded to this but his account is currently not accepting messages from those who are not friends, and it doesn’t seem possible to make a friend request.
0 -
Much appreciated mateMuttleyCAFC said:Robbo is a Charlton legend.1 -
I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?0 -
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?0 -
So is Michael Gray.MuttleyCAFC said:Robbo is a Charlton legend.1 -
Sponsored links:
-
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?2 -
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?7 -
Let's put it this way, Leaburn's shirt from the draw against Stevenage went for £307. This is from what many call the greatest game in the club's history.2
-
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.3 -
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.0 -
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.2 -
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?
2 -
Maybe I misunderstood but the earlier post suggested @henryirving did have a view on the sums.North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?Moreover as I said I simply don’t know.My guess would be relatively modest sums as I doubt it’s a desired item to all but Charlton fans.0 -
No it's not!North Lower Neil said:
How's he supposed to know? Depends on how much John Robinson might sell for, and how much a buyer is willing to pay.valleynick66 said:
Why forever not? Wasn’t the original post about generating interest in the shirts?Henry Irving said:
No thanksvalleynick66 said:
That really isn’t a helpful response.Henry Irving said:
Ok, if you're going to be like that forget I said anythingR0TW said:
So what would? Mr font of all knowledge?Henry Irving said:
noR0TW said:I would love to have a bid on it. The hardest working player I can remember in a Charlton shirt.
Would £300 touch the sides?State a ballpark.I suspect most of us don’t have a clue what sums are being discussed.
ROTW asked if £300 would get close, Henry and Talal have said no.
Bizarre the things people bicker about. If you're potentially interested and maybe want to know a price, go on the Facebook message or get hold of Dubai like he's offered on the first page?2 -
Pure guesswork but I imagine 2k gets it.CAFCsayer said:No idea what he would be looking at for it, but Id potentially be interested in the play-off one0
https://youtu.be/C2cMG33mWVY?si=zUYKMAZ3PwdDK6I3
