Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

POST-MATCH THREAD: Charlton Athletic v Reading: Saturday 4th January 2025: KO 15:00

145791012

Comments

  • We do have someone who can deliver a deadball accurately. 

    Terry Taylor.

    Only problem is Jones doesn't rate him.
    Could maybe argue he should be on the bench but he just isn’t good enough for the starting eleven 
  • edited January 4
    23 games played and 34 points attained.

    Need 41 from the remaining 23 to get to the 75 mark that’s usually needed for top six.
    Brum, Wycombe, Wrexham & Stockport all away from home will be a tough ask 
    On the other end though, that means there’s plenty of poor teams still to come to the Valley where picking off three points consistently will be critical.

    We can do it. 12 points from the last six with only two goals conceded and four clean sheets so recent form is tracking the right way.
    Win all our remaining home games and pick up a point at every away equals 79 points. 

    It’s not going to happen.

    Blame first half of season for our downfall .
    Blimey. Sack the rest of the season off then. See you in August!
    Come back to me in August. 

    Anything other than a play-off finish is failure.
    No its not they want  an improvement on last season as the first step in the process.… top 10 would be an improvement.…… 


    You know my comment is correct...One place above our finish last season would be an improvement..,.,
    What process is this?....,.,.
  • Simonsen said:
    Lastly, Campbell rolling around on the deck long after being flagged was hilarious. GREAT finish but nicely comical too. One for the dressing room fines' committee, that one. Ps...he didn't have a bad game at all....very wholehearted. 
    Annoyingly they cut to the lino flagging before the attempted knee slide on the ITV coverage, but a kind soul on twitter clipped it up for the enjoyment of those of us who missed the game.
  • the minutes applause for the dead should have been at 2.50 before the players comeout not at 2.58 so as not to have to rush it at the end before kick off
  • TeeC said:
    supaclive said:
    I enjoyed that today.   We were SO much better than we have been.   Gillesphey weak link.   Keeper's distribution is poor.  But we worked damn hard.

    Jones (Lloyd) brilliant.  TC worked tirelessly.  Leaburn caused them problems.  Small needs a little more composure 

    Left sided centre half
    Attacking midfielder
    Goalkeeper (Reading's preferably)

    PLEASE

    Their GK couldn’t kick and all the saves he made were  because the shots ended up being comfortably in reach
    And he fumbled a cross straight to the feet of Leaburn. I’d be gutted if we signed him. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • The biggest question of the day. Did those 50 pissed up Reading get to the Antigallican, and did they order peanuts or pork scratchings?
  • Happy to be critical when it's deserved but overall there are 0-0's and then there are 0-0's, and this was a 0-0.
  • edited January 5
    Great performance and a good unbeaten run over the last few games. Unfortunately our poor form over Sept to early Dec has given us too much to do in the 2nd half of the season to reach the playoffs. We would need to go on league winners form from here, and I just dont see that happening. Ultimately I think we will finish around 10th.
  • Entertaining last 30 as Reading tired, but up to then, they were the better team. We lack quality. Bad first touches, poor passing, rushed finishing and no creativity going forward. Maybe the pitch is a factor, or maybe it's just mid-table League One football. I imagine we are coming out of this seasons purple patch now. Rotherham away will be tough.


  • We are only two points behind the 20/21 and 17/18 teams which finished 7th (on goal difference) and 6th respectively.
    Your optimism/wumming will be slammed in your face if the s*** hits the fan at the end of the season.
  • We do have someone who can deliver a deadball accurately. 

    Terry Taylor.

    Only problem is Jones doesn't rate him.
    The problem is that dead ball situations are the only thing he does do, in a Jones formation/set up. He's not as defensively sound as Coventry, he's not particularly dynamic and doesn't really suit a pressing game. 

    He's a very good player but doesn't fit into the way that Jones wants to play sadly. He'll probably be very good at this level and maybe even higher but he's not kept out of the squad just out of spite and stubbornness. Good player but at the wrong place at the wrong time.
  • Sponsored links:


  • wmcf123 said:
    wmcf123 said:
    Small is the biggest enigma in the side. 80% of what he does is utterly brilliant & the other 20% is absolutely horrendous 😂😂
    I’ll take the 80%.  Him and Campbell are the reason why we’ve somewhat improved .  
    Oh absolutely he’s great. Just has some very funny brain fades 
    He wouldn’t be in league 1 if he had consistent end product  
    His end product is consistent, and woefully poor. I can’t remember a player who promises so much in the build up, and delivers so little. 
  • Cloudworm said:
    Entertaining last 30 as Reading tired, but up to then, they were the better team. We lack quality. Bad first touches, poor passing, rushed finishing and no creativity going forward. Maybe the pitch is a factor, or maybe it's just mid-table League One football. I imagine we are coming out of this seasons purple patch now. Rotherham away will be tough.
    Next time get a seat that can see the pitch... Reading were not in that game.. One effort in 95 mins and that was following a mistake by Leaburn.. We battered them secind half one the best 45 mins seen at the valley.. we were by far the better team, there keeper had one of them lucky days. 
  • Decent enough but a lack of quality when it mattered , their keeper got one in the nuts and was pony after that .
    Were any of their handball shouts close , I thought we looked a bit John Terry handsy on occasions looking to charge down defensively .
    Tremendous effort from our team but we didn’t really make much noise I could hear the Reading fans a lot more from halfway line .
    TC was man of the match in the lounges .
    Good day for thermals and golf hand warmer thingys , my toes struggled just a pair of old school ski socks and trainers on , inappropriate footwear for the conditions .


    saw Shaun Derry a bit lost in the prawn sandwich areas and he was looking for the boardroom, just googled he was with O’Neil at Wolves till recently and has a 17.5 year old son in the palace academy , Jesse , who’s a winger and England u 18 international .

  • Well he was definitely in an offside position.


    You then have to go to the rule book which changed last season I believe.

    In addition, IFAB provides these indicators as to when a player "deliberately played" the ball:

    - The ball had travelled from distance and the players had a clear view of it
    - The ball was not moving quickly
    - The direction of the ball was not unexpected
    - The player had time to coordinate their body movement
    - A ball moving on the ground is easier to play than a ball in the air


    I think you could put a X in a good few of those.

    Offside for me.


  • Thought it was an entertaining game and Reading gave us a few problems. They had loads of luck when the guy cleared it off the line looks like it just hit him rather than anything else.

    Good to see Chiucks come on and give them something else to think about. Another day those chances go in but fair play to Reading they have a great set of youngsters, their manager walked out and their (are/were) under a transfer embargo.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!