Famewo and Millar are no where near PL ready so we should be trying to get them back on loan. If we can buy them perm even better as they both have plenty of potential to improve with us but that may be a long shot. Get Stockley, renew Aneke. Would be a good start.
Millar is dogshit really, reckon there's many young wingers from the Prem that would be 10x more effective than he was
No chance but Ronan Curtis looks a very good player on the left but probably destined for a higher league.
Famewo and Millar are no where near PL ready so we should be trying to get them back on loan. If we can buy them perm even better as they both have plenty of potential to improve with us but that may be a long shot. Get Stockley, renew Aneke. Would be a good start.
Millar is dogshit really, reckon there's many young wingers from the Prem that would be 10x more effective than he was
I don’t rate him that highly but he’s done better than a lot of loans we’ve had in the past, he’s got a decent return in both goals and assists.
We need to do what hayes said powell said when convincing him to join and snap up as much of the top talent in league 1 / top league 2 in there prime with the poss of growing still if we go up
money talks at end of the day and if you offer what the club wants plus good wages they will come ! and i know its not my/our money so easy to say but if we steal players from rival clubs and make them weaker it wld be perfect
Famewo and Millar are no where near PL ready so we should be trying to get them back on loan. If we can buy them perm even better as they both have plenty of potential to improve with us but that may be a long shot. Get Stockley, renew Aneke. Would be a good start.
Millar is dogshit really, reckon there's many young wingers from the Prem that would be 10x more effective than he was
MIllar is a lot better than that - he has scared a good few fullbacks since we signed him. He needs to polish his final decision making and develop an ability to go both ways more often instead of usually always cutting inside onto his right, but he's a very young player so no reason to expect he would be the finished article yet. I'd take him on a permanent but not loan, and I'd want to sign a more experienced winger as well, someone closer to the finished article with more consistent end product.
We need to do what hayes said powell said when convincing him to join and snap up as much of the top talent in league 1 / top league 2 in there prime with the poss of growing still if we go up
money talks at end of the day and if you offer what the club wants plus good wages they will come ! and i know its not my/our money so easy to say but if we steal players from rival clubs and make them weaker it wld be perfect
Plus Nigel’s boundless enthusiasm. Think it’s going to be a good summer.
I’ve been told that aneke didn’t turn up for contract talks as he thinks he can get a championship gig.
He’s clearly too talented to be in League One. But on the other hand, he can only play 30 minutes a week.
I’m not sure we should be building a squad around players who can’t stay fit. That’s been part of our undoing the last couple of years.
Give me someone like Pigott over Chuks every time.
This is true but if a championship side is after him then they likely only want him as a backup striker anyway, so he can get a decent contract and sit on the bench.
GK is an interesting one for me. I’m not sure we’ll start with Amos next season.
Can't see any reason not to retain Amos, personally. Think he's a very good season and earnt us a good number of points. Just today there was a key save at 0-0 early in the first half.
GK is an interesting one for me. I’m not sure we’ll start with Amos next season.
You maybe right as someone said on here - so it must be true, mustn't it - that his missus wanted to go back north.
Personally, I hope he stays. He's a perfectly capable keeper at this level with a solid defence in front of him. And, in fact, he catches the ball from crosses as well as any Charlton goalkeeper I have ever seen - and that's important at this level.
Long term I would have a little bet that Maynard-Brewer is in with a chance of establishing himself but he probably needs a year out on loan somewhere. (That was really beneficial for Phillips when he did that).
All that said, if Dillon Phillips doesn;'t want to sit on the subs bench all next year, I'd love to have him back!
Adkins must already have it in his head who he wants to keep if the meetings are on Tuesday. I think there might be some surprises on Friday when the list is made public. I dont get the people saying millar is shite. He is 21 and yes obviously needs to develop but if you think we will get better at the moment I think your dreaming. Bags of potential and will grow into a top class winger imo. All I keep thinking to myself is how great it is that for once we are making decisions early and I think we will also get signings completed early rather than waiting to see who is available at the end at bargain basement terms. I wonder if that young lad (cant remember his name sorry) that was linked to us from national league will reappear ?
Adkins must already have it in his head who he wants to keep if the meetings are on Tuesday. I think there might be some surprises on Friday when the list is made public. I dont get the people saying millar is shite. He is 21 and yes obviously needs to develop but if you think we will get better at the moment I think your dreaming. Bags of potential and will grow into a top class winger imo. All I keep thinking to myself is how great it is that for once we are making decisions early and I think we will also get signings completed early rather than waiting to see who is available at the end at bargain basement terms. I wonder if that young lad (cant remember his name sorry) that was linked to us from national league will reappear ?
I assume you mean Sorba Thomas, he signed for Huddersfield in January.
Adkins must already have it in his head who he wants to keep if the meetings are on Tuesday. I think there might be some surprises on Friday when the list is made public. I dont get the people saying millar is shite. He is 21 and yes obviously needs to develop but if you think we will get better at the moment I think your dreaming. Bags of potential and will grow into a top class winger imo. All I keep thinking to myself is how great it is that for once we are making decisions early and I think we will also get signings completed early rather than waiting to see who is available at the end at bargain basement terms. I wonder if that young lad (cant remember his name sorry) that was linked to us from national league will reappear ?
Me neither. He's far from the finished item but if anyone thinks we are going to get miles better in League 1 they are not being very realistic.
Unreliable source says Shane Ferguson from the Toolbox.
You aren't that unreliable.
Thanks but I'm not the source
I understand from a 'Millwall mate' that he was close to signing on deadline day (Cowley tweeted similar). When this didn't happen we went for Josh Morris at Fleetwood which also fell through
Would he still be a target for Nigel? I would see him as a squad player but as a versatile left sider a useful one.
Comments
He can’t keep what’s wrong “confidential” in those situations.
money talks at end of the day and if you offer what the club wants plus good wages they will come ! and i know its not my/our money so easy to say but if we steal players from rival clubs and make them weaker it wld be perfect
Personally, I hope he stays. He's a perfectly capable keeper at this level with a solid defence in front of him. And, in fact, he catches the ball from crosses as well as any Charlton goalkeeper I have ever seen - and that's important at this level.
Long term I would have a little bet that Maynard-Brewer is in with a chance of establishing himself but he probably needs a year out on loan somewhere. (That was really beneficial for Phillips when he did that).
All that said, if Dillon Phillips doesn;'t want to sit on the subs bench all next year, I'd love to have him back!
Could potentially get a 2 year deal as a squad player at somewhere like (for example) QPR and be used as an impact sub.
Would you rather bring on Bonne with 20 minutes to go or Aneke?
Amos is 50/50.
Not it bothered about keeping any of the other out of contract players.
stockley on a perm would be good.
Here's an actual rumour.
Unreliable source says Shane Ferguson from the Toolbox.
I dont get the people saying millar is shite. He is 21 and yes obviously needs to develop but if you think we will get better at the moment I think your dreaming. Bags of potential and will grow into a top class winger imo.
All I keep thinking to myself is how great it is that for once we are making decisions early and I think we will also get signings completed early rather than waiting to see who is available at the end at bargain basement terms.
I wonder if that young lad (cant remember his name sorry) that was linked to us from national league will reappear ?
Would he still be a target for Nigel? I would see him as a squad player but as a versatile left sider a useful one.