Airman, sorry if I've missed this but precisely what form of recognition are you suggesting? Is it to name a stand or is it something else. I am all in favour of him being recognised, but I am not yet ready to commit to stand-naming. We only have three un-named stands and the whole future to label them. I'd prefer to keep our powder dry in the hope of a more illustrious future.
What are the chances of us having a manager who lasts in the job for 15+ years, gets us promoted to the Premier League twice (and keeps us there), oversees the club’s greatest game (Wembley 1998), brings in legendary players like Powell/Mendonca/Hunt/Bowyer/Kinsella/Di Canio/Rufus/Brown/Robinson/Kiely/Parker etc, whilst providing enough firepower for the club to double the capacity of the stadium?
If we’re going to have *three* more managers who go and exceed the above in their own way then I’ll be thrilled - but it’s not going to happen in our lifetimes.
The chances are low. Not sure what the relevance of 'our lifetimes' is though. I want the club to last longer than all of us.
Because it’s the fan base of the here and now who are voting for it. He represents the modern era of Charlton in a way very few, if any, can match.
If we just say that we’ll have to wait and see who can exceed his achievements, then we’ll be waiting forever. And then if someone does come along and wins us the FA Cup, then the logic would be suggested that we should wait for someone to come along and win us the Premier League. Where does the line sit for someone who is stand-worthy?
We have to be realistic and recognise that Curbishley’s contribution to Charlton is likely to be as good as we get for a club of our size.
On top of this, he is probably the most iconic figure of our club to the outside footballing world. If you go on holiday and someone sees you out and about in a Charlton shirt - who is the first name they bring up? Alan Curbishley.
Airman, sorry if I've missed this but precisely what form of recognition are you suggesting? Is it to name a stand or is it something else. I am all in favour of him being recognised, but I am not yet ready to commit to stand-naming. We only have three un-named stands and the whole future to label them. I'd prefer to keep our powder dry in the hope of a more illustrious future.
What are the chances of us having a manager who lasts in the job for 15+ years, gets us promoted to the Premier League twice (and keeps us there), oversees the club’s greatest game (Wembley 1998), brings in legendary players like Powell/Mendonca/Hunt/Bowyer/Kinsella/Di Canio/Rufus/Brown/Robinson/Kiely/Parker etc, whilst providing enough firepower for the club to double the capacity of the stadium?
If we’re going to have *three* more managers who go and exceed the above in their own way then I’ll be thrilled - but it’s not going to happen in our lifetimes.
The chances are low. Not sure what the relevance of 'our lifetimes' is though. I want the club to last longer than all of us.
The relevance of "our lifetimes" is mute, the relevance of the life time of the stands isn't. Or for that matter the life expectancy of football its self.
Joking aside, I quite like the sound of 'The Alan Curbishley Covered End'.
Plus it was essentially funded off the back of the sustained success he brought to the club wasn't it?
The two greatest managers of our first 100 years opposite each other.
Sort of means we are just renaming one of the two already named stands, and leaves two available for when we get to the Champions League within six years or whatever the current plan is!
An excellent idea, I've always been a fan of having "named" stands, rather than the boring North, South, East, West or the rather desperate sounding "Perkins replacement windows stand". It's a great way of honouring club legends, and works especially well when you have clearly defined separate stands, rather than a continuous bowl
Similarly, I was pleased when the club "officially" gave the Covered End its name
This is long overdue, and the naming of the North Stand would be completely appropriate. The Covered end was effectively closed forever in 2001. The replacement North Stand was largely down to the efforts of Curbs, supported by many others, but the increase of the grounds capacity from 20k to 27k was all due to him completely overachieving in his job.
Airman, sorry if I've missed this but precisely what form of recognition are you suggesting? Is it to name a stand or is it something else. I am all in favour of him being recognised, but I am not yet ready to commit to stand-naming. We only have three un-named stands and the whole future to label them. I'd prefer to keep our powder dry in the hope of a more illustrious future.
3 unnamed stands so I think its about time after 116 years we recognised someone else with one of the stands. He is the stand out candidate for the North Stand to be named after due to how it was built due mainly due to his outstanding achievements.
This is long overdue, and the naming of the North Stand would be completely appropriate. The Covered end was effectively closed forever in 2001. The replacement North Stand was largely down to the efforts of Curbs, supported by many others, but the increase of the grounds capacity from 20k to 27k was all due to him completely overachieving in his job.
I’ve a slightly different view, the Covered End to me will always be ‘the fans stand’ and the heartbeat of the club and The Valley (and I say that as someone whose sat elsewhere in recent years).
I’d rather it not associated with an individual, and if it ever was, would need to be someone in the ‘darling of the Covered End’ category like say Killer.
Curbs is a Charlton legend and was fantastic for our club, but he was never ever a ‘darling of the Covered End’ imo.
This is long overdue, and the naming of the North Stand would be completely appropriate. The Covered end was effectively closed forever in 2001. The replacement North Stand was largely down to the efforts of Curbs, supported by many others, but the increase of the grounds capacity from 20k to 27k was all due to him completely overachieving in his job.
I’ve a slightly different view, the Covered End to me will always be ‘the fans stand’ and the heartbeat of the club and The Valley (and I say that as someone whose sat elsewhere in recent years).
I’d rather it not associated with an individual, and if it ever was, would need to be someone in the ‘darling of the Covered End’ category like say Killer.
Curbs is a Charlton legend and was fantastic for our club, but he was never ever a ‘darling of the Covered End’ imo.
Agree, it should be the East or West. The West would probably be a better fit? As it was built, as is now, as a direct result of him being there.
With the West Stand being developed in line with our first Premier League run, I’ve always felt it would be appropriate for Curbs.
All other stands already have their own identity (Covered End, Jimmy Seed stand, and the East Stand having the ‘old East terrace’ folklore), whereas the West is a bit non-descript and can do with an update in status
With the West Stand being developed in line with our first Premier League run, I’ve always felt it would be appropriate for Curbs.
All other stands already have their own identity (Covered End, Jimmy Seed stand, and the East Stand having the ‘old East terrace’ folklore), whereas the West is a bit non-descript and can do with an update in status
At Old Trafford for example, the 2 names stands are the side ones (after Ferguson and Bobby Charlton), at Anfield it's a side stand named after Dalglish.
Definitely feel there’s a discussion / debate to be had on it, but not sure imo if a petition is the right way to go about it.
As we saw with Roland, EFL and Government petitions during the protesting, you just don’t get the numbers to support that you’d like or reflect what you think is strength of feeling / support. We learnt through that, there’s a general petition-signing reluctance, lethargy and big numbers not social media / online active.
And If you don’t then get the numbers to support, does that then provide an alternative argument against, that there is a degree of indifference, that probably would not have been there had it looked to be progressed in an alternative approach?
Here's a thought. We name the stand after him. He becomes Palace manager. We ok with that? (The name thing, I mean. He's entitled to take any job he wants).
If you read the article the North Stand has been officially named The Covered End so it’s either the West Stand or the East Stand. Either would be fine with me unless Curbs has a preference.
Here's a thought. We name the stand after him. He becomes Palace manager. We ok with that? (The name thing, I mean. He's entitled to take any job he wants).
There's little chance of that now, he's been out of the game so long, you can safely put him in the category of ex football managers
Three of our stands already have names. The Jimmy Seed, The Covered End and The East Stand. The latter two evolved and are as much a part of our history (perhaps morso) than Curbs. I'd hate to see them change.
So that leaves the West Stand. I like it being the west stand.
I have to say that I'd prefer different recognition. Lets create an avenue of statues. We already have one. Curbs could be no. 2. There could be a group statue based on the 47 cup winning team picture with Don Welsh on shoulders. There could be Clive Mendonca with that pose, etc etc. Loads of moments to commemorate..
I think we should re name the East Stand the Les Berry Stand in recognition for the amount of long clearances that ended up on the East Terrace......Only joking of course good old Les!
Comments
If we just say that we’ll have to wait and see who can exceed his achievements, then we’ll be waiting forever. And then if someone does come along and wins us the FA Cup, then the logic would be suggested that we should wait for someone to come along and win us the Premier League. Where does the line sit for someone who is stand-worthy?
We have to be realistic and recognise that Curbishley’s contribution to Charlton is likely to be as good as we get for a club of our size.
Next we can name the North Stand toilets the Southall Shitter
Plus it was essentially funded off the back of the sustained success he brought to the club wasn't it?
The two greatest managers of our first 100 years opposite each other.
Sort of means we are just renaming one of the two already named stands, and leaves two available for when we get to the Champions League within six years or whatever the current plan is!
Have signed. It's a good initiative.
Similarly, I was pleased when the club "officially" gave the Covered End its name
New Voice has landed here too this morning.
Good idea but think Keith Peacock also deserves recognition
All other stands already have their own identity (Covered End, Jimmy Seed stand, and the East Stand having the ‘old East terrace’ folklore), whereas the West is a bit non-descript and can do with an update in status
I would also go with naming the West Stand.
At Old Trafford for example, the 2 names stands are the side ones (after Ferguson and Bobby Charlton), at Anfield it's a side stand named after Dalglish.
As we saw with Roland, EFL and Government petitions during the protesting, you just don’t get the numbers to support that you’d like or reflect what you think is strength of feeling / support. We learnt through that, there’s a general petition-signing reluctance, lethargy and big numbers not social media / online active.
And If you don’t then get the numbers to support, does that then provide an alternative argument against, that there is a degree of indifference, that probably would not have been there had it looked to be progressed in an alternative approach?
Maybe i’m overthinking it.
also i know for a fact there was a few in the East that wanted rid of Curbs or for Curbs to have more ambition in his latter seasons at the club.
I'm not a fan of naming stands after individuals.
Three of our stands already have names. The Jimmy Seed, The Covered End and The East Stand. The latter two evolved and are as much a part of our history (perhaps morso) than Curbs. I'd hate to see them change.
So that leaves the West Stand. I like it being the west stand.
I have to say that I'd prefer different recognition. Lets create an avenue of statues. We already have one. Curbs could be no. 2. There could be a group statue based on the 47 cup winning team picture with Don Welsh on shoulders. There could be Clive Mendonca with that pose, etc etc. Loads of moments to commemorate..