Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Worst ever Charlton player

1235

Comments

  • Pawel Abbott and Amdy Faye for me.
  • Evina & Sordell.
  • Ralph Milne....only to find him popping up at Man U under Ferguson after he left us!!!
  • Terry Bullivant was pretty pony. Not in Amdy Faye's class i might add.
  • Good shout for Geoff Hammond. Both David Campbells were poor. There was a 5 ft 2 bloke who came from Brighton who was really poor - can't recall his name. Bullivant was supposed to be a good signing - he wasn't. Jason Lee played half a game in the mid 80s and was terrible but not so bad in his second spell. Alan Dugdale.
  • I don't remember amdy faye being that bad. But I don't remember him being good either. Just remembered frank nouble from a coupla years back. He was truly dire.
  • It's funny. Last season people were moaning at Powell for his left back choices. Playing Solly there, bringing in Seabourne on loan etc. Then he finally played Ceddy and he did the job and we all wondered why he couldn't have done that in the first place. Now some people are listing Ceddy as our worst ever player. Obviously he isn't, but it goes to show how quickly things can change in football. Maybe Powell was right to protect him a bit last season
  • Gary Churchouse, Billy Lansdowne, Hugh McAuley, Tony Towner, Viggo Jacobson, Johnny Ostergard and probably loads I've forgotten in the mists of time - we had tonnes of dross in the 70's and 80's

    Agree with McAuley....and your right we did have some crap players back then.
  • Ray Tumbridge; Jim Stannard; Tony Hazell; Peter Shaw and Lawrie Madden had some awful games; Gary Churchouse was very poor; Paul Davies and Billy Lansdowne came from bigger clubs but were very average players.
  • Simon Francis wins it easy for me
  • Sponsored links:


  • Dave Mehmet was pretty awful.
  • Dave Mehmet was pretty awful.

    How old would he be now? seem to remember him coming to our primary school.
  • edited February 2014

    Dave Mehmet was pretty awful.

    How old would he be now? seem to remember him coming to our primary school.
    Deptford lad, lived on The Pepys I think. I reckon he'd be about 52 now.

    Make that 53.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Mehmet
  • The "official" worst player is probably Rogers who played during the World War 2 when Jimmy Seed appealed for a guest professional (as was common in wartime).

    Seed subsequently admitted that he had been conned.
  • edited February 2014
    LenGlover said:

    The "official" worst player is probably Rogers who played during the World War 2 when Jimmy Seed appealed for a guest professional (as was common in wartime).

    Seed subsequently admitted that he had been conned.

    Did Pardew use that excuse for all the geniuses he recruited?
  • Traore was awful- makes evina look class!!! Also, Paul Gorman- way out of his depth, from Fisher to us!!
  • Evinas gotta go he is nowhere near good enough.

    Wasn't actually the worst I've seen him play last weekend , was even worse against Sheffield Wednesday at home.

    Evina didn't have a bad 1st half against Birmingham, defensively sound.
  • Dave Mehmet still playing vets even after treble heart by pass a few years back. Good lad.
  • dean chandler
  • Sponsored links:


  • Anyone remember Tom Hovi?
  • Players like Hovi, Chandler who only played a game or two, you put down as a worthwhile experiment. More baffling are the ones like Churchouse and Bacon who played a few times even though it was obvious that they weren't good enough.
  • Without doubt, Kenny Achampong.
  • OK redlanered and Richard J respect your opinions about Harry Cripps after all it is only about opinions and nothing else which goes to show how three people can watch a team and form completely different impressions of what we see which is why i like this site so much, when it isn't getting abusive that is.

  • Without doubt, Kenny Achampong.

    Kumbaya
  • Good shout for Geoff Hammond. Both David Campbells were poor. There was a 5 ft 2 bloke who came from Brighton who was really poor - can't recall his name. Bullivant was supposed to be a good signing - he wasn't. Jason Lee played half a game in the mid 80s and was terrible but not so bad in his second spell. Alan Dugdale.


    Was the 5ft 2 bloke from Brighton Peter O'Sullivan ?
  • Players like Maurice Setters, Eamon Rodgers, Eamon Dunphy and Harry Cripps were terrible playing for us but had decent careers before so dont think they should be counted. Roger Smart always struck me as a poor footballer.
  • Barry Endean, he even had the face and build of a pub team player.
  • Must add Bobby Goldthorpe to the list made big Dave Shipperley look a class act!. Loved Jim Giles but did not have a lot of ability.
  • Chris Bart williams
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!