Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Grand National 2025

1678911

Comments

  • Senior Chief still attracting money - available at 33s for 6 places but a number have cut him to 25s now.
    Perhaps there is a view that Rachel will choose him.
    There are some very interesting sectionals, courtesy of a GN blogger, for the Coral GC (in which he stayed on strongly into 6th) which show him quickening over the last furlong, rather than simply staying on past tired horses. Glad to have had a nibble e/w at 66 but will look to top up with extended places when they're offered.

    Minella Indo is 20/1 for 6 places but 50s if you're content with 5.
    I rewatched his season's bow in a Grade 3 at Puchestown over 23f on Gd/Y, in which he really ran a nice race, close 2nd in just 2.8 secs slow of std - Hewick was 4.5L behind giving Indo 6lbs. He gives him 4lbs in the GN and is generally 12s.
    3rd last year, at the end of his stamina on Soft, a most unlikely winner but there's plenty worse e/w value than the old boy. 

    I got the chief at 75-1 when you mentioned him ages ago but only four places unfortunately.  I forgot to check that bit. 
  • L'Homme Presse is a non runner. Anyone know who the reserves are?
  • L'Homme Presse is a non runner. Anyone know who the reserves are?
    Reserves will be decided after declarations, which is next Thursday.
    There’s a Confirmation stage on Monday first.
    Presumably he’ll come out then.
  • Conflated with an entry for the Bowl.
    To be sacrificed if needed for Three Card Brag perhaps.

  • Just looked on oddschecker and sky bet the only one giving 6 places
  • 801912601 said:
    Just looked on oddschecker and sky bet the only one giving 6 places
    I tend to put my bets on and then when/if the bookies start offering 7/8 places double up.
    Risky because you’ll likely double your losses/winnings.
    But I’ve never regretted it.
  • Shouldn't @PeanutsMolloy have his own articles in racing literature somewhere? Maybe he has? I don't know
    His insights for us bunch of numbskulls is something to behold!
    ;-)
    The depth of knowledge he provides on this particular event is astounding. We're lucky to have him.

    Long live Peanuts!



    Too kind.

    PS Mrs Molloy says “if you want him, you can have him”.
  • Sponsored links:


  • The nightmare dream is over.

    Mr Incredible is a non-runner.
  • The nightmare dream is over.

    Mr Incredible is a non-runner.
    Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
  • edited March 29
    Bluffers Guide continued .......

    Just rounding up the stragglers that might make the cut


    HORANTZAU D'AIRY

    Is nailed on to win because:
    • close 2nd in both Kerry and Munster Nationals in late summer (the former won by Montys Pass in his GN-winning season and the latter previously by the likes of Tiger Roll and The Big Dog), finishing 30L ahead of Perceval Legallois in the former
    • 8yo, 2nd season chaser, the sweetest of sweet spots: 5 of the last 9 GN winners (55.6%) from just 47 runners (13.5% = x4.1 outperformance)
    Has no chance because:
    • 3 flops in last 3 outings (well beaten in the Coral Gold Cup and Paddy Power Hdcp) and Ricci and Mullins have seen enough and sold him
    • dismal best chase RPR of 145, 3lbs lower than any horse to make the first 3 in a modern GN


    HYLAND

    Is nailed on because:
    • fine 2nd in Ladbrokes Trophy last outing notched a career best and GN-winning RPR154: GNOR+7lbs compared to ave +8lbs for last 11 winners
    • inherited from his mum the GN-outperforming mitochondrial DNA N2a: 4 of last 8 GN winners = x4.3 outperformance of representation
    Has no chance because:
    • won't get the trip: sired by Turgeon whose offspring have a record of 15 runs at 4m+ but not a single frame-maker
    • trained by Nicky Henderson: yet to break his GN duck after 43 attempts


    CELEBRE D'ALLEN

    Is nailed on because:
    • a winner at Aintree over 25f and beaten only 2L in last April's Topham over the GN fences
    • sired by Network: sire of 2 GN stalwarts, Saint Are and Delta Work
    Has no chance because:
    • 13 yo: other than on Soft or Heavy going (which is most unlikely), no 13yo has even made the frame since 1969


    FONTAINE COLLONGES

    Is nailed on because:
    • closely related to 2012 GN winner Neptune Collonges
    • trained by GN-winning Venetia Williams (scoring with 100/1 Mon Mome)
    Has no chance because:
    • 6 fails at 26~31f: 0PU9PP 
    • no mare has won the race since 1951


    THREE CARD BRAG

    Is nailed on because: 
    • nicely-handicapped off GNOR146: beaten last season only 5.5L by 160-rated Montys Star and <1L by 161-rated Corbetts Cross (RIP) 
    • half-brother of Scottish National 4th Idle Talk and related to x2 GN frame-maker Addington Boy
    • shares damsire Strong Gale with 3 GN frame-makers (Cappa Bleu x2, Teaforthree and Shutthefrontdoor)
    • trained by x3 GN winner Gordon Elliott
    Has no chance because:
    • wears black silks: 30 horses with predominantly black silks have run in the last 11 GNs - none has made the first 5 home

    TWIG

    Is nailed on because:
    • pedigree has strong GN winning connections: only 2nd son of Sulamani to run in a GN (the other was 2016 winner Rule The World) and shares damsire (Poliglote) with last year's winner I Am Maximus
    • 26f winner (furthest trip attempted) and on decent ground, as likely for 5 April
    • trainer (Ben Pauling) in great form: 6 wins from last 19 to run 
    Has no chance because:
    • hasn't won for almost 2 years, disappointing badly last run in ideal conditions
    • best chase RPR147 lower than any to make the first 3 home in a modern GN


    QUICK WAVE

    Is nailed on because:
    • related to 1982 GN winner Grittar and, more distantly, to 1987 winner Maori Venture
    • 2 wins from 3 runs at 3.5 miles+, notching 2 best RPRs; best 158 = GNOR+12lb (ave of last 11 GN winners GNOR+8lbs)
    • both those wins on GS, which is the probable going for 5 April
    Has no chance because:
    • 1 run (27L 6th) since a 25 month injury lay off: no horse with only 1 run in the prior 2 years has made the frame in a GN for at least 37 years 
    • the double-whammy: no mare has won the race since 1951 AND
    • wears black silks (0 frame-makers from 30 horses with predominantly black silks to run in GNs since 2013)

  • Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
    Indeed. I will miss the comedy element.
  • The nightmare dream is over.

    Mr Incredible is a non-runner.
    It's a shame  because he is a very good horse on his day but unfortunately has a mind of his own. 
    The right decision to let something else run. 
  • edited March 30
    Ok, I know you're gagging for more about mitochondrial DNA.
    So, to feed your insatiable lust for specious bullshit knowledge - or just to save you the price of a cup of ovaltine at bedtime - here's the basis of my mtDNA hypothesis concerning the GN.
    And it's good ...... honest, it is.

    My theory is that all brontosauruses are thin at one end ..... oh, hang on,.............. wrong theory.

    My theory is that different mtDNA suits different types of phsyiological demands placed upon the racehorse. Most obviously, that their relative performance is specific to race type and especially trip.

    The simple explanation concerns the relative capacity of horses of a certain mtDNA type to produce aerobic (based on lung and heart capacity) and anaerobic energy (based on muscular endurance).
    And it sort of makes sense that if the DNA of horses, like that of humans, can identify differing blends of ancient geographic ancestry, then a blend that has high component of ancient horse that required an emphasis on stamina at sustained high speed, thus with a greater relative dependency on aerobic energy, may be particularly suited to a "modern" GN (i.e. the race since the fences were made much less formidable, after 2012).
    That would fit the phsyiological characteristic of The Barb (Barbary), from North Africa, known for hardiness and stamina.
    Now, the Barb happens to be principal origin of Family 1, which is the family that has the N2a mtDNA.
    And, as noted ad nauseam above, horses with that N2a haplotype have the strongest level of outperformance in modern GNs. Interestingly, other families that have the Barb prominent in their origin is Family 4. And Family 4 is one of the families that have the mtDNA I2a1, which while itself not a strong GN outperformer, as a sire or damsire of a runner with N2a creates super-outperformance. 


    Moreover, the old-style GNs (1988~2012) show a different pattern of mtDNA outperformance altogether.

    In these GNs, the strongest outperforming mtDNA was L2b1a (most of Family 3): 

    1988~2012: 58 runners or 6.6% of fields / 4 winners  [Rhyme n Reason, Party Politics, Montys Pass, Ballabriggs] or 17.4% of winners = x2.6 representation

    But also, consider the winning stats for the near-identical mtDNA L2b1 (generally Family 14):

    1988~2012: 37 runners or 4.2% of fields / 2 winners [Earth Summit, Mon Mome] or 8.7% = x2.07

    Incidentally, N2a held its own (at "par") with a winning performance factor of x1.11 representation from 1988~2012 (3 winners [13%] from 103 runners [11.7%). 


    BUT, that most outperforming mtDNA in old-style GNs has totally collapsed in terms of correlation with modern GN success.

    L2b1a and L2b1 combined

    2013~2024: 37 runners or 8.7% of fields.

    Random distribution should lead us to expect them collectively to have produced by now 1 winner and 4~5 frame-makers.

    In fact, they've produced ZERO frame-makers. Their best finisher was 
    Ain't That A Shame, 6th last year.

    And, as already noted, particularly since the GNs became truly "modern" from 2015, N2a has shown meaningful winning outperformance with 4 winners: x3.04 representation from 2013 (x3.67 from 2015).


    So, my hypothesis is that the old GN that demanded super stamina with the ability to cope with repeated steadying and quickening as the runners overcame large obstacles (and the energy demands of getting over those obstacles - logically requiring short, repeated bursts of anaerobic [muscular] energy despite fatigue, in addition to the aerobic energy demanded for endurance) was particularly suited to one mtDNA haplotype and its close variant.

    While the modern GN, that demands super stamina at a consistent high-cruising speed is particularly suited to another. 

    The former is perhaps your Triathlete, the latter your pure marathon runner.

    And the origins of Families 3 and 14 fit that phsyiological characteristic. Family 3’s is a "Byerley Turk" and Family 14’s also a Turk.

    Turks are thought to originate from Hungary or Turkey, descended from Arabians but typically longer in the body and of a larger size. The Byerley Turk was a war horse and Capt Byerley's charger in King William's wars in Ireland in the late 17th century, according to the General Stud Book.

    So, it sort of figures that the Byerley Turk was built for both strength and stamina; brave and able to cope with any sort of terrain and obstacle.

    Sounds like an old style Grand National winner to me. 

    Anyway, that's my theory and it's sure to explode in my face when the sole representative of L2b1a (Beauport) canters home in front next Saturday  :/


    ZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzz
  • Wow, that’s amazing.
    Numbersixvalverde, GN winner in 2006 and my model’s first winner is still alive and kicking at 29 years old
     :) 

    Customer phones bookies: "£20 win on Numbersixvalverde please"
    After a bit of a pause the telbet operator responds: "Sorry sir, could you repeat that please?"
    Customer: "I'd like £20 win on Numbersixvalverde" 
    After another lengthy pause: "I'm sorry sir but I can't find any racecourse called Valverde!"

    A true story. 
  • edited March 31
    Greys and the Grand National

    Adding Fil Dor at a wild price as my fun runner, makes it 4 Greys on my betting slip, with nap Kandoo Kid, 3rd pick Vanillier and "saver-bet" Intense Raffles.

    A horse's colour plays no part in my model's assessment but some say that greys don't do well in GNs.
    Certainly in times of yore, they had a point. Prior to Neptune Collonges's slightly fortunate win in 2012, only 2 greys had won a GN - The Lamb (1868 and 1871) and Nicolaus SIlver (1961). Though there were notable greys that went close in living memory: Suny Bay twice (1997 and 98) and Whats Up Boys (<2L) in 2002.

    Since 2013, 30 greys have run in GNs (7% of fields) and they've produced 3 frame-makers (Farclas 5th in 2021, Vanillier close 2nd and Gaillard Du Mesnil 3rd in 2023). That's about par for the course (supported by Swing Bill's 6th in 2013) and, with that % representation, you'd expect a grey winner on average every 14~15 years.

    So, 13 years after Neptune Collonges (Paul Nicholls' only GN winner to date), we're about due. And, with more greys likely to run (6 - Coko Beach and Hyland the others, with an outside chance of Duffle Coat making a 7th) than in any other modern GN, all carrying less than 10-12, 2025 could well be the year of the Grey.  
  • Sponsored links:


  • Greys and the Grand National

    Adding Fil Dor at a wild price as my fun runner, makes it 4 Greys on my betting slip, with nap Kandoo Kid, 3rd pick Vanillier and "saver-bet" Intense Raffles.

    A horse's colour plays no part in my model's assessment but some say that greys don't do well in GNs.
    Certainly in times of yore, they had a point. Prior to Neptune Collonges's slightly fortunate win in 2012, only 2 greys had won a GN - The Lamb (1868 and 1871) and Nicolaus SIlver (1961). Though there were notable greys that went close in living memory: Suny Bay twice (1997 and 98) and Whats Up Boys (<2L) in 2002.

    Since 2013, 30 greys have run in GNs (7% of fields) and they've produced 3 frame-makers (Farclas 5th in 2021, Vanillier close 2nd and Gaillard Du Mesnil 3rd in 2023). That's about par for the course (supported by Swing Bill's 6th in 2013) and, with that % representation, you'd expect a grey winner on average every 14~15 years.

    So, 13 years after Neptune Collonges (Paul Nicholls' only GN winner to date), we're about due. And, with more greys likely to run (6 - Coko Beach and Hyland the others, with an outside chance of Duffle Coat making a 7th) than in any other modern GN, all carrying less than 10-12, 2025 could well be the year of the Grey.  
    In 1961 my dad was going out on the Saturday lunchtime to place his bets on the GN and he asked me to pick a horse - I chose Nicolaus Silver. I was coming up to four years of age and it was my first bet - quite prophetic based on my subsequent 40+ year career in the game!

  • And Duffle Coat will make it 7 Greys.
    Confirmations today make the cut in the 145s and, by my reckoning, Duffle Coat has the highest current OR of the 3 on that GNOR and is now #34.
  • MrOneLung said:

    "I am desperately frustrated, annoyed and sad," said Scottish trainer Thomson.

    "James [Manclark] is pretty devastated, he has been trying to get this for three years and we found him a horse, and his health comes and goes. Our aim is now to get the horse to run next year."

    I'm sorry Sandy but you really didn't need to be much of a judge to realise that, as much as I love the animal, it was always going to be a gamble buying this horse. I would offer you no better than evens that Mr Incredible will be racing next year let alone lining up for the National. I hope that I'm proven wrong. 


  • "It is understood this is not an isolated case, with six horses not running in last year's race due to concerns raised by the panel."

    Interesting.
  • edited March 31
    Will Bookmakers now refund stakes placed on horses that were intended runners but then banned by the panel? Lol
  • "It is understood this is not an isolated case, with six horses not running in last year's race due to concerns raised by the panel."

    Interesting.
    Particularly interesting if they were in the qualifying weight range. 
  • edited 3:10PM
    Interesting that Mullins has brought in Jonathan Burke (Fergal O'Brien's main jockey) to ride Minella Cocooner.
    Nicholls had thought he'd secured his services for Stay Away Fay to replace Bryony Frost but Burke (5th on Goonyella in 2016) opted for MC.

    The fact that one of the regular Mullins' team is not on board is perhaps of note. Danny Mullins had been expected to partner him, as he usually has, but looks like he'll be on JP's Meetingofthewaters, whom he rode to 7th last time and to win last year's Paddy Power Hdcp.

    With Townend obviously booked for Max and Paul Mullins wanting to ride Nick Rockett, it's possible that MC's owner, a successful entrepreneur, didn't fancy the yard's 4th choice jock (and, personally, I don't blame him).

    On the plus side, it's been a thing down the years for first-time/deputising jocks to ride a GN winner and Grade 1 winner Burke is no mug  :)   

    Mullins commented on weight-day that Meetingofthewaters has an eye-catching mar, and that it will be difficult for MC to win another big handicap. Far be it from me to disagree with the #1 trainer, and actually I don't - MC's GNOR is at full stretch. 

    But I do think spring ground and a marathon trip will bring out the best in MC and, given the forecast, he's got a great chance IMHO of reversing Bobbyjo and Irish GN placings with Nick Rockett and Intense Raffles. 


    Why?

    His best 2 hurdle runs (both in Grade 1s) came in March and April 2022 on GS and Gd/Y (at Cheltenham and Punchestown festivals) and, of course, last April he followed up his close 3rd in the Irish GN on Heavy with a stonking win in the 28.5f Bet365 on Good(GS) – the form of which is decent (9 wins and 12 places from 73 subsequent runs).

    Considering the sectional times for that race, he was the fastest in the field over 4~2f out, the fastest over 2~1f out and the fastest up the Sandown hill – Nick Rockett (30.22mph) the only rival coming anywhere near his average speed (30.69mph) over the last 4f.

    MC will be 10lbs better off vs NR on Saturday but, on the ground, I think he also stands every chance of reversing places from the Irish GN and BJ with Intense Raffles, who's only ever run on Soft or Heavy in 14 runs over obstacles. That's not to say he can't handle a decent surface but, unlike MC, he's in unknown territory.

    Notwithstanding the usual nutty GoingStick readings coming out of Aintree, with the 100% dry and sunny forecast and a 4pm start, I expect the going on Saturday to ride as safe Good ground (despite the official GS), just as in 2015, 2017, 2019, 2022 and 2023, as per the Racing Post time-based going assessments.
  • On the plus side, it's been a thing down the years for first-time/deputising jocks to ride a GN winner and Grade 1 winner Burke is no mug  :)   


    From your lips to God's ears, so to speak. I am a bit worried.


  • edited 2:54PM

    From your lips to God's ears, so to speak. I am a bit worried.




    ....... though it's not compulsory  :)
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!