Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton Summer Transfer Rumours 2024
Comments
-
I wonder if other teams fans go into meltdown when we make a bid for one of their players?3
-
It isn't for me. I look at what he's done in a similar situation at Luton, I have total faith.blackpool72 said:
It's a bit early to say you have total faith in Jones.J BLOCK said:In the minority, but I wouldn’t be devastated if May goes. I have total faith in Jones and trust his judgment and decision making.I support Charlton Athletic, not Alfie May.
Like you and everyone else I hope he proves to be a great success.
But it's too early to say I have total faith.
If May leaves he better have a good replacement lined up.6 -
Do we bid for players?sillav nitram said:I wonder if other teams fans go into meltdown when we make a bid for one of their players?5 -
46 -
https://x.com/RichCawleySLP/status/1801553699044540505?t=rMrKC9kKBjRbCanuloGhjA&s=19
#Millwall have agreed a deal with #cafc for centre-back Alex Mitchell. Personal terms not an issue.Permanent transfer.Edging closer.6 -
Really happy with Alex Mitchell. Feel like that's the type of centre back we have been missing.
Just a shame around the uncertainty with Alf12 -
Would the Mitchell signing be a replacement for Jones the defender, or Hector / Thomas?0
-
Found this from a Lincoln fan on Mitchell & echoed by others: "We would be very sad to see Mitchell rock up anywhere other than at Lincoln in League One. Became a fans favourite with his attitude and commitment, let alone his defensive performances for us. Not just down to him but a good reason we had one of the best defensive stats for goals conceded last season. IMO a top player."
Think that extra commitment and desire is part of what we've been missing at CB. We've had players who switch on and off throughout games. A proper 100% battling defender could be one of the upgrades we need.21 -
Interesting that we're sticking with 3 at the back. That certainly opens up a possible space for Zach, as with 3 centre backs you do need one who can carry the ball out, rather than 3 pure stoppers. That was Naby Sarr's best position for us.fenaddick said:
Quite a lot in that piece. Ruddy explored but unlikely, interest in Isted & AMB, Zach Mitchell to be assessed by NJ but has admirers elsewhere and we're set to continue with 3 at the back.shirty5 said:9 -
Given Jones was in talks to take over that lot not a surprise to see us buying Mitchell, you’d imagine he’d assessed their squad in depth. Lincoln fans seem positive so I’m optimistic
1 -
Sponsored links:
-
Would imagine we get bids weekly for players not all you hear about … followed up on my source and they said May not beenjams said:To be fair, the club can't control the bids they receive so I don't think you can read too much into that alone
told of of any bids made as far as he concerned he will
be a Charlton player come start of season , and he does not want to uproot his family again now there settled and happy ..
7 -
The whole business plan for these investors, or any tbh, only works if we get out of L1 asap.You only sell May, imo, if overall the money enables you to buy other key players that brings that closer than having a 20 goal plus striker.If they sell him for cash as they see it as value, that’s a mistake imo as a false economy if it reduces the chance of promotion, they will lose more in the long term with an extended stay at this level than the make from the sale.
Although the ideal is keep him and get other key players in but have to balance that with some realism.So I’d be ok with if the sale enabled bringing in already identified players that notably upgrade the team. Not if an opportunist sale to turn a short term profit.I hope and believe NJ wouldn’t be here if the latter were the approach, so will trust the process.2 -
0
-
Just realised......fenaddick said:Huddersfield forum saying they've bid again, could be their version of RM though
RM - Ronnie Moore
RM - Richard Murray.
I think he's true identity has been rumbled 😀.8 -
That's a pretty stupid comment ............... but don't let that stop you.Major said:
You actually don't know anything. But don't let that stop you.charltonbob said:
I wouldn't know that but he was a success with both clubs, I'm not really sure how but he managed.Billyboy said:
But he didn't rebuild them teams like nj did with Lutoncharltonbob said:
Appleton got Oxford promotion & Lincoln into the league 1 playoffsBillyboy said:Didn't NJ say everyone has to trust the process and get behind the team, love alfie but one player doesn't make the team... NJ has got promotion out of this league before, so I think he knows what he is doing, and if alfie doesn't fit in with NJ'S ideas so be it...3 -
Yep but with a flexibility. If May goes, I’m not expecting a 25 goal replacement. I would expect maybe a 15 goal replacement and a 10 goal attacking midfielder.Croydon said:
Spot on.blackpool72 said:
It's a bit early to say you have total faith in Jones.J BLOCK said:In the minority, but I wouldn’t be devastated if May goes. I have total faith in Jones and trust his judgment and decision making.I support Charlton Athletic, not Alfie May.
Like you and everyone else I hope he proves to be a great success.
But it's too early to say I have total faith.
If May leaves he better have a good replacement lined up.What I’m trying to get at is that jones might see mays goals spread around a bit more rather than a direct replacement.0 -
Some standout comments on Mitchell from The 100% Imps forums:
'He's our quickest centre back, covers well, strong as an ox and has battling fearlessness. I would say that if you are playing Roughan on the left and one of Jackson/O'Connor he is one of our important three. I wouldn't ideally want to play O'C and Jacko together due to the pace issue.Mitchell's passing appears to have picked up judging by some of his diagonals recently, and if he can add that consistently he would be a favourable addition; with due acknowledgement to your caveat about cost.'
-
'I have been very impressed with him. Not sure what the diff would be between his Millwall salary and what we’d pay him but I’d hope we’d go all out to sign him. Future captain in my humble opinion'
-
'I’ll go for ALEX MITCHELL - terrific all round contribution and would love to sign him permanently. So much passion and fight, but I don’t think Millwall will let us have him if we go up.'
-
'If he does go to Charlton, as appears, really disappointing, but not at all surprised. South London club, potential sleeping giant who should be up there this season under Jones, but above all, money and location were always going to be the big persuader for him no matter how much of a passion he had shown for us. Good luck to the lad, apart from the two games against us.'
-
The general opinion seems to be that he's a solid defender. With Lincolns fantastic run towards the end of last season, and Mitchell being a regular feature, it sounds quite a promising signing.25 -
As of 3 minutes ago No "For Sale" signs outside the property, back to Ralph in the studio for the weather :-)Mendonca In Asdas said:Any ‘For Sale’ signs up outside Alfie’s house?
Having said that he's renting anyway :-)43 -
Did Rich have to disclose his edging habits though?fenaddick said:7 -
Lincoln fans seem to think they've signed mcgrandles
28 -
Sponsored links:
-
Good if we can get him off the books, just need to get rid of Fraser and the 2 keepers. Arguably get rid of Edun too.ButtleJR said:Lincoln fans seem to think they've signed mcgrandles5 -
https://x.com/LincolnCity_FC/status/1801562043792691216ButtleJR said:Lincoln fans seem to think they've signed mcgrandles
Hope it's him!1 -
Seen some say it's Mcgrandles and some say it's Tom Bayliss the ex Cov and Shrewsbury midfielder.1
-
Both of whom would cost more than what we would get for May.Todds_right_hook said:
Yep but with a flexibility. If May goes, I’m not expecting a 25 goal replacement. I would expect maybe a 15 goal replacement and a 10 goal attacking midfielder.Croydon said:
Spot on.blackpool72 said:
It's a bit early to say you have total faith in Jones.J BLOCK said:In the minority, but I wouldn’t be devastated if May goes. I have total faith in Jones and trust his judgment and decision making.I support Charlton Athletic, not Alfie May.
Like you and everyone else I hope he proves to be a great success.
But it's too early to say I have total faith.
If May leaves he better have a good replacement lined up.What I’m trying to get at is that jones might see mays goals spread around a bit more rather than a direct replacement.0 -
Hopefully he's hard and doesn't feature on reality TV...5
-
https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/sport/charlton-athletic-agree-deal-for-millwall-defender-alex-mitchell/Cawley article on Mitchell - fee and personal terms agreed and we’re expected to sign Edwards next week when he’s back from holiday.8
-
I do agree that a basic issue with our side for the last few years is that there are not enough goals through the team. But there is a simple formula that IMO works in a rough sense at least. If you score 85-90 goals in a season, you will usually be well up there. And if you look at averages in terms of goals, it is harder for young players without that history to go on, but if you look at averages and apply them you need to see the goals figure there or there abouts. That will mean from defence and midfield as well as attack. I agree about not counting pens as somebody else can score them, but if you lose the major source of your goals you are already playing catch up trying to find them from other areas.1
-
My question re Mitchell would be why was he surplus at Millwall last season ?2
-
We can but hope! He did provide an excellent moment with that last minute equaliser against Pompey but other than that, not very much. Prime example of it not working out for a variety of reasons, so I hope his career gets back on track a bit (except against us).ButtleJR said:Lincoln fans seem to think they've signed mcgrandles5
This discussion has been closed.
