Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Leaburn or Josh?

24

Comments

  • uie2uie2
    Carlo! Josh isn't fit to clean Leaburn's boots
  • BedsaddickBedsaddick
    Leaburn - Just
  • PopIconPopIcon
    Leeaaaaaburn....
  • markofkentmarkofkent
    edited March 2018
    Leaburns deflection goal a Villa was my dad's lasts game before passing

    https://youtu.be/5A7QLVSqn18

    great memories


  • MrLargoMrLargo
    Not even a debate, 350 appearances in the top two divisions, the best strike partner Mendonca ever had. Legend.

    Only thing they've got in common is that they both got somewhat unjustly slated for their scoring record. Carl got around 8-10 a season but set up or played a major part in probably another thirty on top of that. Magennis would be a decent strike partner for a goal poacher. Only a total idiot would rely on him to be your primary source of goals.
  • HartleypeteHartleypete
    Leaburn by a country mile.
  • scabbyhorsescabbyhorse
    Leaburn all day long as he could actually hold the ball up, loved Leaburn.
  • _MrDick_MrDick
    Only seen Josh play once but from what I've heard, it has to be Carlo. Wimbledon wouldn't have snapped him up if he was useless
  • wmcf123wmcf123
    This isn't even a debate, for me. I don't get what Magennis offers. Leaburn was a real problem for defences, even when not scoring
  • guinnessaddickguinnessaddick
    Leaburn
  • Sponsored links:


  • letthegoodtimesrollletthegoodtimesroll
    Leaburn
  • Briston_AddickBriston_Addick
    Well, this debate could have gone a bit better for Josh.
  • AddickUpNorthAddickUpNorth
    Without question it has to be Leaburn. Arguably my favourite Charlton player of all time.
  • CHGCHG
    Like saying Messi or Kim Grant.
    Leaburn all day long.
  • charente addickcharente addick
    Leaburn by some distance, hugely underrated player.
  • iamdaniamdan
    Martin Pringle
  • IsawsummersplayIsawsummersplay
    No contest. Carlo by a country mile.
  • ForeverAddicktedForeverAddickted
    If Leaburn was the best that Mendonca has played with it makes you wonder how the Play-Off Final would have gone had he stayed and started instead of Mark Bright - As of course, you've the famous incident where Bright discreetly blocked Perez from getting to the ball, which then allowed Rufus to get the late equaliser and send it to Extra Time
  • HardyAddickHardyAddick
    Leaburn all day long. Played in the highest division.
  • Sponsored links:


  • RedroboRedrobo
    Leaburn.

    Mag tries to flick on a header. Karl had the strength to hold off a player and chest the ball down.
  • PringlePringle
    Carlo was top man. Apparently he became a cult hero at Wimbledon as well.
  • ElthamaddickElthamaddick
    Karim_myBagheri said:

    Clive definitely said he was the best player he's ever played alongside.

    so did Paul Williams I believe
  • Chris_from_SidcupChris_from_Sidcup
    edited March 2018
    Leeeaaaabuuuuurrrrrnnnnnnnn

    His hat trick at Ipswich will always live in the memory, one of the best Charlton away games ever.
  • bobmunrobobmunro
    Leaburn by a country mile - one of my Charlton heroes.
  • superdulvertonredsuperdulvertonred
    Leaburn was an underrated player who I personally thought was great. I remember how much the rest of the team thought of him and were aware of what he contributed. Paul Williams also said that he was great to play up front with. As for that penalty at Ipswich as I remember it, it was not a good penalty but it went in! I was so glad that I was there on the day to say that I saw his hat-trick.
  • killerandflashkillerandflash
    I imagine Carl will be amused by the love for him on his thread, when for much of his career with us he was constantly slagged off!
  • RedroboRedrobo
    We can stop now. Karlo wins hands down.
  • cfgscfgs
    LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAABBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBUUUUUUUUUUUUUUURRRRRRRRRRNNNNNN.
  • thewolfboythewolfboy
    Always Leaburn, great team player.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!