Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

The Takeover Thread - Duchatelet Finally Sells (Jan 2020)

1195219531955195719582265

Comments

  • 1955, Ruth Ellis becomes the last woman to be hanged in Britain at Holloway Prison.
  • Redrobo said:
    Redrobo said:
    1955 was a very good year for handsome, intelligent boys to be born. I hear that those born at the beginning of August are also now known for their virility.
    Right year. Wrong month 
    February was the month for the best looking most intelligent people. 
    I had not heard that and certainly not confirmed. Even so, I see you are not claiming the virility aspect. 

    I think we all agree though. 1955 was an excellent year for handsome intelligent boys to be born. Probably the best in the history of mankind.
    There can, of course, be exceptions to the rule. 
  • Question, would RD stating that any buyer had walked away due to the running costs and this not being the case, not be in breach of the NDA they signed? Just curious as if I was a potential buyer, surely you would leak the real reason out to increase pressure on him to sell?
  • CAFCDAZ said:
    Question, would RD stating that any buyer had walked away due to the running costs and this not being the case, not be in breach of the NDA they signed? Just curious as if I was a potential buyer, surely you would leak the real reason out to increase pressure on him to sell?
    RD believes NDAs don’t apply to him, only to the buyer. He refused to meet PV’s investor because the latter wouldn’t agree to that.
  • We’re not for sale. Roland needs some gentle convincing that getting rid is in his best interests. Storming his office worked for Liege fans, not that I’m suggesting we get violent.

    Please, not that old chestnut again.
  • Scoham said:
    Can we keep a log on here like the updated squad list thread, where it shows all the EFL clubs being bought and sold since they changed the FFP rules as per according to him, send it to talksport next time we know yellow tooth is on and ask them to ask him why these clubs managed to be bought and sold despite you claiming no one is buying clubs anymore now.
    I've gone through every Championship club to see when they last had a change of ownership.

    Financial Fair Play increased the loss limit in the Championship to £13m for the 16/17 season (http://www.financialfairplay.co.uk/financial-fair-play-explained.php)

    Since then 9 current Championship sides have been taken over, 7 were in the Championship at the time. West Brom and Swansea were the two who were in the Premier League when they were sold.


    Two were bought a few years before 16/17, us and Fulham, who were a Premier League club when they were taken over in 2013.

    The remaining clubs appear to have had the same majority shareholder since 2010 or earlier.

    Things might have have been different for us had Woolwich born Trevor Hemmings and his family hadn't been relocated to Lancashire during the second World War.

    The owners at Blackburn (Venky's), QPR (Tony Fernandes), Hull (Assem Allam) and Cardiff (Vincent Tan) surely haven't enjoyed the success they imagined or expected, but as I said they've been at their clubs since at least 2010, something is keeping them interested.

    You can't just take Championship clubs into account, there will be owners in League 1 and possibly below aiming to get to take their clubs up to this level in the near future. Blackpool were taken over this summer and Sunderland last summer. Michael Eisner bought Portsmouth in August 2017.

    What would be interesting to know is which other Championship clubs are up for sale, if any, and how long their owner(s) have been trying to sell.
    Hull City is, or at least it was until recently. I'm sure someone else can confirm this.
    I'm also fairly sure the same applies to Sheffield Wednesday.
  • We’re not for sale. Roland needs some gentle convincing that getting rid is in his best interests. Storming his office worked for Liege fans, not that I’m suggesting we get violent.

    His most insane outbursts have usually come after a protest visit to his hometown. Why are some people against a repeat?
    In what was did it work for Liege fans?  The 2 year delay would suggest it didn't work so well.
  • Redrobo said:
    1955 was a very good year for handsome, intelligent boys to be born. I hear that those born at the beginning of August are also now known for their virility.
    Yes, 1955, particularly around April was a very good year.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Finally got around to the exact wording in the interview. To me, it confirms something I have been wondering... he did NOT WANT to get promoted and is actually wanting to break-even this year financially, which he is close to doing, and then go back DOWN. He feels he can lose less money in League One. He claimed months ago he was more worried about being in The Championship than League One and the fact he essentially confirmed that again here, tells me he WANTS to go back down.

  • Agreed. He believes his view is absolutely rationale from the standpoint of a business model and the rest of the world has gone mad. He is probably right but anyone buying a football club should go into it expecting they will likely lose money unless they are in the Premier League.

    The problem is, he wants out but appears to expect any potential buyer to pay for the ongoing errors made on his watch in terms of management rotations, poor player acquisitions, handling of outgoing player valuations and as he moved up the learning curve on English football economics. As has been said, he had the option to get out as soon as he realised the EFL had moved the goalposts as regards FFP. However, if he can keep the club on life support by breaking even, despite relegations back to League 1 or even 2, at least it isn’t costing him money.

    Whilst I concede having a reasonable level of current operating costs to outline  to potential buyers is good, they will have their view on their appetite for annual losses over the near term. They are however more likely to be interested in a reasonable upfront purchase price and what might be considered reasonable for a Championship club is unlikely to be considered reasonable the further down the leagues the club goes.

    Promotion back to the Championship was probably his best chance of extricating himself with a reasonable price to defray some of his investment and it looks like he is closing the window on that.

    It may not make any difference in terms of changing his stubbornness but I think in the Fans Forum, CAST communications, interaction with the press etc there has to be continued emphasis on his quotes above and the fact that he has no footballing ambition for the club and that he is living in cloud cuckoo land if he is holding out for a price that covers his aggregate losses for the past 5 years. It would be good if any of the buyers who have walked away would reveal the exact price they had offered.
  • This was potential the very best year, especially around the back end of March.....when a certain RedMidland was born.
  • 1955 Charlton sold the great Eddie Firmani to Sampdoria for £35.000. one in a long line of excellent players Charlton have sold over the years
  • Oh ok then let’s do nothing. That’ll definitely encourage him to lower his asking price.

    Honestly, the apathy disappoints me.
    I’m not sure we should do nothing, but it’s not true that Liege fans stormed his office forced him to sell. It happened two years before he sold them.
  • Oh ok then let’s do nothing. That’ll definitely encourage him to lower his asking price.

    Honestly, the apathy disappoints me.
    Dealing in facts is hardly apathy, I believe we protests need to happen in Belgium, as regularly as possible.

    It would be a form of revenge, rather than forcing him to sell though.
  • Scoham said:
    Can we keep a log on here like the updated squad list thread, where it shows all the EFL clubs being bought and sold since they changed the FFP rules as per according to him, send it to talksport next time we know yellow tooth is on and ask them to ask him why these clubs managed to be bought and sold despite you claiming no one is buying clubs anymore now.
    I've gone through every Championship club to see when they last had a change of ownership.

    Financial Fair Play increased the loss limit in the Championship to £13m for the 16/17 season (http://www.financialfairplay.co.uk/financial-fair-play-explained.php)

    Since then 9 current Championship sides have been taken over, 7 were in the Championship at the time. West Brom and Swansea were the two who were in the Premier League when they were sold.


    Two were bought a few years before 16/17, us and Fulham, who were a Premier League club when they were taken over in 2013.

    The remaining clubs appear to have had the same majority shareholder since 2010 or earlier.

    Things might have have been different for us had Woolwich born Trevor Hemmings and his family hadn't been relocated to Lancashire during the second World War.

    The owners at Blackburn (Venky's), QPR (Tony Fernandes), Hull (Assem Allam) and Cardiff (Vincent Tan) surely haven't enjoyed the success they imagined or expected, but as I said they've been at their clubs since at least 2010, something is keeping them interested.

    You can't just take Championship clubs into account, there will be owners in League 1 and possibly below aiming to get to take their clubs up to this level in the near future. Blackpool were taken over this summer and Sunderland last summer. Michael Eisner bought Portsmouth in August 2017.

    What would be interesting to know is which other Championship clubs are up for sale, if any, and how long their owner(s) have been trying to sell.
    Excellent work, would love this asked to the him the other prick at the meetings.
  • Agreed. He believes his view is absolutely rationale from the standpoint of a business model and the rest of the world has gone mad. He is probably right but anyone buying a football club should go into it expecting they will likely lose money unless they are in the Premier League.

    The problem is, he wants out but appears to expect any potential buyer to pay for the ongoing errors made on his watch in terms of management rotations, poor player acquisitions, handling of outgoing player valuations and as he moved up the learning curve on English football economics. As has been said, he had the option to get out as soon as he realised the EFL had moved the goalposts as regards FFP. However, if he can keep the club on life support by breaking even, despite relegations back to League 1 or even 2, at least it isn’t costing him money.

    Whilst I concede having a reasonable level of current operating costs to outline  to potential buyers is good, they will have their view on their appetite for annual losses over the near term. They are however more likely to be interested in a reasonable upfront purchase price and what might be considered reasonable for a Championship club is unlikely to be considered reasonable the further down the leagues the club goes.

    Promotion back to the Championship was probably his best chance of extricating himself with a reasonable price to defray some of his investment and it looks like he is closing the window on that.

    It may not make any difference in terms of changing his stubbornness but I think in the Fans Forum, CAST communications, interaction with the press etc there has to be continued emphasis on his quotes above and the fact that he has no footballing ambition for the club and that he is living in cloud cuckoo land if he is holding out for a price that covers his aggregate losses for the past 5 years. It would be good if any of the buyers who have walked away would reveal the exact price they had offered.
    I don't totally agree with this as it may be considered too commercially sensitive and may not be the real problem as a price seems to get agreed.  However, it would be interesting to know what he uses to increase the price.  Eg does he throw in a percentage of the sale price of any youngsters in the academy ?  
  • Sponsored links:


  • Chunes said:
    What does Roland do when he's wrong? He finds someone or something else to blame. 

    I wouldn't get too distracted by his claims around the championship's FFP rules being the problem

    If that were the case, why weren't we bought when we were in League One?

    Why did he let on that it would be easier for us to be bought when were in the Championship?

    Why was the narrative that we'd be more attractive in the higher league? If, in fact, it makes us far less attractive? 

    This is just the same circle of behaviour we've always seen. He doesn't believe he could possibly be the problem, the real problem must lie somewhere else. 

    Unfortunately, this time, he raised a valid point about rules being a bit off, so the distraction is working a bit more than it normally would. But a distraction it still is.

    If one accepts that Roland genuinely believed that being in division 1 is economically better than the Championship, why did he increase his asking price when we got promoted?

    The logical thing to do would be to get rid asap. Even reduce the price to avoid the extra running costs.

    What I cannot reconcile is how someone so obviously stupid got to make so much money.

    I think we need to protest some how, but while we wait for anyone to think of something that will be effective, I am going to make a small gesture and get a ball rolling.

    I have a season ticket, but I am boycotting the first home game unless we are sold. I will also boycott the first televised home game.

    Probably all pointless, but it is what it is.
  • I think how much debt to him is left on may also be an issue.
  • I'm going to risk (understandable) criticism for re-posting a previous post because i don't think enough people read it properly, based on subsequent comments here. 

    It is alleged and insinuated by some that Standard fans various protests had no role in influencing RD's decision to sell. They have presented no evidence to support their claims, just vague references to the timeline of certain events. 

    Below I re-present the considerable evidence that I have at my disposal. Much of it consists of direct quotes from Duchatelet himself. I urge anyone who wants to pronounce on the merits or otherwise of activity in Belgium, to read and digest them. Post follows...
  • Say we finish 21st this season, stay up and break even and Millwall finish a place higher losing say £10,000,000 in the process, Roly will add their losses to the asking price. He will say I deserve the extra money to reward my greatness and vision.
  • @PragueAddick - It's a good thing RD is always open and honest when dealing with the media, otherwise we might not be able to trust anything he says.

    If those protests were such a huge reason for the sale of Liege, why the 2 year delay? Or was it more to do with RD selling on his own terms?
  • Redrobo said:
    Chunes said:
    What does Roland do when he's wrong? He finds someone or something else to blame. 

    I wouldn't get too distracted by his claims around the championship's FFP rules being the problem

    If that were the case, why weren't we bought when we were in League One?

    Why did he let on that it would be easier for us to be bought when were in the Championship?

    Why was the narrative that we'd be more attractive in the higher league? If, in fact, it makes us far less attractive? 

    This is just the same circle of behaviour we've always seen. He doesn't believe he could possibly be the problem, the real problem must lie somewhere else. 

    Unfortunately, this time, he raised a valid point about rules being a bit off, so the distraction is working a bit more than it normally would. But a distraction it still is.

    If one accepts that Roland genuinely believed that being in division 1 is economically better than the Championship, why did he increase his asking price when we got promoted?

    The logical thing to do would be to get rid asap. Even reduce the price to avoid the extra running costs.

    What I cannot reconcile is how someone so obviously stupid got to make so much money.

    I think we need to protest some how, but while we wait for anyone to think of something that will be effective, I am going to make a small gesture and get a ball rolling.

    I have a season ticket, but I am boycotting the first home game unless we are sold. I will also boycott the first televised home game.

    Probably all pointless, but it is what it is.
    Therein lies the problem as things stand with 10,000 already having given Duchatelet several million pounds in advance sales this season. I am afraid our next big protest opportunity will only come in the close season of 2020 when the appetite to renew will be considerably smaller after a year of struggle and humbling losses as we are outclassed this season due to our small and weak squad. If we could manage a serious season ticket boycott (we don't necessarily need to stop going altogether) I am convinced Duchatelet would take notice and have to consider cutting his losses and selling-up far more seriously than he has done to date.
  • I way prefer to hear that we aren’t being sold than all this will he/won’t he. At least we know where we stand. 
  • edited July 2019
    X
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!