Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Underrated Charlton players

12467

Comments

  • Stig said:

    Kish
    Matt Holland

    Didn't everyone rate Holland ? I thought he was shite. Lovely guy though
  • edited December 2016
    Dear old Les Berry. You have to do something right to play nearly 400 games but affectionately remembered for the back pass from anywhere and the hoof over the gable stand.

    ............and the own goal against Fulham when he back headed into his own net in front of the Covered End which put us well on the way to relegation.
  • edited December 2016

    I never understood why Salim Kerkar got loads of abuse.

    In the history books as a scorer of one of the six in our record away win at Barnsley.
  • Peter Shaw after a shaky start
  • Mark Reid
    Carl Leaburn
    George Shipperly
    Mark Bowen
  • Phil warman
  • edited December 2016
    Big Dave Shipperley, see him getting some beers at the Golden Lion Bexleyheath off-license one night when in the team.
  • Mark Penfold
    Harry Cripps
  • Sponsored links:


  • Mark Bowen.

    Wished there was a stat for the tackles he won - Can't remember too many attackers getting round him.
  • Jason Pearce
  • Lawrie Madden
  • Great thread this.

    Gary Nelson for sure was underrated. Rarely gets a mention in dispatches when discussing decent ex players.

    Mark Bowen was a better player than people realised as was Darren Pitcher. Plenty of reason to dislike Pitcher but he won his tackles and scored his share.
  • Jon Fortune - did great for us at a time our centre backs were up against the likes of Shearer, Henry, Cole, Van Nistelrooy etc

    Good shout for JF Damo, likewise Chris Perry and Sweaty Balmer were very underrated CB's neither were the tallest but won more than their fair share of the ball. Chris Perry timed his jumps so well and often seemed to do just enough to nick the ball away.
  • Of all the names I've read Mathias Svensson stood out the most. Haven't read his name for years and years, but he did an awful lot for the team with those cameo appearances. Just looked him up and surprised to see he played for 8 clubs, but a full quarter of his appearances were with us.
  • Can't believe no-one has mentioned him: Luke Young.

    Not many would put him in an all time favourite Charlton XI, but I believe still holds the record for most England caps as a Charlton player.

    Well I'd say here's the winner.

    I don't even remember Young playing for England, whilst at Charlton, let alone 7 times.

    One of my mates absolutely hated Young, (could never understand it myself).
  • Sponsored links:


  • I'll add Nicky Bailey into the mix, that Swindon game defined him a bit but people forget he hit a cracking 25 yard effort into the inside of the post in the first leg at 0-0. Fine margins eh
  • wmcf123 said:

    Stig said:

    Kish
    Matt Holland

    Didn't everyone rate Holland ? I thought he was shite. Lovely guy though
    I think you've answered your own question there!
  • Mickey Bennett
    Paul Williams
    Joe McLaughlin

    All from Selhurst days.
  • edited December 2016
    Sage said:

    Andy Reid.

    Not the fittest, but a wand of a left foot who was wrongly asked to play out wide by Pardew. He had so much class and could control a game by himself if allowed to sit in the middle with some runners next to him. Our first season down in the Championship fell apart when we sold him to Sunderland.

    Finding it hard to agree he was underrated......he was far and away our best player and the crowds favourite for a long period of time.
  • jamescafc said:

    All the obvious candidates have gone so I'm going for Shields (was it that goal against Forest?), Illic (think I saw his best game away at Stoke) and Salmon.

    Ilic's best game was away at Birmingham I think.
  • Jim Stannard.
  • JiMMy 85 said:

    Of all the names I've read Mathias Svensson stood out the most. Haven't read his name for years and years, but he did an awful lot for the team with those cameo appearances. Just looked him up and surprised to see he played for 8 clubs, but a full quarter of his appearances were with us.

    Poor for us but a local legend back in Sweden for the mighty Elfsborg.

    Cracking fella and a very successful businessman.

    Not forgetting he scored up at Blackburn to make us champions in 2000.
  • Nicky Bailey, our best player for the 2 years he was with us (and only remembered for that penalty!)

    I don't think anyone disliked bailey and he wasn't underrated.

    The star of the 09/10 season. Quality player.
  • Jon Fortune - did great for us at a time our centre backs were up against the likes of Shearer, Henry, Cole, Van Nistelrooy etc

    Good shout for JF Damo, likewise Chris Perry and Sweaty Balmer were very underrated CB's neither were the tallest but won more than their fair share of the ball. Chris Perry timed his jumps so well and often seemed to do just enough to nick the ball away.
    Chris Perry was awesome for us... Surely was never underrated by people?... He was as tall as Solly yet boy could he win headers against anyone!!
  • How about Kevin Smith ? Young player with talent and intent. Seem to remember he fell out of favour with Mullery.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!