Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Birmingham

135

Comments

  • Thuram-----6 didnt do to much wrong
    Wilson------6
    Morrison ----6
    Wood ------6
    Evina------5 have no idea what CP sees in this guy
    Cousins----6
    Poyet----7 MOM shouldnt have been taken off
    Jackson----6
    AA--------6 ok with ball at feet dosnt win it
    Sordell-----5 see Evina
    Reza------6 light weight but fast

    Green----- no idea why he was brought on
    Church------as above

    Polish Dave----------CP why on earth bring him on with 3 mins to go ?

    CP awful ------3 go now and save face ---we are going down
  • Thuram.. 6 .. Thought he could have done better for the first goal. TV replay will tell.
    Wilson.. 6... Some good crosses into the box.
    Morrison..5.... Looked nervy.
    Wood..6.... Better than Morro.
    Evina....5... Poor game. Miskicked a few.
    Ajdarevic...7... Some real classy touches, looks a real prospect.
    Poyet..8... Mom performance. Bossed the midfield. Why have we waited so long to pick him.
    Cousins...6... Wasted on the wing.
    Jackson...5.... Off the pace. Think he is now a bench warmer.
    Sordell... 5... Our worst player.
    Reza... 7... Good movement. May come good with games under his belt.
  • edited February 2014
    Thuram 6 Did his keeping duties well but kicking awful
    Wilson 6.5 Shame he didn't start at RM, but best of our defenders today
    Morrison 6 Ok
    Wood 6 Ok
    Evina 4 Ceddy oh Ceddy, had high hopes for you this year, just gone backwards
    Cousins 5 Yet again CP plays him as right winger, just a waste of a talent
    Poyet 8 Great home debut
    Ajdarevic 8.5 Have to be honest, I didn't rate him at all last week, but he did really well this week. Only downside is his lack of pace.
    Jackson 6 Love JJ but his place in the team is costing us points
    Sordell 5 Same as last week, just don't rate him, sorry
    Reza 6.5 High hopes for him once he gets a decent strike partner
  • Thuram 6
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 5
    Wood 6.5
    Evina 4
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7.5
    Ajdarevic 7.5
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Reza 6
  • Thurman 5
    Wilson 5
    Morrison 5
    Wood 6
    Evina 3
    Cousins 4
    Poyet 8
    Ajdarevic 8
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 3
    Reza 4
  • Thuram 6 - to me he seems to be another average championship keeper. I feel he may be marked down because Powell "has to play him"

    Wilson 6.5

    Morrison 5 - wasn't interested in listening to the new guys. His misorganisation was responsible for the first goal. Could have been sent off for lashing out near the end of the first half. Seems to think as part of the old guard he is better than the new players. Should have been dropped long ago.

    wood 5.5 - gave away a needless free kick for the first goal, seemed like a below average CB today.

    Evina 3 - will upset some people with this low score. Gave away the ball often, free header straight out of play under no pressure was symptomatic of his day. Not good enough for this level I'm afraid.

    Cousins 7 - out of position but provided drive and energy.

    Poyet 7 - same as cousins, I can see him growing into a great player, needs a haircut.

    Ajdarevic 8 - classy touches, should he in the middle but forced out on the wing to accommodate captain pathetic. Drifted in to become more involved in the game. Looked the most likely to make something happen.

    Jackson 4 - invisible first half. Upped his game in second half. Not good enough for the championship. I get the feeling he and Morrison feel they are untouchable as all that is left of the league one team. Powell, call time on his Charlton career before he causes RD to call time on yours.

    Sordell 5.5 - some good things, some bad. He was very frustrating and his demeanor sometimes comes off as lazy
    Reza 5.5 - flashes of talent but raw. Possibly needs match fitness. Went down too easily and eventually the ref had enough. Probably cost us a number of free kicks.

    Big Powell supporter but left the game feeling like his era as a manager may be coming to an end, just seems like there is a negative air of inevitability around the club . I'll be sorry to see this happen but it may cause the shake up we need.
  • Thuram 2 worst kicking I've seen from any charlton keeper scared to catch the ball.

    Wilson 6

    Morrison 5

    Wood 5

    Evina 1 disgraceful performance.

    Cousins 7 working hard as per.

    Poyet 8 gunna be a big player in our relegation battle.

    Ajdarevic 6 nice touches and flicks but poorin the final third.

    Jackson 6 worked hard but defiantly lost it.

    Sordell 4 terminate loan please.

    Reza 5 was expecting a lot more very weak needs a week or 2 in the gym.

    Hurts to say but don't expect Powell to be our manager next Saturday.
  • Thuram 5.5 - he doesn't look the part and I worry that the defence is more jittery

    Wilson 7.5 - gave his all and worked hard

    Morrison 6.5 - pretty solid

    Wood 7.5 - don't think he put a foot wrong

    Evina 5 - Wiggins would have made a big difference today

    Cousins 6.5 - decent performance - pity he didn't stick away his chance

    Poyet 8.5 - this lad looks good. He has good positional play and time on the ball

    Jackson 6 - not as good as he was but not as bad as some say

    Ajdarevic 7.5 - looks a quality player. Think we lack a bit of pace with both Jacko and him in the side

    Sordell 6 - thought he tried harder than last time I saw him. Looks to be lacking confidence

    Reza 7.5 - worked hard and looks promising
  • Thuram 6 - Didn't have much to do
    Wilson 6 - Again played alright but nothing much more
    Morrison 5.5 - Looked nervy and gave the ball away a bit.
    wood 6 - See above
    Evina 3 - Embarrassing, makes Wiggins look unbelievable
    Cousins 6 - Tidy passing and won a few headers to but wasted on the right wing.
    Poyet 7 - Class act especially first half
    Ajdarevic 7 - Thought he played well, comfortable on the ball
    Jackson 5.5 - Perhaps harsh but the game passed him by - again
    Sordell 5 - Didn't look interested, waste of money this loan deal
    Reza 5 - Worked hard but little quality

  • Thuram 5.5
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 6
    wood 6.5
    Evina 4 - with regret
    Cousins 6.5
    Poyet 7.5 mom
    Ajdarevic - 7.5
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 4 - with regret
    Reza 7

    Church n/a
    Green n/a
    Parzyszek n/a



  • Sponsored links:


  • don't get the low marks for Morro. I thought he was pushing for MOTM. guess its a game of opinions!
  • Thuram 6
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Wood 6.5
    Evina 5
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7.5 MoM
    Ajdarevic 7.5
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Reza 6.5

    Danny Green 3, sorry but I needed to say that.
  • Thuram 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    wood 6
    Evina 5
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 6.5
    Ajdarevic 6.5
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 5
    Reza 6.5


  • Thuram 6 didn't inspire confidence
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 6
    wood 6.5
    Evina 4
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7
    Ajdarevic 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Sordell 5
    Reza 6

  • edited February 2014
    Thuram 6 people scoring this guy a 2 and 3 are taking the piss and went to the game with preconceived ideas
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    wood 6
    Evina 3 just go don't pass go or collect this weeks wages
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7 very good young man
    Ajdarevic 8 mom very good performance very very assured on the ball
    Jackson 4
    Sordell 5
    Reza 7 been a long time since we had a forward with movement like him
  • Thuram 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    wood 7
    Evina 5
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7.5
    Ajdarevic 7
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 5
    Reza 7
  • Thuram 6
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Wood 6
    Evina 4
    Cousins 5
    Poyet 7.5
    Ajdarevic 8
    Jackson 5.5
    Sordell 5.5
    Reza 6.5
  • Thuram 4 - Static for the first goal, that was in his space and he should have dealt with it. Some of his kicking was dreadful
    Wilson 5 - league 1 player - end off.
    Morrison 5 - One of the leagues best CBs about time he started to show it.
    Wood 6 - Not the same player we saw when he broke into the team but looks our better CB.
    Evina 3 - Shocking better playing with 10 men than with him in the side.
    Cousins 6 - Too much is now left on his young shoulders he should be given a rest. But there isnt anyone else.
    Poyet 8 - Felt sorry for him played like he wants to play for Charlton.
    Ajdarevic 7 - Looked good in patches. Unlucky with overhead kick.
    Jackson 5 - Championship is just a level too much for him.
    Sordell 5 - Better he went back to Bolton.
    Reza 6 -
  • Reza 6 dives too much and should be told to cut it out. Nice touches and worked hard for the team
  • how was the first goal his fault who let macheda free in the box to nod in that was a shit goal either wood or morrow
  • Sponsored links:


  • Thuram 7
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 7
    wood 6.5
    Evina 5
    Cousins 6.5
    Poyet 8
    Ajdarevic 7.5
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Reza 7

    Church n/a
    Green n/a
    Parzyszek n/a
  • Thuram 5
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6.5
    wood 6
    Evina 3
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 8
    Ajdarevic 8
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 4
    Reza 7

    Powell made awful substitution again. Killed the 10 minutes of momentum we had with Danny Green who gifted them their 2nd goal.
  • Thuram - 6
    Wilson - 7
    Morrison - 6.5
    Wood - 6.5
    Evina - 3
    Cousins - 6.5
    Poyet - 7.5
    Ajdarevic - 8
    Jackson- 5
    Sordell - 5
    Reza - 7

    Church n/a
    Green n/a
    Parzyszek n/a



  • Thuram 6 good one on one save, not much to do. Only one punch, not sure the defence are confident in him but better tha he's been trailed
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 5 not his best, extra .5 for his lung busting run back to intercept after Wood came forward.
    wood 5.5
    Evina 4
    Cousins 6.5
    Poyet 7.5 enjoyed his home debut, mature beyond his years, looks comfortable and put in a shift
    Ajdarevic 7 fair bit of skill on show, adjusting to England yet I think, but could well be a very good find
    Jackson 4.5 pretty anonymous
    Sordell 4
    Reza 6.5 looked promising. Should have realised earlier on that the ref was not going to give him anything, that said he was lively and showed a lot of desire. optimistic for him for the future.

  • edited February 2014
    With Reza didnt Mendonca take a while to score his first goal? But after he did well we all know what happened after
  • Thuram 5
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6.5
    wood 6
    Evina 3
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 8
    Ajdarevic 8
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 4
    Reza 7

    Powell made awful substitution again. Killed the 10 minutes of momentum we had with Danny Green who gifted them their 2nd goal.

    But then last week Powell was slaughtered by some for not Bringing on Green and bringing on Dervite. I know the match was in different circumstances but really he seems to be damned if he does and damned if he don't.
  • Had to sleep on these ones!

    Thuram 6.5 Not at fault for the first goal - the wind caught it and it really sped up after hitting the ground. Good one on on save - unconventional but I'd persevere with him.
    Wilson 6.5 Needed Solly or a proper wide man playing with him on right side
    Morrison 6 I thought he was ok
    Wood 6 Same
    Evina 4 Lacking in confidence- always chose the easy option and often got that wrong.
    Cousins 5.5 Battled, but clearly out of position
    Poyet 6.5 Was decent, but the team didn't need this type of player - Cousins would have been better off playing with Ajderevic in the middle,
    Ajdarevic 7 A few wrong choices in decent attacking positions, but I like him - will look good in a better team
    Jackson 6 Battled, but I think the bench is his best starting position now
    Sordell 5.5 Marvin Sod-All - ponced his way through the game, I'm sorry to say
    Reza 7.5 MOTM I was very impressed - very lively and willing and would have enjoyed Kermogant's flick ons.



  • Thuram - 5
    Wilson - 7
    Morrison - 7
    Wood - 6.5
    Evina - 2
    Cousins - 6
    Poyet - 8
    Ajdarevic - 6
    Jackson- 5
    Sordell - 4
    Reza - 7.5

    Church n/a
    Green n/a
    Parzyszek n/a
  • Thuram - 6
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Wood - 6
    Evina - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Poyet - 6
    Ajdarevic - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Sorrdell - 5
    Reza - 6





  • edited February 2014
    Slept on it, I was gutted last night.

    Disappointed by the result but impressed by the Standard Liege trio and Diego Poyet. I think we can stay up if they can bed in quickly. We can enjoy next week at Hillsborough and then ironically I think the pitch could be a leveller against QPR.

    Thuram 6 Not at fault for either goal , not as bad as I had feared. If he improves I could see him becoming a favourite.
    Wilson 6 Prefer him in RM ,we need Solly back if not I hope Nego can step up to the plate.
    Morrison 6 Turned for the goal
    Wood 6 Not looking as good as in his first few games.
    Evina 5 Why did he play? His confidence has gone, surely Fox or Lennon would have been a better bet?
    Cousins 7 Tried to get things going
    Poyet 8 Really looks the part , get him signed on a long term contract. Looked like an experienced pro.
    Ajdarevic 8 I'm sure no one is complaining about signing him now.MOTM ,best player on the pitch.
    Jackson 6 Kept going and tried hard. Probably can't play every week any more. Ajdarevic gives us another left footed option now.
    Sordell 6 A couple of moments of promise. Here for the season now.
    Reza 7 Promising home debut , look forward to seeing him bed in.

    Church n/a Ran around as usual
    Green n/a Gave the ball away that led to the second goal
    Parzyszek n/a Looks like a massive unit
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!