Evina -Stay if he wants to,wouldn't be surprised if he moved on.Having seen Morgan Fox in U21 and youth teams I think he might challenge Ceddy as an alternate left back next year Waggy- Undecided I like him but he seems to be out of favour and like Ceddy might he wish to move on? Kerkar- Undecided possibly as an alternate wide left footer supplementing Callum Harriott if we can't get better in. Dervite- Stay.Improved in the last three games Taylor- Go.Not CCC quality in my honest opinion Haynes- Undecided,this one is about fitness BWP- Go Fuller- Undecided like Haynes when fit is the best we have got and has earned us 6/7 points this season Cort- Stay but as cover,too old to be starting so will he be content with this? Harriott- Stay Sullivan- Go Hughes- Stay has provided us with something last three games.
Hard one to answer. Not knowing salaries or targeted alternatives it is hard to say. I think any of them can do a job in the right setup, so the rationale comes down to whether they're on a low or a high wage and if Powell is looking at a better alternative. None have really let themselves down.
It depends enormously on how much money we have to either buy better replacements or sign them on frees, but assuming we will have limited room for manouvre I would say:
Not Sure: Fuller - Wages and fitness will be the decider.
Go: Waggy - Powell doesn't seem to rate him. Kerkar Taylor- Need to get rid of one CB and think Dervite will stay due to versatility, younger. Sullivan BWP - Obvious
Evina -Depends on whether Fox is considered good enough or not. Will probably get an offer but may want to move on for first team football elsewhere.
Waggy- Powell doesn't seem to like him one little bit. Shame as I think he has a lot to offer and has the attitude and determination to improve. Will probably go.
Kerkar- Go although the fact he made the squad on Saturday might mean he is still in SCP's plans.
Dervite- Stay as can do a job in midfield too.
Taylor- If Mambo is considered ready and Leon has another year in him he will probably be the centre back to get the chop.
Haynes- Stay if considered fit enough. Big IF though!
Evina -stay, 1 more year to see see how Morgan Foxprogresses Waggy- Go Kerkar- Go Dervite- Stay Taylor- Go Haynes- Go, too injury prone BWP- Go Fuller- Stay, lazy half the time, but has top Championship team quality Cort- Go, knocking on a bit now, lack of pace Harriott- Stay, club must be scrambling to get an extension if not already in the pipeline Sullivan- Go Hughes - Stay Mambo - Stay, 1 more year again progressing slowly but surely, otherwise may fear another Shittu, Primus, Turner...
Evina - realistically he should go, Wiggins is first choice LB and in front of him we have Harriot and JJ so he will be third choice to play in midfield. For the sake of his career he needs to play regular football.
Waggy -I'd keep, he can score goals but isn't a winger and he isn't a forward, I'd like to see him play inside right.
Kerkar - we have enough left sided players and he hasn't set the world alight.
Taylor/Dervite - keep one, release one. We need a new CB and need a spare, but not both of them.
Cort - retain.
Haynes - retain, if he keeps fit he will score goals and can play on the wing to boot.
Fuller - not fit enough. Given that he has shoulder problems and doesn't look fit I wonder if he's training?
BWP - he's gone in all but name.
Sullivan - go, we have Button and Hamer and have Pope bubbling under.
Hughes - retain, we look better with him in midfield and he can cover at RB.
Haynes with 15 starts and 9 goals in 15 months is a luxury we can ill afford. I also see he went 28 appearances without scoring a goal for Barnsley and us. His current tally could be described as a rich vein of form in the context of his overall career.
Haynes with 15 starts and 9 goals in 15 months is a luxury we can ill afford. I also see he went 28 appearances without scoring a goal for Barnsley and us. His current tally could be described as a rich vein of form in the context of his overall career.
On the surface you may appear to be right, but if we look at what Haynes has contributed this season I feel he's worth another year, dodgy hamstrings and all.
It's like with Fuller. You could look at his stats and think, what? only 4 goals - get rid! But that doesn't tell the whole story.
Match winning performances that he put in away to Ipswich, Blackpool, Watford; and home to Peterborough and Bolton (vitally involved in all 3 of our goals), ensured wins that without, would have seen an otherwise limited team struggling in the relegation positions.
In the first half at Palace, Fuller was unplayable. We know he has the quality - the question is, can we expect more next season and is he worth the money.
Evina - Go Waggy- Go Kerkar- Go Dervite- Stay Taylor- Go Haynes- Stay BWP- Go Fuller- stay Cort- Stay Harriott- Stay Sullivan- Go Hughes- Stay
really, cracking LB back up with age on his side?
I think his an ok back up, cant ever seeing him challenging a fully fit Wiggins and wouldn't be confident him owning that position for a whole season. may as well leave that position for a youngster like Fox. Would probably benefit his career as well if he found a league 1 club where he was starting.
Evina - Go Waggy- Go Kerkar- Go Dervite- Stay Taylor- Go Haynes- Stay BWP- Go Fuller- stay Cort- Stay Harriott- Stay Sullivan- Go Hughes- Stay
really, cracking LB back up with age on his side?
I think his an ok back up, cant ever seeing him challenging a fully fit Wiggins and wouldn't be confident him owning that position for a whole season. may as well leave that position for a youngster like Fox. Would probably benefit his career as well if he found a league 1 club where he was starting.
agreed with the majority but if Wiggins got injured again then I wouldn't want to rely on Fox. We need a good squad to compete and Evina's good enough to be a back up, I don't think Fox is. If he wants to leave thats a different matter.
Evina - Would like to re sign but think he will chose to go and get first team footy, a big loss I reckon in terms of our squad but Wiggins is undoubtedly better
Waggy - Go, love the bloke for his effort but not the quality for the Championship, wish him the best
Kerkar - See ya, don't look back, would be amazed if anyone above League2 took him on.
Dervite - No strong feelinsg either way
Taylor - Go, great job and goes with best wishes but reckon we could do better
Haynes - Go, always injured and whilst his scording record for us is good I am still not convinced.
BWP - Go, as per Waggy, not Champ quality
Fuller - If he takes low wages then sign but if his wages are such we could bring in 3 decent players we should get rid.
Cort - Release (subject to budget for replacements as concsious I am saying same about Taylor)
Harriott - Sign, great prospect
Sullivan - Go, done ok when called upon but we have plenty better.
Hughes - Sign, nice to see him getting a coaching role too
Amazing that so many on here have banged on about "we need to go out and buy real Championship quality, not just hard workers" and would then drop the likes of Fuller in a flash yet keep Andy Hughes.
Evina -stay - but we are late in tying him up, so others may come in if we do not have the cash. Waggy- Go Kerkar- Go Dervite- Stay Taylor- Go Haynes- Not sure, great on the pitch, too often in the medical room. Our modern Anyinsah and CP got rid of him. BWP- Go Fuller- Probably go Cort- Stay Harriott- Stay, but as with Evina we are leaving it late to tie him up and others with more cash than us may come in for him. Palace could be an option for this Noirwood boy ... hope not Sullivan- Go Hughes- Stay
What cash we have and when we get it is so important. We do not want to be like the Parkie season where a week before the new season we hardly had a squad together
Evina -stay Waggy- Not sure - had more than enough chances - League 1 his level Kerkar- Go Dervite- Go Taylor- Stay for squad if he's fit enough Haynes- Stay for squad if he's ever fit enough BWP- Go Fuller- Go really expensive failed experiment no heart Cort- Stay Harriott- Stay got lots to learn gotta get his head up and his crosses in Sullivan- Stay although dunno why he'd want to - done nothing wrong & frozen out - weird Hughes- Stay a proper pro and they're invaluable
Evina- Stay Waggy- Stay Kerkar- Go Dervite- Stay Taylor- Go, unfortunately Haynes- Stay BWP- Go Fuller- Stay Cort- Stay Harriott- Stay Sullivan- Go Hughes- Stay, get him involved in more backroom stuff
Evina - Stay, but he may want to go for first team football Waggy - Go Kerkar - Go - but could end up staying if no better options come in during the summer Dervite - Stay Taylor - Go - Reckon he'll want first team football somewhere Haynes - Stay BWP - Go Fuller - Go Cort - Stay Harriott - Stay Sullivan - Go Hughes - Stay
Comments
Waggy- Undecided I like him but he seems to be out of favour and like Ceddy might he wish to move on?
Kerkar- Undecided possibly as an alternate wide left footer supplementing Callum Harriott if we can't get better in.
Dervite- Stay.Improved in the last three games
Taylor- Go.Not CCC quality in my honest opinion
Haynes- Undecided,this one is about fitness
BWP- Go
Fuller- Undecided like Haynes when fit is the best we have got and has earned us 6/7 points this season
Cort- Stay but as cover,too old to be starting so will he be content with this?
Harriott- Stay
Sullivan- Go
Hughes- Stay has provided us with something last three games.
Defintely GO - Kerkar, Sullivan, BWP
Probably GO - Waggy, Dervite
Probably STAY - Taylor, Cort, Fuller
Defintely STAY - Evina, Haynes, Harriott, Hughes (player/coach)
Evina
Dervite
Haynes
Cort
Harriott
Hughes
Not Sure:
Fuller - Wages and fitness will be the decider.
Go:
Waggy - Powell doesn't seem to rate him.
Kerkar
Taylor- Need to get rid of one CB and think Dervite will stay due to versatility, younger.
Sullivan
BWP - Obvious
Waggy- Powell doesn't seem to like him one little bit. Shame as I think he has a lot to offer and has the attitude and determination to improve. Will probably go.
Kerkar- Go although the fact he made the squad on Saturday might mean he is still in SCP's plans.
Dervite- Stay as can do a job in midfield too.
Taylor- If Mambo is considered ready and Leon has another year in him he will probably be the centre back to get the chop.
Haynes- Stay if considered fit enough. Big IF though!
BWP- Go
Fuller- Wage and shoulder dependent.
Cort- Stay if SCP thinks he can do another year
Harriott- Stay
Sullivan- Go
Hughes- Stay if SCP thinks he can do another year
Waggy- Go
Kerkar- Go
Dervite- Stay
Taylor- Go
Haynes- Go, too injury prone
BWP- Go
Fuller- Stay, lazy half the time, but has top Championship team quality
Cort- Go, knocking on a bit now, lack of pace
Harriott- Stay, club must be scrambling to get an extension if not already in the pipeline
Sullivan- Go
Hughes - Stay
Mambo - Stay, 1 more year again progressing slowly but surely, otherwise may fear another Shittu, Primus, Turner...
Waggy -I'd keep, he can score goals but isn't a winger and he isn't a forward, I'd like to see him play inside right.
Kerkar - we have enough left sided players and he hasn't set the world alight.
Taylor/Dervite - keep one, release one. We need a new CB and need a spare, but not both of them.
Cort - retain.
Haynes - retain, if he keeps fit he will score goals and can play on the wing to boot.
Fuller - not fit enough. Given that he has shoulder problems and doesn't look fit I wonder if he's training?
BWP - he's gone in all but name.
Sullivan - go, we have Button and Hamer and have Pope bubbling under.
Hughes - retain, we look better with him in midfield and he can cover at RB.
I think Mambo's contract is up as well??
Danny Hollands will leave as well.
It's like with Fuller. You could look at his stats and think, what? only 4 goals - get rid!
But that doesn't tell the whole story.
Match winning performances that he put in away to Ipswich, Blackpool, Watford;
and home to Peterborough and Bolton (vitally involved in all 3 of our goals), ensured wins that without, would have seen an otherwise limited team struggling in the relegation positions.
I don't think people necessarily want Taylor to go but, given the fact he hasn't played much, they think he probably will.
I like Waggy and would dearly like him to stay but SCP doesn't so he will go which is why I said above he will probably go.
In other words there can be a distinction in what you would like to happen and what you think will actually happen.
Waggy - GO
Kerkar - GO
Dervite - SIGN
Taylor - SIGN
Haynes - SIGN
BWP - GO
Fuller - SIGN
Cort - SIGN
Harriott - SIGN
Sullivan - GO
Hughes - SIGN
Waggy - Go, love the bloke for his effort but not the quality for the Championship, wish him the best
Kerkar - See ya, don't look back, would be amazed if anyone above League2 took him on.
Dervite - No strong feelinsg either way
Taylor - Go, great job and goes with best wishes but reckon we could do better
Haynes - Go, always injured and whilst his scording record for us is good I am still not convinced.
BWP - Go, as per Waggy, not Champ quality
Fuller - If he takes low wages then sign but if his wages are such we could bring in 3 decent players we should get rid.
Cort - Release (subject to budget for replacements as concsious I am saying same about Taylor)
Harriott - Sign, great prospect
Sullivan - Go, done ok when called upon but we have plenty better.
Hughes - Sign, nice to see him getting a coaching role too
Waggy- Go
Kerkar- Go
Dervite- Stay
Taylor- Go
Haynes- Stay
BWP- Go
Fuller- Stay
Cort- Stay
Harriott- Stay
Sullivan- Go
Hughes- Stay
Waggy- Go
Kerkar- Go
Dervite- Stay
Taylor- Go
Haynes- Not sure, great on the pitch, too often in the medical room. Our modern Anyinsah and CP got rid of him.
BWP- Go
Fuller- Probably go
Cort- Stay
Harriott- Stay, but as with Evina we are leaving it late to tie him up and others with more cash than us may come in for him. Palace could be an option for this Noirwood boy ... hope not
Sullivan- Go
Hughes- Stay
What cash we have and when we get it is so important. We do not want to be like the Parkie season where a week before the new season we hardly had a squad together
Waggy- Not sure - had more than enough chances - League 1 his level
Kerkar- Go
Dervite- Go
Taylor- Stay for squad if he's fit enough
Haynes- Stay for squad if he's ever fit enough
BWP- Go
Fuller- Go really expensive failed experiment no heart
Cort- Stay
Harriott- Stay got lots to learn gotta get his head up and his crosses in
Sullivan- Stay although dunno why he'd want to - done nothing wrong & frozen out - weird
Hughes- Stay a proper pro and they're invaluable
Waggy- Stay
Kerkar- Go
Dervite- Stay
Taylor- Stay
Haynes- Stay
BWP- Go
Fuller- Stay
Cort- Stay
Harriott- Stay
Sullivan- Go
Hughes- Stay
providing we can afford them
Is anyone worried Harriott is out of contract and he's making an impression every week and getting name-dropped on Late Kick Off?
Waggy - Go
Kerkar - Go - but could end up staying if no better options come in during the summer
Dervite - Stay
Taylor - Go - Reckon he'll want first team football somewhere
Haynes - Stay
BWP - Go
Fuller - Go
Cort - Stay
Harriott - Stay
Sullivan - Go
Hughes - Stay
GO:
Sullivan
Cort (think Dailly in 11/12)
Waggy - like Lisbie, a move will benefit all
Fuller
BWP
STAY:
Dervite (as CB)
Evina
Hughes (player /coach)
Harriott
Others depends on wages and who else is available
Sullivan - Go
DF
Dervite - Sign
Cort - Sign
Mambo - Sign
Taylor - Go
Evina - Sign
Osborne - ?
Ajayi - ?
Fox - ?
Cousins - Sign
MF
Harriott - Sign
Hughes - Sign
Kerkar - Go
Harris - ?
Wagstaff - ?
FW
BWP - Go
Haynes - ? (Subject to Fitness)
Fuller - ? (Same as Haynes)
Azeez - ?
Pigott - ?