Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Cardiff

13»

Comments

  • Hamer - 6.5
    Morrison - 7
    Cort - 6.5
    Devite - 7
    Solly - 7.5
    Haynes - 8
    Pritchard - 8
    Stephens - 7.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Kerkar - 7.5
    Hulse - 7.5
  • edited November 2012
    Hamer - 6 - didn't exactly cover himself in glory but made a couple of decent saves and just about kept control of his box in the frantic last 90 seconds.
    Morrison - 6 - great centre-back, but not a right back. So immobile not sure about CPs decision to put him there again.
    Cort - 6 - great in the air but not so good on the floor and missed his partner. Unlucky not to score with decent effort.
    Dervite - 6 - looks like a decent squad player.
    Solly - 6.5 - solid game and even on his wrong side an attacking threat, but can’t give any defender a 7 when they conceded 4 goals.
    Haynes - 8 - electric pace. Terrorised their defence.
    Pritchard - 7.5 - extra half for a superb assist for Haynes’ goal. Usual excellent workrate but just not quite strong enough physically to take himself to the next level.
    Stephens - 8 - he was controlling the midfield in the second half, taking him off nearly cost us the game.
    Jackson - 7.5 - two excellent goals and a great captain but aside from that still not convinced he is quite good enough at this level.
    Kerkar - 8.5 - frustrated on Saturday as our biggest threat but was not able to deliver a good ball; rectified that though and rewarded with 3 quality assists.
    Hulse - 7 - the best we could hope for as cover in the circumstances and took his header well, but overall not strong enough in the air had a poor first half and many don’t seem to realise his goal on Saturday took a big deflection. Sooner Kerm / Fuller are back the better!

    BWP - 6
  • edited November 2012
    Hamer 5.5
    Morrison 6
    Cort 6.5
    Devite 6.5
    Solly 7.5
    Haynes 8.5
    Pritchard 8.5
    Stephens 8.5
    Jackson 7.5
    Kerkar 7
    Hulse 8
  • Hamer - 5
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 7
    Devite - 7
    Solly - 8
    Haynes - 8
    Pritchard - 8
    Stephens - 8
    Jackson - 7
    Kerkar - 7
    Hulse - 7
  • Hamer - 5
    Morrison - 5.5
    Cort - 5.5
    Devite - 5
    Solly - 7
    Haynes - 9
    Pritchard - 9
    Stephens - 8.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kerkar - 7.5
    Hulse - 8.5

  • Hamer - 6 Could do nothing with the goals, seemed a bit low on confidence
    Morrison - 8 excellent at right back
    Cort - 7 - Good display
    Devite - 7.5 - Good performance.
    Solly - 8 Hes just Solly.
    Haynes - 8.5 Scared the crap out of them well taken goal.
    Pritchard - 9.5 MOM by a street, was everywhere, great assist for Haynes goal.
    Stephens - 7 Poor first 20 mins, great second half
    Jackson - 8.5 Shook of his recent bad form 2 well taken goals
    Kerkar- 8.5 Great display, good assists
    Hulse - 8 Improving every game, very good movement for his goal
  • Hamer 6
    Morrison 6
    Cort 6.5
    Devite 6.5
    Solly 6.5
    Haynes 8
    Pritchard 7.5
    Stephens 8
    Jackson 7.5
    Kerkar 7
    Hulse 8
  • Hamer - 6 something not right there with some flapping and mis-communications
    Morrison - 6.5 not bad considering he was out of position
    Cort - 7 I felt he was solid and couldn't tell if the last two Cardiff goals were attributable to his errors
    Devite - 6.5 put in a shift after being put in at the deep end again.
    Solly - 8 love this guy and shows that even when you are out of position you can still play well if you got the skills
    Haynes - 8.5 (MOM) he is what I always wanted to see from BWP at this level and glad it was only cramp at the end for him. Our play went noticeably downhill after his exit.
    Pritchard - 7.5 a willing player who just kept on going, just needs to bulk up a bit
    Stephens - 8.5 more of this type of performance please!
    Jackson - 7 would be lower scoring if it weren't for the captain fantastic two goals dragging us back into the game. I felt JJ was at fault for their first goal.
    Kerkar - 8 wily at times, three assists gets the extra half point.
    Hulse - 8 two goals in as many games should see his confidence go up more. Constant thorn in Hudson's backside and is the hold up forward we need at the moment.
  • Hamer 6 Can't say he did a lot wrong tbf.

    Morrison 6.5 Did ok especially as out of position

    Cort 5 Thought he did ok until I saw the replay. Definitely at fault for their 3rd as he missed the ball completely & probably at fault for 4th as he slipped over, when about to block the goalbound shot. (on top of being at fault for 2 of of Boro's goals as well).

    Devite 6.5 Looked decent again
    Solly 6.5 Did well & his cross set up the 4th goal
    Haynes 8.5 MOM. Just what we've been missing. He ran at them & ran them ragged at times.
    Pritchard 7.5 Getting knocked off ball too much 1st half.2nd half he was excellent.
    Stephens 8 Got stuck in & ran about as well as excellent passing. If only he can do this every game.
    Jackson 7.5 Thought he was awful at the start & then scores 2 goals. Unbelieveable.
    Kerkar 8 Did very well. Excellent running & crossing.
    Hulse 7.5 Very good game, played his part.
  • Hamer 6
    Morrison 6.5
    Cort 6.5
    Devite 6.5
    Solly 7
    Haynes 9
    Pritchard 7.5
    Stephens 8.5
    Jackson 8
    Kerkar 8
    Hulse 7.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer 6 - Needs to rebuild confidence
    Morrison 5 - He is no full back and was crucified for first half-hour. Improved as game went on, though.
    Cort 6 - Another who needs to rebuild confidence.
    Devite 6 - Okay performance, although still needs better understanding with rest of the defence.
    Solly 6 - Poor start but back to his old self later in the game.
    Haynes 7 - So much better than BWP. He actually looks to be a threat.
    Pritchard 8 - Usual powerhouse in midfield. Yes, one or two mistakes, but he is still learning.
    Stephens 7 - Much better than Sat - but he needed to be. Reckon his goal was a fluke, though.
    Jackson 7 - Couldn't work out why he wasn't played at FB, rather than Morrison. I guess his 2 goals answered that!
    Kerkar 7 - Back to his old position and caused their defence problems.
    Hulse 7 - Good performance & glad he got his goal.

    Wright Phillips 4 - Not in the same class as Haynes.
    Hollands n/a
  • Hamer - 6 Not his best but still ok.
    Morrison - 5.5 Gave it a good go at RB but obviously a bit uncomfortable.
    Cort - 6 Some great headers and blocks but made a bit of a mistake for the last goal.
    Devite - 6 Some good bits and not bad at all but like most of his co-defenders was ball-watching for the 2nd goal.
    Solly - 6 Same as Morrison with a touch more class.
    Haynes - 8 Excellent movement even when we weren't making much progress in the 1st half. Also, like others, I was pleasantly suprised by his control with his back to goal. A real menace to Cardiff.
    Pritchard - 8 Ran himself into the ground and helped Morrison a lot. Great work for the Haynes goal.
    Stephens - 8.5 Looked a class above anyone else on the pitch in the 2nd half and it was good to see him cropping up in forward positions. Brilliant crunching tackle and lots of interceptions. His best ever Charlton performance?
    Jackson - 7.5 He's such a good finisher. Got the game going for us and did his bit thereafter.
    Kerkar - 8 A real threat in the 2nd half and was much more decisive in his play. He also added an end product which had been previously missing. More consistency and we might have another Mortimer on our hands.
    Hulse - 8 Practically unbeatable in the 2nd half. His movement was good and he looked fit/sharp.











  • edited November 2012
    Hamer - 5.5
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 6
    Devite - 7
    Solly - 7
    Haynes - 8.5
    Pritchard - 8.5
    Stephens - 8.5
    Jackson - 8
    Kerkar - 8
    Hulse - 8
  • Hamer - 5.5
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 5.5
    Devite - 5
    Solly - 6
    Haynes - 7.5
    Pritchard - 7.5
    Stephens - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Kerkar - 6
    Hulse - 7
  • Hamer 5
    Morrison 5
    Cort 5
    Dervite 6
    Solly 7
    Haynes 9 MoM
    Pritchard 8
    Stephens 7
    Jackson 7.5
    Kerkar 7
    Hulse 8
  • Hamer - 5.5 - To flappy for my liking and he's starting to scare me again
    Morrison - 5.5 - Purely not a right back but still put in a shift and a good effort
    Cort - 6 - At fault for some of there goals, still put in some heroic blocks
    Dervite - 6.5 - I like him, he's good at passing about but is still quite sound defensively
    Solly - 7 - Even at left back he is quality
    Haynes - 8.5 - The guys pace is unreal and he caused them loads of problems. I would like to see him start alot more now he's fit
    Pritchard - 8.5 - His engine is great and combined with his grit and determination he is one hell of a worker. Great work to set up Haynes goal to
    Stephens - 8.5 - Dictated play in midfield brilliantly and showed why Villa bidded for him, great delivery from set pieces to and that goal was class
    Jackson - 8.5 - Scored 2 great goals and really lifted the team. Much better in the middle and he showed he is more than good enough for this level
    Kerkar - 7.5 - Caused them problems with his trickery but his final ball is to inconsistent. I he can get more quality balls into the box like he did when we scored more often he will be class
    Hulse - 8.5 - Took his goal well and harried Cardiff the whole game. Him and Haynes up front together could be a lethal combination

    MenOTM is everyone apart from the defense. Last nights performance has had me on a mental high since the final whistle.

    Crowd: 11/10 Unreal atmosphere, the east had more than 20 people singing for a change!!!
  • Hamer - 6 - Seen him play a lot better.
    Morrison - 6 - Much better than Saturday, even though playing out of position.
    Cort - 6 - Steady game.
    Devite - 6 - Getting better every game.
    Solly - 7.5 - Usual solid game, 100% where ever he plays.
    Haynes - 8.5 - Great game, hope he's not too hurt when their defender took him out, surely a sending off offence!
    Pritchard - 8.5 - Best game I've seen him play for Charlton, great assist, shame 'Mouthie McKay' got him booked by mouthing to Ref! Hate to see fellow pro's or managers doing this!
    Stephens - 8.5 - Along with Pritch and Danny joint MOM, hope he can silence the clowns on this site who knock him now!
    Jackson - 8 - Much better than the Middlesboro' game.
    Kerkar - 8 - As above!
    Hulse - 7.5 - Good goal, worked hard, well done Rob!
  • Hamer 5.5 Lacked some confidence, will come good again, badly needs a clean sheet Sunday
    Morrison 6 Out of position but did OK.
    Cort 5 Shaky at times
    Dervite 6 Got potential to be very good centre half at this level
    Solly 7.5 Best of the back four - again.
    Haynes 8.5 Great direct pace. Also looked good out wide before moving inside.
    Pritchard 8.5 MOM Most of game out of best position but played really well, protected Morrison well at times and great control for assist - would love to see him score
    Stephens 8.5 Such a contrast to Saturday, controlled centre mid really well
    Jackson 7.5 First 20 mins thought game was passing him by and exposed for pace - then he scores twice!!!
    Kerkar 8.5 Very good performance and assists - time for a contract extension I think!
    Hulse 8 Don't think he realises that loan players aren't meant to put in that amount of effort! Classic centre forward goal.

    Felt bit sorry for Ade Azeez, look all set for a debut cameo on 90 mins at 5-2. Then 6 minutes added, then a goal, the the tracksuit was back on!
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Morrison 5
    Cort 6
    Dervite 6
    Jackson 7
    Stephens 8
    Pritchard 8
    Kerkar 7.5
    Hulse 7.5
    Haynes 8.5 MOM
  • Hamer- 7 (Extra point for winding up rthe Cardiff player with that goal kick near the end.)
    Morrison-5
    Cort-6
    Devite-7
    Solly-7
    Haynes-7
    Pritchard-7
    Stephens-8
    Jackson-8
    Kerkar-9
    Hulse-8
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 6
    Devite - 6
    Solly - 7
    Haynes - 8
    Pritchard - 8.5
    Stephens - 8
    Jackson - 8
    Kerkar - 7.5
    Hulse - 8
  • Hamer - 6
    Morrison - 6
    Cort - 6
    Devite - 6
    Solly - 7
    Haynes - 8.5
    Pritchard - 7
    Stephens - 8
    Jackson - 8
    Kerkar - 7.5
    Hulse - 8.5
  • hamer 6
    morrison 6
    cort 6
    dervitte 6.5
    solly 7
    kerker 8.5
    stephens 8.5
    jackson 8
    pritchard 8.5
    haynes 9
    hulse 8.5
  • right, that's it Lifers, no more marks please, stats soooon
  • Just one more??!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!