I'm not voting on this as I was too pissed. Here's my main observations: Hamer - ok, but I think we should replace him in goal and play him up front ;-) Solly - not bad for a position that's not his first choice. Wilson - the only one of our team that seemed to have any time on the ball. Sadly nothing came of it. Jackson - Particularly disappointing.
Hamer 6 Solly 5 struggled against his man. Morrison 5 Cort 5 Pritchard 4 worst game for him Hollands 4 same as pritchard Stephens 5 Jackson 5 Kermorgant 5 Wright Phillips 6
Hamer - 7 If that header had gone in he would have been in the history books forever. Didn't have much to do as every Palace cross went straight into his chest. Solly - 6.5 Dealt with Zaha ok but struggled a little as the game wore on Morrison - 7 Calm and collected on the ball. Utterly untrouble by Murray Cort - 6.5 Solid. Little to do and did it well Pritchard - 5 Seemed oddly tired and did offer much going forward or tracking back Hollands - 4 Utterly anonymous whichis unusual for him. Needed to drop back and bring the ball out as Palace were bypassing the middle out to the wings Stephens - 7 Brilliant with his passing and tackling in the first half but disappeared in the second. Jackson - 5 Good crossing in the first, taken off early in the second. Didn't offer too much Kermorgant - 5 Very quiet by his standards. Not much came from him Wright Phillips - 6.5 Worked hard, ran hard. Scared Palace defenders when running at them and scored a perfectly good goal
Wilson - 6.5 Dealt with Bolasie well and put the ball into the box to cause trouble Fuller - 6.5 Strong, brave. Unlucky not to score
Wiggins n/a Green n/a Can't give him a score but he was excellent and scared the hell out of them
Wilson and solly dealt with zaha and bolassie? Were you there or pissed mate? They were their 2 best players!
Tell me, how many goals did Palace score as a result of those two wingers? Zaha played very well and Bolasie was good too, but all their trickery and running led to exactly sod all. They scored a goal from a corner and the result of poor marking. If the best player on the pitch is restricted to dinking the ball onto the goalkeeper because you've pushed them far enough towards the line then you've done your job as a full back
Obviously watching a different game to many lifers. Thought Wilson was poor and his positional play was naive at best. Seemed to be the only player who was afforded any time and space by palace but did nothing with it. His shot in the last minute summed up his decision making for me.
Tell me, how many goals did Palace score as a result of those two wingers? Zaha played very well and Bolasie was good too, but all their trickery and running led to exactly sod all. They scored a goal from a corner and the result of poor marking. If the best player on the pitch is restricted to dinking the ball onto the goalkeeper because you've pushed them far enough towards the line then you've done your job as a full back
Tell me, how many goals did Palace score as a result of those two wingers? Zaha played very well and Bolasie was good too, but all their trickery and running led to exactly sod all. They scored a goal from a corner and the result of poor marking. If the best player on the pitch is restricted to dinking the ball onto the goalkeeper because you've pushed them far enough towards the line then you've done your job as a full back
Okay maybe solly was alright but wilson!!!!!!!
I thought Wilson was decent. He stood Bolasie up fine and pushed him out wide. He let him get the wrong side of him once or twice which wasn't good but he used his pace to track back and move him out again. Bolasie contributed no decent crosses all night and in the end he got frustrated and had to be brought off because he was in danger of getting a red. Going forward he put in some decent balls that amounted to chances, had one great run and pass where Fuller really should have scored but put it wide and linked up well with Green, bringing him in to the game. He also showed great composure on the ball when he took it round Murray, and stayed on his feet when the little shit had a kick at him. That shot at the end was a bad decision but there we go. If one of our strikers had converted one of his passes or free kicks his marks would have shot up. That's just my view on Wilson's game though, I know a lot of people were disappointed with him. Everything I've said is backed up with evidence as I did watch him quite closely, and I think it's fair. Certainly doesn't deserve to be written off the way he has been by some
Hamer 6 - took crosses well and good header Solly 7 - looked typically unflappable on both sides Morrison 6.5 - started nervy but settled well Cort 7.5 - unbeatable in the air Pritchard 4 - totally out of his depth Hollands 5 - anonymous Stephens 6 - lightweight Jackson 5 - looked tired Kermorgant 5 - quiet but good in the air Wright Phillips 5.5 - unusually poor touch
Wilson 6 - great crosser Fuller 6 - looks dangerous
Hamer 7. Not really troubled too much. Done what was needed. Would have got 900/10 if header went in Solly 7. Decent shift in an unfamliar position Morrison 7. Decent game Cort 7.5 Won the ariel battle Pritchard 5. Looks lost out wide Hollands 5. Game past him by Stephens 6. Saw good and bad in his play but at least showed some drive Jackson 4. Oh dear Kermorgant 5. An off game for him, summed up by his woeful free kick Wright Phillips 7. Never stopped chasing down. good shift. Goal should have stood
Wilson. 6. thought he done well coming into a difficult match. Nowhere near as bad as some suggest Fuller 6. Finishing not up to scratch but showed signs that he's going to be a quality player for us this season
Hamer 7 - not a lot to do, great header at the end Solly 8 MOM - Zaha couldn't get past him, had to keep going to the other flank Morrison 7 - Solid as ever, liked how he brought the ball into midfield rather than hoof it Cort 7 - Solid Pritchard 5 - Like the rest of the midfield seems to be struggling with the formation Hollands 5 - we're not getting the best out of him right now, looks confused Stephens 7 - best game for a while Jackson 5 - he's not got going this year yet Kermorgant 5 - poor game, seemed to forget to work hard too Wright Phillips 7.5 - worked his socks off, didn't stop running - no service though
Wilson 6 - poor defensively but looked better coming forward. Fuller 7 - his presence changed the game but poor miss
Hamer 7 Did well. Extra point for nearly scoring. Solly 7.5 MOM. Played very well, as on the left. Morrison 7 Very good game. Cort 6.5 Good game. Pritchard 4 Sorry to say, that's 2 games running, he's been completely lost. Needs to be dropped I'm afraid. Hollands 5.5 Not great but must be difficult being the only one in midfield, who can compete. Stephens 5 Too many poor passes & getting brushed aside. If he's to remain he needs some big battlers to do his work.
Jackson 5 A little better, but bystander in the main as he has been all season. Kermorgant 5 Worst game for Charlton. Didn't win a lot tonight. Wright Phillips 6 Did Ok & of course should have had a goal.
Wilson 6 Did quite well. I can't understand all the criticism. I really can't. Fuller 7.5 Changed the game for the 2nd game running. Class above the rest.
Hamer - 7 One fumble, but otherwise good Solly - 7 Positive going forwad, switched sides well. Morrison - 7 Decent showing Cort - 7 Massive, nothing passes him Pritchard - 3 Triple frightmare, just seemed too much for him Hollands - 5 Poor, game passed him by Stephens - 5 One misplace pass after another. Jackson - 5 Out of position, lost his man constantly and gave the ball away under no pressure. Kermorgant - 7 The amount he won in the air was amazing Wright Phillips - 7 Terrifying in full flight.
Wilson did well, Green was excellent, Fuller got into the right places but it didn't come off. Wiggins was getting ripped up before he came off. Funny game, flat crowd, flat performance, but we were unlucky to come away with nothing.
Hamer 7 Did well. Extra point for nearly scoring. Solly 7.5 MOM. Played very well, as on the left. Morrison 7 Very good game. Cort 6.5 Good game. Pritchard 4 Sorry to say, that's 2 games running, he's been completely lost. Needs to be dropped I'm afraid. Hollands 5.5 Not great but must be difficult being the only one in midfield, who can compete. Stephens 5 Too many poor passes & getting brushed aside. If he's to remain he needs some big battlers to do his work.
Jackson 5 A little better, but bystander in the main as he has been all season. Kermorgant 5 Worst game for Charlton. Didn't win a lot tonight. Wright Phillips 6 Did Ok & of course should have had a goal.
Wilson 6 Did quite well. I can't understand all the criticism. I really can't. Fuller 7.5 Changed the game for the 2nd game running. Class above the rest.
You really are missing something sitting behind the goal And what were they giving you in the Lib before the game?
Stephens was the only one in the midfield with any drive. Tracking back, composed on the ball, interceptions, tackling, some good passes (albeit a few poor ones also). With Solly and Hamer was one of our best players.I thought Hollands was the better player but from what I've seem so far this I may be changing my opinion.
Agree with you regarding Wilson though.. but was concentrating on him going forward more.
Comments
Hamer - ok, but I think we should replace him in goal and play him up front ;-)
Solly - not bad for a position that's not his first choice.
Wilson - the only one of our team that seemed to have any time on the ball. Sadly nothing came of it.
Jackson - Particularly disappointing.
Solly - 7
Morrison - 6
Cort - 6
Pritchard - 5
Hollands - 5
Stephens - 7
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 5
Wright Phillips - 6
Wilson - 6
Fuller - 6
Solly 7
Morrison 7
Cort 7.5
Pritchard 5.5
Hollands 6
Stephens 7
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 6.5
Wright Phillips 7
Wilson 6
Fuller 6.5
Solly - 7
Morrison - 6.5
Cort - 6.5
Pritchard - 5
Hollands - 5
Stephens - 4
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 5
Wright Phillips - 6
Wilson - 6
Fuller - 6.5
Solly 5 struggled against his man.
Morrison 5
Cort 5
Pritchard 4 worst game for him
Hollands 4 same as pritchard
Stephens 5
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 5
Wright Phillips 6
Wilson 4
Fuller 5
Hamer. 6.5
Solly. 7
Morrison. 6.5
Cort. 7
Pritchard. 6
Hollands. 6
Stephens. 6.5
Jackson. 5.5
Kermorgant. 6
Wright Phillips 6.5
Solly 6
Morrison 6
Cort 6
Pritchard 5
Hollands 5
Stephens 5
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 5
Wright Phillips 6
Wilson 5
Fuller 6
Obviously watching a different game to many lifers. Thought Wilson was poor and his positional play was naive at best. Seemed to be the only player who was afforded any time and space by palace but did nothing with it. His shot in the last minute summed up his decision making for me.
Solly 7
Morrison 7.5
Cort 7
Pritchard 5
Hollands 7
Stephens 7
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 6
Wright Phillips 7
Wilson 7
Fuller 7.5
Solly 7 - looked typically unflappable on both sides
Morrison 6.5 - started nervy but settled well
Cort 7.5 - unbeatable in the air
Pritchard 4 - totally out of his depth
Hollands 5 - anonymous
Stephens 6 - lightweight
Jackson 5 - looked tired
Kermorgant 5 - quiet but good in the air
Wright Phillips 5.5 - unusually poor touch
Wilson 6 - great crosser
Fuller 6 - looks dangerous
Solly - 7
Morrison - 6.5
Cort - 7
Pritchard 5.5
Hollands - 6
Stephens - 6
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 7
Wright Phillips - 6.5
Wilson - 7
Fuller - 7
Wiggins n/a
Green n/a - but would have been 7
Solly 7. Decent shift in an unfamliar position
Morrison 7. Decent game
Cort 7.5 Won the ariel battle
Pritchard 5. Looks lost out wide
Hollands 5. Game past him by
Stephens 6. Saw good and bad in his play but at least showed some drive
Jackson 4. Oh dear
Kermorgant 5. An off game for him, summed up by his woeful free kick
Wright Phillips 7. Never stopped chasing down. good shift. Goal should have stood
Wilson. 6. thought he done well coming into a difficult match. Nowhere near as bad as some suggest
Fuller 6. Finishing not up to scratch but showed signs that he's going to be a quality player for us this season
Solly - 8
Morrison - 7.5
Cort - 7
Pritchard - 5
Hollands - 5
Stephens - 6
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 5.5
Wright Phillips - 7
Wilson - 5.5
Fuller - 6.5
Hamer. 7
Solly. 7
Morrison. 7
Cort. 6
Pritchard 5
Hollands. 5
Stephens 6.5
Jackson. 5
Kermorgant. 5
Wright Phillips. 6.5
Wilson. 6
Fuller. 6.5
Wiggins n/a
Green n/a
Solly 8 MOM - Zaha couldn't get past him, had to keep going to the other flank
Morrison 7 - Solid as ever, liked how he brought the ball into midfield rather than hoof it
Cort 7 - Solid
Pritchard 5 - Like the rest of the midfield seems to be struggling with the formation
Hollands 5 - we're not getting the best out of him right now, looks confused
Stephens 7 - best game for a while
Jackson 5 - he's not got going this year yet
Kermorgant 5 - poor game, seemed to forget to work hard too
Wright Phillips 7.5 - worked his socks off, didn't stop running - no service though
Wilson 6 - poor defensively but looked better coming forward.
Fuller 7 - his presence changed the game but poor miss
Solly 7
Morrison 7
Cort 7
Pritchard 4
Hollands 6
Stephens 6
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 5
Wright-Phillips 6
Wilson 5
Fuller 6
Solly 7
Morrison 7
Cort 6
Pritchard 5
Hollands 6
Stephens 6
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 5
Wright Phillips 6
Wilson 5
Fuller 6
Green played well when he came on against tired legs.
Solly - 7.5
Morrison - 7
Cort - 7
Pritchard -4.5
Hollands - 5
Stephens - 7
Jackson - 3
Kermorgant - 4
Wright Phillips - 6
Wilson - 6
Fuller - 6
Solly 7.5 MOM. Played very well, as on the left.
Morrison 7 Very good game.
Cort 6.5 Good game.
Pritchard 4 Sorry to say, that's 2 games running, he's been completely lost. Needs to be dropped I'm afraid.
Hollands 5.5 Not great but must be difficult being the only one in midfield, who can compete.
Stephens 5 Too many poor passes & getting brushed aside. If he's to remain he needs some big battlers to do his work.
Jackson 5 A little better, but bystander in the main as he has been all season.
Kermorgant 5 Worst game for Charlton. Didn't win a lot tonight.
Wright Phillips 6 Did Ok & of course should have had a goal.
Wilson 6 Did quite well. I can't understand all the criticism. I really can't.
Fuller 7.5 Changed the game for the 2nd game running. Class above the rest.
Solly - 7 Positive going forwad, switched sides well.
Morrison - 7 Decent showing
Cort - 7 Massive, nothing passes him
Pritchard - 3 Triple frightmare, just seemed too much for him
Hollands - 5 Poor, game passed him by
Stephens - 5 One misplace pass after another.
Jackson - 5 Out of position, lost his man constantly and gave the ball away under no pressure.
Kermorgant - 7 The amount he won in the air was amazing
Wright Phillips - 7 Terrifying in full flight.
Wilson did well, Green was excellent, Fuller got into the right places but it didn't come off. Wiggins was getting ripped up before he came off. Funny game, flat crowd, flat performance, but we were unlucky to come away with nothing.
Solly - 7
Morrison - 7
Cort - 7
Pritchard - 6
Hollands - 6.5
Stephens - 7.5
Jackson - 6
Kermorgant - 6.5
Wright Phillips - 7
Wilson - 6.5
Fuller - 7
Stephens was the only one in the midfield with any drive. Tracking back, composed on the ball, interceptions, tackling, some good passes (albeit a few poor ones also). With Solly and Hamer was one of our best players.I thought Hollands was the better player but from what I've seem so far this I may be changing my opinion.
Agree with you regarding Wilson though.. but was concentrating on him going forward more.
Solly - 6
Morrison - 6
Cort - 6.5
Pritchard - 4
Hollands - 5
Stephens - 6.5
Jackson - 4
Kermorgant - 4
Wright Phillips - 6
Wilson - 6
Fuller -6
Solly 7
Cort 6
Morrison 6
Jackson 5
Stephens 6
Hollands 6
Pritchard 5
Kermorgant 5
Wright- Phillips 6
Wilson 6
Fuller 6
Solly 8
Morrison 7
Cort 7
Pritchard 6.5
Hollands 6
Stephens 6.5
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 6
Wright Phillips 7
Wilson 7
Fuller 7