Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Deadline Day from Pg.641 - Summer 2025 Charlton Athletic Transfer Rumours

15051535556682

Comments

  • AndyG
    AndyG Posts: 5,906
    CAFCDAZ said:
    AndyG said:
    £3.5m plus add ons is a great deal for us imo
    That is absolutely ridiculous to believe 3.5m is a good deal
    You think ? How many games has he been fit to play the last 2 years ? 
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,219
    Sounds like something that might have happened a year ago rather than now.
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 627
    That Leaburn link is complete rubbish you click on the actually website and it has other ridiculous transfer rumours that make no sense 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,285
    No one is paying 3.5m for leaburn when they can wait and see how his fitness is this season and then get him for a fraction of that amount next summer 
  • Woodwork
    Woodwork Posts: 423
    CAFCDAZ said:
    AndyG said:
    £3.5m plus add ons is a great deal for us imo
    That is absolutely ridiculous to believe 3.5m is a good deal
    Indeed. It would be a fucking amazing deal. 
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,319
    edited June 1
    NabySarr said:
    No one is paying 3.5m for leaburn when they can wait and see how his fitness is this season and then get him for a fraction of that amount next summer 
    What if a club waits till next summer, miss out on him, and he turns into the next Harry Kane - Highly unlikely but its why teams will tend to take the risk.

    If a club has the money to burn these days, they tend to take the risk because they can afford it. If Leaburn has a stormer of a season; Hertha BSC will probably be one of the last clubs he'd consider joining compared to now.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,285
    NabySarr said:
    No one is paying 3.5m for leaburn when they can wait and see how his fitness is this season and then get him for a fraction of that amount next summer 
    What if a club waits till next summer, miss out on him, and he turns into the next Harry Kane - Highly unlikely but its why teams will tend to take the risk.

    If a club has the money to burn these days, they tend to take the risk because they can afford it. If Leaburn has a stormer of a season; Hertha BSC will probably be one of the last clubs he'd consider joining compared to now.
    That is true but 3.5m is too much. With a year on his deal and injury issues I think we’d be lucky to get 2m this summer 

    I’m hoping with our promotion that we can get him on a new contract
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,285
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
  • Swisdom
    Swisdom Posts: 14,977
    Selling Leaburn now would be daft.  He’s had a rough time with injuries but he has literally only just stopped growing.  His body is constantly adjusting to the stresses it goes through so it’s expected it will fail at at times.  Hopefully he’ll get a full Nathan pre-season into him and come out of the blocks flying.   
  • Sponsored links:



  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 26,127
    Can PNE really afford four times a salary from Charlton? 
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    Can PNE really afford four times a salary from Charlton? 
    Yes, it's the same as when Bauer went there, they can just afford more wages than us. 

    Look at their wage bill compared to ours (not sure how accurate but probably won't be far off) 


  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    NabySarr said:
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
    But that is the championship. Most decent players are on 5 figures a week. 

    Oxford United have multiple players on 5 digits a week and then the higher end of the thousands. 

    This is championship football, the wages are genuinely crazy.
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    Swisdom said:
    Selling Leaburn now would be daft.  He’s had a rough time with injuries but he has literally only just stopped growing.  His body is constantly adjusting to the stresses it goes through so it’s expected it will fail at at times.  Hopefully he’ll get a full Nathan pre-season into him and come out of the blocks flying.   
    As much as I like him, and recognise his ceiling, if 3.5 million were true, we'd be daft to turn it down.

    That could change our season. Too much money to ignore for someone who doesn't start for us, and we don't know if he can get back to his best now.

    That said, I can't see anyone paying a fee like that after all the injuries.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,051
    Can’t see anywhere offering him a 5 year deal, he’s young but deals that long don’t happen much outside of the top tier 
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 21,269
    All of those numbers for Charlton would have gone up with promotion bonuses, so the jump between us and Preston will be a lot smaller. 

    Also we're at the start of the summer, in a couple of months time, depending on a lot of our activity in the market, 10k a week might be the going rate for our squad, so I can't see why "offering him 10k" will be a big deal
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,765
    1. Doubt it’s true from a random fan account

    2. We can’t stop other teams paying over the odds for unproven young players - we don’t even know if he’ll make the step up, so 10k p/w on a five year contract would be horrendous for the club

    3. The challenge is finding better, for cheaper - we got a better left back (Edwards) last summer and I’m sure we can find a better winger this summer
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,219
    Can PNE really afford four times a salary from Charlton? 
    Yes, it's the same as when Bauer went there, they can just afford more wages than us

    Look at their wage bill compared to ours (not sure how accurate but probably won't be far off) 


    Is it a case of affording more wages than us or just willing to pay more wages and rack up more losses but retain Championship status? 

    They clearly pay more for being an established Championship team but they average 16.5k gates and don't receive parachute money so not sure how they afford to pay wages other than just paying the going rate to stand still. I find them a really curious case, certainly feel they could be in potential relegation trouble this season.

    So the question really is how ambitious are our owners? are they willing to match the likes of Preston's wage bill and how quickly will they do that? will our best players then want new contracts with wages to match? again all roads lead to the owners
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,765
    Yeah reckon he’s a solid source of info


  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    edited June 1
    1. Doubt it’s true from a random fan account

    2. We can’t stop other teams paying over the odds for unproven young players - we don’t even know if he’ll make the step up, so 10k p/w on a five year contract would be horrendous for the club

    3. The challenge is finding better, for cheaper - we got a better left back (Edwards) last summer and I’m sure we can find a better winger this summer
    Not being rude, but I think you're underestimating the magnitude of this league and its wage structure. 

    I am not saying it is right, and I don't expect the club to pay it, but these are the going rates.

    He is 20, English, plays for the England u21s, has Premier league pedigree, has interest from Blackburn, Millwall, Preston and God knows who else.

    10k a week is not a lot of money for a player of that talent in the Championship. All there is to it.

    If we aren't willing to pay those sort of wages, we will have to find some real gems to compete. 
  • Sponsored links:



  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,051
    Just for clarity he doesn’t play for England U21s, he played 1/2 games for the U20s due to others pulling out 
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,376
    NabySarr said:
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
    But that is the championship. Most decent players are on 5 figures a week. 

    Oxford United have multiple players on 5 digits a week and then the higher end of the thousands. 

    This is championship football, the wages are genuinely crazy.
    Exactly, if we don’t compete on wages we’ll go straight back down.

    I doubt we were limited to paying under £5k for everyone last season, it’s probably that not much of a stretch to start paying £10k a week.
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    fenaddick said:
    Just for clarity he doesn’t play for England U21s, he played 1/2 games for the U20s due to others pulling out 
    So he has still played for England at an international level at some capacity.

    The point is, he's no schmuck, and will be on a lot of radars.
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,765
    edited June 1
    1. Doubt it’s true from a random fan account

    2. We can’t stop other teams paying over the odds for unproven young players - we don’t even know if he’ll make the step up, so 10k p/w on a five year contract would be horrendous for the club

    3. The challenge is finding better, for cheaper - we got a better left back (Edwards) last summer and I’m sure we can find a better winger this summer
    Not being rude, but I think you're underestimating the magnitude of this league and its wage structure. 

    I am not saying it is right, and I don't expect the club to pay it, but these are the going rates.

    He is 20, English, plays for the England u21s, has Premier league pedigree, has interest from Blackburn, Millwall, Preston and God knows who else.

    10k a week is not a lot of money for a player of that talent in the Championship. All there is to it.

    If we aren't willing to pay those sort of wages, we will have to find some real gems to compete. 
    Who said we aren’t willing to pay those wages? We probably will, for the right player.

    I’m saying I don’t think it’s smart to overpay for an unproven young player who hasn’t had success anywhere else but in SE7. He’s struggled against any full back who can match his pace and physicality - it’ll only get harder for him a level up. Good luck to him if a club is silly enough to pay it.

    I have every confidence we find the gems you are worried we won’t. In fact, I bet we finish above Preston in the league table, regardless of which club Thierry Small ends up at.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,285
    Scoham said:
    NabySarr said:
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
    But that is the championship. Most decent players are on 5 figures a week. 

    Oxford United have multiple players on 5 digits a week and then the higher end of the thousands. 

    This is championship football, the wages are genuinely crazy.
    Exactly, if we don’t compete on wages we’ll go straight back down.

    I doubt we were limited to paying under £5k for everyone last season, it’s probably that not much of a stretch to start paying £10k a week.
    Everyone’s contract will have had a promotion wage increase written in so I’m sure we’ve got players not far off that already now 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,051
    edited June 1
    fenaddick said:
    Just for clarity he doesn’t play for England U21s, he played 1/2 games for the U20s due to others pulling out 
    So he has still played for England at an international level at some capacity.

    The point is, he's no schmuck, and will be on a lot of radars.
    Agreed but the U20s team is a weird one because the proper elite talent tend to bypass it and go straight to the 21s. Still high pedigree of course but not the same as if it was the 21s. 

    I’m of the view that the longer this goes on the more chance there is that he signs with us for a year, that’s if Jones would take him after what could be viewed as a possible lack of commitment 
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 21,269
    Also Josh Bowler on that list was on loan to them for the first half of the season from Forest so they wouldn't have been paying the full £30k and the second guy on the list Okkels spent the second half of the season on loan at Aberdeen and I'd be amazed if they were loaning out their top earner, so either that wage is a poor guess or they're not the type of club to base budgets on because they're clearly turd at it
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    Scoham said:
    NabySarr said:
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
    But that is the championship. Most decent players are on 5 figures a week. 

    Oxford United have multiple players on 5 digits a week and then the higher end of the thousands. 

    This is championship football, the wages are genuinely crazy.
    Exactly, if we don’t compete on wages we’ll go straight back down.

    I doubt we were limited to paying under £5k for everyone last season, it’s probably that not much of a stretch to start paying £10k a week.
    Last season we done really well. The reports look like we had the 8th highest budget (despite being told we were top4) and fair play to Jones, he got us promoted. Identified some real gems as well in Edwards, Ramsay etc.

    The issue is now, we are without a doubt operating with the lowest wage structure. 8th to to the top 6 was just 1.4 million isn't too unrealistic to keep up with. Whole different structure now. 

    The owners are going to have to take the hit if we want survival, it's just how it goes nowadays, or risk being a club like Rotherham, Barnsley, Peterborough, Wigan etc.

    Main thing is we have Jones, with him and his style we have a chance. Just disappointing that we can't offer competitive wages. 
  • charente addick
    charente addick Posts: 3,808
    Can PNE really afford four times a salary from Charlton? 
    Yes, it's the same as when Bauer went there, they can just afford more wages than us. 

    Look at their wage bill compared to ours (not sure how accurate but probably won't be far off) 


    Little wonder that football has problems
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,765
    Scoham said:
    NabySarr said:
    It’s a tough balancing act though, if we give Small 10k a week then every player will be knocking on Jones door asking for similar 
    But that is the championship. Most decent players are on 5 figures a week. 

    Oxford United have multiple players on 5 digits a week and then the higher end of the thousands. 

    This is championship football, the wages are genuinely crazy.
    Exactly, if we don’t compete on wages we’ll go straight back down.

    I doubt we were limited to paying under £5k for everyone last season, it’s probably that not much of a stretch to start paying £10k a week.
    Last season we done really well. The reports look like we had the 8th highest budget (despite being told we were top4) and fair play to Jones, he got us promoted. Identified some real gems as well in Edwards, Ramsay etc.

    The issue is now, we are without a doubt operating with the lowest wage structure. 8th to to the top 6 was just 1.4 million isn't too unrealistic to keep up with. Whole different structure now. 

    The owners are going to have to take the hit if we want survival, it's just how it goes nowadays, or risk being a club like Rotherham, Barnsley, Peterborough, Wigan etc.

    Main thing is we have Jones, with him and his style we have a chance. Just disappointing that we can't offer competitive wages. 
    It’s the first of June. Why not wait and see how it all works out? We can’t control what other clubs offer Thierry Small. 

    If the club is building sustainably then we should have a figure in mind of what we believe he is worth - if he wants to go elsewhere then that’s his prerogative. 

    We trust in Nathan Jones and Phil Chapple to find a worthy/better replacement.