Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

January Transfer Window (rumours + actuals)

1…7071737576…169

Comments

  • Scoham
    Scoham
    SteveACS said:
    Scoham said:
    SteveACS said:
    sarge1g said:
    Redhenry said:
    alburyaddick said:
    I am completely mystified by those on here who keep on saying we should be getting another keeper 
    NJ has woken up to the fact that AMB is better than both Isted ( completely useless) and now Mannion 
    The only weakness in his game is distribution but as a keeper who saves goals he is very good.
    So long as the defence in front of him remains solid 
    he is a perfectly good keeper at this level and I would argue / Championship too - if we ever get there !!!! 


    Mystified :)
    Apart from stays on his line, flaps on crosses and gets pushed around too easily on set pieces...
      
      I think the criticism about AMB's faults should be aimed at the goal keeping coach, surely it is his job to improve the keepers. 
    A coach can improve technically a players abilities, not his character.

    If a player is bone idle, there's no way a coach can change that. (I am emphatically NOT saying that about AMB!)

    The coming out to claim crosses, one of the important factors is bravery. Again, I'm not saying AMB is cowardly, but the number of broken noses/concussions he's suffered has probably dented his confidence.

    One of our best all round 'keepers we've had in recent years was Ben Amos. Decent shot stopper, and, crucially, very brave. He came and claimed crosses when there were heads, boots, elbows flying around.

    The effect of that was the defenders in front of him had much more confidence in him.

    The result? There was a period when we had Inniss and Famwe in front of him when we went something like 9 hours without conceding a goal.

    It was a shame he wanted to return back to his roots up North.
    The amount of head injuries AMB has had doesn’t suggest bravery is an issue, he throws himself where he can get hurt.

    I think that’s different to confidence to come and claim crosses, he’s never been that type of GK. Some naturally do it, and some GKs are 6 ft 5+ plus which makes it easier.
    Again, though, it's not just height...

    Who was the keeper we had last year that played in the LVPM Cup games? He was enormous! Even bigger than Miles, but hardly ever caught a cross. Always came and punched. (Usually feebly!)

    I remember one game where he actually caught the ball, and the ironic cheers from the Charlton fans could be heard in Gillingham!
    Never said it was just height, I said it's easier for those huge GKs. Of course there will be huge GKs who still don't do it, despite their height.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    They’ve got injuries so no chance. He will be starting tonight I think 
  • ross1
    ross1
    MintoHumbugs said:
    I don’t think a keeper will come in this window.
    Mannion good in the air and commands the box and AWB is a good shot stopper .
    A decent keeper between them 
    In that case, can we play both at the same time 😂
  • eaststandmike
    eaststandmike
    MarcusH26 said:

    I'd expect the midfielder to be signed and announced before the meeting tonight and then some hints from NJ and the SMT that " more deals are in the works" 
    Prepare to be disappointed 
  • Oh Eddie Youds...
    Oh Eddie Youds...
    John_Fitzpatrick1 said:
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    He has started and played 90mins the last three games. 21 appearances this season. Get a grip mr idiot 
    Chill @John_Fitzpatrick1

    A Birmingham fan discussed Leonard being one who could be on the move in this article a couple of days ago:

    https://footballleagueworld.co.uk/theres-always-a-question-mark-birmingham-city-advised-to-explore-shock-23-year-old-departure/

    Wasn’t aware Brum had injuries & he had began to start games (believe the majority of the 21 games you mention have been short sub & EFL trophy appearances)
  • Sponsored links:


  • 19addickted96
    19addickted96
    Junior Quintera could be off to Argentina.
    any add ons or cash due to us?
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick
    19addickted96 said:
    Junior Quintera could be off to Argentina.
    any add ons or cash due to us?
    I guess we might get a tiny amount as a development fee but it’ll be peanuts 
  • Oh Eddie Youds...
    Oh Eddie Youds...
    ForeverAddickted said:
    Callumcafc said:
    John_Fitzpatrick1 said:
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    He has started and played 90mins the last three games. 21 appearances this season. Get a grip mr idiot 
    Steady on!!
    Rude of him to presume @Oh_Eddie's gender... ;)
    LOL. I’ve been called a lot worse than Mr.Idiot tbf!

    Terry Taylor has started more league one games for Charlton than Marc Leonard has for Birmingham this season….& TT obviously moved to get more playing time.

    It’s not unthinkable that Leonard will do the same if Birmingham’s first choice midfielders are close to coming back from injury.
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc
    I wanted Leonard in the summer and wouldn’t be at all opposed to it now. But I don’t think Birmingham let him go - not until this upcoming summer when they will probably sign another 20 players and the likes of Leonard, May, etc. probably become available.
  • North Lower Neil
    North Lower Neil
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    Don't think they'd sell him in January - hasn't been an automatic starter but is a useful squad player.

    If they go up could see him being sold in the summer though.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick
    I think the reality is that a CAM of decent pedigree will be hard to come by in this window. Just thinking back to last Jan when Collins was reportedly sold for 1m+. Do we have those funds and do the club consider it worthwhile to spend that in January to supersede/challenge what was meant to be one of our statement signings over the summer. 

    I know NJ is against them but it’s a position where I’d be tempted to see if there’s someone in a PL academy who might be able to come in. They would likely have legs and technical ability at the very least. Harvey Vale is the name that stands out to me 
  • L0rd_M0ntagu3
    L0rd_M0ntagu3
    fenaddick said:
    I think the reality is that a CAM of decent pedigree will be hard to come by in this window. Just thinking back to last Jan when Collins was reportedly sold for 1m+. Do we have those funds and do the club consider it worthwhile to spend that in January to supersede/challenge what was meant to be one of our statement signings over the summer. 

    I know NJ is against them but it’s a position where I’d be tempted to see if there’s someone in a PL academy who might be able to come in. They would likely have legs and technical ability at the very least. Harvey Vale is the name that stands out to me 
    Harvey Vale would be a very good option. Can play LWB and Left wing too. Would bring real versatility. 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick
    L0rd_M0ntagu3 said:
    fenaddick said:
    I think the reality is that a CAM of decent pedigree will be hard to come by in this window. Just thinking back to last Jan when Collins was reportedly sold for 1m+. Do we have those funds and do the club consider it worthwhile to spend that in January to supersede/challenge what was meant to be one of our statement signings over the summer. 

    I know NJ is against them but it’s a position where I’d be tempted to see if there’s someone in a PL academy who might be able to come in. They would likely have legs and technical ability at the very least. Harvey Vale is the name that stands out to me 
    Harvey Vale would be a very good option. Can play LWB and Left wing too. Would bring real versatility. 
    He’s also not wanted at Chelsea so could even be a permanent option. No idea on how much he would cost or his contract situation though 
  • cafcsinger
    cafcsinger
    Harvey Vale was average at Bristol Rovers last season and has only played u21 football for Chelsea this season. Not what we need imo 
  • Sponsored links:


  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted
    Depends why it didnt work out at Bristol Rovers last season.

    Vale is the type of U21 (individual who looks to have to build his career from the lower reaches of the EFL) that we absolutely should be at least scouting... We've missed out on too many released Academy gems.
  • Richard J
    Richard J
    I liked Harvey Vale in the Vertu Cup tie at the Valley. However , he is being linked with Championship clubs.
  • Pelling1993
    Pelling1993
    John_Fitzpatrick1 said:
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    He has started and played 90mins the last three games. 21 appearances this season. Get a grip mr idiot 
    Mr Idiot is my fathers name, just call me Idiot.
  • StanTheMan
    StanTheMan
    Gribbo said:
    "Mr Idiot" - Goes straight into the book of favourite insults.

    I think I'd rather be called a silly old goat, politely off course👍
  • soapy_jones
    soapy_jones
    ForeverAddickted said:
    Callumcafc said:
    John_Fitzpatrick1 said:
    Oh Eddie Youds... said:
    If we have money to spend then we should definitely be offering to match the £500k that Birmingham paid in the summer for Marc Leonard…to take him off their hands.

    Cant get in the team at Brum but would be perfect as the man to pull the strings in our side.
    He has started and played 90mins the last three games. 21 appearances this season. Get a grip mr idiot 
    Steady on!!
    Rude of him to presume @Oh_Eddie's gender... ;)
    Did they inquire about their pronouns before they cnuted them off?
  • Major
    Major
    Redhenry said:
    alburyaddick said:
    I am completely mystified by those on here who keep on saying we should be getting another keeper 
    NJ has woken up to the fact that AMB is better than both Isted ( completely useless) and now Mannion 
    The only weakness in his game is distribution but as a keeper who saves goals he is very good.
    So long as the defence in front of him remains solid 
    he is a perfectly good keeper at this level and I would argue / Championship too - if we ever get there !!!! 


    Mystified :)
    Apart from stays on his line, flaps on crosses and gets pushed around too easily on set pieces...
      
    And doesn't take charge of the defence.
  • Danny Addick
    Danny Addick
    Gribbo said:
    "Mr Idiot" - Goes straight into the book of favourite insults.
    Ha, I was thinking the same thing!

Categories

“Marketplace”

Sponsored links: