Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Summer 2022 transfer rumours (Gilbey loan confirmed p513, a signing falls through last minute p541)
Comments
-
You were all crying out for a Washington replacement.
He's better than Washington.
Not really too upset about it if it does happen.5 -
Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.5
-
The funniest thing about Bonne signing is the fact that people will be left so confused - I mean your options are him and Stockley up top... Which one are you gonna whinge about.. decisions... decisions
1 -
Bonne not official yet, but I don't know what anyone realistically expects that would be much better than Bonne as a centre forward. He was a frustrating player when here last time, but also had his moments. It's clear the budget was never going to stretch to a real marquee, talismanic type signing. You'd all be better off to stop slagging off Chuks and start praying he gets fit asap and stays fit so he can contribute a significant number of goals off the bench.1
-
Imitation ? How fucking dare you. I've been supporting this club for 57 years & I've seen enough shite players & shite teams getting shite results to have become a miserable bastard without copying another miserable bast er gentleman. I can think for myself thanks......imitation my arse.eastterrace6168 said:golfaddick said:
Oi Mods ! someone's hacked my account & copied & pasted my thoughts from the past few years.charltonbob said:
Considered? FFS isn't it a bit late to be considering? Surely we should have had a list of targets lined up & should have been negotiating on the last day not considering. Why has it taken so long to decide to sign a striker? Oh yes prices come down apparently on the last day. bargains galore on the last day of the sales ! Great to see we learned the lessons from last yearRedrobo said:Cawley says Bonne being considered
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery that mediocrity can pay to greatness you know golfie...6 -
As I've said previously, I trust Ben Garner more than any other manager we've had for a long time. I'm not a fan of Bonne, but if Garner wants him, then I trust his ability to get the best out of him8
-
Your forgetting the mythical loan clause that he MUST play no ifs no buts.BR7_addick said:Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.1 -
I just can't see how Bonne does anything for us. There's a reason Ipswich fans don't want him back.
If we sign him over anyone else it puts a massive dampener on this window for me.4 -
What player seemingly triggers a large number of Charlton fans more than any other?LargeAddick said:Macauley effing Bonne. What was the question again?10 -
Bonne as cover for Stockley and Aneke is pretty good for League 1, stop the whinging15
- Sponsored links:
-
When did Stockley score double figures in the Championship? Bonne is better than Stockley, especially in this system with 1 up topBR7_addick said:Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.0 -
Seeing as it’s looking unlikely, don’t suppose you know who it was? 😉Covered End said:So the 95% done deal for the striker is looking unlikely. No surprise.0 -
Because they’ve got a massive budget and can afford someone better.Laddick01 said:I just can't see how Bonne does anything for us. There's a reason Ipswich fans don't want him back.
If we sign him over anyone else it puts a massive dampener on this window for me.2 -
Bonne is not better than Stockley.NabySarr said:
When did Stockley score double figures in the Championship? Bonne is better than Stockley, especially in this system with 1 up topBR7_addick said:Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.3 -
Do they? - Or are they just gambling with people's pension money? - I mean its potentially worked so far, they got Scott Fraser and then could have sold him on to us for more money (if true) just six months down the lineBR7_addick said:
Because they’ve got a massive budget and can afford someone better.Laddick01 said:I just can't see how Bonne does anything for us. There's a reason Ipswich fans don't want him back.
If we sign him over anyone else it puts a massive dampener on this window for me.0 -
Personally, I'd as sooner sign no one than Bonne who is neither that prolific or much of a target man, but the mob have been baying for blood over a new striker so the club have felt they have to sign someone. It seemed fairly clear a few weeks ago that the club didn't think there was a good enough player out there within budget but the message from the fans was "sign someone, anyone!". Well, be careful what you wish for.11
-
I’d rather have nobody.MuttleyCAFC said:Well he is a striker and will provide cover so I don't think we can be too sad if we get Bonne. I was expecting nobody.7 -
You really think Garner had a say in it. 3 hours before the window shuts and we are scrambling around the bargain bins yet again.AndyG said:If the Manager thinks Bonne can do a job that's good enough for me, on the proviso that he passes a test on the offside rule before he signs
Dont think Bonne is the player to get in behind defences that Sandgarrd mooted 2 days ago. Always offside & his finishing is worse than Washington's.5 -
Surely it's a loan right?
We haven't sold him for millions and then taken him back for next to nothing 2 years later have we?0 -
Like that Spurs player last season?Cafc43v3r said:
Your forgetting the mythical loan clause that he MUST play no ifs no buts.BR7_addick said:Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.1 - Sponsored links:
-
Morgan Fox on his way back to the Valley...
2 -
Thats a strong statement.hoof_it_up_to_benty said:Morgan Fox on his way back to the Valley...0 -
I don’t think there’s much between them but in this system I think he scores more goals and helps the team more than Stockley does. Every away game stockley has been dreadful. Bonne played on his own up front away at the likes of Fulham, West Brom etc and scored goals at a higher level than we are at now. If we get that player back then he’s better than StockleyBR7_addick said:
Bonne is not better than Stockley.NabySarr said:
When did Stockley score double figures in the Championship? Bonne is better than Stockley, especially in this system with 1 up topBR7_addick said:Bonne’s gonna sit on the bench behind Stockley in the pecking order. And when Aneke is fit he’ll be lucky to even make the bench.I think we’re being a bit dramatic here, unless you were expecting someone better than Stockley, which I don’t think was ever going to be the case.3 -
Henry Irving said:
Give us an "ISELR_addicks said:
There's only one Isaac Tanitoluwaloba Aduraoluwatimileyin Olaofe!Covered_End_Lad said:We have made contact with Millwall about Olaofe2 -
Chris Maguire anyone?
0 -
I know it's not saying much, but Bonne's finishing was one of his best attributes. The issue was the rest of his game.golfaddick said:
You really think Garner had a say in it. 3 hours before the window shuts and we are scrambling around the bargain bins yet again.AndyG said:If the Manager thinks Bonne can do a job that's good enough for me, on the proviso that he passes a test on the offside rule before he signs
Dont think Bonne is the player to get in behind defences that Sandgarrd mooted 2 days ago. Always offside & his finishing is worse than Washington's.8 -
Just imagine a starting eleven containing Fox and Bonne - how delighted our fans would be...ForeverAddickted said:
Thats a strong statement.hoof_it_up_to_benty said:Morgan Fox on his way back to the Valley...3 -
Loan if it happens ….. we never got anywhere the 2 mill that was mentioned for himSELR_addicks said:Surely it's a loan right?
We haven't sold him for millions and then taken him back for next to nothing 2 years later have we?1 -
If you want someone to keep getting caught offside and missing chances, then Bonne's your man!
What's with the collective amnesia hereabouts?
Selling him to QPR was one of the most un-Charlton transfer deals in recent memory - they were desperate and we managed to offload someone who wasn't good enough and get paid handsomely for it in the process.
We need him back like we need an outbreak of Ebola in the dressing room.7 -
Yup the mob will be gathering at the gates of The Valley with pitch forkseastterrace6168 said:You just know how this thread is going to end up come 11pm tonight...
1
