Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

David Whyte tribute applause at 10th minute, suggestion

This is just a suggestion but seeing as we did the applause at 3rd minute for Powell perhaps we can do the same for David Whyte and sing David Whyte Whyte Whyte at the 10th minute?
«13

Comments

  • Greenie
    Greenie Posts: 9,174
    This.
  • DiscoCAFC said:

    This is just a suggestion but seeing as we did the applause at 3rd minute for Powell perhaps we can do the same for David Whyte and sing David Whyte Whyte Whyte at the 10th minute?

    Nice idea Disco. Anyone with contacts at the club on here these days? Maybe a picture of David on the screen for that minute of the game would be good?
  • DiscoCAFC said:

    This is just a suggestion but seeing as we did the applause at 3rd minute for Powell perhaps we can do the same for David Whyte and sing David Whyte Whyte Whyte at the 10th minute?

    Nice idea Disco. Anyone with contacts at the club on here these days? Maybe a picture of David on the screen for that minute of the game would be good?
    Great idea
  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 58,153
    Good stuff
  • Halix
    Halix Posts: 2,237
    Would personally prefer a minutes silence to offer our respects.
  • nichorob
    nichorob Posts: 1,794
    Halix said:

    Would personally prefer a minutes silence to offer our respects.

    Same here.

    Would like this to catch on if the club don't though.

    As someone born in '84 he was one of my first Charlton heroes.
  • carly burn
    carly burn Posts: 19,645
    Halix said:

    Would personally prefer a minutes silence to offer our respects.

    Think both could be easily accommodated. I'll be singing Whyte Whyte Whyte in the tenth regardless
  • DiscoCAFC said:

    This is just a suggestion but seeing as we did the applause at 3rd minute for Powell perhaps we can do the same for David Whyte and sing David Whyte Whyte Whyte at the 10th minute?

    That would be a lovely tribute, Disco.



  • uie2
    uie2 Posts: 4,596
    Lovely idea
  • Absolutely this

  • Sponsored links:



  • Top idea.
  • Yeah, great idea. Definitely show our respects one way or another.
  • PL54
    PL54 Posts: 10,757
    There's a day a year to formally honour the fallen isn't there?

    Have any other former players died this year?
  • Think a minutes applause is more achievable than a silence, what with Watford selling out and that. Saying that If the club got involved then maybe we could do the silence.
  • Be great to have a montage of Whytey's goals on the screen before the match! Anyone know how we could ask to make this happen?
  • Great idea Disco.
  • dancafc
    dancafc Posts: 1,009
    I can't make tthe game Saturday my inconsiderate mates getting married but my 10 year old sons gonna pay my respects for me by singing his name.iv shown him all his goals on here and he loved them all so if your looking down Mr whyte you have a new fan
  • cafctom
    cafctom Posts: 11,397
    A minute's silence before the game is much more appropriate, but that doesn't seem to happen in football nowadays with fans breaking into contrived clapping anyway.

    With that said probably best to go for the 10th minute thing, and then just sing his name all game anyway!
  • Really think this is a good idea but would also like a proper minute's silence to reflect as well. In this way everyone would have a chance to remember.
  • DiscoCAFC
    DiscoCAFC Posts: 1,767
    cafctom said:

    A minute's silence before the game is much more appropriate, but that doesn't seem to happen in football nowadays with fans breaking into contrived clapping anyway.

    With that said probably best to go for the 10th minute thing, and then just sing his name all game anyway!

    I personally think a minutes applasue with a chant is better, it kind of brings back good memories of this player as well. David Whyte's family clearly knows he was a favourite back then and also enjoyed listening to his name at the Valley back then so I think that would probably put a smile to their faces.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 64,375
    IMO (although appreciate it should be dealt with case by case)

    where one person has passed away, applause is usually appropriate as a celebration of a life
    where we are reflecting upon a large scale conflict or a human disaster where many lives are lost, silence would be best
  • Be great to have a montage of Whytey's goals on the screen before the match! Anyone know how we could ask to make this happen?

    I'm happy to contact Iain Liddle tomorrow ( Comms Dept) to see what he thinks as he would probably be involved with the Big Screen pic/montage and the publicity around the tribute.

    Do Lifers want me to try to get this off the ground ?

  • IMO (although appreciate it should be dealt with case by case)

    where one person has passeddressapplause is usually appropriate as a celebration of a life
    where we are reflecting upon a large scale conflict or a human disaster where many lives are lost, silence would be best

    Passed away too young for it to be a celebration. It's tragic and therefore silence is more fitting imo. Think it should form part of the annual remembrance.
  • se9addick
    se9addick Posts: 32,195

    Be great to have a montage of Whytey's goals on the screen before the match! Anyone know how we could ask to make this happen?

    I'm happy to contact Iain Liddle tomorrow ( Comms Dept) to see what he thinks as he would probably be involved with the Big Screen pic/montage and the publicity around the tribute.

    Do Lifers want me to try to get this off the ground ?

    Yes please. Would be wonderful to see him score at the Valley one last time.
  • Didn't realise the amount of goals he scored for us. Good idea. Again RIP David.
  • Valley11
    Valley11 Posts: 12,030
    Applause on 10mins is a great idea. I'll be thinking about when he pushed the ball past Steve Walsh (I think), ran round him and tucked it home.
    We went mental on the North Bank.
    RIP
  • It would be nice to do something, even if it was showing some of his goals before the match, he was part of my youth growing up and it's very sad news.
  • Iain Liddle is on leave but the Comms team are aware and have been discussing different options.

    Personally I think the 10th minute idea is spot on.
  • superclive
    superclive Posts: 1,813
    Agreed lovely idea. Perhaps the club could also I invite his family. Might be too early but would be nice to give them the option. What a player he was,
  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,640
    I would personally prefer a minutes silence pre game with pic of DW on the screen, but given some pratt will spoil it, a minutes applause.