MATCH THREAD : Barnsley V Charlton Athletic : Tuesday 22nd October 2024 : KO 19:45

Redhenry

Keillor-Dunne best player first half, we were poor

Chris81

Small, Berry (just to get Anderson off the pitch) need to be on. Potts even if he hadn't disappeared!

Dazzler21

sam3110 said:

follett said:

sam3110 said:

follett said:

Berry on at HT please

We need pace, not another pass merchant who can't actually score or assist goals

Given Anderson and Campbell are killing every attack I’d take someone who can pass

That's what Taylor and Coventry are meant to be good at.

I'd say fuck it and go 
Mannion
Watson Mitchell Gillesphey Edwards 
Dixon Coventry Taylor Campbell 
Leaburn Godden

Edited to remove REG who NEEDS subbing.

paulsturgess

Same old shite. Another dreadful half with absolutely zero threat. 

One goal in the first half all season! 

Let’s hope for another vast improvement in the second half, but the reality is we are going absolutely absolutely nowhere based on th season so far - Birmingham aside we’ve been poor all season and we’re a quarter of the way through. 

Leuth

The Coventry/Taylor midfield has looked largely good at least 

Brown59

Anderson totally overrated. He’s not good enough for this league. Then most the team tonight don’t look good enough. 

soapy_jones

I just want to see Wrexham anyway!

hoof_it_up_to_benty

We surely have to improve at some stage? Can't be a mediocre L1 mid table team indefinitely?

So many poor signings once again...

Old_Mike

Anderson just runs around. I’m baffled as to why he’s selected for every game. He offers nothing!

_MrDick

Those first three matches seem light years away now. Very poor first half performance 

Lazy_eye_metaphor

One word - lacklustre.

eastterrace6168

I can't help but feel for those die hard 500+ travelling Addicks travelling all that way on a Tuesday night, Nathan needs to kick some butts or this will end up very embarrassingly.... 

AmpshireAddick

REG off for me, I’d get Berry on for A.Campbell too.. Doc for Anderson. 

Dazzler21

LMAO who's our number 5 for the women's team? No pace at all and gifted Newcastle 2 and almost a third. 

Bailey

Not a lot in that, got to say we saw a defender on Saturday doing what he was told never to do, let the ball bounce' and tonight Mannion pushes the shot central rather than wide, two goals conceded from elementary mistakes. We need Tyreece on if possible, we are too predictable again, get him on the wing, make the full backs mark him, Godden and Leaburn are being marked by the whole of Barnsley's back four. 

golfaddick

Anderson off - Berry on
A.Cambell off - T. Campbell on

CL_Phantom

Meh. Started ok, and I guess we still were after the goal but we just cant find that killer ball/ shot. Play is breaking down around the Barnsley box mainly from our own doing thanks to a lack of quality, Leaburn has tried to make it happen but hes one lad and its a team game after all. Godden has tried getting shots off when he can but its slim pickings for Charlton strikers.... as usual.

Barnsley made their spell on the ball count. We didnt.

Anderson and Campbell have run around a lot, Campbell won a few fouls but thats about it from those two. 

Anderson off for TC or Berry please.

AFKABartram

Good half if you ignore that the opposition have had more goals, more possession, more shots, more shots on target, more corners, more crosses, more dribbles and more tackles won.  

Southbank

Old_Mike said:

Anderson just runs around. I’m baffled as to why he’s selected for every game. He offers nothing!

Maybe because we have nobody else who can play in that position  in a high press?

arny23394

I have been saying how bad Anderson is all season. No amount of running makes up for being that crap when you actually have possession of the ball. 

oohaahmortimer

The good news is, it’s actually not possible for Karoy to play any worse than he currently is 
utterly pony tonight 

charente addick

Can't think anyone is playing well. TC needs to come on, preferably for Taylor or A Cambell. REG looks targeted.

MrOneLung

As it stands table

only 2 points of playoffs

Chunes

What I don't understand is, in the latter stages of the transfer window NJ said he wanted to bring in some real quality, and then he signed Alan Campbell. 

BoysOwn

What a turgid performance so far. Charlton's problem is not a lack of effort, coordination or will. Just a pure lack of any real talent anywhere.

IR94

So many charlton fans try to make a player out of Anderson, 'he runs around' etc, but he is simply not up to the standard

sm

What is Alan Campbell doing? Can anyone enlighten us?

cazo

an absolute shit average league one side let’s all get fucking real

Dazzler21

Campbell has been better than Karoy. Not saying much though is it.

AmpshireAddick

No idea what we are doing letting them have that time and space to get the shot off.. looking at the replay I’m pretty sure Campbell actually moved out of the way of the ball… think Manion should do better too.