Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Josh Edwards
Comments
-
Yeh maybe you've got a point, but I never saw Solly drop a shoulder and score with his weak foot the way Edwards did vs Bristol Roverspaulsturgess said:
Think your memory is failing you there, prime solly was superb on the offensive and certainly much more of a threat than Edwards (who I like a lot but isn’t really offensive or turning opposing defenders inside out)LittleAddick said:In fairness to Edwards he's got a bit more about him in an attacking sense than Solly IMO, not saying he's a better full back mind0 -
Maybe some midfielders? Alan Campbell, Scott Fraser?Scoham said:Wouldn’t be surprised if we see more signings from Scotland in the next few years. Got to be more bargains out there.
6 -
Scoham said:Wouldn’t be surprised if we see more signings from Scotland in the next few years. Got to be more bargains out there.
Will be interesting to see what the transfer strategy looks like when Scott's replacement comes in , clearly Jones has identified Scotland as somewhere he thinks he can get talent , obviously the Theo Bair move didn't come off in the end because Auxerre offered a lot more money but Edwards has been superb and an absolute bargain for £75k.
1 -
Eswards has a great game for us. He injects energy and fight and is very consistent.0
-
I’m more impressed that someone decided he was worthy of a 4 years contract upon signing and has actually been worth it.
Since the RD era we’ve either signed good players on short deals or been lumbered into long deals for players we can’t get shot of.
Feels great we have Edwards tied in for another 3 years still.23 -
Brilliant once again today. So rarely puts a foot wrong15
-
Thought he was excellent today, playing alongside MacIntyre today couldn't have been easy. My MOTM.0
-
What a great signing Josh was. Consistently good and goes under the radar a lot of the time. Such an important player for us9
-
It might not have been his weaker foot but I'd take Solly's screamer away at Blackpool over that goal every day of the weekLittleAddick said:
Yeh maybe you've got a point, but I never saw Solly drop a shoulder and score with his weak foot the way Edwards did vs Bristol Roverspaulsturgess said:
Think your memory is failing you there, prime solly was superb on the offensive and certainly much more of a threat than Edwards (who I like a lot but isn’t really offensive or turning opposing defenders inside out)LittleAddick said:In fairness to Edwards he's got a bit more about him in an attacking sense than Solly IMO, not saying he's a better full back mind2 -
Sponsored links:
-
I absolutely love Josh. Rock hard, rarely gets beaten,decent ent skill for a left back. Proper Charlton type of player and seems like a top lad too. Fantastic signing for us29
-
Love him. My current favourite player. Biggest compliment I can pay him is he is exactly the sort of player Curbs used to sign.Looked much more solid at left centre back than MacIntyre did.Whoever scouted him deserves a big bonus. He was good from game one but has really come into his own as his settled into League One.
Has areas he needs to work on, but has time to do that and he’s building on such a solid base of consistency and doing the basics very well. He strikes me as the kind of player who could grow with a team as they work their way up the ladder and eventually get established in the Premier League - similar to how someone like Simon Francis did at Bournemouth.
I hope he gets a chance to do something like that with us and can rack up a few hundred more 7/10 performances.10 -
Been a long time since I last had an affinity with a player, but josh is definitely on that list. He's a proper player that runs through brick walls for the team and also has the ability to back it up.
2 -
Also never seen Edward’s score like solly did away at Blackpool in the championship. Calm.LittleAddick said:
Yeh maybe you've got a point, but I never saw Solly drop a shoulder and score with his weak foot the way Edwards did vs Bristol Roverspaulsturgess said:
Think your memory is failing you there, prime solly was superb on the offensive and certainly much more of a threat than Edwards (who I like a lot but isn’t really offensive or turning opposing defenders inside out)LittleAddick said:In fairness to Edwards he's got a bit more about him in an attacking sense than Solly IMO, not saying he's a better full back mind
i love Edwards. Think he’s great. Top lad and great, versatile player.
that said, he should have closed that fella down at the end today and not let him just bring it down!1 -
What's not to like about Josh4
-
He's Scottish!!...Rothko said:What's not to like about Josh
5 -
FA should have said he had a bit of stiffness and got pulled off by the manager.DamoNorthStand said:ForeverAddickted said:Sounds like Edwards had a bit of stiffness and fatigue according to Jones, hence why he got taken off when he did.
Well someone has to do it.2 -
I don’t really buy the Lloyd Jones hype. Edwards is probably our best player.
7 -
It definitely isn't hype.The Red Robin said:I don’t really buy the Lloyd Jones hype. Edwards is probably our best player.1 -
Sponsored links:
-
I like what Josh brings to the team but he's not out best/most important defender let alone player.The Red Robin said:I don’t really buy the Lloyd Jones hype. Edwards is probably our best player.2 -
Edwards has been our 4th best defender this season imo. He's still been really good but Jones, Gillesphey and Ramsay have been titanic2
-
He isn't Lloyd Jones level but he suffers from being ultra consistent. He hasn't had the highs of Gillesphey but he hasn't made the mistakes Gillesphey has either. It's brilliant to have someone who is almost always a 7/10 every fixture4
-
I think Josh has improved his attacking role as the season's gone on and of course he's got that long throw weapon too. We definitely look weaker when he not in the starting 11.5
-
He's a left footed, Scottish version of (prime) Chris Solly. Very rarely can you point out something spectacular that he did to win a game but on the other hand you would probably not notice him making any mistakes that lead to goals or even opportunities.Leuth said:Edwards has been our 4th best defender this season imo. He's still been really good but Jones, Gillesphey and Ramsay have been titanic
2 -
All flash and pomp on the surface but sink like many tons of metal as soon as they encounter some frozen water?Leuth said:Edwards has been our 4th best defender this season imo. He's still been really good but Jones, Gillesphey and Ramsay have been titanic6 -
I rate him very highly. Think he’s ready for the Championship - hopefully we are there ourselves, or no one else takes a punt in the summer. An underappreciated cog in the defensive machine that Nathan Jones has built.4
-
Any news on Josh's injury?0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0ju5anciV0&ab_channel=CharltonAthleticFootballClub
