Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Macauley Gillesphey [Signed 1 year extension, pg 12]

1679111214

Comments

  • follett said:
    Naby Sarr 2.0. Hated at first, before becoming good. Ping of a left foot, big mistake in him, stands over free kicks. Just awaiting the own goal at Wembley in May
    Or Laurie Wilson.
  • Macca was genuinely made up when we presented his MOM award. You could tell it meant a lot - and he spent some decent time chatting to my son. Said the spirit in the squad is the best he has ever been part of and all in all comes across as a thoroughly good bloke.
    Not heard that line before, hopefully it is true in this case.

    I'm sure it is. 
    Unless he was actually asked "how is the spirit in the squad" he'd have no reason to say it.
  • Ferryman
    Ferryman Posts: 2,921
    What a character arc!
  • Sage
    Sage Posts: 7,278
    Credit to him because for a long time I’ve not liked him as a player and there are glaring deficiencies in his game but he’s really improved over the last few games and came up with a vital goal for us at the perfect time. 
  • ElliotCAFC
    ElliotCAFC Posts: 2,553
    You have to give credit where it's due, I've been critical of him this season but he's been brilliant in the last few games. He's clearly got ability but seems like a confidence player, I really hope he kicks on for the rest of the season. 

    Special mention to how shy he was getting the plaudits last night, he seems like a lovely lad. 
  • AberystwythAddick
    AberystwythAddick Posts: 913
    edited February 12
    follett said:
    Naby Sarr 2.0. Hated at first, before becoming good. Ping of a left foot, big mistake in him, stands over free kicks. Just awaiting the own goal at Wembley in May
    Or Laurie Wilson.
    Used to be shite now he’s alright walking in a Macca wonderland! 

    For the record I’ve always thought he was a decent enough defender at the level 
  • Macca was genuinely made up when we presented his MOM award. You could tell it meant a lot - and he spent some decent time chatting to my son. Said the spirit in the squad is the best he has ever been part of and all in all comes across as a thoroughly good bloke.
    Great to hear all that..... thank you for sharing  :)
  • YTS1978
    YTS1978 Posts: 1,703
    Billy_Mix said:
    Credit where it’s due 
    a whole game without a serious error 
    that’s progress
    his recent trajectory has been upward
    a workinprogress 
    he’s still massively in debt on the goals conceded v scored/saved ledger
    here’s to more games like today 
    I'm not sure how many of his mistakes have led to goals being conceded....
    That's a very good question! We have one of the best defences we've had for years and don't really concede. Yeah, he fucked up at Blackpool but I'm struggling to think of another error leading to a goal?
  • Last time he spent a full season in
    league one he got promoted, the season before he was part of a team that had the 5th best defensive record.

    Not saying he’s a world beater - but he is nowhere near as bad as people made out.
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,229
    I did say 3 months ago Macauley Gillesphey may become a cult figure at CAFC; despite his improved form if he makes a bad mistake in a playoff match, cult may become altered.
  • Sponsored links:



  • comparing Macca to Naby is a sacrilege.  Naby’s outstanding plays were significantly better and his mistakes were much worse
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,229
    I was surprised when I heard Macca G speak as I thought he was going to speak in a west Country accent but I couldn't have been more wrong.

    Strong North east accent sounding more Geordie than Mackem but not Newcastle but the Old Mining centre of Ashington 15 miles North of the Geordie City.

    "Not a lot of people know this" but Pitmatic is the local Dialect and now Macauley Gillesphey joins the likes of Jackie Milburn, Bobby and Jackie Charlton, in the Ashington football hall of fame !

    Cricketers Steve and Ben Harmison and the person who I thought Gillesphey sounds like, Mark Wood all hail from Ashington. 
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    edited February 13
    Follow the fantasy points. Players don't end up top of the marks on stats by accident.

    He started off awful and very clumsy, there was no other way of looking at it tbh. 

    Last few months he's completely turned it around. 

    Top of the scores over every league1 club. The 24th highest rated player on the most renowned stats site and I think the 11th highest rated centre back in this league currently. 
  • Alwaysneil
    Alwaysneil Posts: 13,806
    Long may it continue as I am quite liking humble pie with HP sauce 
  • i hadn’t realised he was a Geordie until I heard his post match interview. From Ashington like the Charlton brothers. 
  • RC_CAFC
    RC_CAFC Posts: 1,756
    Have always thought he got a bit of unfair stick, but like our dear Naby, I suspect he is definitely one of those cb's that looks really good in a decent team and really bad in a poor one. 

    His combination of being decent on the ball but a bit slow, means that when the team's positioning isn't good around him, he can misplace a pass or dawdle on the ball too much. But, when he has consistent players around him who know their positions, he knows how to find them quickly and effectively.

    His positioning and read of the game is good and he has a good relationship with Edwards and Jones.

    He will always be susceptible to pace and balls in behind which is where the defence needs to work as a team to cover.
  • iaitch
    iaitch Posts: 10,230
    comparing Macca to Naby is a sacrilege.  Naby’s outstanding plays were significantly better and his mistakes were much worse
    Macca just has to get sent off one minute into a game to equal Naby.
  • Redhenry
    Redhenry Posts: 5,359
    Macca was genuinely made up when we presented his MOM award. You could tell it meant a lot - and he spent some decent time chatting to my son. Said the spirit in the squad is the best he has ever been part of and all in all comes across as a thoroughly good bloke.
    Why was you presenting MOM award @DamoNorthStand
  • Pelling1993
    Pelling1993 Posts: 6,673
    Redhenry said:
    Macca was genuinely made up when we presented his MOM award. You could tell it meant a lot - and he spent some decent time chatting to my son. Said the spirit in the squad is the best he has ever been part of and all in all comes across as a thoroughly good bloke.
    Why was you presenting MOM award @DamoNorthStand
    The Patel's offered the sponsor opportunity as a peace offering I heard.
  • Simonsen
    Simonsen Posts: 5,503
    edited February 13
    Gillesphey is better in the air than Sarr and Sarr MUCH better than Gillesphey on the deck. 


  • Sponsored links:



  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    Simonsen said:
    Gillesphey is better in the air than Sarr and Sarr MUCH better than Gillesphey on the deck. 


    Sarr was poor in the air, genuinely poor considering his height and general size. 

    Reminds me of Leaburn a bit in that sense, if you're over 6'4 you should be leaving people for dead in the air. Sarr always looked a bit weak against tougher centre forwards.
  • BalladMan
    BalladMan Posts: 1,116
    Simonsen said:
    Gillesphey is better in the air than Sarr and Sarr MUCH better than Gillesphey on the deck. 


    Sarr was poor in the air, genuinely poor considering his height and general size. 

    Reminds me of Leaburn a bit in that sense, if you're over 6'4 you should be leaving people for dead in the air. Sarr always looked a bit weak against tougher centre forwards.
    But we will always have that cross against Nottingham Forest to remember him by (scored by the snake)..... Perfection. 
  • North Lower Neil
    North Lower Neil Posts: 22,954
    edited February 13
    Helps he's not being asked to try 7103 diagonal long balls a match now, think that made him an easy scapegoat.
  • IanJRO
    IanJRO Posts: 691
    thenewbie said:
    Possibly he's a victim of a bit of his own myth - everyone knows/says "he's got a massive mistake in him" so every time he makes any kind of error (even a relatively minor one) it gets elevated to Major Mistake instead of just being expected that even the best of L1 CBs are going to make the odd slip.

    He's deserved that goal - and he's now scored just as many as L. Jones this season and has two more assists to his name as well.

    Not going to win POTS but if there was a "most improved" award he'd surely be a shoe-in.
    Exactly this.

    If it was him who gave away the penalty last night I'm sure there'd be plenty of noise on here about him being 'clumsy' and criticism 'yet another Gillesphey error'. Same if it was him who played the awful pass on Saturday that put Stevenage clean through (thankfully AMB made a superb save).

    Yet because those instances were Ramsay and Edwards respectively there's very little criticism and more acceptance that sometimes these things happen, quite right too - it’s L1 after all. If we had players incapable of making errors they wouldn't be playing at this level.
    In spades. Combine his qualities with consistent faultless performance and he isn’t playing in League 1! 
  • IanJRO
    IanJRO Posts: 691
    comparing Macca to Naby is a sacrilege.  Naby’s outstanding plays were significantly better and his mistakes were much worse
    There was great entertainment value in Naby, could go from looking like Beckenbaur to looking like a Beckenham town player in the blink of an eye!
  • Simonsen
    Simonsen Posts: 5,503
    Simonsen said:
    Gillesphey is better in the air than Sarr and Sarr MUCH better than Gillesphey on the deck. 


    Sarr was poor in the air, genuinely poor considering his height and general size. 

    Reminds me of Leaburn a bit in that sense, if you're over 6'4 you should be leaving people for dead in the air. Sarr always looked a bit weak against tougher centre forwards.
    I know what you mean. Sarr wasn't the strongest in open play but he did score a few headers; Crystal Palace, Huddersfield and Derby come to mind. 

    Lloyd Jones is very strong in the air but seemingly hasn't scored as many headers yet. Let's hope he starts to do so, as that could make a big difference to us. 
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,851
    I was surprised when I heard Macca G speak as I thought he was going to speak in a west Country accent but I couldn't have been more wrong.

    Strong North east accent sounding more Geordie than Mackem but not Newcastle but the Old Mining centre of Ashington 15 miles North of the Geordie City.

    "Not a lot of people know this" but Pitmatic is the local Dialect and now Macauley Gillesphey joins the likes of Jackie Milburn, Bobby and Jackie Charlton, in the Ashington football hall of fame !

    Cricketers Steve and Ben Harmison and the person who I thought Gillesphey sounds like, Mark Wood all hail from Ashington. 
    Lloyd Jones is from Plymouth, but doesn't sound at all yokely!
  • hermann
    hermann Posts: 481
    Simonsen said:
    Simonsen said:
    Gillesphey is better in the air than Sarr and Sarr MUCH better than Gillesphey on the deck. 


    Sarr was poor in the air, genuinely poor considering his height and general size. 

    Reminds me of Leaburn a bit in that sense, if you're over 6'4 you should be leaving people for dead in the air. Sarr always looked a bit weak against tougher centre forwards.
    I know what you mean. Sarr wasn't the strongest in open play but he did score a few headers; Crystal Palace, Huddersfield and Derby come to mind. 

    Lloyd Jones is very strong in the air but seemingly hasn't scored as many headers yet. Let's hope he starts to do so, as that could make a big difference to us. 
    LJ is a master of the art of 'permissible middle of the pitch wrestling' to get ahead of the opposing player, or get a clearer path to heading the ball. Unfortunately relativity principles apply to the laws of the game and he I don't think he can get away with the same approach in the opposing box for a corner 
  • DamoNorthStand
    DamoNorthStand Posts: 10,934
    Redhenry said:
    Macca was genuinely made up when we presented his MOM award. You could tell it meant a lot - and he spent some decent time chatting to my son. Said the spirit in the squad is the best he has ever been part of and all in all comes across as a thoroughly good bloke.
    Why was you presenting MOM award @DamoNorthStand

    Been acting as an advisor to the club / board for a few months and as part of that my business has a partnership with CAFC where we provide commercial and fan insights. We were match sponsors on Tuesday.
  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,328
    This guy has gone from being my least favourite player to be in my top three favourites. Absolutely love him!