Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Birmingham v Charlton (closes Thursday teatime)

your marks here and please do not comment on other Lifers marks, we all have our own ideas please respect them:

Phillips: 
Matthews: 
Lockyer: 
Pearce: 
Doughty: 
McGeady: 
Cuillen: 
Field: 
Williams: 
Bonne: 
Hemed: 
Aneke: 
Referee: 

Purrington: n/a
Pratley: n/a 
Morgan: n/a
Sarr: n/a

«13

Comments

  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 6.5
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 7
    Hemed: 6.5
    Aneke: 6.5
    Referee: 

    Purrington: n/a
    Pratley: n/a 
    Morgan: n/a
    Sarr: n/a
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7.5
    Lockyer: 7.5
    Pearce: 7.5
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 7.5
    Cuillen: 7.5
    Field: 7
    Williams : 6.5 
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 6
    Aneke: 6.5
  • edited July 2020
    Phillips: 7 - some great saves, could argue he could've parried the ball better for the goal
    Matthews: 6 - not bad but better as a wing back
    Lockyer: 5 - almost got caught out a few times, too many touches
    Pearce: 6 did his best as always but lack of pace shows
    Doughty: 7.5 - bad start to the game but played well second half
    McGeady: 7 - decent first half, should've had a goal
    Cuillen: 3 - worst game in a Charlton shirt today, not his usual self. Bowyer leaving?
    Field: 5 alright but always looking sideways/backwards
    Williams: 7 decent for the goal, won lots of free kicks. If he was a couple inches taller he'd have a goal
    Bonne: 7 - +1 for goal, tries hard but does look out of his depth at times
    Hemed: 2 - rubbish
    Aneke: 6 - showed good strength and skill and was unlucky not to set bonne up for a second 
    Referee: 7 - decent
  • Phillips: 8.5
    Matthews: 8
    Lockyer: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Doughty: 7 
    McGeady: 6.5
    Cuillen: 6.5
    Field: 6.5
    Williams: 6.5
    Bonne: 4 cant header cant hold the ball up, cant control and cant pick a pass. scores an open goal so his marks will be high on here, but also missed an open goal, not good enough
    Hemed: 6
    Aneke: 6
    Referee: 2
  • Phillips: 7.5 don't know if he could have done better for the goal? otherwise heroic
    Matthews: 6.5 poor delivery, defended ok
    Lockyer: 6.5 some dodgy passing
    Pearce: 6 quite a lot of dodgy passing, didn't scrap for the loose ball when they scored  
    Doughty: 7.5 a ray of light in an otherwise toiling team
    McGeady: 6.5 so nearly his moment, just couldn't quite do it
    Cullen: 5 one of his worst games for us 
    Field: 7.5 thought he was great - why take him off?
    Williams: 7.5 gave us that extra bit of incision we needed
    Bonne: 6 scored when it was impossible to miss. when it was possible to miss, he missed
    Hemed: 6.5 thought he held it up ok
    Aneke: 7.5 thought he held it up very well
    Referee: 5 not a penalty

    Purrington: n/a why though
    Pratley: n/a Bellingham did indeed end his career as predicted; watching him lumber two yards behind the youngster as he put the cross in for their goal was truly the sign that his time as a pro is nigh done
    Morgan: n/a can't do it when we're in panic mode
    Sarr: n/a should have either started the game, come on at half time or not come on at the point he did, but didn't let us down
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7.5
    Lockyer: 7.5
    Pearce: 7.5
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 8
    Cullen: 7
    Field: 7.5
    Williams: 6.5
    Bonne: 7
    Hemed: 6
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 5
  • Phillips:  8
    Matthews:  6.5
    Lockyer:  7
    Pearce:  6.5
    Doughty:  6
    McGeady:  7
    Cuillen:  6
    Field:  7
    Williams:  6.5
    Bonne:  6
    Hemed:  3
    Aneke:  7
    Referee:  6
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7.5
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 6.5
    Aneke: 6.5
    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 6.5
    Williams: 7.5
    Bonne: 7
    Hemed: 4
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Phillips: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Lockyer: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 6
    Cuillen: 5
    Field: 6
    Williams: 6.5
    Bonne: 4
    Hemed: 4
    Aneke: 7.5
    Referee: 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips 9
    Matthews 3 all attacks come down his side and he did not make a tackle , normally good going forward - but lacking tonight
    Pearce 7
    Lockyer 7 
    Doughty 8
    McGeady 7 - his best game for us
    Cullen 6 
    Field 7
    Wiiliams 6
    Bonne 6 
    Hemed 4 
    Aneke 7 
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 8
    Lockyer: 8
    Pearce: 8
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 8
    Cuillen: 7
    Field: 8.5
    Williams: 7.5
    Bonne: 7.5
    Hemed: 6
    Aneke: 7.5
    Referee: 5
  • Have to be very careful this week! Apparently my marks and words were too harsh last week for some sensitive souls... so I guess spineless bottlejobs with poor decision making will be too harsh?

    Phillips: 7 Would have been a 9 if he had held onto the fucking ball at the end.
    Matthews: 7 Solid for majority of the game. But needs more help 5-3-2 doesn't help him him being left alone.
    Lockyer: 6.5 Battled hard throughout but always looks like he will get caught out in possession.
    Pearce: 7 Solid until the end.
    Doughty: 8 Our only chance for ever creating any opening. Few mistakes and bad decisions here and there but easily one of our best players this season.
    McGeady: 6.5 I wanted so badly to rate him higher but his shooting is just so poor, unlucky hitting the post but needed to do better with the follow up.
    Cuillen: 6 Poorest game I've ever seen him play by a long time. Not just the mistake for the penalty his overall play was not up to his usual standards.
    Field: 7.5 One of out best players on the pitch, was solid making challenges and helping out the defence... and then he was taken off???
    Williams: 7.5 Can understand him coming off rather than the other 2 as he can't do 90mins but he was the only one making things happen. 
    Bonne: 5 Yes he scored... but he didn't do anything else, and missed another sitter (okay Camp made a good save)
    Hemed:6 Half decent hold up play but just offers nothing else.

    Aneke: 6 Solid hold up play, great run and pass for Bonne's miss.

    Referee: 5 Kept stopping us taking quick free kicks slowed the game down. Missed a lot of the elbows being thrown as well

    Purrington: n/a 
    Pratley: n/a I love Prats but Field should have stayed on as well! 
    Morgan: n/a
    Sarr: n/a His substitution invited so much pressure
  • Phillips: 9 POTY
    Matthews:8 solid as always
    Lockyer: 7.5 
    Pearce: 8 has been the stand out player since return. superb and a leader
    Doughty:7 great assist, better as a winger than defender
    McGeady: 6.5 hmmm
    Cuillen: 5 uncharacteristically bad tonight
    Field: 7 Why did he take him off
    Williams: 7 one driving one, one assist of an assist
    Bonne: 7 sturdy
    Hemed: 5 shit
    Aneke: 7 why didn't he start
    Referee: 2 shit
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 7.5
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6
    Hemed: 5
    Aneke: 6.5 
    Referee: 1
  • Phillips: 8
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 8
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 7
    Field: 8
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 7
    Hemed: 7
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Phillips: 8.5
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 6
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 7
    Williams: 6
    Bonne: 6 
    Hemed: 6
    Aneke: 6
    Referee: 5
  • Phillips: 8 - could have done better for the goal but still my MOM
    Matthews: 6.5
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 6 - some of his passes put us under pressure
    Doughty: 7 - great attacking play, if a little tunnel visioned at times. Could have squared to mcgeady for a 1 on 1. Great assist but poor defensively in the first half with loose touches.
    McGeady: 7 unlucky not to score.
    Cuillen: 5 - did ok but his poor pass for the pen could have cost us.
    Field: 6 - did ok
    Williams: 6.5 busy and busy being fouled.
    Bonne: 5 - made a couple of clearances +1 for the goal.
    Hemed: 6 some decent hold up play.
    Aneke: 6.5 made an impact. Would like to see him and hemed up top as the ball might stick a bit better then.
    Referee: 4 - complete  lottery as to what he'd blow up for.

    Purrington: n/a
    Pratley: n/a 
    Morgan: n/a
    Sarr: n/a
  • Phillips: 8, superb, great penalty save. Debatable whether he could have prevented it to begin with but not his fault and pulled off a few crucial saves as ever. 
    Matthews: 5-poor, struggled defensively today and didn't really get much going forward
    Lockyer: 7.5 Solid, good battle with their dirty forward and won alot of crucial tackles/battles
    Pearce: 7.5, a solid game, i dont really understand if we are playing the ball for him to come out from defence or lump forward it should be Sarr playing. Not marked down for this but just seems a bit silly
    Doughty: 7.5, struggled early on defending, but always our biggest threat going forward and works well with Johnny, would prefer him not to have to worry about the defensive side. lovely run for the assist
    McGeady: 7, worked hard, didn't look like much final ball/shot, was unlucky not to score and cant really be faulted
    Cuillen: 5.5, struggled today, dont like to criticise as he has been huge, but alot of misplaced passes which put us on the back foot. Didn't really break up the play as well
    Field: 6.5, thought he did well enough defensive, but doesn't really offer much going forward. 
    Williams: 7.5, works bloody hard, shows a bit of quality when he can get on the ball and links up well with Alfie, i would prefer in a central role behind striker/s
    Bonne: 7 Works bloody hard and most likely to pop up with the goal, not sure who is his best partner at present miss lyle :(
    Hemed: 6, didn't really offer too much, couldn't fault the effort but dont really feel he offers anything in the air or much goal threat
    Aneke: 7, i think he does a good job holding the ball up and neat footwork. puts a shift in again but probably wouldn't be good enough if we had proper options
    Referee: 3 Shite, bias and didn't help

    Same old shite really, today we were lucky to be ahead but then we sit back and take our biggest threats going forward so not surprised we concede. Bowyer 5
  • edited July 2020
    Phillips: 7.5 Would have got a nine but I thought he should have done better with the goal.
    Matthews: 6.5
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7.5
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 5.5 Has been our best player since the return but he was dreadful today
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 6.5
    Aneke: 7
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 8.5
    Matthews: 7.5
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 7.5
    Cuillen: 6.5
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6 
    Hemed: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 4
  • Phillips: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7.5
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 7
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 4
    Aneke: 6.5
    Referee: 4
  • Phillips: 8.5
    Matthews: 8
    Lockyer: 6.5 
    Pearce:  6.5
    Doughty: 6.5
    McGeady: 7.5
    Cuillen: 5.5
    Field: 7.5
    Williams: 7
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 6.5
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Phillips: 8
    Matthews: 8
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 8
    Cuillen: 5
    Field: 8
    Williams: 6
    Bonne: 6
    Hemed: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 4

    Purrington: n/a
    Pratley: n/a 
    Morgan: n/a
    Sarr: n/a
  • Phillips: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 6.5
    McGeady: 5
    Cullen: 5.5
    Field: 6.5
    Williams: 6
    Bonne: 5.5
    Hemed: 5
    Aneke: 6.5
    Referee: 7
  • edited July 2020
    Phillips: 8 Some great saves and one that he palmed to their player to tap home.
    Matthews: 7 Decent enough, has some engine to track back when needed.
    Lockyer: 6.5 okay
    Pearce: 7 solid
    Doughty: 8.5 great player
    McGeady: 7.5 flashes of brilliance, he's coming closer to what we wanted.
    Cullen: 5 really didn't impose himself, too much time whining at the ref, cost us a penalty and plenty of wayward passes. When he's off we don't win. 
    Field: 8 back up to speed, he's very decent.
    Williams: 7 some good, lots of bad.
    Bonne: 7 got a goal, which is his job, unlucky with the second one.
    Hemed: 6.5 great workrate today - not going to come good here.
    Aneke: 8 bullied Brum, needs to shoot once he breaks free rather than just flattening everyone. Very good in our 18 too on corners.
    Referee: 4 seemed to always break our attacks down over little fouls, could have been better, but not the worst 

    Purrington: n/a okay
    Pratley: n/a  okay
    Morgan: n/a good
    Sarr: n/a  
  • Phillips: 8.5 MOM magnificent
    Matthews: 7
    Lockyer: 7 
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7 Good going forward, dodgy defending.
    McGeady: 7 Decent game, best for us so far.
    Cullen: 5 Poor, possibly tired after playing every game since lockdown.
    Field: 7
    Williams: 6.5
    Bonne: 7 Extra point for the goal
    Hemed:5.5 He'll never score 
    Aneke: 7 Did well
    Referee: 4.5 Definite homer.
  • Phillips: 9 would have given him 10 if he had held on to that shot, but alas...
    Matthews: 7 got beaten a couple of times 
    Lockyer: 6.5 a shaky warrior tonight
    Pearce:7 he give everything for the cause. 
    Doughty: 8 mainly good
    McGeady. 7 so close to getting 2nd goal.
    Cuillen: 6.5 made mistakes and wayward passes, never hides though.
    Field: 7.5 why take him off at business end of game !
    Williams: 7 we need him to play longer.
    Bonne: 7.5 scored one, good smothering save by keeper, now has 10 goals in champ but Cafc fans need a scapegoat.
    Hemed: 7 does some good work outside the box but not winning headers in box.
    Aneke: 7.5 good cameo.
    Referee: 5 no complaint with pen but another mediocre ref in champ.

  • Phillips: 7
    Matthews: 6
    Lockyer: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Doughty: 7
    McGeady: 6
    Cuillen: 6
    Field: 6
    Williams: 6
    Bonne: 6
    Hemed: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Referee: 5
  • edited July 2020
    Phillips: 7
    Matthews: 6.5
    Lockyer: 6.5
    Pearce: 6.5 (solid defensively but awful distribution)
    Doughty: 7 (8 for his attacking play, 6 for his defensive work)
    McGeady: 7
    Cuillen: 5.5
    Field: 7
    Williams: 6 (One bit of good play, but we need more end product)
    Bonne: 6.5
    Hemed: 5.5
    Aneke: 6.5 (A definite improvement over Hemed)
    Referee: 6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!