Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton / L1 - January 2019 Transfer Rumours (ed, deadline day starts p98)
Comments
-
This is going well6
-
Come on ladies, no need to argue with each other. Everyone is entitled to have an opinion but calling him shit is slightly unfair. For me, he hasn't had enough chances, especially an extended run to have a proper judge. But we definitely need another keeper and if we sign someone like Maxwell that will be good business.5
-
Stick with Phillips.3
-
ThisNapaAddick said:Stick with Phillips.
2 -
We needed to replace Steer. Maxwell is a good replacement. Dillon will move on at the end of the season and will have a decent career elsewhere4
-
I like Phillips and do want the best for him but he doesn't fill me with confidence at all, if getting a goalie in that can get us a better chance of promotion and make us more likely to hang on to our key players like Aribo, Grant and Taylor etc then so be it, can't be an emotional decision6
-
This. We need to get out of this league. We'll do that by playing the best players we can attract / put out.Braziliance said:I like Phillips and do want the best for him but he doesn't fill me with confidence at all, if getting a goalie in that can get us a better chance of promotion and make us more likely to hang on to our key players like Aribo, Grant and Taylor etc then so be it, can't be an emotional decision
A LB & McNulty on loan and we'll be on our way.0 -
I think Phillips is a keeper.5
-
Take a break Paulie.0
-
Take a break from what.Stu_of_Kunming said:Take a break Paulie.
I am a Charlton fan
Someone has called one of our players shit with no evidence.
The players need our support not being called shit for no reason2 - Sponsored links:
-
It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?1 -
But like when you called Reeco "shit" then with no "evidence".paulie8290 said:
Take a break from what.Stu_of_Kunming said:Take a break Paulie.
I am a Charlton fan
Someone has called one of our players shit with no evidence.
The players need our support not being called shit for no reason
It's an opinion.
PS Reeco is a kid, he may or not make it with us but he's a professional footballer and a better footballer than 99.99% of people on this forum or in this country so clearly the evidence shows he's not "shit"2 -
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?0 -
That's his job shame he can't kick the ball or command his area he's just not good enough for promotion anyway did you see he mistakes at Sunderland and southendpaulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?2 -
Did you see the mistakes Nick Pope made of us on his first few appearances. Jed Steer the same.FAVADDICK said:
That's his job shame he can't kick the ball or command his area he's just not good enough for promotion anyway did you see he mistakes at Sunderland and southendpaulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?
A run in ANY side and all the little errors start to be eradicated.
Hes young like 90% of the squad. They need support as most of them are doing well above expectations.
6 -
Just one aspect of being a keeper, so he might not be shit, but his distribution, flappiness at crosses and some of the absolute howlers he's let in might suggest he is a bit, well..... shit.paulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?
I happen to think he's good enough for our current aspirations of Top 6, However I'd replace ANY player, if the replacement was better, this is a results business, nothing else matters.
Still no need to lose it and start swearing just because you disagree with someone and abusing the flag system, it's childish.0 -
SLP now reporting on the Maxwell loan
https://www.londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-athletic-set-to-sign-preston-keeper-on-loan/5 -
Twenty fckin three the kid is and made 8 league starts and being hounded for errors/
Just wow9 -
Everyone was on popes back, but they seem to forget the shite defending going on in front of him.
More shots = more mistakes = fans giving you shit = poor confidence.
He didn’t suddenly improve in one full season at Burnley, he was already good. Just needed a defence and a confidence boost.
Philips kicking was poor on Saturday without question.
Decent keeper, but if there’s a better keeper available you take them.
Being nice to people in a results business doesn’t work.2 -
Abusing the flag systemStu_of_Kunming said:
Just one aspect of being a keeper, so he might not be shit, but his distribution, flappiness at crosses and some of the absolute howlers he's let in might suggest he is a bit, well..... shit.paulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?
I happen to think he's good enough for our current aspirations of Top 6, However I'd replace ANY player, if the replacement was better, this is a results business, nothing else matters.
Still no need to lose it and start swearing just because you disagree with someone and abusing the flag system, it's childish.
Haha have u seen half my flags most of those have been jokes
I flagged someone who slagged off a charlton player, imo that was worthy of a flag.
Also as for swearing there are loads of people who have done it just read the takeover thread3 - Sponsored links:
-
So you'd keep playing him, even of better options are available? Why bother signing any players then, we can field an entire team of academy players.Charltonparklane said:Twenty fckin three the kid is and made 8 league starts and being hounded for errors/
Just wow3 -
Keepers improve with age and experience, Phillips will be very good he just needs games. Either play him or loan him out.2
-
All players improve with age and experience, whilst Phillips probably does need a loan, we need a 2nd keeper, all clubs do.cfgs said:Keepers improve with age and experience, Phillips will be very good he just needs games. Either play him or loan him out.
0 -
The flag system is there for people who break the rules, not for posts you disagree with.paulie8290 said:
Abusing the flag systemStu_of_Kunming said:
Just one aspect of being a keeper, so he might not be shit, but his distribution, flappiness at crosses and some of the absolute howlers he's let in might suggest he is a bit, well..... shit.paulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?
I happen to think he's good enough for our current aspirations of Top 6, However I'd replace ANY player, if the replacement was better, this is a results business, nothing else matters.
Still no need to lose it and start swearing just because you disagree with someone and abusing the flag system, it's childish.
Haha have u seen half my flags most of those have been jokes
I flagged someone who slagged off a charlton player, imo that was worthy of a flag.
Also as for swearing there are loads of people who have done it just read the takeover thread
http://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/64954/misuse-of-flagging-button-guidelines3 -
His kicking is shite though.Henry Irving said:
But like when you called Reeco "shit" then with no "evidence".paulie8290 said:
Take a break from what.Stu_of_Kunming said:Take a break Paulie.
I am a Charlton fan
Someone has called one of our players shit with no evidence.
The players need our support not being called shit for no reason
It's an opinion.
PS Reeco is a kid, he may or not make it with us but he's a professional footballer and a better footballer than 99.99% of people on this forum or in this country so clearly the evidence shows he's not "shit"0 -
True, not saying we don't just that Phillips will not improve sitting on our bench. I would sign Maxwell and loan out Phillips with a recall clause.Stu_of_Kunming said:
All players improve with age and experience, whilst Phillips probably does need a loan, we need a 2nd keeper, all clubs do.cfgs said:Keepers improve with age and experience, Phillips will be very good he just needs games. Either play him or loan him out.
0 -
Trust in LB. He obviously doesn’t think Phillips is good enough at this current moment and he knows more than any of us...2
-
Be careful you will get into trouble for swearingCharltonparklane said:Twenty fckin three the kid is and made 8 league starts and being hounded for errors/
Just wow2 -
I thought non transfer window recalls could only happen with non league clubs, or is it different for keepers?cfgs said:
True, not saying we don't just that Phillips will not improve sitting on our bench. I would sign Maxwell and loan out Phillips with a recall clause.Stu_of_Kunming said:
All players improve with age and experience, whilst Phillips probably does need a loan, we need a 2nd keeper, all clubs do.cfgs said:Keepers improve with age and experience, Phillips will be very good he just needs games. Either play him or loan him out.
If it's possible, then I'd 100% agree, as I've always thought it a total waste to have a keeper on the bench.0 -
Again look at my flagsStu_of_Kunming said:
The flag system is there for people who break the rules, not for posts you disagree with.paulie8290 said:
Abusing the flag systemStu_of_Kunming said:
Just one aspect of being a keeper, so he might not be shit, but his distribution, flappiness at crosses and some of the absolute howlers he's let in might suggest he is a bit, well..... shit.paulie8290 said:
Did u watch the 3 home games where he made fantastic saves(sorry cant remember exactly what game)Stu_of_Kunming said:It's an opinion, just because that opinion differs from yours isn't a reason to get all sweary.
As for evidence, did youy watch the first game of the season?
I happen to think he's good enough for our current aspirations of Top 6, However I'd replace ANY player, if the replacement was better, this is a results business, nothing else matters.
Still no need to lose it and start swearing just because you disagree with someone and abusing the flag system, it's childish.
Haha have u seen half my flags most of those have been jokes
I flagged someone who slagged off a charlton player, imo that was worthy of a flag.
Also as for swearing there are loads of people who have done it just read the takeover thread
http://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/64954/misuse-of-flagging-button-guidelines-1
