Rudd 7 a couple of good saves Byrne 7 thought he looked quite good today, used the ball well Bauer 4.5 what is he doing Teixeira 6.5 quite enjoyed his go at being a wing forward Page 6 a mixture of a good defender and a fairly hopeless passer Forster-Caskey 5 not sure what he's up to. doesn't seem suited. one peachy cross and a load of crap Aribo 7.5 what feet the man has! Konsa 7 a generally dominant show, covered so much ground Holmes 6 his delivery was inconsistent - some good, some (very) bad Mavididi 8 presumably that's him out for the season. this run of games has been the Curse of Mavididi. runs the show, nearly scores goal of the season, doesn't, injured Novak 4.5 up for it, got into goalscoring positions, finished like a skunk Crofts 6.5 brought some bite and we were better for his presence Magennis 5.5 still unclear quite what's happened to him Watt n/a
Rudd 3 Doesn't talk to his players, distribution is all wrong and he doesn't hold onto shots Byrne 6 worked hard, booked for a decent foul and bombed up and down the right Bauer 6 played ok, scored a disallowed goal, subbed for injury at halftime Teixeira 6 makes a mistake or two but he is a good defender Page 1 fuck off Forster Caskey 2 what does he bring? He's a playmaker that can't pass FFS Aribo 4 didn't get into the game really Konsa 5 decent in midfield, not so much at the back Holmes 3 why is he taking set pieces? They've been awful Mavididi 7 shame he seemed to tear his hamstring near the end, he makes stuff happen Novak 6 unlucky not to score, then missed a sitter. Worked bloody hard Crofts 3 can't control the ball and gets in the way of other players Magennis 2 checked out for the season, KR had to send Crofts over and tell him, JJ and TWatt to actually warm up after they fucked off to the corner flag for a chat Watt n/a 1 crowd chant for this useless turd, he comes on and immediately lays it off to their striker, sums the unfit wanker up
Rudd 7 did what he had to Byrne 7 looked OK filling in, few times I think he forgot he was right back and ran across field. Bauer 5 think after the bang on the head he looked all over the shop. Teixeira 6 all be it off side anyway nearly scored after being converted to a winger/forward. He wants out Page 5. I've seen nothing really to impress so far. Forster-Caskey 4 similar to Page, he's had one half decent game otherwise looks at best average. Aribo 7.5 a steady game Kona 7.5 a steady game Holmes 5.5 closing down was good, otherwise thought average, poor delivery numerous times. Also shows how weak a squad we are when captain and leader of the day was Holmes Mavididi 7.5 boys got some tricks, still learning, guess thats him done for the season. Novak 5 one good header at the front post otherwise what did he do, particulalrly for the first half? Crofts 4.5 he just gets in the way and poor passing and negative. Magennis 6 a shadow of his former self, we've had one season wonders before, he looks like a half season wonder.
Watt 0.1 - I want to score him anyway as I fail to see why people like him, he's unfit, lazy and not very good. One moment of magic every 5 games is not enough.
Robinson- 0.2 for failing to be able to turn this bunch (which lets not forget includes a few he signed) into at least a competitive side capable of scoring a goal or two, stop trying to mould this bunch of misfits into something they aren't and play with what you have accordingly.
Rudd 6 Ok Byrne 7 I thought he played pretty well Bauer 5 Can't pass Tex 5.5 not convinced Page 5 very average Forster-Caskey 4 Shit Aribo 6.5 did ok Konsa 6 not awful Holmes 5.5 not his best game Mavididi 7 skills.Prob out for season now Novak 6 tried hard Crofts 5.5 prob a bit generous score for him Magennis 5 looks sulky now Watts the point? 2
Rudd 6 Byrne 6 Looked ok Bauer 5 Won quite a few headers Teixeira 5 Page 5 Easily 'bullied'. Forster Caskey 5 Disappointing Aribo 6.5 Good on the ball Konsa 6 Decent game Holmes 6 Scurried around a lot. One great cross. He tried. Mavididi 7 Different class. Hope he's ok. Novak 5.5 Tried hard, could have scored a couple. Crofts 5.5 Better than he has been recently. Magennis 4 His game was based on effort. Showed none today. Why??
Rudd 7 not at fault with the goal - did his job Byrne 7 HAd a good game Bauer 4.5 Maybe the injury affected him! Teixeira 6 Not his best but was decent Page 4 when we were chasing the game - what was he doing on the pitch! Forster-Caskey 5.5 Was rubbish apart form a delightful ball in to Novak Aribo 4 Did he do anything remotely dangerous? I mean - that is the point! Konsa 4 When he has time in midfield he looks ok - until you work out that he doesn't do anything with it. It is all ultra safe tosh - pass to somebody else to do it! Doesn't see the quick balls, incisive passes - he is not a midfielder. Holmes 6.5 Inconsistent, but a threat Mavididi 8 Great game - hope injury is not as bad as it looked Novak 6 I thought he did well - a bit unlucky when he hit the bar - the header he missed really came at him Crofts 6.5 He had a decent game Magennis 4 Not the same player since his injury Watt 6.5 Well he didn't have long - but he did force the keeper in a smart save - Should have been brought on a bit earlier for Page.
Rudd 7 comfortable commanding dug defence out rightly Byrne 7 I'd get him on a perm if possible Bauer 6.5 dominated but odd lack of concentration Teixeira 7 effective but nervous given rotation of partners. Ditto Bauer Page 6 poor and decent combined. Young so jury out. Forster Caskey 4 Dogshite Aribo 8 Quality. Pace power quick feet but have a dig Konsa 7 As a defender looks a better CM Holmes 7 kept us ticking. Rightly captain Mavididi 7.5 mustard but needs passes before 10 men facing him Novak 6.5 rusty but did ok. Needs a partner Crofts 5 I can see why we have failed to win many games Magennis 6 see Novak
Rudd 6 - made some good saves/stopped Bury players getting the shot away when they should have scored a few times Byrne 4 Bauer 5 Teixeira 5 Page 3 - disappointing Forster Caskey 4 - I can see why he hasn't done well for the last few years Aribo 5 - good effort Konsa 5 - good effort Holmes 5 - poor decision making Mavididi - 6 - exciting player, great jink into the box, shame about the injury Novak - 5 made more effort than most but just not good enough, disappointing to hear people booing him off Crofts - 6 tried hard when he came on, more than can be said for most of the players Magennis - 4 - did he do anything when he came on apart from running after the ball in the first couple of minutes Watt n/a - had a good shot that drew a good save but little else
Rudd. 7 did everything tidily Byrne 4. Poor delivery Bauer. 5. Ok Teixeira 5.5. Aggressive Page. 4. Awful passing Forster Caskey. 3.5. Done nowt since his debut assist Aribo. 5. Quiet game Konsa. 7. Quality Holmes. 5. Poor end product Mavididi. 7. Magic in those feet Novak. 5.5. Was just singing his praises for once then "that header" Crofts. 5. Tried Magennis 5. Not involved enough
Rudd - 6.5 - made some decent stops to prevent a Bury 2nd. Exposed by some truly terrible defending. Byrne 6 - looked better going forward than defending Bauer 5 - some sloppy passing first half Teixeira 5 - loses mark for goal. Page - 5.5 Competed Forster Caskey - 4 really disappointing perfomance, looks really average. Not a holding central midfielder. Not sure if he is any better further forward. Aribo - 6 - Looks like he will be a decent midfielder. Liked the look of him. Konsa 6 - Looks like he will be a very good player. Holmes 5.5 - Some wayward crossing. Mavididi 6.5 - has quality, pushed forward, tried to do it all himself on occassions. With the injury looks like the last Charlton will see of him for the season. Novak 5 - missed a sitter and does not not do what is required of strikers, which is score Crofts 5 - Better than Forster Caskey. Charlton midfield looked better with him it (not thats saying much) Magennis 5.5 Doesn't look recovered from injury at least Charlton had a focal point of attack with him on. Watt n/a - Hmmm
Robinson - first half set up provided the team with no cohesion or focal point of attack. Subs on for second helped but damage had been done by first half set up. Team looked like a bunch of strangers who had never played together with only a general & vague idea of what they or their teammates are supposed to be doing. What happens in training ? Needs to stop trying to play a formation he does not have the players for. Stop the prematch heads up for the opposition, and keep chat to minimum.
Comments
Byrne 7 thought he looked quite good today, used the ball well
Bauer 4.5 what is he doing
Teixeira 6.5 quite enjoyed his go at being a wing forward
Page 6 a mixture of a good defender and a fairly hopeless passer
Forster-Caskey 5 not sure what he's up to. doesn't seem suited. one peachy cross and a load of crap
Aribo 7.5 what feet the man has!
Konsa 7 a generally dominant show, covered so much ground
Holmes 6 his delivery was inconsistent - some good, some (very) bad
Mavididi 8 presumably that's him out for the season. this run of games has been the Curse of Mavididi. runs the show, nearly scores goal of the season, doesn't, injured
Novak 4.5 up for it, got into goalscoring positions, finished like a skunk
Crofts 6.5 brought some bite and we were better for his presence
Magennis 5.5 still unclear quite what's happened to him
Watt n/a
Byrne - 5
Bauer- 6
Tiexera - 5
Page - 5
Forster Caskey - 4
Aribo - 6
Konsa - 5
Holmes - 6.5
Mavididi - 5
Novak- 2
Crofts -5
Magennis- 5
Byrne 6 worked hard, booked for a decent foul and bombed up and down the right
Bauer 6 played ok, scored a disallowed goal, subbed for injury at halftime
Teixeira 6 makes a mistake or two but he is a good defender
Page 1 fuck off
Forster Caskey 2 what does he bring? He's a playmaker that can't pass FFS
Aribo 4 didn't get into the game really
Konsa 5 decent in midfield, not so much at the back
Holmes 3 why is he taking set pieces? They've been awful
Mavididi 7 shame he seemed to tear his hamstring near the end, he makes stuff happen
Novak 6 unlucky not to score, then missed a sitter. Worked bloody hard
Crofts 3 can't control the ball and gets in the way of other players
Magennis 2 checked out for the season, KR had to send Crofts over and tell him, JJ and TWatt to actually warm up after they fucked off to the corner flag for a chat
Watt n/a 1 crowd chant for this useless turd, he comes on and immediately lays it off to their striker, sums the unfit wanker up
Byrne 7 looked OK filling in, few times I think he forgot he was right back and ran across field.
Bauer 5 think after the bang on the head he looked all over the shop.
Teixeira 6 all be it off side anyway nearly scored after being converted to a winger/forward. He wants out
Page 5. I've seen nothing really to impress so far.
Forster-Caskey 4 similar to Page, he's had one half decent game otherwise looks at best average.
Aribo 7.5 a steady game
Kona 7.5 a steady game
Holmes 5.5 closing down was good, otherwise thought average, poor delivery numerous times. Also shows how weak a squad we are when captain and leader of the day was Holmes
Mavididi 7.5 boys got some tricks, still learning, guess thats him done for the season.
Novak 5 one good header at the front post otherwise what did he do, particulalrly for the first half?
Crofts 4.5 he just gets in the way and poor passing and negative.
Magennis 6 a shadow of his former self, we've had one season wonders before, he looks like a half season wonder.
Watt 0.1 - I want to score him anyway as I fail to see why people like him, he's unfit, lazy and not very good. One moment of magic every 5 games is not enough.
Robinson- 0.2 for failing to be able to turn this bunch (which lets not forget includes a few he signed) into at least a competitive side capable of scoring a goal or two, stop trying to mould this bunch of misfits into something they aren't and play with what you have accordingly.
Roland - -10, he doesn't do failure
Byrne 7 I thought he played pretty well
Bauer 5 Can't pass
Tex 5.5 not convinced
Page 5 very average
Forster-Caskey 4 Shit
Aribo 6.5 did ok
Konsa 6 not awful
Holmes 5.5 not his best game
Mavididi 7 skills.Prob out for season now
Novak 6 tried hard
Crofts 5.5 prob a bit generous score for him
Magennis 5 looks sulky now
Watts the point? 2
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer- 6
Tiexera -65
Page - 4
Forster Caskey - 4
Aribo - 6
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 5.5
Mavididi - 5
Novak- 4.5
Crofts -4.5
Magennis- 4.5
Byrne 6 Looked ok
Bauer 5 Won quite a few headers
Teixeira 5
Page 5 Easily 'bullied'.
Forster Caskey 5 Disappointing
Aribo 6.5 Good on the ball
Konsa 6 Decent game
Holmes 6 Scurried around a lot. One great cross. He tried.
Mavididi 7 Different class. Hope he's ok.
Novak 5.5 Tried hard, could have scored a couple.
Crofts 5.5 Better than he has been recently.
Magennis 4 His game was based on effort. Showed none today. Why??
One good turn and shot by Watt.
Byrne 4
Bauer 5
Tex 5
Page 1 bloke is dog shit
Forster Caskey 1 same as above
Aribo 6
Konsa 6
Holmes 3
Mivididi 7
Novak 4
Crofts 2
Maginess 3
Robinson. Go away tosser
Byrne 7 HAd a good game
Bauer 4.5 Maybe the injury affected him!
Teixeira 6 Not his best but was decent
Page 4 when we were chasing the game - what was he doing on the pitch!
Forster-Caskey 5.5 Was rubbish apart form a delightful ball in to Novak
Aribo 4 Did he do anything remotely dangerous? I mean - that is the point!
Konsa 4 When he has time in midfield he looks ok - until you work out that he doesn't do anything with it. It is all ultra safe tosh - pass to somebody else to do it! Doesn't see the quick balls, incisive passes - he is not a midfielder.
Holmes 6.5 Inconsistent, but a threat
Mavididi 8 Great game - hope injury is not as bad as it looked
Novak 6 I thought he did well - a bit unlucky when he hit the bar - the header he missed really came at him
Crofts 6.5 He had a decent game
Magennis 4 Not the same player since his injury
Watt 6.5 Well he didn't have long - but he did force the keeper in a smart save - Should have been brought on a bit earlier for Page.
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer- 5.5
Tiexera -6
Page - 3.5
Forster Caskey - 4
Aribo - 6
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 6
Mavididi - 7
Novak- 6
Crofts - 5
Magennis- 5
Byrne - 5
Bauer - 5
Texeira - 5
Page - 3
Forster-Caskey - 3 mouthy gobshite, no wonder Robinson likes him
Aribo - 6
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 5.5
Mavididi - 7
Novak - 6.5
Crofts - 5
Magennis - 5
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer- 7
Tiexera -6
Page - 5
Forster Caskey - 5
Aribo - 7
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 6
Mavididi - 6
Novak- 6
Crofts -6.5
Magennis- 5
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer- 6
Tiexera -6
Page - 4
Forster Caskey - 4
Aribo - 7
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 5.5
Mavididi - 7 Hope he is okay.
Novak- 6
Crofts - 5
Magennis- 4.5
Byrne 7 I'd get him on a perm if possible
Bauer 6.5 dominated but odd lack of concentration
Teixeira 7 effective but nervous given rotation of partners. Ditto Bauer
Page 6 poor and decent combined. Young so jury out.
Forster Caskey 4 Dogshite
Aribo 8 Quality. Pace power quick feet but have a dig
Konsa 7 As a defender looks a better CM
Holmes 7 kept us ticking. Rightly captain
Mavididi 7.5 mustard but needs passes before 10 men facing him
Novak 6.5 rusty but did ok. Needs a partner
Crofts 5 I can see why we have failed to win many games
Magennis 6 see Novak
Byrne - 2
Bauer- 1
Tiexera - 2
Page - 1
Forster Caskey - 0
Aribo - 0.5
Konsa - 1
Holmes - 2
Mavididi - 5
Novak- 0.5
Crofts -0
Magennis- 0
I think that was the worst Charlton performance I have ever seen. How anyone thinks the players deserve a mark above 2 I have no idea.
As I said the other day 5 is avergae and they were ALL below average with the possible exception of Mavidi.
Byrne - 6
Bauer - 6
Teixeira -6
Page -5
Forster Caskey -5
Aribo -6
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 6
Mavididi -6
Novak -5
Crofts -5
Magennis -5
Byrne 7
Bauer 6
Teixeira 6.5
Page 6
Forster Caskey 6
Arigo 6
Cons 5.5
Holmes 6
Mcvididi 7
Novak 5
Crofts 5
Magennis 6
Watt n/a
Byrne 5
Bauer 6
Teixeira 5.5
Page 5.5
Forster Caskey 5
Aribo 7.5
Konsa 6
Holmes 5.5
Mavididi 7
Novak 5
Crofts 6
Magennis 5
Byrne 6
Bauer 4
Teixeira 7
Page 6
Forster Caskey 5.5
Aribo 6.5
Konsa 6.5
Holmes 6.5
Mavididi 7
Novak 5
Crofts 5
Magennis 5
Watt n/a
Byrne 4
Bauer 5
Teixeira 5
Page 3 - disappointing
Forster Caskey 4 - I can see why he hasn't done well for the last few years
Aribo 5 - good effort
Konsa 5 - good effort
Holmes 5 - poor decision making
Mavididi - 6 - exciting player, great jink into the box, shame about the injury
Novak - 5 made more effort than most but just not good enough, disappointing to hear people booing him off
Crofts - 6 tried hard when he came on, more than can be said for most of the players
Magennis - 4 - did he do anything when he came on apart from running after the ball in the first couple of minutes
Watt n/a - had a good shot that drew a good save but little else
Byrne 6
Bauer 6
Teixeira 6
Page 5.5
Forster Caskey 5.5
Aribo 6.5
Konsa 6.5
Holmes 7
Mavididi 7
Novak 5
Crofts 5.5
Magennis 5.5
Rudd. 7 did everything tidily
Byrne 4. Poor delivery
Bauer. 5. Ok
Teixeira 5.5. Aggressive
Page. 4. Awful passing
Forster Caskey. 3.5. Done nowt since his debut assist
Aribo. 5. Quiet game
Konsa. 7. Quality
Holmes. 5. Poor end product
Mavididi. 7. Magic in those feet
Novak. 5.5. Was just singing his praises for once then "that header"
Crofts. 5. Tried
Magennis 5. Not involved enough
Byrne - 6
Bauer - 5
Teixeira - 5
Page - 5
Forster Caskey - 5
Aribo - 6
Konsa - 6
Holmes - 6
Mavididi - 7
Novak - 6 dreadful dead ball delivery
Crofts - 6
Magennis - 5
Watt n/a
Byrne 6 - looked better going forward than defending
Bauer 5 - some sloppy passing first half
Teixeira 5 - loses mark for goal.
Page - 5.5 Competed
Forster Caskey - 4 really disappointing perfomance, looks really average. Not a holding central midfielder. Not sure if he is any better further forward.
Aribo - 6 - Looks like he will be a decent midfielder. Liked the look of him.
Konsa 6 - Looks like he will be a very good player.
Holmes 5.5 - Some wayward crossing.
Mavididi 6.5 - has quality, pushed forward, tried to do it all himself on occassions. With the injury looks like the last Charlton will see of him for the season.
Novak 5 - missed a sitter and does not not do what is required of strikers, which is score
Crofts 5 - Better than Forster Caskey. Charlton midfield looked better with him it (not thats saying much)
Magennis 5.5 Doesn't look recovered from injury at least Charlton had a focal point of attack with him on.
Watt n/a - Hmmm
Robinson - first half set up provided the team with no cohesion or focal point of attack. Subs on for second helped but damage had been done by first half set up. Team looked like a bunch of strangers who had never played together with only a general & vague idea of what they or their teammates are supposed to be doing. What happens in training ? Needs to stop trying to play a formation he does not have the players for. Stop the prematch heads up for the opposition, and keep chat to minimum.
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer - 5
Teixeira - 5
Page - 4.5
Forster Caskey - 4
Aribo - 7
Konsa - 6.5
Holmes - 5
Mavididi - 7.5
Novak - 6.5
Crofts - 6
Magennis - 5
Watt n/a
Byrne - 6.5
Bauer- 5.5
Teixeira -6
Page - 5
Forster Caskey - 4.5
Aribo - 7
Konsa - 6.5
Holmes - 5.5
Mavididi - 7.5
Novak- 6
Crofts -7
Magennis- 5
Byrne 6
Bauer 5
Teixeira 5.5
Page 4.5
Forster Caskey 4
Aribo 6.5
Konsa 6.5
Holmes 6.5
Mavididi 6.5
Novak 6
Crofts 6.5
Magennis 5
Watt n/a