Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v A.F.C.Wimbledon

2

Comments

  • Your marks please

    Rudd: 5 terrible distribution.
    Solly: 6 good but made mistake for goal
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 5
    Holmes: 7 v good player.
    Ulvestad: 5 not v good player
    Crofts: 5 not v good player
    Lookman: 7 bye bye in January
    Magennis: 5 fat lump
    Ajose: 2 pointless.

    Novak n/a



  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6.5
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvested: 6.5
    Crofts: 6.5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis 7.5
    Ajose: 5.5

    Novak n/a
  • edited September 2016
    Rudd: 6 No chance with the goals. What little he did do was competent.

    Solly: 6 Reasonable first half but second half was probably as bad as I can remember from him possibly partially at fault for one if not both of their goals from where I was sitting.

    Fox: 7 One great block in the first half. Up for it and played well.

    Konsa: 6.5 Coping with the level

    Pearce: 6.5 Committed and brave but does tend to give the ball back to the opposition

    Holmes: 7 Offered a threat and worked well with Solly at times

    Ulvestad: 6.5 Some good moments but faded

    Crofts: 6.5 Better in the first half

    Lookman: 7.5 In and out but offered some moments of real skill and quality

    Magennis: 6.5 Isolated at times but stuck at it

    Ajose: 5 A striker might have shots saved but he should hit the target at least
  • edited September 2016
    Rudd: 6 nothing to do except pick the ball out the net.
    Solly: 4.5 he got mullered 2nd half, worst ever performance ?
    Fox: 6.5 decent game
    Konsa: 7 best game so far
    Pearce: 6 at fault for 2nd goal, got outjumped by the scorer
    Holmes: 7.5 MOM as usual
    Ulvestad: 6 better than last week, faded 2nd half
    Crofts: 6
    Lookman: 6.5
    Magennis: 6.5
    Ajose: 4.5 leave him out, he's offered nowt all season.

    Slade 3 he lost the game, we were crying out for 3 subs, Wimbledon did & Slade inexplicably didn't. Even Powell would have brought on 3 subs, by the 75th minute, latest.

  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 5
    Konsa: 5
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 6.5
    Ulvestad: 6
    Crofts: 6
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 6
    Ajose: 5

    Midfield is crap, Full backs look like they are struggling too.

  • Rudd: 6 didn't really have much to do.
    Solly: 5 at fault for one goal, one of the worst alfa i've see him play for a long while.
    Fox: 7 One of his best games.
    Konsa: 5.5 Clearly a skilful player, but starting to get found out defensively. Stick Bauer in now and give the kid a break.
    Pearce: 6 Commands the back four well, helpful to Konsa. Struggles against 'lumps up front;
    Holmes: 6.5 Did well but lacked today the end product (goal or pass)
    Ulvestad: 6 Drifted in and out a bit, but better than Foley!
    Crofts: 6 Did what he needed most of the time
    Lookman: 6 Great Goal, but he needs to be playing in the centre.
    Magennis: 5 For such a big bloke (height) he can't jump or win many headers. Huffs and Puffs but isn't good enough.
    Ajose: 5 What an earth has happened to him since last year.....

    Novak - i'd rather see him up front with Lookman than Ajose/Magennis at the moment.
  • Rudd: 6.5 - not at fault for either goal for me, distribution was reasonable and had to deal with a few tasty back passes from Pearce.
    Solly: 5 - out played and suffered when Lookman tired in 2nd half as didn't have protection or out ball as much. Not a captain.
    Fox: 8 - thought he was our best defender. Covered for Pearce when pulled out wide well, one terrific block in first half to stop a shot on goal. Distribution was okay with one poor cross early in second half. Good link up play with the wingers. Did well.
    Konsa: 6 - looks great on the ground but doesn't time his clearing headers well (gets underneath them and the ball ends up being knocked on). Started to panic more when afcw brought on 2 big lumps, sat deep and lost his position slightly.
    Pearce: 6 - got pulled out wide occasionally but covered well. Disappointing tendency to lump it forward. Needs to be better at managing Konsa's position - he failed in the second half.
    Holmes: 8 - glides past players for fun. Right mix of shooting and trying to influence the game by taking players on as the game progressed.
    Ulvested: 7 - I was impressed. Drives forward 10/15 yards at a time from midfield and looks to pass the ball forward. Has a knack of not losing it. Think he'll be good for us. Tired in 2nd half but unsurprising given lack of game time in last 18 months. Slade at fault for not rotating players or bringing on additional midfield support.
    Crofts: 6.5 - industrious if slightly agricultural at times, happy with him in midfield.
    Lookman: 7.5 - was a class above in first half. After 70 min could barely run, resulting in Solly being exposed for first goal and contributing to lack of shape on second. Blame lies with Slade.
    Magennis 7 - tireless, hero for the cause. One phenomenal touch to bring a 40yard ball down perfectly over his head to create a chance. Needs help up top.
    Ajose: 5 - not his day. But then you play long ball football to Nick Ajose and you're not going to get the best from him.

    Novak n/a - tried to work some space but with a tiring midfield was fighting a losing battle.

    Slade - 3 - we played well first half and should have been out of sight. Credit to Slade fircthe way he set the team out. The Novak sub for Ajose was straight out of management for dummies - "make like for like subs". The game was crying out for another midfielder as afcw were beginning to overrun us and defence was sitting too deep as a result. Botaka or Jackson had to come on for Lookman - the boy could hardly run after 70 min. I just don't know what he was thinking. It was so obvious and at 1-1 only afcw were in with a chance of winning. Really disappointing.
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 5
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvestad: 6
    Crofts: 6.5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 6.5
    Ajose: 4
  • Rudd: 5.5 - Hard to mark when practically all he has had to do is pick the ball out the back of the net...
    Solly: 4.5 - I can't believe some STILL marked him as better than Fox. Absolutely mugged for the first, (you shouldn't be nut megged in your own penalty area) and committed a terrible howler just afterwards, smashing the ball against an opposition player from about 2". His cross that he pulled back to the edge of the area was because he didn't look, there were 2 players inside the 6 yard box. When Foxy was windmilling his arms, trying to gee up the players and crowd up, there was nothing from Solly. Possibly his worst game, that I have seen, in a Charlton shirt.
    Fox: 6.5 - Very good. Got forward well, creating good overlaps. A number of thunderous tackles, and on numerous occasions, showing strength when marshalling the ball out of play. Solid with both Lookman and Holmes in front of him.
    Konsa: 5.5 - Found out a bit, against some extremely powerful forwards. Not bad, but not up to the standard he has shown so far this season. Bailed out by his pace a few times. Still a number of excellent tackles.
    Pearce: 6 - Old fashioned centre back, who's skill is not based on his distribution. Throws himself at everything, and gets rid. Marshalls the back line well, but struggled a bit against the big centre forward.
    Holmes: 7.5 MOTM - So good with the ball, and worked so hard to win it when we didn't. Lost count of the number of tackles he made on both wings. Such a lovely, direct runner with the ball. Unlucky not to score with a superb volley, that I still can't believe the keeper got to...
    Ulvestad: 6.5 - Decent Valley debut. Looked brilliant in the first half, but less influential when Wimbledon went more direct in the 2nd half, missing out the midfield. Tired, but less so than Lookman did...
    Crofts: 6 - Does his job effectively. Top tackler in the team, and maintained that standard. Tireless running, who's job is to win re ball and pass it on.
    Lookman: 7 - I want to make this clear. This score is based on his 1st half performance, and his scoring of the goal. When we were under the cosh, went totally AWOL, leaving others to do his job. Should have been taken off, which would have lead to certain sections of the crowd booing, and singing "you don't know what you're doing!"...
    Magennis: 7 - Won header after header. Brilliant skill to fabricate a chance out of nothing, from Novak brilliant pass. Took on 3 men, and still got his shot away.
    Ajose: 5 - Nothing is working for him at the moment. Isn't reading flicks or passes, so constantly out of position. In his defence, never stopped trying. Maybe time to let Novak start...
  • Rudd: 6 Little to do. Not at fault for goals.
    Solly: 4.5 Below par performance and at fault for first goal. Not a captain!
    Fox: 6 Reasonable game
    Konsa: 5.5 Although he shows great promise for the future, he is raw and inexperienced. Time for Bauer.
    Pearce: 7 Immense performance, although partly at fault for second goal.
    Holmes: 7 Constant threat.
    Ulvestad: 7 Great performance in first half, but faded in second as he got tired. Should have been subbed.
    Crofts: 6 Solid without being outstanding.
    Lookman: 7 A real threat in first half but faded in second.
    Magennis: 6.5 Needs to improve his timing when jumping for headers but quite a threat.
    Ajose: 5.5 It's not happening for him. One poor miss from close range.

    Novak n/a Looks more of a threat than Ajose. Needs to start.

    Slade Lack of substitutions was our downfall, so he must accept a large chunk of blame.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rob7Lee said:


    Magennis: 5 For such a big bloke (height) he can't jump or win many headers. Huffs and Puffs but isn't good enough.

    It starts
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvestad: 6
    Crofts: 6.5
    Lookman: 8
    Magennis: 6.5
    Ajose: 5


  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Ulvestad: 7
    Crofts: 6.5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 6
    Ajose: 5

    Novak n/a

    Slade - 3. Only one substitution, and that was a bad one.

  • Rudd: 5.5
    Solly: 5.5
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 6
    Ulvestad: 7
    Crofts: 6.5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 6
    Ajose: 4
  • Rudd: 5
    Solly: 4
    Fox: 5
    Konsa: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Holmes: 6
    Ulvestad: 3
    Crofts: 5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 5.5
    Ajose: 3
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvestad: 6
    Crofts: 5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 6.5
    Ajose 5
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6 Bauer is better
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvestad: 7
    Crofts: 3 and people think Jacko's legs have gone. Garbage
    Lookman: 7 good goal and some quality touches. Tired second half
    Magennis: 7
    Ajose: 3 other than 2 scrappy goals done fuck all in a Charlton shirt. Not a confidence issue just don't think he's any good
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Ulvestad 8
    Crofts: 5.5
    Lookman: 7
    Maggenis: 6.5
    Ajose: 5
  • Russell Slade, Russell Slade,
    Summer spent drinking lemonade,
    Fleetwood, Wimbledon, put him in the shade,
    Russell Slade, Russell Slade.

    Russell Slade never explained,
    Why his team were poorly trained,
    Never once did he assert,
    That none were fit to wear the shirt.

    Russell Slade always ignoring
    Hoof-ball makes for football boring.
    Fans all watch like graveside mourners,
    Charlton botch up all their corners.

    Russell Slade will never win it,
    His team gives up in the tenth minute,
    Can't be asked to run and strike it,
    Eff of fans, if you don't like it.

    Russell Slade, Russell Slade,
    Under worked, and overpaid,
    Yet when he's sacked, he'll have it made,
    Russell Slade, Russell Slade.
  • Rudd: 5
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Holmes: 6.5
    Ulvestad: 5.5
    Crofts: 5.5
    Lookman: 8
    Magennis: 6.5
    Ajose: 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Poplcon! Frank 3 ? Wasn't there but all reports say he made goal with a superb pass. Unless that was his only pass to a red shirt, this mark is nonsense and you are demeaning the thread. Is the guy shagging your wife?
  • That one's started too
  • Rudd: 6 1st went through his legs but not uncommon. 2nd no chance. Piss poor defending for both.
    Solly: 4.5 -1 for the 1st goal conceded. Let their man walk into the box.
    Fox: 6 our best defender today. Too much hoof at times.
    Konsa: 5 dealt with Lyle Taylor very well in the first half. Second half everything fell apart. Think it's time to start Bauer and Lennon together.
    Pearce: 4.5 very slow and beaten far too easily at times. As above. Bauer and Lennon please.
    Holmes: 7 tried hard. Had a good shot well saved. His energy was superb. That tackle on the side line was spot on.
    Ulvestad: 6 played well and we are more creative with him in the side (as opposed to Jacko and Foley).
    Crofts: 6 Decent tackling but a player with his experience should be telling the team to push up more.
    Lookman: 6.5 1st half they couldn't deal with him. Second half, like the rest of the team, they thought it was won.
    Magennis: 6 Tried hard to win all the aerial balls.
    Ajose: 4 you don't go and score 20+ goals in one season and then fail to make ANY sort of impact in the next whilst staying in the same league. Something is seriously wrong, but I think he needs to be dropped. No impact, no movement and Magennis may as well be a lone striker.

    Novak n/a

    These marks might seem harsh but the players did not give 100% effort in the second half which is most disappointing. Think we need to make a few changes for Scunthorpe.
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 5 - usual shit hoofball to no-one
    Konsa: 6 - did some ok stuff
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 6 - flattered to deceive
    Ulvestad: 7 - good in first
    Crofts: 5 - non-existant
    Lookman: 7 good goal - not a lot else
    Magennis: 5 huffed and puffed but failed to blow the door down
    Ajose: 3 pony - had to check in 2nd half that he was still on pitch
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 6
    Pearce: 6
    Holmes: 7
    Ulvestad 6
    Crofts: 5.5
    Lookman: 6
    Maggenis: 6
    Ajose: 4
  • Rudd: 6 - very little to do other than to fish the ball out of the net twice
    Solly: 5 - exposed in the second half against a strong and speedy winger
    Fox: 7 - very sound
    Konsa: 6 - pretty good. One or two slip ups but he has excellent powers of recovery
    Pearce: 6 - solid, if somewhat industrial
    Holmes: 6.5 - some good moments but it didn't quite fall for him on the day. Drew an excellent second half save from their keeper
    Ulvestad: 6 - had some good moments before understandably fading, given his very limited game time during the last 12 months
    Crofts: 5.5 - some good interceptions and tackles in the first half but ran out of steam in the latter stages
    Lookman: 7 - excellent in the first half, faded in the second and should probably have been subbed (particularly as we have a game on Tuesday)
    Magennis: 6 - worked hard but the service/'hoofball' to him was poor. Missed a decent headed chance in the second half
    Ajose: 4.5 - contributed very little and snatched at the first half chances that came his way
  • Rudd: 5
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 5
    Konsa: 5
    Pearce: 5
    Holmes: 6
    Ulvestad: 5
    Crofts: 5
    Lookman: 7
    Magennis: 5
    Ajose: 4

    Novak n/a
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 5
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 6.5
    Pearce: 6.5
    Holmes: 7.5
    Ulvestad: 7
    Crofts: 6
    Lookman: 6.5
    Magennis: 6
    Ajose: 4

    Novak n/a
  • Love how some people can't give Solly a low mark no matter how shit he plays
  • Rudd: 6 Left exposed with the goals
    Solly: 5 Been our best player until this game
    Fox: 7 Good performance
    Konsa: 5 Time to be left out
    Pearce: 6 Solid
    Holmes: 6 Average , but a couple of times he looked as though he might do something
    Ulvestad: 6 Good first half
    Crofts: 6 Another mixed bag . He does lose possession too much for my liking at the moment , but at other times looks impressive .
    Lookman: 6 Extra point for the goal
    Magennis: 6 Looks menacing
    Ajose: 5 . Disappointing so far . Are we playing to his Strengths?

    Novak n/a Should start Tuesday .
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!