Pope - 6 Not able to criticise wall positioning for the 1st goal based on my view, but he didn't play too badly Solly - 3.5 loses half a point (I'm being generous at that) for completely ineffectual performance as captain. He might be fit to wear the shirt, but never give him that armband again Sarr - 4.5 hard to believe he played in the CL Diarra -4 never looked comfortable Fox - 4 some shocking passing Bergdich - 2 - car crash of a performance Ba - 2.5 Ok he kept trying, but that's the only positive thing you can say Cousins - 3 worst CAFC performance. Have to question his technical ability for that role. Better as a RB? Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 a few glimmers of hope, did his best Ahearne-Grant - 3.5 lightweight, and if (according to the programme) he is the fastest player in the squad he must surely have been nobbled on Monday night Watt - 4 too often isolated, too deep. there's a player there but he needs to be managed better McAleny - 2 hopeless. lightweight and often his 1st touch sends the ball 5m back towards his own goal Makienok - 4.5 huffed & puffed. Jackson -5 ditto, but the attitude was right, for 15 min or so
For those who watched the match this evening your marks please:
Pope - 4 his inadequacy didn't cost points, this time Solly - 6 did what he could but overrun by the deluge of effluent from his colleagues Sarr - 3 not nearly good enough Diarra - 5 shaky start but next best after Solly Fox - 3 had a horror show even for him Bergdich - 1 shamefully disinterested robbing his wages only non-league at his best Ba - 2 back to the clueless passenger he seemed in August, dreadful Cousins - 4 tirelessly headless chicken who is colourblind or can't pass Holmes-Dennis - not fair to rate someone of his inexperience amongst such sewage Ahearne-Grant - 4 seems to try hard enough but lacks the tools passing worse than JC Watt - 3 shamefully bizarrely unfit useful for 20mins max McAleny - busy but wholly ineffective Makienok - given an impossible task with no support Jackson - made more tackles than all his midfield "colleagues" put together must have felt like the little Dutch boy with his finger in the dyke.
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performence should there be a MoM: Yes No, no, 10 times NO
Pope - 4 - Another "meh" game. +1 for not dropping the ball at an opposition players feet. Progress, he will be a Conference South quality keeper in no time.
Solly - 4.5 - Meh
Sarr - 2 - This guy does not have a bloody clue.
Diarra - 5 - Better than most, he has quality in him, not sure about his fitness/passion though
Fox - 5.5 - Love this guy. A lot of what he does doesn't necessarily come off, but he attacks, and he defends, he plays the wing back role well, and is involved in a lot of attacks. 99% of the time he would play a pass and get the ball straight back, there was no real outlet for him a lot of the time.
Bergdich - 3 - We really have made some awful additions to our squad.
Ba - 3 - Always frustrates me.
Cousins - 5 - Has the fight in him, he really, really wanted it. Which at this point is what is getting people up to a 5...
Holmes-Dennis - 4 - Meh
Ahearne-Grant - 3 - Absolutely rubbish. League 2 at best, not blaming the lad, he seems to want it, but he is nowhere near the required quality to play at this level.
Watt - 4 - Showed some flair, but his constant moaning at our players when everything doesn't go right really pisses me off, I think he's a twat to be honest, but to be fair I have thought this since a couple goals in. He can be a twat and a good footballer, but the way he acts, he clearly has an attitude.
McAleny - 4 - looked nippy at times, I think he needs a group of fitter players around him.
Makienok - 6 - We need to be playing him as often as possible, with players around him who understand the concept of receiving the second ball, he was quality, but he isn't a goalscorer, he is much more of a playmaker. Needs the right people around him.
Jackson - 5 - Passion gets you points, and he seemed to really want to be there which is something at this point!
Pope - 4 One day he'll be a decent keeper but right now we need Henderson to come back and kick some ass Solly - 4 Not comfortable as a captain. Sarr - 5 Looked reasonable. Some nice touches. He could be decent with a few more games under his belt. Diarra - 4.5 too quiet for my liking. He should be first choice as a captain but he isn't vocal enough. Nobody is a leader at the back when Bauer isn't around. Fox - 3.5 His crossing is absolutely terrible. HE always hits the man (except the one last night that went straight into the North stand). Couple of petulant pushes and shoves show there is passion in there but our defence needs a leader and it isn't him. Bergdich - 3 Woeful. I don't care if he is being played out of position - he gave Solly no protection and was shocking in possession. Ba - 3 Almost every second touch was a tackle - what does that say about his first touch. Passing was off and has no pace. Cousins - 4 Shadow of his former self. His passing always has been pretty average but was especially shit last night Holmes-Dennis - 5 Forgot about him in the first half until he challenged Fox for 3 headers in midfield. He'll grow but tonight could end up being damaging for a while. Ahearne-Grant - 5 I appreciate he is just a kid - but he needs a lot more strength and a much better first touch. Worried he'll become the next Kim Grant and start getting abuse Watt - 5.5 He tried harder than most but was still below average McAleny - 5 Nice touches but not strong. Could be worth persisting with. Makienok - 6.5 Won everything aerially but nobody was within 20 yards of him most of the time. I genuinely wonder what the coaches say "Hit the big man, he can lay it off and then we can watch our opponents play on". Get someone near him and he'll be a shit load more effective. Jackson - 4 Chased shadows and kicked a bloke. Standard Jacko stuff really.
MOM Kashi
My lowest scores ever. Fully deserved from that shower of shit.
First time in years I have come away questioning why I bother - last time was the 2-5 reverse against Sheff Utd when Pards was relieved of his duties.
I was getting frustrated at the number of "something isn't right" comments I was reading but I have to say....I'm starting to wonder it now. Has Guy lost the team?
Luzon - 2 - I can normally find things to defend Guy on, but tonight playing players out of position and not working out that Preston were killing us in midfield because of formation as early as the first 10 minutes was criminal last night.
Pope - 6 At fault (I think) for 1st goal otherwise okay. Solly - 5 Sarr - 4.5 Diarra - 5.5 Fox - 4 From Man U to Accrington Stanley Bergdich - 3 Ba - 3.5 Cousins - 5 Holmes-Dennis - 5 Ahearne-Grant - 4 Watt - 7 McAleny - 4.5 Makienok - 6.5 Jackson - 5
Pope - 3 Should have done better for first two goals. Does well on loan but poor for us. Coaching staff to blame? Solly - 2 Poor captain. Seems worried about injuring his knee Sarr - 3 Champions league????? Diarra - 5 Missed Bauer Fox - 2.5 terrible crossing. Poor header lead to third Bergdich - 0.5 terrible Ba - 1 terrible Cousins - 3 Still young and was dragged down by the others Holmes-Dennis - 6 MOM made a few good runs, one good tackle but could have done better for the third. I would keep him involved with the squad Ahearne-Grant - 3 Young, raw and needs under 21 football/loan to help development Watt - 4.5 I thought he was greedy and could have played a simple ball to a red shirt a few times. the problem was that the free man was Bergdich! Please get in the box rather than sit deep McAleny - 5 Tried to be positive and run at defenders Makienok - 6 Won headers and held the ball but not a red shirt near him Jackson - 5 busy but didn't achieve much
Pope - 6 not as bad as some say. Bench on Saturday please Solly - 4 awful captain Sarr - 3 should be on loan at Gillingham Diarra - 4 missed Bauer Fox - 4.5 needs to up his game and fast. Bergdich - 3 awful Ba - 2.5 would misplace a pass and then do feck all to get it back Cousins - 5 not a good game Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 looked promising but it's hard to look good when about 9 of your teammates couldn't give a shite Ahearne-Grant - 4 for his sake put him on the bench Watt - 4 his lack of desire angers me McAleny - 3 should be on loan at Colchester Makienok - 6 it was too late for him to change anything Jackson - 5 as above
Luzon got it wrong today and has got it wrong of late - however to sack him would be ridiculous.
Pope - 2 Was at fault with that pathetic punch for their 2nd Solly - 4 Is suffering from the effects of the rest of the pathetic bunch Sarr - 1 Poor excuse for a centre half Diarra - 4 Same as Solly Fox - 0 Manchester United interested in him !!! FC United of Manchester is more his level. Useless Tw*t Bergdich - 0 As bad a Fox. we were atrocious down the left last night Ba - 0.5 Awful player. Constantly out of position in a midfiled that was all over the place Cousins - 2 Worst game in a Charlton shirt. see comments for solly and diarra Holmes-Dennis - 3 Felt sorry for him. Looked like he at least tried Ahearne-Grant - 0 Awful player. Should also be turning out for FC United of Manchester.. More his level Watt - 3 Tried to make up for the lack of talent around him but again tried too hard. McAleny - 3 What are we and him gaining from this loan !?1 Makienok - 6 A striker that we need in the starting 11 each week. Jackson - 5 Need the captains spitit to stir up this bunch
Luzon - -1 Get rid of him ASAP. Look what Brum, Brighton, and Reading are doing with quality BRITISH managers
Pope - 4 - Simply not good enough, too timid. The "setting up" of the wall for the 1st goal was abysmal. Solly - 5 - Not a captain, but does his best. Sarr - 4 - Very disappointed in him so far, was expecting much better. Diarra - 5 - Classy at times, but does concede a lot of free kicks. Fox - 4 - I just don't see what he brings to the team. Bergdich - 4 - Not a right midfielder and a terrible decision to play him there. Ba - 4 - Going backwards after starting so brightly. Cousins - 4 Holmes-Dennis - 4.5 - Give him a run-out at left back instead of Fox. Ahearne-Grant - 4 - Looks lost. Watt - 5 - Some of his dribbling tonight was much better than of late. McAleny - 4 - Wanders from his position so much, must confuse the rest of the team. Makienok - 5.5 - The only one who tried. Jackson - 4.5
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performance should there be a MoM:
Pope - 4 Can be a decent keeper. Did Ok. Solly - 4 Not a good captain. Exposed by Bergdich. Sarr - 4 Poor first touch but under pressure from a poor midfield and PNE players running at them Diarra - 4.5 Did ok but suffered from the above Fox - 4 Did ok but couldn't show much going forward due to poor midfield and lack of movement from the forwards Bergdich - 1 One of the worst players I've seen in a Charlton shirt. Constantly out of position against Reading and again last night- he gave Solly no protection and was shocking in possession. Ba - 3 Poor tackling. Cousins - 4 Confidence very low. Holmes-Dennis - 4 Same as above Ahearne-Grant - 5 Poor first touch and passing needs to improve. I think it was his very poor pass which PNE the ball which lead to the first goal. Watt - 5.5 Tried a few things and I think Luzon made changes to accomodate him. But sadly it failed. McAleny - 4 Fortunately I had to leave early so cant comment. But based on other comments I'l be generous Makienok - 6 See above Jackson - 4 See above
Luzon - 2 - Players out of position and did nothing tactically to change the game. Preston used all the pitch and at least should have told Bergditch to stop drifting in. I now think his pitch antics are now inaffective and a waste of time.
Pope - 5 not helped by a static defense, we need SH back for calmness. Solly - 5 average Sarr - 4 poor Diarra -5 struggled Fox -4 poor all night but keep trying. Bergdich -4 looks lightweight. Ba - 4 wins the odd tackle but struggled. Cousins -4 poor centre mid performance after being picked in his best position. Holmes-Dennis - 5 coming into a struggling team is tough. Ahearne-Grant -4 should be learning his trade on loan in League 1. Watt -5.5 kept trying in his Languid way, extra point for only shot that reached the keeper ! McAleny -5 the lad tries but is ineffective. Makienok -5.5 within a minute of coming on the game had gone. Jackson - 5 ditto.
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performence should there be a MoM: Yes No players but the crowd who stayed to the bitter end which included me !
Pope - 5 Didn't inspire confidence. Solly - 4.5 Looked quite weak. Sarr - 4.5 Ok on the ball. Not ok without it. Heading is a massive problem. At least three routine headed clearances from long balls misjudged and not made. Diarra - 5 A couple of good interceptions but even his heading wasn't clean last night. Fox - 4 Tried to get forward but lacked any real quality. Got wrong side of his man quite a lot and looked hesitant. Bergdich - 3 Played out of position but didn't make a good fist of it. Think he's probably an ok player but at the moment he looks like a left-wing sub. Ba - 5 Tried to get stuck in. Bit unlucky with receiving poor ball behind him for the opening goal but doesn't look the part without Kashi. Confidence very low. Cousins - 5 Passing was poor. Did try to get stuck in a bit but too similar to Ba. Holmes-Dennis - 5 A couple of bits of skill but looked very lightweight. Had one chance to burn into the area in 1st half but looked nervous (understandable) and didn't go for it. Ahearne-Grant - 5 Tried and did make a few off ball runs that weren't seen. Looked lightweight. Watt - 6 Mainly for effort. Ran his himself into the ground and may have tweaked a muscle with about five mins to go. Didn't get close enough to Makienok but that might have been to do with fatigue rather than lack of nous. McAleny - 6 Did his best to get us going. Has good feet and may have to play up front if Watt can't last. Makienok - 7 Even with very little service he did at least allow us to get up the field a bit. We won't see the best of him until we can sort out a supply (be it long ball or crosses). Jackson - 6 Was ok but looked short of sharpness. Will have to play in the absence of Kashi.
Pope - 3 Plays like the kid at school who is shit so they put him in goal Solly - 4 not a captain, has lost all fight he had 2 years ago Sarr - 3.5 For someone so big, it staggers me at how poor he is in the air. Diarra -6 Feel sorry him, if we are his last professional club, what a way to go out Fox - 3 At fault for the third for a shite header, typical fox performance Bergdich -2 would be happy to never see him in a charlton shirt again Ba - 2 see above Cousins -5 passing is atrocious at times, makes up for it in graft Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 terrible game to make his debut in, said that thought he did okay. Ahearne-Grant -3 Out of his depth, as for ducking in the wall for the first goal? Pftt Watt -5.5 kept trying, has to drop so deep because he is the only one who actually wants to get on the ball McAleny -3 Up there with our worst ever loan signing, there's a reason no one had heard of him when he signed. Makienok -6 did what was needed, think he cares which is more than can be said for most of them Jackson - 5 should of started.
Pope - 4 lets hope Hendo's fit for saturday Solly - 4 kept at it, not much of a leader though Sarr - 2 Diarra - 4 Fox - 2 him and THD where confused and lost the whole game Bergdich - 1 one of the worst players I've seen where the shirt Ba - 1 same as above, its a struggle to watch him play Cousins - 4 feel sorry him Holmes-Dennis - 3 good player thrown in wrongly imo Ahearne-Grant - 3 not ready Watt - 4 McAleny - 2 send him back.. Makienok - 5 Jackson - 5
Pope - 4 should only be played as a back up, harsh but hes going to cost us points Solly - 4 Sarr - 4 Diarra - 5 Fox - 5.5 Bergdich - 2 Ba - 1 awful performance Cousins - 5 Holmes-Dennis - 5 Ahearne-Grant - 5 Watt - 5 McAleny - 1 back to Everton please Makienok - 5 Jackson - 5
Comments
Solly - 3.5 loses half a point (I'm being generous at that) for completely ineffectual performance as captain. He might be fit to wear the shirt, but never give him that armband again
Sarr - 4.5 hard to believe he played in the CL
Diarra -4 never looked comfortable
Fox - 4 some shocking passing
Bergdich - 2 - car crash of a performance
Ba - 2.5 Ok he kept trying, but that's the only positive thing you can say
Cousins - 3 worst CAFC performance. Have to question his technical ability for that role. Better as a RB?
Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 a few glimmers of hope, did his best
Ahearne-Grant - 3.5 lightweight, and if (according to the programme) he is the fastest player in the squad he must surely have been nobbled on Monday night
Watt - 4 too often isolated, too deep. there's a player there but he needs to be managed better
McAleny - 2 hopeless. lightweight and often his 1st touch sends the ball 5m back towards his own goal
Makienok - 4.5 huffed & puffed.
Jackson -5 ditto, but the attitude was right, for 15 min or so
Pope - 4 his inadequacy didn't cost points, this time
Solly - 6 did what he could but overrun by the deluge of effluent from his colleagues
Sarr - 3 not nearly good enough
Diarra - 5 shaky start but next best after Solly
Fox - 3 had a horror show even for him
Bergdich - 1 shamefully disinterested robbing his wages only non-league at his best
Ba - 2 back to the clueless passenger he seemed in August, dreadful
Cousins - 4 tirelessly headless chicken who is colourblind or can't pass
Holmes-Dennis - not fair to rate someone of his inexperience amongst such sewage
Ahearne-Grant - 4 seems to try hard enough but lacks the tools passing worse than JC
Watt - 3 shamefully bizarrely unfit useful for 20mins max
McAleny - busy but wholly ineffective
Makienok - given an impossible task with no support
Jackson - made more tackles than all his midfield "colleagues" put together must have felt like the little Dutch boy with his finger in the dyke.
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performence should there be a MoM:
Yes
No, no, 10 times NO
Solly - 4.5 - Meh
Sarr - 2 - This guy does not have a bloody clue.
Diarra - 5 - Better than most, he has quality in him, not sure about his fitness/passion though
Fox - 5.5 - Love this guy. A lot of what he does doesn't necessarily come off, but he attacks, and he defends, he plays the wing back role well, and is involved in a lot of attacks. 99% of the time he would play a pass and get the ball straight back, there was no real outlet for him a lot of the time.
Bergdich - 3 - We really have made some awful additions to our squad.
Ba - 3 - Always frustrates me.
Cousins - 5 - Has the fight in him, he really, really wanted it. Which at this point is what is getting people up to a 5...
Holmes-Dennis - 4 - Meh
Ahearne-Grant - 3 - Absolutely rubbish. League 2 at best, not blaming the lad, he seems to want it, but he is nowhere near the required quality to play at this level.
Watt - 4 - Showed some flair, but his constant moaning at our players when everything doesn't go right really pisses me off, I think he's a twat to be honest, but to be fair I have thought this since a couple goals in. He can be a twat and a good footballer, but the way he acts, he clearly has an attitude.
McAleny - 4 - looked nippy at times, I think he needs a group of fitter players around him.
Makienok - 6 - We need to be playing him as often as possible, with players around him who understand the concept of receiving the second ball, he was quality, but he isn't a goalscorer, he is much more of a playmaker. Needs the right people around him.
Jackson - 5 - Passion gets you points, and he seemed to really want to be there which is something at this point!
Solly - 4 Not comfortable as a captain.
Sarr - 5 Looked reasonable. Some nice touches. He could be decent with a few more games under his belt.
Diarra - 4.5 too quiet for my liking. He should be first choice as a captain but he isn't vocal enough. Nobody is a leader at the back when Bauer isn't around.
Fox - 3.5 His crossing is absolutely terrible. HE always hits the man (except the one last night that went straight into the North stand). Couple of petulant pushes and shoves show there is passion in there but our defence needs a leader and it isn't him.
Bergdich - 3 Woeful. I don't care if he is being played out of position - he gave Solly no protection and was shocking in possession.
Ba - 3 Almost every second touch was a tackle - what does that say about his first touch. Passing was off and has no pace.
Cousins - 4 Shadow of his former self. His passing always has been pretty average but was especially shit last night
Holmes-Dennis - 5 Forgot about him in the first half until he challenged Fox for 3 headers in midfield. He'll grow but tonight could end up being damaging for a while.
Ahearne-Grant - 5 I appreciate he is just a kid - but he needs a lot more strength and a much better first touch. Worried he'll become the next Kim Grant and start getting abuse
Watt - 5.5 He tried harder than most but was still below average
McAleny - 5 Nice touches but not strong. Could be worth persisting with.
Makienok - 6.5 Won everything aerially but nobody was within 20 yards of him most of the time. I genuinely wonder what the coaches say "Hit the big man, he can lay it off and then we can watch our opponents play on". Get someone near him and he'll be a shit load more effective.
Jackson - 4 Chased shadows and kicked a bloke. Standard Jacko stuff really.
MOM Kashi
My lowest scores ever. Fully deserved from that shower of shit.
First time in years I have come away questioning why I bother - last time was the 2-5 reverse against Sheff Utd when Pards was relieved of his duties.
I was getting frustrated at the number of "something isn't right" comments I was reading but I have to say....I'm starting to wonder it now. Has Guy lost the team?
Solly - 4
Sarr - 4
Diarra - 5
Fox - 4
Bergdich - 3
Ba - 3.5
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 3
Watt - 4
McAleny - 3.5
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 4
No MOM!
Solly - 5
Sarr - 4
Diarra - 6.5
Fox - 4
Bergdich - 3
Ba - 4
Cousins - 6
Holmes-Dennis - 6
Ahearne-Grant - 5
Watt - 5
McAleny - 5
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 6
Luzon - 2 - I can normally find things to defend Guy on, but tonight playing players out of position and not working out that Preston were killing us in midfield because of formation as early as the first 10 minutes was criminal last night.
Solly - 5
Sarr - 4.5
Diarra - 5.5
Fox - 4 From Man U to Accrington Stanley
Bergdich - 3
Ba - 3.5
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 5
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 7
McAleny - 4.5
Makienok - 6.5
Jackson - 5
Solly - 2 Poor captain. Seems worried about injuring his knee
Sarr - 3 Champions league?????
Diarra - 5 Missed Bauer
Fox - 2.5 terrible crossing. Poor header lead to third
Bergdich - 0.5 terrible
Ba - 1 terrible
Cousins - 3 Still young and was dragged down by the others
Holmes-Dennis - 6 MOM made a few good runs, one good tackle but could have done better for the third. I would keep him involved with the squad
Ahearne-Grant - 3 Young, raw and needs under 21 football/loan to help development
Watt - 4.5 I thought he was greedy and could have played a simple ball to a red shirt a few times. the problem was that the free man was Bergdich! Please get in the box rather than sit deep
McAleny - 5 Tried to be positive and run at defenders
Makienok - 6 Won headers and held the ball but not a red shirt near him
Jackson - 5 busy but didn't achieve much
Luzon - -5 Poor team selection
Solly - 4 awful captain
Sarr - 3 should be on loan at Gillingham
Diarra - 4 missed Bauer
Fox - 4.5 needs to up his game and fast.
Bergdich - 3 awful
Ba - 2.5 would misplace a pass and then do feck all to get it back
Cousins - 5 not a good game
Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 looked promising but it's hard to look good when about 9 of your teammates couldn't give a shite
Ahearne-Grant - 4 for his sake put him on the bench
Watt - 4 his lack of desire angers me
McAleny - 3 should be on loan at Colchester
Makienok - 6 it was too late for him to change anything
Jackson - 5 as above
Luzon got it wrong today and has got it wrong of late - however to sack him would be ridiculous.
Solly - 5
Sarr - 3
Diarra - 5
Fox - 3
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 4
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 5
Ahearne-Grant - 3
Watt - 5
McAleny - 3
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 4
Solly - 5
Sarr - 3
Diarra - 3
Fox - 3
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 2
Cousins - 3
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 6
McAleny - 5
Makienok -
Jackson -
Solly - 4
Sarr - 2
Diarra - 4
Fox - 4
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 2
Cousins - 3
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 5
McAleny - 5
Makienok -
Jackson -
Solly - 4
Sarr - 4.5
Diarra - 4.5
Fox - 3
Bergdich - 4
Ba - 3
Cousins - 4.5
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 3
McAleny - 4.5
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 5
Solly - 4 Is suffering from the effects of the rest of the pathetic bunch
Sarr - 1 Poor excuse for a centre half
Diarra - 4 Same as Solly
Fox - 0 Manchester United interested in him !!! FC United of Manchester is more his level. Useless Tw*t
Bergdich - 0 As bad a Fox. we were atrocious down the left last night
Ba - 0.5 Awful player. Constantly out of position in a midfiled that was all over the place
Cousins - 2 Worst game in a Charlton shirt. see comments for solly and diarra
Holmes-Dennis - 3 Felt sorry for him. Looked like he at least tried
Ahearne-Grant - 0 Awful player. Should also be turning out for FC United of Manchester.. More his level
Watt - 3 Tried to make up for the lack of talent around him but again tried too hard.
McAleny - 3 What are we and him gaining from this loan !?1
Makienok - 6 A striker that we need in the starting 11 each week.
Jackson - 5 Need the captains spitit to stir up this bunch
Luzon - -1 Get rid of him ASAP. Look what Brum, Brighton, and Reading are doing with quality BRITISH managers
Solly - 5 - Not a captain, but does his best.
Sarr - 4 - Very disappointed in him so far, was expecting much better.
Diarra - 5 - Classy at times, but does concede a lot of free kicks.
Fox - 4 - I just don't see what he brings to the team.
Bergdich - 4 - Not a right midfielder and a terrible decision to play him there.
Ba - 4 - Going backwards after starting so brightly.
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4.5 - Give him a run-out at left back instead of Fox.
Ahearne-Grant - 4 - Looks lost.
Watt - 5 - Some of his dribbling tonight was much better than of late.
McAleny - 4 - Wanders from his position so much, must confuse the rest of the team.
Makienok - 5.5 - The only one who tried.
Jackson - 4.5
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performance should there be a MoM:
No
Solly - 2
Sarr - 4
Diarra - 4
Fox - 5
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 2
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 3
Watt - 5
McAleny - 3
Makienok - 3
Jackson - 4
Fives for the two players who never hid regardless of how poor they were playing themselves.
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performance should there be a MoM:
No
Solly - 4 Not a good captain. Exposed by Bergdich.
Sarr - 4 Poor first touch but under pressure from a poor midfield and PNE players running at them
Diarra - 4.5 Did ok but suffered from the above
Fox - 4 Did ok but couldn't show much going forward due to poor midfield and lack of movement from the forwards
Bergdich - 1 One of the worst players I've seen in a Charlton shirt. Constantly out of position against Reading and again last night- he gave Solly no protection and was shocking in possession.
Ba - 3 Poor tackling.
Cousins - 4 Confidence very low.
Holmes-Dennis - 4 Same as above
Ahearne-Grant - 5 Poor first touch and passing needs to improve. I think it was his very poor pass which PNE the ball which lead to the first goal.
Watt - 5.5 Tried a few things and I think Luzon made changes to accomodate him. But sadly it failed.
McAleny - 4 Fortunately I had to leave early so cant comment. But based on other comments I'l be generous
Makienok - 6 See above
Jackson - 4 See above
Luzon - 2 - Players out of position and did nothing tactically to change the game. Preston used all the pitch and at least should have told Bergditch to stop drifting in.
I now think his pitch antics are now inaffective and a waste of time.
Solly - 5 average
Sarr - 4 poor
Diarra -5 struggled
Fox -4 poor all night but keep trying.
Bergdich -4 looks lightweight.
Ba - 4 wins the odd tackle but struggled.
Cousins -4 poor centre mid performance after being picked in his best position.
Holmes-Dennis - 5 coming into a struggling team is tough.
Ahearne-Grant -4 should be learning his trade on loan in League 1.
Watt -5.5 kept trying in his Languid way, extra point for only shot that reached the keeper !
McAleny -5 the lad tries but is ineffective.
Makienok -5.5 within a minute of coming on the game had gone.
Jackson - 5 ditto.
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performence should there be a MoM:
Yes
No players but the crowd who stayed to the bitter end which included me !
Solly - 4.5 Looked quite weak.
Sarr - 4.5 Ok on the ball. Not ok without it. Heading is a massive problem. At least three routine headed clearances from long balls misjudged and not made.
Diarra - 5 A couple of good interceptions but even his heading wasn't clean last night.
Fox - 4 Tried to get forward but lacked any real quality. Got wrong side of his man quite a lot and looked hesitant.
Bergdich - 3 Played out of position but didn't make a good fist of it. Think he's probably an ok player but at the moment he looks like a left-wing sub.
Ba - 5 Tried to get stuck in. Bit unlucky with receiving poor ball behind him for the opening goal but doesn't look the part without Kashi. Confidence very low.
Cousins - 5 Passing was poor. Did try to get stuck in a bit but too similar to Ba.
Holmes-Dennis - 5 A couple of bits of skill but looked very lightweight. Had one chance to burn into the area in 1st half but looked nervous (understandable) and didn't go for it.
Ahearne-Grant - 5 Tried and did make a few off ball runs that weren't seen. Looked lightweight.
Watt - 6 Mainly for effort. Ran his himself into the ground and may have tweaked a muscle with about five mins to go. Didn't get close enough to Makienok but that might have been to do with fatigue rather than lack of nous.
McAleny - 6 Did his best to get us going. Has good feet and may have to play up front if Watt can't last.
Makienok - 7 Even with very little service he did at least allow us to get up the field a bit. We won't see the best of him until we can sort out a supply (be it long ball or crosses).
Jackson - 6 Was ok but looked short of sharpness. Will have to play in the absence of Kashi.
Solly - 4 not a captain, has lost all fight he had 2 years ago
Sarr - 3.5 For someone so big, it staggers me at how poor he is in the air.
Diarra -6 Feel sorry him, if we are his last professional club, what a way to go out
Fox - 3 At fault for the third for a shite header, typical fox performance
Bergdich -2 would be happy to never see him in a charlton shirt again
Ba - 2 see above
Cousins -5 passing is atrocious at times, makes up for it in graft
Holmes-Dennis - 5.5 terrible game to make his debut in, said that thought he did okay.
Ahearne-Grant -3 Out of his depth, as for ducking in the wall for the first goal? Pftt
Watt -5.5 kept trying, has to drop so deep because he is the only one who actually wants to get on the ball
McAleny -3 Up there with our worst ever loan signing, there's a reason no one had heard of him when he signed.
Makienok -6 did what was needed, think he cares which is more than can be said for most of them
Jackson - 5 should of started.
Solly - 5
Sarr - 4.5
Diarra - 5
Fox - 4.5
Bergdich - 3.5
Ba - 3.5
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 5.5
McAleny - 3.5
Makienok - 5
Jackson - 4.5
We always give the highest average marked player the Man of the Match accolade, on tonight's performence should there be a MoM:
Yes - Simply on basis that Watt made some effort to create openings that were ignored by an inept mid-field
Solly 5
Sarr - 5
Diarra - 6
Fox - 4
Bergdich - 3
Ba - 3.5
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 6
Ahearne-Grant - 3
Watt - 5
McAleny - 4
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 6
Decent pint of Addicks Ale from the East Stand before kick off. Then a game of football broke out and ruined the night.
Solly - 4 kept at it, not much of a leader though
Sarr - 2
Diarra - 4
Fox - 2 him and THD where confused and lost the whole game
Bergdich - 1 one of the worst players I've seen where the shirt
Ba - 1 same as above, its a struggle to watch him play
Cousins - 4 feel sorry him
Holmes-Dennis - 3 good player thrown in wrongly imo
Ahearne-Grant - 3 not ready
Watt - 4
McAleny - 2 send him back..
Makienok - 5
Jackson - 5
Solly - 4
Sarr - 4
Diarra - 5
Fox - 5.5
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 1 awful performance
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 5
Ahearne-Grant - 5
Watt - 5
McAleny - 1 back to Everton please
Makienok - 5
Jackson - 5
motm - not a chance NO!
Solly - 4
Sarr - 3
Diarra - 3
Fox - 2
Bergdich - 1
Ba - 1
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 2
Ahearne-Grant - 3
Watt - 5
McAleny - 1
Makienok - 4
Jackson - 4
Solly - 6
Sarr - 6
Diarra - 6
Fox - 7
Bergdich - 5.5
Ba - 5
Cousins - 5.5
Holmes-Dennis - 5.5
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Watt - 5
McAleny - 5.5
Makienok - 6
Jackson - 5.5
Solly - 4
Sarr - 3
Diarra -4
Fox - 4
Bergdich - 2
Ba - 2
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Ahearne-Grant - 4
Watt - 5
McAleny - 3
Makienok - 5
Jackson 4
Cant be bothered to comment on players
Solly 5
Sarr 5
Diarra 5
Fox 5
Bergdich 2
Ba 3
Cousins 3
Holmes-Dennis 7
Ahearne-Grant 3
Watt 6
McAleny 3
Makienok 3
Jackson 4
Yes.