Pope - 3 crap for the 1st goal. Really shit if the ball bounces in front of him Solly - 4 Fox - 4 Bauer - Sarr - 5. No need to drop diara Gudmundsson - 4 Kashi - 4 Sarr - 5 Cousins - 2 let's pretend he didn't play on the left again. Luzon is a fucking idiot for putting him there again. How many more cock managers are gonna do it. Makienok - 5 Watt- 2 dog shit.
Pope - 6 shocking defending for the first goal but should've done a lot better with it. Second wasn't his fault. Not a lot else to do all game. Solly - 5.5 weak and bullied Fox - 4.5 weak and bullied Bauer - 5 our defence were bullied throughout. Sarr - 5 if it was his goal - well done. But I don't think he won a single header all game. Gudmundsson - 5 still hungover from the party in Iceland. Kashi - 6 Ba - 4 piss poor Cousins - 6.5 our best player. The only player who was willing to carry the ball forward. Makienok - 5.5 not many flick ons went anywhere - but not always his fault. Would never have taken him off Watt- 3.5 disinterested all game. Thinks he can run the show. His decision making is awful. When things don't go for him he strops.
Bergdich - 6 at least a bit of attacking intent when he came on McAleny n/a sponge foot is very harsh. Two weak shots from distance as none of the other players could be bothered to give him any other options. Vetokele n/a
The ref again was piss poor but there was absolutely no defence for the performance today - however their number 10 should've been sent off.
for those of you watching the match this evening your marks please and do try and keep to order of players below:
Pope - 5 Solly - 5 Fox - 4 Bauer - 7 Sarr - 5 - lost a lot of headers. Gudmundsson - 5 - needs to see more of the ball. Kashi - 6 BA- 2 - honestly one of the worst performances I have ever seen in a charlton shirt. Constantly gave away the ball. Cousins - 5 - was he playing on the left in the first half ? Because I couldn't tell Makienok - 5 Watt- 4 - can't do it all himself. Should have been taken off instead of Makienok.
Pope - 4 - How many more? Solly - 5 - meh. Fox - 4 - old foxy. Bauer - 5.5 - good in scattered parts. Sarr - 3.5 - woeful at the back, Miller wrecked him. Gudmundsson - 4.5 - Did t do anything, looked knackered at the end. Kashi - 5.5 - average. Ba - 5 - Cousins - 6 - better when in the middle 2nd half. Makienok - 5 - flick ons landed in open space and couldn't finish. Watt - 3 - gotta take the good with the bad I suppose.
Bergdich - 6 - Looked good at LB. McAleny n/a Vetokele n/a
Pope - 5 - Terrible for the goal, but have to accept he's still learning. Solly - 5 - Good going forward, appalling at the back Sarr - 3.5 - +1 for the goal. Embarrassing, consistently outpaced and beaten in the air by ISHMAEL MILLER. Say no more. Bauer - 7 - Didn't do much wrong at all , without being spectacular Fox - 5 - Average Gudmundsson - N/A - Did he play? Ba - 5 - Average, Gave it away a fair bit Kashi - 6 - Meh Cousins - 6 - Not a fecking winger Watt - 4 - Greedy bastard, stop running into players Makienok - 7.5 - Surprised by the opinions on here. I, as did everyone around me, thought he was good today. Won the majority of things and the things he didn't he was forcing their players into bad headers; in the right places too. No movement around him. Constant pain in the arse. Should have scored when he fluffed his lines though.
Pope - 4 from where I was sitting it looked like it would have been a very good save but generally his distribution is very poor and he doesn't command the defence
Solly - 5 I might have this wrong but I think his miss allowed them to release the ball and get it in for the first goal. Need to get tighter sometimes.
Fox - 4 not one of his better games, very little forwards movement and a few classic Fox errors.
Bauer - 6 did well but not quite as immaculate as we've seen him. Looked a bit rattled against some of their big men.
Sarr - 5 (+1 for goal) seemed ok but oddly seemed later in the game to be playing in midfield. Not a bad start.
Gudmonsson - 6 if only he had scored in the first 5 minutes, or not let Kashi take a free kick into the wall. Looked a bit short of options.
Kashi - 5 had some good work, liked him pulling the great time wasting lump off the floor but not quite as sharp as he has been
Ba - 4 too many wasted balls and a couple of wasted chances even if they were tricky
Cousins - 6 quite busy but not very effective especially when out on the left
Makienok - 4 really needs to get more flicks to a player and to get more of his chances on target. Defends well, attacks like a giraffe trying to sort his legs out. Is good at leaving the ball but that only works if the ball is then going to someone. Really should have scored at least twice.
Watt 4 disappointing game for watt. They closed him down pretty effectively and he lost the ball a heap of times trying to go through three players. Needs more than one trick (drop shoulder and shimmy through to goal). Needs someone there to help.
Bergdich 5 lot of skill sometimes and could be very good but still finding his feet a bit and also a net ball loser today
Overall a very disappointing game against a big but very ordinary side and we should be stuffing them.
Pope - 4 - Could have had a second mistake that led to a goal today but their striker was too slow off the mark. People go wild when he makes saves you would expect any Football league goalkeeper to make, and then make excuses for him when he makes absolutely piss poor mistakes. He is not good enough. I would like to see Mitov given a game. Solly - 5 - Whoever their winger was had him all game Fox - 5 - Was at fault for their first goal as much as Pope... Another mitigating factor is he has absolutely no one in front of him, Cousins does not play left mid when he is told to. Bauer - 7 - Solid Sarr - 4.5 - Plus .5 for the goal, he won next to nothing all game. Gudmundsson - 6 - Worked hard. Kashi - 6 - Extra point for his attitude, dragging their players up when they were on the floor etc, but some of his passing is really frustrating - he was leathering the ball at people when there was no need for it sometimes. Ba (Loving how people haven't noticed their mistakes and given Sarr 2 different marks!!!) - 4 - Not good enough, was infuriated again by his ridiculous shot. Cousins - 5 - I feel like he was selling Fox short a lot of the time. We know he doesn't want to play on the left but he really should have played a more left role, he was on the right more than the bloody left! Makienok - 6 - He should do better for a guy of his size, his game relies entirely on his size, he doesn't seem to have any of the hold up play or quality with the ball on his feet that *coughs* similar players in a similar role in the past might have had. Watt- 4 - Can I just say, I am happy that people don't have blinkered views on Tony watt just because of the goals he scored in the past, he is greedy, thinks he is the best player in the team by a country mile, and when he does try and pass, he is awful at it. I would have definitely taken him off rather than Makienok... Then again I probably would have brought someone other than Vetokele on.
Pope - 4 first goal through his arms that he didn't extend, dithers on playing it out and struggles to get down to shots Solly - 4.5 hoof, foul, hoof, hoof, moan. We need a cover right back to gee him up and remind him he's replaceable Fox - 4 RUN FORWARD FFS! Bauer - 6 best of a bad bunch of defenders, but outbeasted by Miller Sarr - 5 scored a goal, but nowhere near Diarras level, poor touch, average passing, crap positioning Gudmundsson - 5 kept cutting inside, shaping to shoot, then piddling the ball sideways, needs to try something different Kashi - 5 way too many poor passes, caught in possession too often too Ba - 4 Stop fecking shooting from 40 yards! First touch is appalling Cousins - 4.5 if your told to play left midfield, I don't care if you are a central midfielder, a left back, a striker, a bloody goalkeeper, you play left midfield for that game! Makienok - 5.5 unlucky with a couple of his chances, but must try harder to win headers and get on the end of crosses Watt- 3 ball hogging sweaty sock, lost it every time, should have been hauled off instead of Makienok and needs to learn quickly that no matter how often the crowd sing your name, they will soon stop if you don't play well. And TWWW didn't ring out once tonight.
Bergdich 6 tried to make things happen both on the wing and at left back McAleny n/a powderpuff Vetokele n/a fat bastard ain't he
Pope 3 Solly 5 Bauer 7 Sarr 3- horrendous . Why no Alou? Fox 3.5 - there's a 7 above on here; I can only assume Morgan's Dad.Awful in possession and partly to blame for goal 1
for those of you watching the match this evening your marks please and do try and keep to order of players below:
Pope - 6 Solly - 5 struggled Fox - 4 not his best at fault for first goal Bauer - 7 Sarr - 8 MOM tough start but coped well without any help from a poor ref Gudmunnson - 6 man marked Kashi - 6 man marked Ba - 6 Cousins - 5 Big S - 6 Watt- 3 Worst then Saturday
Bergditch - 7 McAleny 6 some nice touches and movement he will be ok Vetokele n/a
Can I just check, without being rude or anything, but you are definitely talking about tonight's game at the Valley against Huddersfield?
Pope - 4. Ok in crosses today but still too shaky Solly - 5. Up against a decent winger. Fox - 3. Poor. Terrible distribution and positioning. Bauer - 5.5 Not great but given more to do due to Sarr Sarr - 3. Bullied. Out of his depth. Gudmundsson - 4.5. Disappointing Kashi - 6 Always available but some poor passing Ba - 3.5 Never found a red shirt and shot from ridiculous distances Cousins - 6. Play him in CM. pushed us on but no support Makienok - 4 some decent flicks but nothing else Watt- 3.5 pass the ball please.
Bergdich - 4.5 tried but too late to make a difference McAleny n/a Vetokele n/a
Pope - 1 both goals his fault, parried another into danger and dropped crosses. Confidence shot. Solly - 5 Fox - 5 no help on the left, no options, defended well. Bauer - 5 defended well Sarr - 6.5 good passing and fought hard against Miller. Gudmundsson -5 not in the game enough, should have scored with the curler, with someone of his quality. Kashi - 6.5 best of a poor bunch tonight. Ba - 4.5 not good, poor shooting Cousins - 4.5 the worst game I've seen Jordan play. Makienok - 5 won a lot of headers, but no one on the end of them, unlike Millers flick ons. Poor miss before subbed. Watt - 3 not himself today, nothing went right. Bergdich - 5 tried to get some urgency in the game, poor miss, should have scored. McAlney looked calm on the ball, but his shooting was dire. Should have scored as well, take a touch and he's in.
Comments
Pope - 4
Solly - 5
Fox - 5
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 4.5
Kashi - 6
Bar - 4
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 5
Bergdich - 3
Pope - 4
Solly - 5
Fox - 4
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5.5
JBG - 5
Kashi - 5
Ba - 5
Cousins - 6
Makienok - 5
Watt- 3.5 (shite - he isn't a one man team)
Bergdich - 5 (better at left back)
McAleny 4 (Spongefoot MK2)
Vetokele 3 (FATokele)
Pope - 6
Solly - 6
Fox - 7
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 4
Gudmundsson - 5
Kashi - 5
Sarr - 6
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 4
Watt- 3
Bergdich - 5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Pope - 4.5
Solly - 6
Fox - 4
Bauer - 7
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 5.5
Kashi - 6
Ba - 5
Cousins - 4.5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 4
Bergdich - 6.5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 4
Fox - 4
Bauer - 5.5
Sarr - 5.5
JBG - 4.5
Kashi - 6
Ba - 5
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5.5
Watt - 3 (appalling, selfish, total crap)
Bergdich - 5
Solly - 6
Fox - 3
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 5
Kashi - 5
Ba - 4
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5.5
Watt- 4
Bergdich - 6
Solly - 4
Fox - 1
Bauer - 5
Sarr - 6
Gudmundsson - 4
Kashi - 4
Ba - 5
Cousins - 4
Makienok - 5.5
Watt- 2
Bergdich - 3
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 6
Fox - 5
Bauer - 7 mom
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6
Ba - 4
Cousins - 6 (5 first half, 7 second)
Makienok - 5
Watt- 5
Bergdich 6
Solly - 4
Fox - 4
Bauer -
Sarr - 5. No need to drop diara
Gudmundsson - 4
Kashi - 4
Sarr - 5
Cousins - 2 let's pretend he didn't play on the left again. Luzon is a fucking idiot for putting him there again. How many more cock managers are gonna do it.
Makienok - 5
Watt- 2 dog shit.
Bergdich - 4
McAleny n/a
Solly - 5
Fox - 4
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6.5
Ba - 4
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 3
Bergdich - 4
Pope - 6 shocking defending for the first goal but should've done a lot better with it. Second wasn't his fault. Not a lot else to do all game.
Solly - 5.5 weak and bullied
Fox - 4.5 weak and bullied
Bauer - 5 our defence were bullied throughout.
Sarr - 5 if it was his goal - well done. But I don't think he won a single header all game.
Gudmundsson - 5 still hungover from the party in Iceland.
Kashi - 6
Ba - 4 piss poor
Cousins - 6.5 our best player. The only player who was willing to carry the ball forward.
Makienok - 5.5 not many flick ons went anywhere - but not always his fault. Would never have taken him off
Watt- 3.5 disinterested all game. Thinks he can run the show. His decision making is awful. When things don't go for him he strops.
Bergdich - 6 at least a bit of attacking intent when he came on
McAleny n/a sponge foot is very harsh. Two weak shots from distance as none of the other players could be bothered to give him any other options.
Vetokele n/a
The ref again was piss poor but there was absolutely no defence for the performance today - however their number 10 should've been sent off.
Pope - 5
Solly - 5
Fox - 4
Bauer - 7
Sarr - 5 - lost a lot of headers.
Gudmundsson - 5 - needs to see more of the ball.
Kashi - 6
BA- 2 - honestly one of the worst performances I have ever seen in a charlton shirt. Constantly gave away the ball.
Cousins - 5 - was he playing on the left in the first half ? Because I couldn't tell
Makienok - 5
Watt- 4 - can't do it all himself. Should have been taken off instead of Makienok.
Bergdich - 5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 5 - meh.
Fox - 4 - old foxy.
Bauer - 5.5 - good in scattered parts.
Sarr - 3.5 - woeful at the back, Miller wrecked him.
Gudmundsson - 4.5 - Did t do anything, looked knackered at the end.
Kashi - 5.5 - average.
Ba - 5 -
Cousins - 6 - better when in the middle 2nd half.
Makienok - 5 - flick ons landed in open space and couldn't finish.
Watt - 3 - gotta take the good with the bad I suppose.
Bergdich - 6 - Looked good at LB.
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 5 - Good going forward, appalling at the back
Sarr - 3.5 - +1 for the goal. Embarrassing, consistently outpaced and beaten in the air by ISHMAEL MILLER. Say no more.
Bauer - 7 - Didn't do much wrong at all , without being spectacular
Fox - 5 - Average
Gudmundsson - N/A - Did he play?
Ba - 5 - Average, Gave it away a fair bit
Kashi - 6 - Meh
Cousins - 6 - Not a fecking winger
Watt - 4 - Greedy bastard, stop running into players
Makienok - 7.5 - Surprised by the opinions on here. I, as did everyone around me, thought he was good today. Won the majority of things and the things he didn't he was forcing their players into bad headers; in the right places too. No movement around him. Constant pain in the arse. Should have scored when he fluffed his lines though.
Solly - 5 I might have this wrong but I think his miss allowed them to release the ball and get it in for the first goal. Need to get tighter sometimes.
Fox - 4 not one of his better games, very little forwards movement and a few classic Fox errors.
Bauer - 6 did well but not quite as immaculate as we've seen him. Looked a bit rattled against some of their big men.
Sarr - 5 (+1 for goal) seemed ok but oddly seemed later in the game to be playing in midfield. Not a bad start.
Gudmonsson - 6 if only he had scored in the first 5 minutes, or not let Kashi take a free kick into the wall. Looked a bit short of options.
Kashi - 5 had some good work, liked him pulling the great time wasting lump off the floor but not quite as sharp as he has been
Ba - 4 too many wasted balls and a couple of wasted chances even if they were tricky
Cousins - 6 quite busy but not very effective especially when out on the left
Makienok - 4 really needs to get more flicks to a player and to get more of his chances on target. Defends well, attacks like a giraffe trying to sort his legs out. Is good at leaving the ball but that only works if the ball is then going to someone. Really should have scored at least twice.
Watt 4 disappointing game for watt. They closed him down pretty effectively and he lost the ball a heap of times trying to go through three players. Needs more than one trick (drop shoulder and shimmy through to goal). Needs someone there to help.
Bergdich 5 lot of skill sometimes and could be very good but still finding his feet a bit and also a net ball loser today
Overall a very disappointing game against a big but very ordinary side and we should be stuffing them.
Solly - 5 - Whoever their winger was had him all game
Fox - 5 - Was at fault for their first goal as much as Pope... Another mitigating factor is he has absolutely no one in front of him, Cousins does not play left mid when he is told to.
Bauer - 7 - Solid
Sarr - 4.5 - Plus .5 for the goal, he won next to nothing all game.
Gudmundsson - 6 - Worked hard.
Kashi - 6 - Extra point for his attitude, dragging their players up when they were on the floor etc, but some of his passing is really frustrating - he was leathering the ball at people when there was no need for it sometimes.
Ba (Loving how people haven't noticed their mistakes and given Sarr 2 different marks!!!) - 4 - Not good enough, was infuriated again by his ridiculous shot.
Cousins - 5 - I feel like he was selling Fox short a lot of the time. We know he doesn't want to play on the left but he really should have played a more left role, he was on the right more than the bloody left!
Makienok - 6 - He should do better for a guy of his size, his game relies entirely on his size, he doesn't seem to have any of the hold up play or quality with the ball on his feet that *coughs* similar players in a similar role in the past might have had.
Watt- 4 - Can I just say, I am happy that people don't have blinkered views on Tony watt just because of the goals he scored in the past, he is greedy, thinks he is the best player in the team by a country mile, and when he does try and pass, he is awful at it. I would have definitely taken him off rather than Makienok... Then again I probably would have brought someone other than Vetokele on.
Bergdich - 5 - Didn't really notice him.
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 4.5 hoof, foul, hoof, hoof, moan. We need a cover right back to gee him up and remind him he's replaceable
Fox - 4 RUN FORWARD FFS!
Bauer - 6 best of a bad bunch of defenders, but outbeasted by Miller
Sarr - 5 scored a goal, but nowhere near Diarras level, poor touch, average passing, crap positioning
Gudmundsson - 5 kept cutting inside, shaping to shoot, then piddling the ball sideways, needs to try something different
Kashi - 5 way too many poor passes, caught in possession too often too
Ba - 4 Stop fecking shooting from 40 yards! First touch is appalling
Cousins - 4.5 if your told to play left midfield, I don't care if you are a central midfielder, a left back, a striker, a bloody goalkeeper, you play left midfield for that game!
Makienok - 5.5 unlucky with a couple of his chances, but must try harder to win headers and get on the end of crosses
Watt- 3 ball hogging sweaty sock, lost it every time, should have been hauled off instead of Makienok and needs to learn quickly that no matter how often the crowd sing your name, they will soon stop if you don't play well. And TWWW didn't ring out once tonight.
Bergdich 6 tried to make things happen both on the wing and at left back
McAleny n/a powderpuff
Vetokele n/a fat bastard ain't he
Solly 6
Fox 5
Bauer 6
Sarr 6
Gudmundsson 6
Kashi 7
Ba 6
Cousins 6
Makienok 4
Watt 5
Bergdich 6
Solly 5
Bauer 7
Sarr 3- horrendous . Why no Alou?
Fox 3.5 - there's a 7 above on here; I can only assume Morgan's Dad.Awful in possession and partly to blame for goal 1
JBG 5
Kashi 5
BA 5
Cousins 5
Watt 3 - just dreadful
Maki 4.5
Worst display for some time
Solly - 5
Fox - 3.5
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6.5 MOM
Ba - 3
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 3
Bergdich - 6
Pope - 4. Ok in crosses today but still too shaky
Solly - 5. Up against a decent winger.
Fox - 3. Poor. Terrible distribution and positioning.
Bauer - 5.5 Not great but given more to do due to Sarr
Sarr - 3. Bullied. Out of his depth.
Gudmundsson - 4.5. Disappointing
Kashi - 6 Always available but some poor passing
Ba - 3.5 Never found a red shirt and shot from ridiculous distances
Cousins - 6. Play him in CM. pushed us on but no support
Makienok - 4 some decent flicks but nothing else
Watt- 3.5 pass the ball please.
Bergdich - 4.5 tried but too late to make a difference
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 5
Fox - 5 no help on the left, no options, defended well.
Bauer - 5 defended well
Sarr - 6.5 good passing and fought hard against Miller.
Gudmundsson -5 not in the game enough, should have scored with the curler, with someone of his quality.
Kashi - 6.5 best of a poor bunch tonight.
Ba - 4.5 not good, poor shooting
Cousins - 4.5 the worst game I've seen Jordan play.
Makienok - 5 won a lot of headers, but no one on the end of them, unlike Millers flick ons. Poor miss before subbed.
Watt - 3 not himself today, nothing went right.
Bergdich - 5 tried to get some urgency in the game, poor miss, should have scored.
McAlney looked calm on the ball, but his shooting was dire. Should have scored as well, take a touch and he's in.
Solly - 6
Fox - 4
Bauer - 6.5
Sarr - 6 extra point for the goal
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6
Ba - 5
Cousins - 5.5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 4.5
Bergdich - 6
Solly - 6
Fox - 5
Bauer - 7
Sarr - 6
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6
Ba - 5
Cousins - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt- 5
Bergdich - 5
Solly - 6
Fox - 6
Bauer - 7.5
Sarr - 7
Gudmundsson - 6.5
Kashi - 7.5
Ba - 5.5
Cousins - 6.5
Makienok - 5.5
Watt - 5
Bergdich - 5.5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 6
Fox - 5
Bauer - 5
Sarr - 5
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 7
Ba - 4
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 5
Watt- 4.5
Bergdich - 4.5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a
Solly - 5
Fox - 5
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 6
Gudmundsson - 6
Kashi - 6
Ba - 5
Cousins - 5
Makienok - 6
Watt- 5
Bergdich - 5
McAleny n/a
Vetokele n/a