Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Norwich

135

Comments

  • cafc-west said:

    colin1961 said:

    Dmitrovic 7 pretty steady no chance with both goals,
    Solly 3 the whole game was awful, struggling at this level at fault for first goal
    Wiggins 3 Same as Solly either full back just cant stop the crosses coming in
    Bikey 7 Done a lot of work spent to much time covering at full back , looked knacked at the end
    Ben Haim7 Same to much time spent covering full back mistakes
    Gudmundsson 6 needs to move central some good touches but not enough of the ball
    Buyens 6 worked his socks off had no help in mid
    Jackson 3 at least Luzon made the right call to take him off, should have been earlier.
    Cousins 6 missed a simple header early on but gives his all but something missing ?
    Bulot 6 Should not have gone off, needed to see more of the ball
    Vetokele 7 worked hard , like Bulot first half needed the ball
    Watt 8 MOM Changed the game.
    Harriott 6 very little from Harriott

    overall a harsh result we deserved a point

    Solly made a few errors - but 3! Bikey 7! - Jeez. Jackson 3! You need to visit Specsavers. And after all your comments you say we deserved a point!! And - to top it all - you start that other stupid threat...Unbelievable.
    My sentiments exactly!! I'll take a couple of pairs of those glasses please @colin1961 and come round yours at Xmas to milk some of that generosity. Bikey and Ben Haim 7's!!?? And I must have missed the bit where Buyens 'worked his socks off' - or was that in changing room after??
    Agree. please start attending games.


  • Dmitrovic 5 will be glad when Henderson is back
    Solly 5 terrible 1st half, better in the 2nd
    Wiggins 4.5 very vulnerable to the ball over his left shoulder
    Bikey 4 way overdue being dropped
    Ben Haim 6 steady but not as commanding as normal
    Gudmundsson 6 heavily marked
    Buyens 4.5 ineffective
    Jackson 5.5 similar to Buyens but a bit more work
    Cousins 7 worked hard on the left and won the ball in the centre. Distribution will improve if he's kept in the middle and has a good partner alongside him.
    Bulot 6 I thought he was ok in the 1st half but too lightweight
    Vetokele 7 worked hard throughout and showed, when fed early, he and Watt could do damage
    Watt 8 made a real difference.
    Harriott 6.5 did well in the build up to Vetokele's goal.


  • Dmitrovic 6 flaky
    Solly 5 see above
    Wiggins 5 see above
    Bikey 6 slow and they targeted that
    Ben Haim 6 some bad decisions
    Gudmundsson 6 not his best night
    Buyens 5 ineffective, but did try
    Jackson 3 this surely has to be the last time he starts
    Cousins 7 tried hard, a few misplaced passes, linked up well in the break for the second goal
    Bulot 6 defended from the front, offered nothing going forward
    Vetokele 7 defended from the front, took his goal well
    Watt 8 class finish
    Harriott 7 lively, played his part in Vetokele's goal
  • cafc-west said:

    colin1961 said:

    Dmitrovic 7 pretty steady no chance with both goals,
    Solly 3 the whole game was awful, struggling at this level at fault for first goal
    Wiggins 3 Same as Solly either full back just cant stop the crosses coming in
    Bikey 7 Done a lot of work spent to much time covering at full back , looked knacked at the end
    Ben Haim7 Same to much time spent covering full back mistakes
    Gudmundsson 6 needs to move central some good touches but not enough of the ball
    Buyens 6 worked his socks off had no help in mid
    Jackson 3 at least Luzon made the right call to take him off, should have been earlier.
    Cousins 6 missed a simple header early on but gives his all but something missing ?
    Bulot 6 Should not have gone off, needed to see more of the ball
    Vetokele 7 worked hard , like Bulot first half needed the ball
    Watt 8 MOM Changed the game.
    Harriott 6 very little from Harriott

    overall a harsh result we deserved a point

    Solly made a few errors - but 3! Bikey 7! - Jeez. Jackson 3! You need to visit Specsavers. And after all your comments you say we deserved a point!! And - to top it all - you start that other stupid threat...Unbelievable.
    Colin, these scores sum you up, your transfer rumours and your ratings are absolute rubbish...

  • Nicholas said:

    Dmitrovic 3 catch the ball you helmet
    Solly 4 crap
    Wiggins 2 dog shit
    Bikey 1.5 calamity of a player
    Ben Haim 2 lazy cock
    Gudmundsson 3.5
    Buyens 1.5 fuckoff
    Jackson 2
    Cousins 2 passing is dog shit
    Bulot 1 piss off
    Vetokele 6 done ok with a decent striker next to him
    Watt 6 see igor
    Harriott 1.5 do one

    If you cant say anything nice, ...
  • Stewart said:


    Dmitrovic - 3
    Solly - fucked up for the first goal - 3
    Wiggins - he was good, not anymore - 3
    Bikey - good for the first 10 games, has he got bored at charlton already? - 3
    Ben Haim - 5
    Gudmundsson - 3
    Buyens - Richard Murray said he was " something special" he's not. - 2
    Jackson - 3
    Cousins - 5
    Bulot - please go - 2
    Vetokele - he isn't that good - 3
    Watt - 3
    Harriott - 2

    It's very harsh of you to give everyone a minus score.
  • Dmitrovic at fault for 2nd goal, did not command the box. 4
    Solly 4 at fault for the 1st goal
    Wiggins 4 got beat to often.
    Bikey headless chicken 3
    Ben Haim 4 did not cope with the high ball
    Gudmundsson 4
    Buyens 4
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 5
    Bulot 3 to light weight.
    Vetokele 5 gets a point for the goal.
    Watt 6 injected energy and scored.
    Harriott 5 ok
    Flag
  • Dmitrovic 6 - No real chance with the goals (even the 2nd where he was damned if he did come out, and damned if he didn't..); unusually flappy though
    Solly 4 - Poor game throughout; gifted them the first goal through sloppy play
    Wiggins 5.5 - Lots of effort and dealt with Redmond quite well, but always on the back foot
    Bikey 5.5 - Did reasonably well until running out of steam a bit toward the end
    Ben Haim 6 - Not at his best, some sloppy passing
    Gudmundsson 6.5 - Tried hard but was closed down continually
    Buyens 5.5 - Better game but struggled when covering Jackson
    Jackson 3.5 - Off the pace, always behind play, not good enough
    Cousins 7 - All effort and the one shining light; booking was a joke!
    Bulot 4 - Just did not seem to fit in or know where he was meant to play
    Vetokele 6 - You can't fault the effort - ran himself to the ground; nice finish for his goal
    Watt 7.5 - Made a huge difference; when will someone pick him to start with Igor??? Terrific finish for his goal
    Harriott 6 - Tried hard and set up second goal

  • Vetokele - 5.5 - Better in 2nd half, but does appear lazy at times.

    He chased and harried all game, what more do you want from him when we can't provide him with any service?
  • Dmitrovic 5
    Solly 4.5
    Wiggins 5
    Bikey 3.5
    Ben Haim 4.5
    Gudmundsson 5
    Buyens 3.5
    Jackson 4.5
    Cousins 5
    Bulot 4
    Vetokele 6
    Watt 6
    Harriott 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Dmitrovic 4 Clown, just catch it you twat
    Solly 5 Not a great game
    Wiggins 4 Poor
    Bikey 2 words fail me, talk about Hero to Zero
    Ben Haim 5 At least he has a bit of passion, most of it mis placed
    Gudmundsson 4 Anonymous most of the match
    Buyens 3 Couldn't give a shit
    Jackson 4 Way off the pace
    Cousins 5 Gave it a go, surprise surprise played better when he came in to the middle, still way to many misplaced passes
    Bulot 1 No Comment
    Vetokele 5 Mark for goal, would like to see him start with Watt
    Watt 6 Ditto above
    Harriott 5 Things got better when he came on, more down to the sensible formation change rather than Callum himself.

    Luzon 2 Credit for the subs, starting formation and line up a complete joke. This crouching thing? Mate the ground won't open up and swallow no matter how low you get, just fuck off.
  • I think most of the people marking must have left at half time

    Dmitrovic 5 needs to catch more, played his part in the second goal
    Solly 5 robbed for first goal, didn't do much going forward
    Bikey 5 shaky for last two goals but dug himself out of a hole a few times
    Ben Haim 6 did ok
    Wiggins 5 had some bad moments but kept going
    Gudmundsson 5.5 Not a great game but showed the odd touch of class
    Buyens 6 Thought he was more combative than usual and perked up in the second half alongside everyone else
    Jackson 4 He goes off and we start to resemble a football team. Happened a few times this season. Nothing against him but this is getting fairly conclusive. Off the pace and only good for the occasional tackle.
    Cousins 8 MOM Enormous final half hour in the middle where he belongs
    Bulot 3.5 Out of position and it showed
    Vetokele 7.5 Strove hard and got some reward despite a few blind alleys
    Watt 8 Looked sharp and took it to them
    Harriott 7.5 His mere presence changed the game. Not his biggest fan - nobody is - but he really wanted it and some of his stuff came off
  • Dmitrovic 6
    Solly 5.5
    Wiggins 5.5
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 6.5
    Gudmundsson 6
    Buyens 5
    Jackson 5.5
    Cousins 6
    Bulot 5
    Vetokele 6.5
    Watt 6.5
    Harriott 6


  • Dmitrovic 5
    Solly 5
    Wiggins 5
    Bikey 4 Can't believe how this guy has gone from looking a decent signing at the start of the season to what he is now!
    Ben Haim 5.5
    Gudmundsson 5.5
    Buyens 5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Bulot 4
    Vetokele 6
    Watt 6
    Harriott 4
  • Dmitrovic 1
    Solly 4
    Wiggins 3
    Bikey 1
    Ben Haim 6
    Gudmundsson 6
    Buyens 1
    Jackson 3
    Cousins 7.5
    Bulot 1
    Vetokele 6
    Watt 7.5
    Harriott 7
  • Dmitrovic - 6
    Solly - 5.5
    Wiggins - 5.5
    Bikey - 4
    Ben Haim - 6
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Buyens - 5
    Jackson - 5
    Cousins - 7
    Bulot - 5
    Vetokele - 7
    Watt - 7.5
    Harriott - 5.5
  • Dmitrovic 3 - can't - won't - catch so giving an already fragile defence kittens.
    Solly 4
    Wiggins 4
    Bikey 3 - lumbering hit and miss, mainly miss
    Ben Haim 5
    Gudmundsson 4
    Buyens 4
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 6
    Bulot 4
    Vetokele 6 ran around a lot, largely chasing shadows but still ...
    Watt 7 - made the difference when he came on but by then we were two down!
    Harriott 5
  • After sleeping on last nights performance...

    Dmitrovic - 5 ... Granted he's European so will punch rather than catch but needs to get distance on them as they're going straight back into the danger zone.
    Solly - 5.5 ... At fault for the first goal
    Wiggins - 5 ... Terrorised by Nathan Redmond who should be playing @ Premier League level
    Bikey - 5 ... Seems to have lost his aerial ability
    Ben Haim - 6 ... Not his best game but tried to bring it out of Defence at times
    Gudmundsson - 5 ... Ineffective tonight but we cant solely rely on him
    Buyens - 5
    Jackson - 5.5
    Cousins - 7 (MOTM) ... Lad doesnt give up, you could clearly see him trying to motivate the players prior to Kick-Off after it went 3-2
    Bulot - 5 ... He tried, did well trying to close down but what could do with no service to feet?
    Vetokele - 6 ... The same with Bulot, he needs service to feet, hopefully his goal will give him much needed confidence

    Watt - 7 ... Caused problems for Norwich and linked up well with Igor
    Harriott - 5 ... Showed flashes and gave the side a bit more balance but lost the ball leaving Wiggins exposed and allowed Norwich to break and almost score
  • Sorry LL but reading some of the marks on here tonight just confirms for me why I don't post my own marks.

    That is a very high handed remark and rather supercilious
    Also, I don't understand what others' marks have to do with one's own.
  • edited February 2015
    Dmitrovic 6
    Solly 5
    Wiggins 5
    Bikey 4
    Ben Haim 7
    Gudmundsson 5
    Buyens 4
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 6
    Bulot 6
    Vetokele 7 (incl +1 for a goal)
    Watt 8 (incl + 1 for a goal - he doesn't seem to have let the "troubles" or not starting affect him too much)
    Harriott 5 (not on long enough to do much wrong)
  • Sponsored links:


  • Dmitrovic - 5.5
    Solly- 6
    Wiggins- 6
    Bikey - 5
    Ben Haim - 5
    Gudmundsson - 6.5
    Buyens - 5.5
    Jackson - 6
    Cousins - 8
    Bulot - 5
    Vetokele - 7
    Watt - 7
    Harriott - 6.5
  • edited February 2015
    Dmitrovic 6 Looked shaky which perhaps impacted on the rest of the back 4

    Solly 6 Rare mistake and not his normal self. Two games close together may have taken their toll

    Wiggins 6 Redmond and Johnson were no mugs and he stuck at it despite struggling at times

    Bikey 5 Seems a shadow of the beast he once was

    Ben Haim 6 Competent. No more than that

    Gudmundsson 5 Very disappointing and bottled tackles which is criminal.

    Buyens 5 Not great but not as bad as some are saying

    Jackson 5 Tried but clearly not match fit after his lay off

    Cousins 7.5 This boy is 20 but put his seniors to shame covering every blade of grass. Yes he misplaced a few passes but only because he refused to hide and ran his wotsits off. Next season he will almost certainly go to a club where the fans appreciate him more's the pity. Charlton need players like him.

    Bulot 5 Not great but at least tried to support Vetokele

    Vetokele 7 Thankless task on his own up top in the first half. Linked well with Harriott and Watt during our good spell

    Watt 7 Grew into the game and took his goal with aplomb

    Harriott 7 His pace running at the defence changed the game and gave us half a chance. Another 20 year old boy unappreciated by many of his own fans.
  • Dmitrovic - 5, did okay except for the two punches. Positive in coming out.
    Solly - 5, both full backs under a lot of pressure on the ball and struggled.
    Bikey - 4, sluggish and dreadful distribution
    Ben Haim - 5, poor but better than Bikey
    Wiggins - 4.5, looked like they targeted, struggled with his matchup with Redmond
    Gundmundsson - 5.5, unable to produce much
    Cousins - 6.5, hardest worker and played well considering the performances of his colleagues
    Buyens - 4, drifts and let's his man go too much for a CM, didn't back it up by being 'classy'
    Jackson - 5.5, though he did alright, tackled well
    Vetokele - 6, stranded first half, worked hard and deserved his goal
    Bulot - 3, can't say that I noticed him actually do anything (except once or twice when I got him mixed up with Cousins)

    Watt - 7, somehow got us back in the game, him coming on was a turning point
    Harriott - 6.5, looked lively/tried, created a couple of chances and made an impact. Losing possession is part of his game though (didn't matter today because if he didn't, someone else would)
  • Dmitrovic 4
    Solly 5
    Wiggins 4
    Bikey 4
    Ben Haim 6
    Gudmundsson 4
    Buyens 4
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 7
    Bulot 5
    Vetokele 6.5
    Watt 6
    Harriott 5
  • Sorry LL but reading some of the marks on here tonight just confirms for me why I don't post my own marks.

    For those of us who dont understand who is in whose gang on here, please explain?
  • Dmitrovic - 5.5
    Solly - 4.5
    Wiggins - 4.5
    Bikey - 4.5
    Ben Haim - 5
    Gudmundsson - 5
    Buyens - 4.5
    Jackson - 4
    Cousins - 6.5
    Bulot - 4
    Vetokele - 6
    Watt - 6.5
    Harriott - 5
  • Dmitrovic - 6 couple of flaps under pressure and one duff punch. Positionally decent and kicking decent. 2nd goal he had a split second decision to make and it was a very good finish. If Bikey hadn't been out of position the keeper wouldn't have had to make the decision.
    Solly - 5.5 at fault for the first and not his finest hour. For those saying he is finished at this level - you are idiots. How many off-days has Solly ever had!
    Wiggins - 5 may have been pissed or on drugs. Currently unable to trap a bag of cement. Still offers more than Fox.
    Bikey - 5 believes his own hype. When he joined he wanted to prove he was worthy. Now has a God complex and is playing awfully
    Ben Haim - 6 apart from his distribution he is vital to our shambolic defence. Without him I dread to think where we'd be.
    Gudmundsson - 6 - needs better players around him to shine. an artist in a midfield of dog toffee
    Buyens - 4 pants. pedestrian. bottle job. booked again.
    Jackson - 4 copy and paste from previous - slow, off the pace, game passed him by. heard he's off to Hudds with Wilson.
    Cousins - 7 - shining light. play him in the middle and his energy will give the midfield a lift.
    Bulot - 4 runs like he is drying his nails. played fairly similar too. not what is needed in a scrap
    Vetokele - 7 better. lovely assist. needs a partner - Watt is that man.
    Watt - 7.5 made the difference. created the first with a dynamic run. Him and Igor looked good together
    Harriott - 6 better than usual - actually applied a bit of brain.

    Fans - 0
    "Getting sacked in the morning" - you should be ashamed of yourselves.

    Luzon 6
    I actually agreed with 4-5-1 to start as Norwich are absolutely flying and he wanted to keep it tight. Made the right subs for the situation and nearly got a point. 4-4-2 is the way to proceed. Cousins at the base of the pyramid, JBG supporting the strikers. Just need 2 hard working wingers who can get up and down.
  • Dmitrovic - 5
    Solly - 5
    Wiggins - 5
    Bikey 3
    Ben Haim 4
    Gudmundsson - 5
    Buyens - 3
    Jackson - 3
    Cousins -3
    Bulot -3
    Vetokele -6
    Watt - 6
    Harriott - 6
  • Dmitrovic - 4.5 (2nd goal was partly his fault, he was caught in no mans land - catch the ball lad!)
    Solly - 5.5 (Lost possession too cheaply, defended very well)
    Wiggins - 5.5 (Had a decent game against Redmond)
    Bikey - 3 (Woeful - tries to act like the hard man, just make a tackle and pass the ball on you pleb)
    Ben Haim - 4.5 (Made some important challenges - can't be easy playing next to a clown)
    Gudmundsson - 4.5 (Tidy player, didn't do much)
    Buyens - 4.5 (Didn't really see much of him)
    Jackson - 4.5 (Same as Buyons)
    Cousins - 6 (Tried hard, never gave up but still can't pass a ball further than 3 yards)
    Bulot - 5.5 (I though he looked lively in the first half and tried to make things happen)
    Vetokele - 5 (Scored but didn't really do much else - horrible first touch when he was through in the first half too)
    Watt - 6.5 (Looks a very good player)
    Harriott - 5.5 (Tidy passes, tried to run at Whitaker when he could)
  • Big_Bob said:



    Wiggins - 5

    Cousins -3

    I know it's all about opinions but I am surprised by these marks.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!