Etheridge 6 Wilson 3 Bikey 6 Ben Haim 6 Fox 2.5 Gudmundsson 6 Buyens 5 Jackson 2.5 done so well chasing shadows. Missed him big time. Cousins 3. Well done Bob you keep playing him there, amazing stuff Church 6 Tucudean 5 Ahearne Grant 5
Etheridge - 6 Wilson - 4 - love the guy but poor today Bikey - 5 Ben Haim - 5 Fox - 4 Gudmundsson - 6.5 Buyens - 4 Jackson - 4.5 Cousins - 5 Church - 6 Tucudean - 5.5 Ahearne Grant - 5
Etheridge - 6 Wilson - 4.5 not his best game Bikey - 4 liability Ben Haim - 5 Fox - 5 Gudmundsson - 6 Buyens - 3.5 Jackson - 4 Cousins - 4.5 Church - 5.5 Tucudean - 6.5 in the land of the blind the one eyed man is King. Ahearne Grant - 5
Etheridge 6.5 - No chance with goals; let down by defence time and again... Wilson 4 - Not at the races; offered little Bikey 6.5 - Tried hard but not his best game Ben Haim 7.5 - Only player that seemed to really want it Fox 4.5 - Some decent tackles but awful passing, and where was he for the winer??? Gudmundsson 8 - Great goal and our only threat Buyens 7 - Doing loads of work and getting no support; silly second booking though Jackson 4 - Two yards too slow, in every direction Cousins 5 - Dealt with Marshall quite well but poor passing/decision making when in possession Church 6 - Ran his heart out until cramp caught up with him Tucudean 5.5 - Some good touches but not really enough Ahearne Grant 6 - Was shifted from up front, to out left, to right midfield, getting worse as he went
I think Bob tried his best today, and I loved the fact that the bench was all youngsters, but that just highlights how skinny our squad is.
Etheridge 6 solid Wilson 4 in his defence I would say that Gudmundsson gave him little help. But he was poor nonetheless. Bikey 5 lax Ben Haim 7 how long before he gets fed up with those around him Fox 5 limited Gudmundsson 7 would have been more but weak defensively Buyens 5 stupid second yellow Jackson 5 tried hard but not imposing Cousins 5 time to stop this left wing nonsense Bob Church 6.5 good runs in 1st half but faded Tucudean 6.5 as per Church Ahearne Grant 6 one or two promising moments
Etheridge 6 Wilson 4 Bikey 5 Ben Haim 5 Fox 4 Gundmundsson 7 Buyens 4 Jackson 4 Cousins 5 Church 5 Tucedean 5 Ahearne Grant 5 Gomez n/a Pigott n/a I think I have generally been generous
Etheridge 6 Wilson 4.5 Bikey 3 = this must be the worst performance by a Charlton centre half I have seen for a very long time Ben haim 5.5 Fox 6 Gudmundsson 7 Buyens 6 Jackson 6 Cousins 5.5 Church 6.6 Tucudean 6 Ahearne Grant 6 Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Etheridge 5 Wilson 5 Bikey 5 Ben haim 6 Fox 5 Gudmundsson 7 hope he isn't injured as we need him in the middle Buyens 3 Jackson 2 don't think it is even a debate anymore. Cousins 4 play him in the middle Church 5 Tucudean 6 Ahearne Grant 5
Etheridge 6 - ok Wilson 5.5 - not very good Bikey 5.5 -sluggish Ben Haim 6.5 - class above Fox 5.5 - defending ok, needs to concentrate on not misplacing passes, not good when past the half way line Gudmundsson 7 - great free kick Buyens 4 - 2 unnecessary and idiotic bookings resulting in cheap sending off Jackson 6 - average Cousins 5.5 - not up to much Church 5.5 - better in first half - ran about like he does Tucudean 5.5 better in first half - a few good bits of link up play Ahearne Grant 5.5 - good start then faded Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Note to RD - The match day entertainment would be improved if there is a competitive championship quality level squad and not a league one level squad at present. Not remotely good enough.
Etheridge - 6 Annoyingly tried to kick ball out to touch when Church was injured but instead kicked it to the centre circle. From the resulting bounce up they attack and score. Wilson - 5 Poor when going forward. Bikey - 6 not as steady as earlier season performances. Ben Haim - 7 as usual steady with some forays in opposition half. Fox - 3 poor passing, poor crossing, poor marking for first goal. Gudmundsson - 8 best player by a mile which included a sweet free kick. Buyens - 4 Looked off the pace and stupid second yellow when done by Marshall. Jackson - 6 infective. Cousins - 6 looked lightweight and some poor passing. Church - 6 did ok but having to run down wings when not a winger. Tucudean - 6 some nice ball control but no service. Ahearne Grant - 6 showed a glimpse of what he can do when he came on. Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Etheridge 7 (Some decent saves, in particular the one when he was sprawled on the deck, but distribution not great today) Wilson 4 (Murdered by their left sided players in the first few minutes, and awful going forward) Bikey 5 (Nowhere near as imposing as earlier in the season) Ben Haim 7 (Reliable) Fox 5 (Curate's egg of a game, some good stuff, but easily beaten for their first goal) Gudmundsson 7 (MoM, our only effective midfielder today) Buyens 3 (Can he actually tackle cleanly?) Jackson 4 (Echo the thoughts of others, looks well past his best) Cousins 5 (Admire his stamina but his ball work today was poor) Church 6 (Energy, pace, but little threat) Tucudean 6 (Not the answer) Ahearne Grant 5 (Promising)
Etheridge 7 - solid and steady Wilson 6 - looked like a player short of match practice Bikey 6 - Love the guy, but is going backwards, started the season as good but complacent, now becoming poor Ben Haim - 7 Played well Fox 6 - Defends well but no forward ball Gudmundsson - 7 great free kick Buyens 6 - more and more frustrating and now absent against Brighton Jackson 7 - busy without being spectacular Cousins 7.5 Church 7 - Lots of energy and very lively Tucudean 6.5 - He's got something, justy not sure what Ahearne Grant - 6.5 Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Etheridge - 5 Not Championship level. (Rumour has it we've signed a Serbian keeper from the network). Wilson - 5 Heard he is about to leave as not rated by Bob! Bikey - 4 After a good season he is becoming a joke. Morro far better in my opinion but Roly doesn't seem to like British players! Ben Haim - 6 Some glimpses of class, but doesn't seem interested! Fox - 4 Not up to this level, perhaps a loan to Div 2 will help! Gudmundsson - 6.5 The only one with any guts, probably about to be sold to a better team! Buyens - 6 Only here on loan and that shows with his poor tackling decisions. Jackson - 4 Sadly passed it, perhaps will be a better player/coach. Cousins - 5 Not one of his best games. Church - 5 No end product. Tucudean - 5 After flattering against Cardiff back to normal falling over. Ahearne Grant n/a Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Not even certain that we are going to get Tony Watt now (Bob hopes to sign him - he was on the pitch before game - surely you know if he is coming here for F's sake). Blackburn embarrased us today, playing keep ball when we were down to 10 men! Shame on the players for such a piss poor effort!
Etheridge 5.5 Wilson 4 Bikey 3.5 CB's got bullied today Ben Haim 4 Fox dreadful Gudmundsson 6 for the goal Buyens 4 Jackson 4 Cousins 4 Church 5 Tucudean 4 Ahearne Grant 4 Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Etheridge - 6 He's an average keeper who could do nothing with the goals. Wilson - 4 Couldn't be bothered to stop the cross for goal no.1. Did himself no favours. Bikey - 4 Two headers in 90 mins? Ben Haim - 6 Unfair to say he wasn't interested. He spent most of his afternoon covering Bikey. Fox - 5 More for effort than attainment. Rabbit caught in headlights and not aggressive enough to be a defender. Gudmundson - 5.5 Good goal. Other set plays were appalling. Four times running he hit their first man. Chased shadows. Buyens - 5 Dozey bastard. Did enough running but didn't tackle. Missed our only chance. Jackson - 4 One burst into the box in the second half. Passenger. Cousins - 4 Pasenger. Church - 6 Had a go and was hauled down when he'd done the bloke out on the left. Tucudean - 6 Had a go. Zero service. Ahearne Grant - 6 Had a go. Ended up in midfield. Poor sod. Needs a loan somewhere like Wimbledon. Gomez n/a Pigott n/a
Don't agree with all this slaughtering of Fox. His defending was ok. Some misplaced passes and not great going forward but not the reason for the defeat. Apologies to all for putting point of view on scores thread.
Comments
Etheridge 6
Wilson 4
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 5
Fox 4.5
Gudmundsson 6
Buyens 5
Jackson 5
Cousins 5
Church 5
Tucudean 4.5
Ahearne Grant 5
Wilson 3
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 6
Fox 2.5
Gudmundsson 6
Buyens 5
Jackson 2.5 done so well chasing shadows. Missed him big time.
Cousins 3. Well done Bob you keep playing him there, amazing stuff
Church 6
Tucudean 5
Ahearne Grant 5
Bob 2.
Urgency at the end was fantastic.
Wilson 4
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 6
Fox 7
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 6
Jackson 5
Cousins 4
Church 7
Tucudean 7
Ahearne Grant 5
Wilson - 4 - love the guy but poor today
Bikey - 5
Ben Haim - 5
Fox - 4
Gudmundsson - 6.5
Buyens - 4
Jackson - 4.5
Cousins - 5
Church - 6
Tucudean - 5.5
Ahearne Grant - 5
Wilson - 4.5 not his best game
Bikey - 4 liability
Ben Haim - 5
Fox - 5
Gudmundsson - 6
Buyens - 3.5
Jackson - 4
Cousins - 4.5
Church - 5.5
Tucudean - 6.5 in the land of the blind the one eyed man is King.
Ahearne Grant - 5
Wilson 4.5
Bikey 5.5
Ben Haim 6.5
Fox 6.5
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 6
Jackson 5
Cousins 5
Church 6.5
Tucudean 6.5
Ahearne Grant 5.5
Wilson 4
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 6.5
Fox 3
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 4
Jackson 4
Cousins 5
Church 6
Tucudean 6.5
Ahearne Grant 5
Wilson 4 - Not at the races; offered little
Bikey 6.5 - Tried hard but not his best game
Ben Haim 7.5 - Only player that seemed to really want it
Fox 4.5 - Some decent tackles but awful passing, and where was he for the winer???
Gudmundsson 8 - Great goal and our only threat
Buyens 7 - Doing loads of work and getting no support; silly second booking though
Jackson 4 - Two yards too slow, in every direction
Cousins 5 - Dealt with Marshall quite well but poor passing/decision making when in possession
Church 6 - Ran his heart out until cramp caught up with him
Tucudean 5.5 - Some good touches but not really enough
Ahearne Grant 6 - Was shifted from up front, to out left, to right midfield, getting worse as he went
I think Bob tried his best today, and I loved the fact that the bench was all youngsters, but that just highlights how skinny our squad is.
Wilson 4.5
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 6
Fox 6
Gudmundsson 6.5
Buyens 4
Jackson 5
Cousins 4.5
Church 5
Tucudean 4
Ahearne Grant 6.5
Wilson 4
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 6.5
Fox 4.5
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 5.5
Jackson 5
Cousins 5.5
Church 6
Tucudean 5
Ahearne Grant 5.5
Wilson 5
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 6
Fox 5
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 4
Jackson 4
Cousins 5.5
Church 5
Tucudean 7
Ahearne Grant 5
Etheridge 7
Wilson 5
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 7
Fox 5
Gudmundsson 6
Buyens 5
Jackson 6
Cousins 5
Church 6
Tucudean 6
Ahearne Grant 5
Generally as bad as I've seen those players, this season anyway
Wilson 4 in his defence I would say that Gudmundsson gave him little help. But he was poor nonetheless.
Bikey 5 lax
Ben Haim 7 how long before he gets fed up with those around him
Fox 5 limited
Gudmundsson 7 would have been more but weak defensively
Buyens 5 stupid second yellow
Jackson 5 tried hard but not imposing
Cousins 5 time to stop this left wing nonsense Bob
Church 6.5 good runs in 1st half but faded
Tucudean 6.5 as per Church
Ahearne Grant 6 one or two promising moments
Etheridge 6
Wilson 4
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 5
Fox 4
Gundmundsson 7
Buyens 4
Jackson 4
Cousins 5
Church 5
Tucedean 5
Ahearne Grant 5
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
I think I have generally been generous
Etheridge 5
Wilson 5
Bikey 5
Ben haim 6
Fox 4
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 4
Jackson 4
Cousins 3
Church 6
Tucudean 6
Ahearne Grant 6
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson 4.5
Bikey 3 = this must be the worst performance by a Charlton centre half I have seen for a very long time
Ben haim 5.5
Fox 6
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 6
Jackson 6
Cousins 5.5
Church 6.6
Tucudean 6
Ahearne Grant 6
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson 5
Bikey 5
Ben haim 6
Fox 5
Gudmundsson 7 hope he isn't injured as we need him in the middle
Buyens 3
Jackson 2 don't think it is even a debate anymore.
Cousins 4 play him in the middle
Church 5
Tucudean 6
Ahearne Grant 5
Etheridge 6
Wilson 4
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 6
Fox 6
Gudmundsson 7 mom
Buyens 5
Jackson 4
Cousins 4
Church 5
Tucudean 5
Ahearne Grant 6
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson 5.5 - not very good
Bikey 5.5 -sluggish
Ben Haim 6.5 - class above
Fox 5.5 - defending ok, needs to concentrate on not misplacing passes, not good when past the half way line
Gudmundsson 7 - great free kick
Buyens 4 - 2 unnecessary and idiotic bookings resulting in cheap sending off
Jackson 6 - average
Cousins 5.5 - not up to much
Church 5.5 - better in first half - ran about like he does
Tucudean 5.5 better in first half - a few good bits of link up play
Ahearne Grant 5.5 - good start then faded
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Note to RD - The match day entertainment would be improved if there is a competitive championship quality level squad and not a league one level squad at present. Not remotely good enough.
Wilson - 5 Poor when going forward.
Bikey - 6 not as steady as earlier season performances.
Ben Haim - 7 as usual steady with some forays in opposition half.
Fox - 3 poor passing, poor crossing, poor marking for first goal.
Gudmundsson - 8 best player by a mile which included a sweet free kick.
Buyens - 4 Looked off the pace and stupid second yellow when done by Marshall.
Jackson - 6 infective.
Cousins - 6 looked lightweight and some poor passing.
Church - 6 did ok but having to run down wings when not a winger.
Tucudean - 6 some nice ball control but no service.
Ahearne Grant - 6 showed a glimpse of what he can do when he came on.
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson 4.5
Bikey 4
Ben Haim 7.5
Fox 4.5
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 6
Jackson 6
Cousins 5.5
Church 6.5
Tucudean 6.5
Ahearne Grant 6
Wilson 4 (Murdered by their left sided players in the first few minutes, and awful going forward)
Bikey 5 (Nowhere near as imposing as earlier in the season)
Ben Haim 7 (Reliable)
Fox 5 (Curate's egg of a game, some good stuff, but easily beaten for their first goal)
Gudmundsson 7 (MoM, our only effective midfielder today)
Buyens 3 (Can he actually tackle cleanly?)
Jackson 4 (Echo the thoughts of others, looks well past his best)
Cousins 5 (Admire his stamina but his ball work today was poor)
Church 6 (Energy, pace, but little threat)
Tucudean 6 (Not the answer)
Ahearne Grant 5 (Promising)
Wilson 6 - looked like a player short of match practice
Bikey 6 - Love the guy, but is going backwards, started the season as good but complacent, now becoming poor
Ben Haim - 7 Played well
Fox 6 - Defends well but no forward ball
Gudmundsson - 7 great free kick
Buyens 6 - more and more frustrating and now absent against Brighton
Jackson 7 - busy without being spectacular
Cousins 7.5
Church 7 - Lots of energy and very lively
Tucudean 6.5 - He's got something, justy not sure what
Ahearne Grant - 6.5
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson - 5 Heard he is about to leave as not rated by Bob!
Bikey - 4 After a good season he is becoming a joke. Morro far better in my opinion but Roly doesn't seem to like British players!
Ben Haim - 6 Some glimpses of class, but doesn't seem interested!
Fox - 4 Not up to this level, perhaps a loan to Div 2 will help!
Gudmundsson - 6.5 The only one with any guts, probably about to be sold to a better team!
Buyens - 6 Only here on loan and that shows with his poor tackling decisions.
Jackson - 4 Sadly passed it, perhaps will be a better player/coach.
Cousins - 5 Not one of his best games.
Church - 5 No end product.
Tucudean - 5 After flattering against Cardiff back to normal falling over.
Ahearne Grant n/a
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Not even certain that we are going to get Tony Watt now (Bob hopes to sign him - he was on the pitch before game - surely you know if he is coming here for F's sake).
Blackburn embarrased us today, playing keep ball when we were down to 10 men!
Shame on the players for such a piss poor effort!
Wilson 4
Bikey 3.5 CB's got bullied today
Ben Haim 4
Fox dreadful
Gudmundsson 6 for the goal
Buyens 4
Jackson 4
Cousins 4
Church 5
Tucudean 4
Ahearne Grant 4
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson - 4 Couldn't be bothered to stop the cross for goal no.1. Did himself no favours.
Bikey - 4 Two headers in 90 mins?
Ben Haim - 6 Unfair to say he wasn't interested. He spent most of his afternoon covering Bikey.
Fox - 5 More for effort than attainment. Rabbit caught in headlights and not aggressive enough to be a defender.
Gudmundson - 5.5 Good goal. Other set plays were appalling. Four times running he hit their first man. Chased shadows.
Buyens - 5 Dozey bastard. Did enough running but didn't tackle. Missed our only chance.
Jackson - 4 One burst into the box in the second half. Passenger.
Cousins - 4 Pasenger.
Church - 6 Had a go and was hauled down when he'd done the bloke out on the left.
Tucudean - 6 Had a go. Zero service.
Ahearne Grant - 6 Had a go. Ended up in midfield. Poor sod. Needs a loan somewhere like Wimbledon.
Gomez n/a
Pigott n/a
Wilson 4
Bikey 5
Ben Haim 6
Fox 5
Gudmundsson 6.5
Buyens 4
Jackson 5
Cousins 4
Church 5
Tucudean 4
Ahearne Grant 6
Wilson 4
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 7
Fox 5
Gudmundsson 7
Buyens 5
Jackson 5
Cousins 6
Church 5
Tucudean 4
Ahearne-Grant 5