Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Barnsley

13»

Comments

  • Hamer - 5
    Solly - 6
    Dervite - 5
    Wood -5
    Wiggins - 6.5
    Harriott - 3
    Poyet - 6.5
    Cousins - 7 MOM
    Jackson - 6.5
    Sordell - 4
    Obika - 5

    Reza 5
  • Hamer 4 - I'm a fan but he only had two things to do last night and ballsed them both up. I've seen the second goal about ten times now and I still can't work out what On earth he was doing.

    Solly 6- ok under the circs. Not remotely match fit but didn't let us down

    Dervite 6 - solid. Like him. Contract please. Will be great in league 1

    Wood 5 - going backwards. Great early in the season decision making is now shaky.

    Wiggins 5 - love him but he's not the player he was before his injury. Sad to see him crocked again. Hampered last night by having cack in front of him.

    Harriott 2 - one point for a decent two minutes before he was pulled. One more for being played out of position. Otherwise just about the most inept, confidence free display I've seen in years.

    Poyet 7 - class act but not his finest hour last night. Still head and shoulders above anything else on the pitch.

    Cousins 5 - I was at a different game to everyone else. He tried phenomenally hard but utterly hamstrung by trying to do the job of three people. Lucky not to get sent off. Good boy though. Will be great.

    Jackson 6 - solid if unremarkable.

    Sordell 2 - lazy, selfish twat of a player. Hope to never see him again.

    Obika 4. Tried hard but is like a three legged Bambi on ice. Out of position. He's a centre forward. But he's not as good as some people think he is.

    Reza 6 - tried hard. He's not a midfielder. Play him off the striker.

    Riga - 0. I just don't understand anything about that team selection or use of subs. Been a fan so far but that was bewildering.
  • Hamer 4
    Solly 8
    Dervite 6
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 8
    Cousins 8
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 3
    Obika 3
    Reza 5

    At least Sordell (presumably) can't play Friday - not that he made much effort last night!)
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 7 (looking tired now)
    Cousins 7.5 (immense)
    Jackson 5 (looking very tired now)
    Sordell 4 (just don't understand how a player with his reputation can be quite so poor)
    Obika 4 as above
    Reza 5 PLEASE PLAY THIS BLOKE UP FRONT FOR 90 MINS NOT LEFT-HALF FOR 20
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 7
    Dervite 7
    Wood 6.5
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 8
    Cousins 7.5
    Jackson 4
    Sordell 6
    Obika 7.5
    Reza 6
  • Hamer 6
    Solly 6
    Dervite 7
    Wood 6.5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7.5
    Jackson 7
    Sordell 5.5
    Obika 5
    Reza 5.5

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a
  • Hamer 5 had a moment. If thuram had done that we'd ruin him.
    Solly 6 tried, but looks skinny and a yard off
    Dervite 6.5 keeps doing the biz
    Wood 5.5 marking for first?
    Wiggins 6 - attacked well, little to do at the back
    Harriott 2 - confidence shot. Decision making poor. Boo boys not helping.
    Poyet 7 a class above
    Cousins 5 worked hard, delivered little
    Jackson 6 tried to drive us on. Didn't get many rewards.
    Sordell 3 rank. Invited the tackle when he was through.
    Obika 4 big lad, plays like he is an 8st 16 year old.

    Reza 3 would be brill if there was no opposition. Runs for balls that will be cut out rather than challenge. One shot gave me a genuine lol. The anti Yann.
  • Hamer 5 Didn't have much to do, but how does someone score from that angle Ben?
    Solly 6 Battled hard, rusty, but effective
    Dervite 6 Solid enough
    Wood 5 Went AWOL for the first. makes you realise Morrison's worth
    Wiggins 6 Another battler, cost him the rest of the season I fear.
    Harriott 2 Words fail me
    Poyet 7 Hunted down everything that was loose, just wish he would push forward with more aggression. Probably too much on such young shoulders.
    Cousins 8 MOM Surprised he didn't give up trying to play the front two in. What was the point.
    Jackson 6 Not bad, but not a Captains performance. Note the way the Barnsley players manipulated and nagged the ref until he was completely in their pocket.
    Sordell 4 Tempted to give him higher mark, but Marvin you are a striker, you are supposed to score goals and frankly you never look like you will
    Obika 5 Only marginally better than Marvin
    Reza 5 Crowd him out, he disappears, took Barnsley about 5 mins to suss this out.
  • Hamer 6
    Solly 6.5
    Dervite 7
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6.5
    Harriott 5.5
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7.5
    Jackson 7
    Sordell 5.5
    Obika 6
    Reza 5
  • Hamer 6 - Suspect re 2nd goal
    Solly 6.5 - Still a way to go till fully fit
    Dervite 6.5 - Dealt with O'Grady quite well but distribution poor at times
    Wood 6 -Ditto
    Wiggins 6.5 - Worked hard but fear that might be his season after going off after his foot was landed on by O'Grady
    Harriott 4 - Poor and missed a great chance to put us in front
    Poyet 7 - Good all round
    Cousins 7.5 - Gave everything, but please find him some shooting boots
    Jackson 6.5 - Tried hard but went missing at times
    Sordell 4.5 - Poor
    Obika 6 - Tried but was too wide most of game
    Reza 6 - Got involved

  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer - 4
    Solly - 6.5
    Dervite - 6.5
    Wood -6
    Wiggins - 6.5
    Harriott - 3.5
    Poyet - 7
    Cousins - 7.5
    Jackson - 6
    Sordell - 5
    Obika - 5
    Reza - 4.5
  • Hamer 5 - Arguably at fault to some extent for both goals
    Solly 7 - Lacked some sharpness but great to see him back.
    Dervite 7 - Steady enough
    Wood 6 – I’ve been impressed with him this season but not his best game tonight
    Wiggins 7 – Valuable to the team, hope we can get him back soon
    Harriott 4 – Awful 1st half miss summed up a poor night
    Poyet 8 (MOM) – One of the few shining lights in an increasingly disappointing season
    Cousins 7 - Has been struggling of late but better tonight.
    Jackson 6 – kept going for the whole game at least
    Sordell 5 – 1 or 2 reasonable touches but again poor anywhere near goal.
    Obika 5 - Ineffective
    Reza 5 - Ditto
  • I thought I would take a day to reflect on the game, it hasn't mad a jot of difference.

    Hamer 5 not much to do couldn't do anything for both goals
    Solly 7 - The only positive from the game
    Dervite 7 - Ok
    Wood 4 - Terrible
    Wiggins 5 - looked tied
    Harriott 1 - utter pony
    Poyet 8 - MOM
    Cousins - 7 did ok
    Jackson - 7 ditto
    Sordell - 4 Donkey
    Obika - 6 Ok
    Reza - 4 just not good enough and too lightweight for Championship
  • Hamer 5.5-
    Solly 6.5- looked steady on return
    Dervite 7- Assured
    Wood 5- Should have scored
    Wiggins 6.5
    Harriott 4- That free header was something else
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7- Looked to get forward
    Jackson 6- Good when on the ball but didn't have it enough
    Sordell 5.5- Some good, some poor
    Obika 5.5 - Didn't get much service
    Reza 6- Made some good runs

    Would Rather see one of Morro, Cort or Dervit Upfront with the way we're playing
  • Hamer 4 culpable for 2nd goal He ducked! WTF? distribution erratic
    Solly 6 good to see him back
    Dervite 6 didn't really notice him much which is usually good for a CH
    Wood 5 failed to mark his man for their first goal - elementary schoolboy error
    Wiggins 7 not error free but wears his heart on his sleeve - will be sorely missed
    Harriott no mark is appropriate he hasn't played for charlton for the last 3 home games he has been the opposition's best player - he must have something very serious over somebody to even be considered let alone selected - performances defy description
    Poyet 8 not error free but his composure and intelligence dwarf almost all his colleagues
    Cousins 8 lets his enthusiasm and frustrations take over but he is young and relatively inexperienced - much better than everyone else bar Diego
    Jackson 7 gives his all which too many of his teammates don't
    Sordell 0 another shaming of the shirt a truly despicable charlatan
    Obika 1 but only cos he's less awful than sodall - a transparent loan makeweight
    Reza 4 not very good and lightweight but enthusiastic contributed more in his first minute than sodall obika and calamity added together for the whole match

    Wilson n/a those crosses!!!!! always always 20 yards high or wide of the mark - unbelievable
    Ajdarevic n/a bone idle show pony

    Riga - you've been found out - the fix is in - relegation now clearly the plan - why else would calamity and sodall be involved? we'd have been better starting with 9 against 11 rather than have those 2 involved at all
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6.5
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 5.5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Obika 4
    Reza 5.5
  • Hamer - 4 - hesitant, looked like he ducked out of the way for the second goal
    Solly - 6.5 - good to see him back; looked like he got a bit lost at the second goal
    Dervite - 7
    Wood - 7
    Wiggins - 7.5
    Harriott - 3 - no confidence; not sure where his skill has got to; why, oh why, did he try to flick in at the near post (if that's what he was doing with that header) rather than the elementary 'back across the keeper' that he must have been taught in training?
    Poyet - 6.5 - again, too many bad passes
    Cousins - 7.5
    Jackson - 6
    Sordell - 6 - wasted possession with speculative shots but he was willing and showed skill in places
    Obika - 5
    Reza - 7 - always looking to receive the ball and tries to do something with it; yes, he's a bit lightweight but he's one of the few skilful players we have (see Ajdarevic).

  • Hamer 5
    Solly 7
    Dervite 7
    Wood. 6.5
    Wiggins 7.5
    Harriott 5
    Poyet 7.5
    Cousins 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Sordell 5.5
    Obika 6
    Reza 7

  • Hamer - 6
    Solly - 7
    Dervite - 7
    Wood - 6.5
    Wiggins - 7
    Harriott - 6
    Poyet - 7
    Cousins - 7.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Sordell - 6
    Obika - 7
    Reza - 7
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 4
    Wood 4
    Wiggins 4
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 5
    Cousins 6.5
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 2
    Obika 2
    Reza 4

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • for those at the Valley tonight your marks out of 10 please:

    Hamer 5
    Solly 8
    Dervite 4
    Wood 7
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 3
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 2
    Obika 2
    Reza 5

    Wilson 6
    Ajdarevic 8

  • Hamer - 4
    Solly - 6
    Wiggins - 6
    Dervite - 5
    Wood - 5
    Harriott - 3
    Poyet - 7
    Cousins - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Sordell - 3.5
    Obika - 3.5
    Reza - 3.5
  • Hamer 5 - Not sure what he was doing for 2nd goal
    Solly 7 - Great to have him back. One tackle in the first half proved he was 100%
    Dervite 7 - Feel comfortable when he is on the ball
    Wood 6 - Was picking up their center half for the first goal
    Wiggins 7.5 - thought he was our best player
    Harriott 4 - Would be having it ripped out of him in the changing room on a Sunday morning for his touch it is that bad
    Poyet 7 - Reads the game so well but some of his touches were a bit lazy (maybe fatigue) last night
    Cousins 6.5 - Did not get into the first half really but improved second half. Not sure he can play the furthest forward midfielder as he is not really a goal threat
    Jackson 6 - Cannot get around the park and it showed last night
    Sordell 4 - uninterested at times. Sorry most of the time.
    Obika 5 - Looked like he was going to give their RB a torrid time early on but again no end product
    Reza 6 - Looked lively when he first come on
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 7
    Dervite 5
    Wood 7
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 2
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 7
    Sordell 5
    Obika 5
    Reza 5
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6.5
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6.5
    Harriott 2 Shocking
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 8 MOTM
    Jackson 6.5
    Sordell 6
    Obika 5.5
    Reza 5.5
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6
    Poyet 7
    Harriot 4
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7.5
    Sordell 4
    Obika 4
    Reza 5
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 8
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 4
    Obika 4
    Reza 5

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a
  • Hamer 6
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 4
    Obika 4

    Reza 4
  • Hamer - 4.5: a couple of good early kick outs to Obika but at fault for both goals
    Solly - 6: understandably a bit rusty but did very well after 8 months out
    Dervite - 7: generally solid and distributed the ball well
    Wood - 5: got out-muscled for their first goal, missed a good chance and his distribution was poor throughout
    Wiggins - 7: showed some good attacking intent at times (Morgan Fox will have to step up now)
    Harriott - 4: needs to rebuild his confidence (and to play wide left). Made an absolute hash of our best chance
    Poyet - 6.5: looked a little jaded but still high quality (his ovation when subbed was one of the only bright spots of the evening)
    Cousins - 7.5: MOM - lacks a bit of finesse in attacking positions but covered a tremendous amount of ground and really tried to impose himself
    Jackson - 6: did ok and had a good effort just over in the first half
    Sordell - 4: really poor. Incapable of controlling and holding the ball and didn't even test their keeper when he had 3 or 4 yards on the centre half inside the box. A very dispiriting player
    Obika - 5: did ok in the first half and has a bit of pace and physical presence. Needs to play in the middle
    Reza -5: the match had gone away from us by the time he came on but he generally wants too much time on the ball
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 5.5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 6
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6.5
    Sordell 5
    Obika 5
    Reza 5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!