Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Barnsley

2

Comments

  • Hamer 4
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 3
    Obika 4
    Reza 5.5
  • Only two that get any recognition tonight is Solly and Poyet. The rest can go and whistle
  • Hamer 6
    Solly 7
    Dervite 6
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 5
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 5
    Obika 6
    Reza 5

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a

    Barnsley are the biggest bunch of cheats I've seen in years - disgraceful behaviour
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 7
    Dervite 7
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 7
    Harroitt 2
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sorrel 6
    Obika 6

    Reza 5
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 6
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Obika 6
    Reza 6
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 8
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 4
    Wiggins 8
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 8
    Cousins 8 MOM
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 4
    Obika 4

    Reza 4
  • Hamer 4 - not great
    Solly 7 - played well in parts but not fully fit
    Dervite 7 - did nothing wrong
    Wood 4 - slow and unsteady
    Wiggins 6 - no one in front helping but ok
    Harriott 3 - shockingly bad on the right but when switched to left side better - then subbed ?
    Poyet 6 - looked out of depth at times
    Cousins 8 - fought all game
    Jackson 3 - Not a captain. No fight, Spineless
    Sordell 6 - not the worst but not great
    Obika 3 - very poor
    Reza 2 - being generous
  • Hamer 4
    Solly 6
    Dervite 5
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 5
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 6
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 4
    Obika 4
    Reza 5
  • Hamer - 6 Kicked well in the first half, could have had a couple of assists if Obika knew what to do once he brought the ball down. Might have been at fault for the second goal, still not sure what the hell happened

    Solly - 6 Struggled more than usual, understandable given how little he's played recently

    Dervite - 7.5 They couldn't get past him. In a way it makes it more unforgivable that we decided to stick Wood on Mvoto instead of him. Stepped out well adn was one of our most creative threats, which is a very sad thought.

    Wood - 5 Looked like he was trying really hard not to fall over 100% of the time. Made such a bollocks of his free header you'd think Stephen Dawson (allegedly) had had a word

    Wiggins - 6.5 Ran well, defended sharply, zero end product

    Harriott - 3 I never give players a 3, but Harriott was irredeemably awful. He failed in basic stuff like controlling gentle passes and managed to mess up some of our clearest openings. Utterly, utterly atroicous

    Poyet - 6.5 Broke down their attacks and passed well but needed to take charge and run at Barnsley. The rare occasion he did they parted for him. Possibly tired but needs to take the initiative a little more

    Cousins - 8 Did everything he could. Ran with the ball, tackled, cajoled, slipped through decent passes that were comically wasted by our strikers, won headers, worked so hard. Can't believe he didn't get a free kick at the end. MOTM

    Jackson - 6 Tidy but too quiet. Someone needed to help Cousins in that midfield and a player with his experience should have been the one to step up

    Sordell - 4 Wilfully wasted the ball whenever challenged. Attempted step-overs when under no pressure for reasons that escape me. When through on goal was essentially tackled by a bollard. Watching him play is almost unbearable

    Obika - 5 Was great at beating his man and trapping the ball in the first half but never created anything. Went quiet in the second half and should have been played central with Sordell subbed and possibly sacrificed to some kind of Pagan god. Didn't get the most out of him

    Reza - 5 Lightweight. Ran a bit and obviously had the pace to cause trouble but seemed happy to float around the middle rather than impose himself. Frustrating

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a
  • Hamer 6 - nothing he could do with either goal.
    Solly 7 amazing how he runs the game from RB.
    Dervite 5 crap ball to Hamer created the situation for their second.
    Wood 5 50p head
    Wiggins 7 made a couple of decent runs and crosses, good to have two decent fullbacks on together
    Harriott 3 I hate low marks but he was awful. Unfair maybe as Riga put him on the wrong side, he was clearly frustrated.
    Poyet 7.5 battled very well and he can dribble so well.
    Cousins 6 poor first half so much better in the second
    Jackson 5 didn't do much of note.
    Sordell 4 both prefer to pass than hit the ball but this numpty dives more than Reza
    Obika 4 as above but can't control the ball.
    Reza 6.5 came on gave us a bit(tiny) more creativity unlucky to have his shot cleared off the line before Ajderavic scored.

    Ref 3 (but not an excuse for the loss)
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited April 2014
    Hamer -4- undecisive off his line -some decent kicks - 2nd goal went in because it was mis hit but was no danger elsewhere so should have been more preapred for it.
    Solly -4- Don't blame hm as not up to speed, but the only way they were going to score was from a set piece - stupid corner to give away - would have been better to let them get a cross in with their strikers outnumbered! Break s football rules but not intelleigence ones! But we play without this attribute.
    Dervite -6- Solid
    Wood - 5- Not really the problem
    Wiggins -7- Best attacking wide player
    Harriott -3- He has ability but has lost confidence and is now playing with fear -needs to go out on loan next season (if we stay up)
    Poyet -7- Not everything was great but a lot was - looked a class apart. Should have done better with free header in first half. MOTM
    Cousins -6.5 Lost his way a bit I thought but we won the midfield battle
    Jackson -6 Did ok, unlucky with shot just over bar - kept going
    Sordell -4 An intelligent striker with an ounce of composure would have bagged a hat-trick tonight in his postion
    Obika -5 Was wierd as was pretty clear the defender wasn't comfortable against him, but he was unable to utlise this!
  • Hamer 5 not sure he was at fault for 2nd, but looked bizarre
    Solly 6.5 not fully fit, but still good to have him back
    Dervite 6.5 our best CB on the pitch and one of our best attacking threats. Therein lies the problem
    Wood 5 good distribution but some mistakes
    Wiggins 7 we'll miss him. good game today
    Harriott 4 not a good day
    Poyet 7 classy
    Cousins 7.5 classy and works very hard, often overlooked next to Diego.
    Jackson 5.5
    Sordell 4 no threat
    Obika 4.5 some good stuff in first 20 minutes, but again no threat
    Reza 5.5 bit more of a threat, but easily brushed off. I'm not sure that Riga understands that the Referees Union all take an oath that they will never protect a Charlton player from fouls unless they are really bad. Putting on someone who goes down really easily when the ref was already clearly not going to protect him... oh I don't know.

    Overall I didn't think we played _that_ badly, but our inability to score will see us down.
  • Hammer----4 at fault for the first --should have come for it.
    Solly------6 ----we really need this guy.
    Dervite----6
    Wood----5---lost his man for first goal.
    Wiggins---5 ---sad but he got done and the wanker of a ref missed it---dont think he will be back this season
    Harriet-----3 ---generous at that awful from a pro footballer---just go.
    Poyet-----7 ---everywhere sadly we wont see him next year to good for us.
    Cousins---7
    jackson----6
    Sordell-----4 never let him wear our shit again---piss off.
    Obika------4 STAND UP YOU TWAT

    Reza---4 never a midfield player


    JR-----------------2 your worst game from start to finish

    we dont deserve to be at this level we stink.
  • Hamer 4
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 2
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 6
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 3
    Obika 4
    Reza 5

  • A worrying performance after the Brighton shambles. Let's hope we havent lost our nerve.

    Hamer 5 Nervous. Should have organised better for their first. Second? Not sure what happened there, fluke, but embarrassing for the keeper
    Solly 6 Rusty I would like to have seen Wilson on in front of him
    Dervite 6 Turning into our best central defender
    Wood 5.5 Out muscled for the first by their brute of a centre half. Very predictable if delivery even half decent.
    Wiggins 6.5 He is slowly getting back to his best but it now looks like that is on hold. I hope it's not too serious. Poor players in front of him
    Harriott 4.5 Lost his confidence. Still hope he will reach the standards of Cousins and Poyet but on tonight's performance he is more like Campbell-Ryce
    Poyet - 7 tiring, couple of errors but some great forward runs and controlling moments when he changing the direction of play. I'm sure the North stand were singing, "Diego Poyet, he's better than us" (I know they weren't really)
    Cousins 8 Outstanding. Never stopped. Looked like we had a chance when he got the ball
    Jackson 6 Kept going
    Sordell 4.5 Bolton want us to play him
    Obika 4.5 Needs a Kermogant
    Reza 4.5 Not a footballer in this league. He might learn given time.

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a

  • Hamer 6
    Solly 7
    Dervite 6.5
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Obika 5
    Reza 6.5



  • Hamer 5 - done nothing wrong apart from that goal which I need to see again.
    Solly 6 good to see him back
    Dervite 6 sign him up. I really rate him.
    Wood 6 if he's on a one year, then him too. Should've scored but from the north upper, looked like he was fouled.
    Wiggins 6 I knew immediately that that was a fracture. So sorry for him. At least he will still be here next year.
    Harriott 2 awful. Confidence shot to bits but that was the chance and he just seemed scared of the ball. So much time and space. Church could've scored that!
    Poyet 7 class.
    Cousins 7.5 even better. Kept things going
    Jackson 6.5
    Sordell 5.5 first half he was good
    Obika 5.5 first half he was good.
    Reza 6 I thought things stated to happen when he came on...

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a

    Riga got it wrong. Such an important game too. Harriott shouldn't have come out for the second half.

    Ref was appalling too. However, not an excuse.
  • Hamer 5
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6.5
    Harriott 4
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 8
    Jackson 7
    Sordell 6.5
    Obika 5.5
    Reza 5

    Wilson n/a
    Ajdarevic n/a
  • CatAddick said:

    Hamer 4
    Solly 6
    Dervite 6
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 3
    Poyet 6.5
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 5
    Sordell 3
    Obika 4
    Reza 5.5

    Bang on the money Cat. Ditto above scores for me.
  • Hamer 5 Looks unsure when to come, comunication with centre backs poor, kicking variable
    Solly 6 sold performance for a return from injury.
    Dervite 5 at best
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 6 solid performance, though passing wayward.
    Harriott 4 bad game
    Poyet 5 solid
    Cousins 7 only one who performed to his ability
    Jackson 5 nothing to say
    Sordell 4 useless, hope this puts to bed any belief he is a footballer.
    Obika 4 almost same as above
    Reza 5 made only a little improvement.

    Jose 3, when he brought on Wilson for Solly he was saying I have given up on getting any thing out of this game, his other subs just reinforced this idea.

  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer 4 looked edgy all night. criminal for 2nd goal
    Solly 6
    Dervite 7
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 7.5 mom
    Harriott 2 inc+1 for not hiding but an absolute stinker!
    Poyet 6
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 6 the hardest I've seen him work
    Obika 6
    Reza 6
  • Hamer 4 how people say he's a good goalkeeper gets to me.
    solly 6.5 looked like he hadnt been away
    dervite 7 good again
    wood 5.5 pretty poor
    wiggins 6 needs to learn to use right foot and pass forward more often
    poyet 7 dependable as usual
    jackson 6 looked leggy
    cousins 8.5 best game in a cafc shirt, thought he bossed it in the middle MOM
    harriott 2 and thats being generous.a shambles
    obika 6 infuriating, on the floor more than on his feet
    sordell 6.5 thought he did well really, sad to say he's the best striking option we've got

    reza 6 should of started
  • Hamer 5

    Solly 6 rusty but so glad he's back
    Wood 5
    Dervitte 6
    Wiggins 5

    Cousins 8 mom everywhere last night and looked absolutely gutted at the end
    Poyet 8 another great game
    Jackson 4 was he playing? Time for a rest I think.
    Harriot 5 poor game but try him on the left.better when he plays there

    Sordell 5 not good but still prefer him to church
    Obika 6 don't understand all the critisicm.thought he tried last night.put him through the middle that's where
  • Hamer 5

    Solly 6 rusty but so glad he's back
    Wood 5
    Dervitte 6
    Wiggins 5

    Cousins 8 mom everywhere last night and looked absolutely gutted at the end
    Poyet 8 another great game
    Jackson 4 was he playing? Time for a rest I think.
    Harriot 5 poor game but try him on the left.better when he plays there

    Sordell 5 not good but still prefer him to church
    Obika 6 don't understand all the critisicm.thought he tried last night.put him through the middle that's where he plays/blockquote>

  • Hamer 6
    Solly 6.5
    Dervite 7.5
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 6.5
    Harriott 4.5
    Poyet 6
    Cousins 7
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 5
    Obika 5.5
    Reza 6.5
  • Hamer 4 Solely and completely to blame for their second goal. What was he thinking??!!
    Solly 7 His attitude and determination will be a real bonus as we battle against relegation.
    Dervite 6 Looked solid and composed.
    Wood 5 At fault for the first goal in not blocking his man. Not one of his better games.
    Wiggins 6 Average performance but we'll still miss him if he's out for the rest of the season.
    Harriott 4 He did a few things right, but not many! Missed a sitter of a chance to score.
    Poyet 8 A class player with skill and determination.
    Cousins 8 Had a good game. He just needs to practice his shooting!
    Jackson 7 Good performance.
    Sordell 6 Showed some skill but, for a big bloke, he is too easily knocked off the ball.
    Obika 6 Good 1st half but fairly anonymous in the 2nd. Why was he not subbed?
    Reza 7 Showed his usual skills. Provided the assist for the goal and unlucky not to score himself with a thunderous drive.

    Riga 3 I have been quite impressed with him up till now, but tonight he got it badly wrong. This was not the match to rest two of our best players - Reza and Ajdarevic. Also, Obika should have been subbed rather than Poyet.
  • Hamer 4 Solely and completely to blame for their second goal. What was he thinking??!!
    Solly 7 His attitude and determination will be a real bonus as we battle against relegation.
    Dervite 6 Looked solid and composed.
    Wood 5 At fault for the first goal in not blocking his man. Not one of his better games.
    Wiggins 6 Average performance but we'll still miss him if he's out for the rest of the season.
    Harriott 4 He did a few things right, but not many! Missed a sitter of a chance to score.
    Poyet 8 A class player with skill and determination.
    Cousins 8 Had a good game. He just needs to practice his shooting!
    Jackson 7 Good performance.
    Sordell 6 Showed some skill but, for a big bloke, he is too easily knocked off the ball.
    Obika 6 Good 1st half but fairly anonymous in the 2nd. Why was he not subbed?
    Reza 7 Showed his usual skills. Provided the assist for the goal and unlucky not to score himself with a thunderous drive.

    Riga 3 I have been quite impressed with him up till now, but tonight he got it badly wrong. This was not the match to rest two of our best players - Reza and Ajdarevic. Also, Obika should have been subbed rather than Poyet.

    This is the game I watched :-)
  • Hamer 5 - I thought his distribution was good. Cannot remember if he was to blame for the second goal
    Solly 7 - Looked good for a man who has been out all season!
    Dervite 7 - One of our many good defenders. Can actually play!
    Wood 6 - Missed a good chance early on. Thought it was harsh blaming him for Barnsley's first, Jenning's ball in was simply superb
    Wiggins 6.5 - Not sure he contributed all that much
    Harriott 2 - Couldn't do anything right but poor show from Charlton fans cheering his substitution
    Poyet 7.5 - Excellent as usual. Milked his substitution!
    Cousins 8 (MOTM) - Improved massively in recent weeks with a slight dip after Christmas. Controlled the midfield completely!
    Jackson 7.5 - Thought Jackson was excellent actually. Everything he did came off and had a good effort first half.
    Sordell 6 - Came away with the ball often in difficult times. Please play to the whistle though, that 1 on 1 was a glorious chance
    Obika 4 - Strikes me as lazy and doesn't offer anything beyond the oh-so-ridiculed Church for me
    Reza 4 - Showpony. Never gets in any decent positions.
  • Solly 6
    Dervite 7
    Wood 6
    Wiggins 7
    Harriott 3 - Played poor but, needs abit of confidence. He apologised to the fans when he was subbed. Getting on his back did not help him.
    Poyet 6
    Cousins 8.5
    Jackson 6
    Sordell 6
    Obika 4
    Reza 6.5

  • Hamer 4
    Solly 7
    Dervite 6
    Wood 5
    Wiggins 6
    Harriott 2
    Poyet 7
    Cousins 8
    Jackson 7
    Sordell 5
    Obika 5
    Reza 5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!