Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Reading

For those at the Valley this afternoon your marks out of 10 please:

Hamer
Wilson
Morrison
Dervite
Wiggins
Cousins
Poyet
Jackson
Harriott
Ajdarevic
Church

Reza

Petrucci n/a
Obika n/a
«13

Comments

  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 5
    Ajdarevic 7
    Church 5

    Reza 5
  • Hamer 7 - can't fault the man
    Wilson 4 - poor display today, wasn't quite himself. Made numerous mistakes
    Morrison 7 - showed organisation, put in a few great tackles
    Dervite 6
    Wiggins 6 - few mistakes, few good runs
    Cousins 7.5 MOTM - a lot of effort, showed passion
    Poyet 7 - wish he had a strike force to supply to
    Jackson 6 - wanted it but didn't do enough
    Harriott 6 - showed pace in parts, fell over a lot
    Ajdarevic 6 - looked tired and sloppy but does offer creativity
    Church 3 - lazy, slow, doesn't even try to win headers

    Reza 7 - energetic and got himself into the game well, just lacked a touch of quality
  • Hamer - 7
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 7
    Dervite - 7
    Wiggins - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Poyet - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Harriott - 4
    Ajdarevic - 6.5
    Church - 5

    Reza - 6
  • Hamer - 7
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 7
    Dervite - 7
    Wiggins - 6
    Cousins - 8
    Poyet - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Harriott - 6
    Ajdarevic - 5
    Church - 6

    Reza - 5
  • Hamer - 7
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 6.5
    Dervite - 6.5
    Wiggins - 6
    Cousins - 6.5
    Poyet - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Harriott - 5
    Ajdarevic - 5.5
    Church - 5

    Reza - 6

    Petrucci - 4
    Obika - 4
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7.5
    Wiggins 8 mom
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Harriott 7
    Ajdarevic 6.5 (good, but not for nearly long enough)
    Church 6

    Reza 5.5
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Devite 6
    Wiggins 5.5
    Cousins 6.5
    Poyet 6.5
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 5.5
    Adjarevic 6
    Church 5.5

    Reza 6
  • edited April 2014
    Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6.5
    Dervite 7.5
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 5.5
    Ajdarevic 5
    Church 3

    Reza 5

    Petrucci 3 (lost possession outside their box cost us the game)
    Obika 6

    Riga 5 got the team wrong,why oh why start Church and Petrucci for JJ cost us at least a point
  • C_A_F_C said:

    Hamer - 7
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 7
    Dervite - 7
    Wiggins - 6
    Cousins - 8
    Poyet - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Harriott - 6
    Ajdarevic - 5
    Church - 6

    Reza - 5

    This, exactly the game I was watching ..
  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 8
    Wiggins 7
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 3 (useless today)
    Ajdarevic 6
    Church 1(for turning up)

    Reza 5
  • Sponsored links:


  • RedChaser said:

    Riga 5 got the team wrong,why oh why start Church and Petrucci for JJ cost us at least a point

    Unfortunately Jacko probably needed a rest prior to Yeovil and Barnsley seeing he's been playing the 90mins every week of late...

    Do agree though... Petrucci wasnt great... What is it with Manchester United and Midfielders at the moment
  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 5
    Ajdarevic 7
    Church 5

    Reza 5

    My marks are identical
    Morrison mom
  • seth plum said:

    Hamer 6.5
    Wilson 7
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7.5
    Wiggins 8 mom
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Harriott 7
    Ajdarevic 6.5 (good, but not for nearly long enough)
    Church 6

    Reza 5.5

    A bit strange that he is your MOM yet seems to get the lowest score among the back four from all the other posters. Don't get me wrong I listened to the cafc player and thought he had a good game and very pleased to see you give him the highest rating.

    I must say when I look through the players marks I sometimes wonder if you all went to the same game, lol...
  • Hamer - 7
    Wilson - 6
    Morrison - 7
    Dervite - 7.5
    Wiggins - 7
    Cousins - 8
    Poyet - 8
    Jackson - 5
    Harriott - 5
    Ajdarevic - 7.5
    Church - 3 Why was he picked? What did he do?


    Reza - 7
  • Hamer 7.5
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 8
    Dervite 8.5 mom
    Wiggins 7
    Cousins 8
    Poyet 8.5
    Jackson 7
    Harriott 7
    Ajdarevic 7.5 doesn't seem able to finish a fame
    Church 6.5 lacks the physical presence to play upfront on his own

    Reza 6.5 nice touches but needs to find a position

    Petrucci n/a
    Obika n/a


  • Hamer 7 Couple of decent saves, distribution better, couple of iffy moments. He's up for a battle
    Wilson 6.5 Not his best game, but he's not the problem hear
    Morrison 6.5 Ditto move on
    Dervite 6.5 Same again
    Wiggins 7 Half a mark more than his defensive colleagues, showed a bit of nastiness, forwards don't like that
    Cousins 6 Started superbly, faded badly, look very tired
    Poyet 7 Battled hard, absolutely nothing going on in front of him
    Jackson 6 Another one that looked tired
    Harriott 5 I want him to do well, but he is just so easy to defended against
    Ajdarevic 6 Showed great promise at the start, but really only gave us 30 mins
    Church 3 His saving grace was his work rate, that's gone, I wish he would go with it. Jose is having a laugh picking this guy to play up top on his own, I am all for a bit of squad rotation provided we use footballers

    Reza 4 Did he really score on Tuesday? He never looks likely to test the keeper let alone score

    Petrucci n/a
    Obika n/a
  • Hamer- 7.5 - Couple of good saves , no chance for the goal

    Wilson- 6 - Not his best game , looked tired
    Morrison- 7-Fairly solid , poor distribution from the back at times
    Dervite-7.5 - Solid in The air
    Wiggins- 6- For every good thing he did , he seemed to undo it with a mistake , seems scared of beating players.
    Cousins-7.5- Excellent first half , faded second
    Poyet- 7.5 - Same as cousins , didn't see him much second half
    Jackson-6- Didn't do anything wrong , then again he didn't contribute much
    Harriott- 5- Seems to be going backwards since last season
    Ajdarevic-6- One of the most technically gifted players in the league , shame he can't seem to last more than a half ...
    Church-5- Didn't seem to work as much today , Bullied by Reading's back four , then again , not much to work with

    Reza- 6- Shows touched of quality , then seems to make a simple mistake
  • Hamer - 6 one of the best passers at the club, just a few errors today. Had a go at North Lower when he got stick early on for one poor punch. Blamed the sun...it's there most games Ben, get a cap!

    Wilson - 6 took a nasty whack at end of first half. Seemed less sure in 2nd

    Morrison - 8 solid performance. MOM

    Dervite - 7.5 Did well with Morrow against their front two.

    Wiggins - 5 fell apart in the 2nd half, too many poor decisions. Please just stop with the spinning around.

    Cousins - 7.5 been a little overshadowed by Diego lately, but very good today

    Poyet - 7 Composed as we have come to expect.

    Jackson - 6.5 I understand there's a lot of games & he can't play 90 every few days. Still amazed that he & JC made way ahead of Church & Harriott.

    Harriott - 4 poor. Complete waste of a game for him. Chasing shadows & added nothing.

    Ajdarevic - 6 some good touches. Wonder how good he'd be if he could get fit.

    Church - 4 awful. Spent first half running into his old teammates, trying to claim fouls. Won two headers jumping on his own. Only mention this as I get to say that Church jumped!

    Reza - 4 lightweight, poor free-kick, nothing else.
  • Hamer - 7 great save from free kick and no chance with their goal.
    Wilson - 7 steady.
    Morrison - 7 steady.
    Dervite - 7.5 reliable next to Morro.
    Wiggins - 6 sloppy at times.
    Cousins - 6 wasted out wide.
    Poyet - 7 looked the most composed on the ball.
    Jackson - 6 kept going but faded second half.
    Harriott - 5 gave the ball away far too often and lack of quality crosses.
    Ajdarevic - 6 looked knackered towards end of 1st half. Gave up running in the second half.
    Church - 4 what to say that hasn't been said a million times before. One half chance with back to goal in 1st half. Only saving grace was the lack of service to him. Managed one clearance from our own half that cleared the halfway line.

    Reza - 5 tried to get things going.
  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7.5
    Wiggins 7
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Harriott 6
    Ajdarevic 6.5
    Church 4 Effort can excuse a lot... but not everything. Just awful.

    Reza 5
  • Sponsored links:


  • This content has been removed.
  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 6
    Dervite 6
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 7.5 (MoM)
    Jackson 5
    Harriott 4
    Ajdarevic 7
    Church 3

    Reza 4
  • Hamer 7.5
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 7
    Cousins 7
    Poyet 6.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Harriott 6
    Ajdarevic 6
    Church 4

    Reza 6
  • Hamer 7.0
    Wilson 6.5
    Morrison 6.5
    Dervite 6.5
    Wiggins 6.5
    Cousins 6.0
    Poyet 7.0
    Jackson 6.0
    Harriott 5.0
    Ajdarevic 6.0
    Church 5.0

    Reza 6.0
  • Church -5
  • Hamer 7
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7 some sloppy passing
    Dervite 7.5
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 8 Works well with Poyet
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 6.5 Some nice turns and crosses and the odd duff ball.
    Ajdarevic 6
    Church 4 Got a cheer when he actually won two headers!

    Reza 5
  • Hamer - 7.5
    Wilson - 6.5
    Morrison - 7
    Dervite - 7.5
    Wiggins - 6.5
    Cousins - 7
    Poyet - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Harriott - 4
    Ajdarevic - 7
    Church - 3

    Reza - 4
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wilson 5.5
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 7
    Wiggins 6
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 6.5
    Jackson 6
    Harriott 6
    Ajdarevic 6
    Church 5

    Reza 6.5
  • Hamer 6.5
    Wilson 6
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 6.5
    Wiggins 6.5
    Cousins 6
    Poyet 7
    Jackson 7
    Harriott 5.5
    Ajderavic 5 (only wanted to play first half)
    Church 5

    Reza 5
  • Hamer 7- no chance with the goal and some excellent long range distribution
    Wilson 6- surprisingly hesitant at times
    Morrison 6-not as dominant in the air as usual
    Dervite 6.5- very assured on the ball
    Wiggins 6- some good attacking movement but then failed to execute the cross
    Cousins 5.5- good first half but when moved wide faded badly
    Poyet 7.5 (MoM)- always in control and some solid tackles
    Jackson 6- no better or worse than many others
    Harriott 4- nothing came off and he was far too easily disposessed by that munter Gunter
    Ajdarevic 5.5- If games were played with 15 minutes each way he would be magnificent. Alas in England they last 90...unlike Astrit. Unless he was injured, his inability to last even an hour is an indictment
    Church 3- he shoots as if he has a sponge tied to his foot yet traps the ball as if he has a concrete boot. Plenty of running but that is way too insufficient to make a professional footballer

    Reza 4- neat first touch...falls over a lot.

    Rega 4- curious starting line-up with Sponge up top Did he make his substitutions by drawing numbers out of a hat???
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!