Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton v Leeds - Player Marks
Comments
-
Hamer 5 at fault for 3rd, distribution poor
Wilson 6 some mistakes today, defensively, that could have led to them pouncing. Some of it was the pitch, but...
Morrison 6 was worried he was going to get sent off
Dervite 5.5
Wiggins 6.5 did well
Stewart 6.5 fantastic goal and a joy to watch him go past people. Not the full player yet, but improving
Cousins 6 solid
Jackson 7 glad he's back and in a good position.
Stephens 6.5 excellent first half, faded in 2nd when we lost our shape
Harriott 5.5 some lovely play but some bad errors. I can live with that if he is going to improve and grow in confidence
Church 7 thought he was excellent today, should have had a penalty.Excellent work for the 2nd
Yann 4 not ready to be back. I understand why CP brought him on, don't think it worked
T'ref 1 got some things right, but was so much in Leeds pocket it was a joke.
Combination of a couple of excellent shots from MacCormack, a couple of excellent saves from Kenny, bad luck and poor refereeing. Scoreline flatters Leeds.0 -
Hamer 5.5
Wilson 7
Morrison 6
Dervite 6
Wiggins 7.5
Stewart 6
Cousins 7
Jackson 7
Stephens 6.5
Harriott 6.5
Church 7
Yann 4.50 -
Hamer 5.
Wilson 6
Morrison 6
Dervite 5
Wiggins 7.5
Stewart 6.5 Terrific goal
Cousins 6
Jackson 7
Stephens 6.5
Harriott 6.5
Church 6 Missed two decent chances.
MOM was Macormack ours was Wiggins0 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 5
Morrison 6
Dervite 5
Wiggins 7
Stewart 6.5
Cousins 6
Jackson 6.5
Stephens 6,5
Harriott 6
Church 6.5
Yann 5
0 -
Hamer 4 shocking again.please drop him now
Wilson 7 didn't stop trying.
Morrison 7 played well.think he misses wood.
Dervitte 5 not one if his better games.missed wood today.
Wiggins 8 mom by far our best player today.back to his best at last.
Harriot.6 played well and he tried hard.
Cousins 6 did his job well.
Jackson 7 good to see him backed.
Stephens 7 not at his best but tried hard
Stewart 6 great day but wished he'd take the full back on instead of doubling back.
Church 3.5 enough said
0 -
Hamer 6
Wilson 7.5
Morrison 5.5
Dervite 5.5
Wiggins 8.5
Stewart7.5
Cousins 6.5
Jackson 8
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7.5
Yann 5
0 -
Hamer 4.5
Wilson 6.5
Morrison 6.5
Dervite 5
Wiggins 8
Stewart 5.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 7.5
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 6.5
Yann 50 -
Hamer 4 needs to get a grip in a crowded penalty area.
Wilson 6 looked tired today
Morrison 6
Dervite 5.5 woeful distribution as usual
Wiggins 7
Stewart 5 great goal but worse player on the pitch with just one trick- cut inside and blast it with right foot.
Cousins 7
Jackson 7
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7
Yann 4 fat, unfit and no use at all at the moment
T'ref 10 MOM great hat-trick and dominated the afternoon. Can enjoy his drive back to Yorkshire.0 -
Hamer 6 lost point for 3rd
Wilson 7 need to stop hoofing
Morrison 7 ditto
Dervite 6.5
Wiggins 7.5
Stewart 5.5
Cousins 7 why are we ignoring him when he comes to collect? Even marked he can move and pass. Our Makalele.
Jackson 7 lost half for 3rd
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7
Yann 4 Did he touch the ball in half hour? Not remotely fit.0 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 5
Morrison 6
Dervite 6
Wiggins 7
Stewart 5.5
Cousins 6
Jackson 6.5
Stephens 6
Harriott 6.5
Church 7
Yann 5
Ref Stroud c**t
0 - Sponsored links:
-
Hamer 6
Wilson 7
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 7.5 (CAFC MoM).
Stewart 5 (would be 3 apart from the goal: how many over hit crosses ?)
Cousins 5
Jackson 5 (thought he was at fault for the 3rd)
Stephens 7
Harriott 6 (cut out the showboating)
Church 7
Yann 4 (game passed him by, still unfit ?)
T'ref 2 (for turning up and going ahead with the game.....git).0 -
Hamer 5.5
Wilson 6
Morrison 6
Dervite 5
Wiggins 7
Stewart 5 (1 for the goal)
Cousins 7
Jackson 7
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7
Ref 10 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 6
Morrison 7
Dervite 6
Wiggins 7.5
Stewart 7.5
Cousins 7.5
Jackson 8
Stephens 8
Harriott 6
Church 7.5
Kermogant 4
0 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 6
Morrison 6
Dervite 5
Wiggins 8 (MOM)
Stewart 7
Cousins 7
Jackson 7
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7.5
Yann 5
Ref 9 - Three great assists. A goal would have rounded off an excellent performance for Leeds. Just behind McCormack as Leeds best player.
0 -
Hamer 5.5
Wilson 6.5
Morrison 7
Dervite 6.5
Wiggins 7.5
Stewart 6.5
Cousins 7
Jackson 8
Stephens 7
Harriott 6.5
Church 7
Yann 6
T'ref 30 -
Hamer - 6 was solid really hate some fans who get on his back
Wilson - 6.5 quality stuff, made a couple of poor passes back to hamer but i think it was more the ground than anything else. Was at fault for the 1st goal however due to not tracking his runner.
Morrison - 6 decent but not quite as good as when he is next to wood
Dervite - 6 did nothing wrong
Wiggins - 7.5 really well played today took control of the game
Stewart - 6.5 stunning goal and caused some trouble but a few overhit crosses, the wind didnt hel
Cousins - 7 good stuff as usual, solid and stable with a great eye for a pass
Jackson - 7 captains performance and should have got a penalty as one of the leeds defenders had him in an obvious headlock inside the box! Lino didnt have the gut s to give it i think
Stephens - 7 not at his best but great work ethic trying his all for the team
Harriott - 7 was so close to scoring 3 times in the first half, great player but due to his age hasnt got the stamina to last on the pitch. Great first half - denied by a top form keeper
Church - 8 MOTM set up a goal constantly worked was so close to scoring but the ball didnt seem to want too go in - great saves by the keeper
Yann - 5 nice to see him fit but didnt have a lot of impact on the game
T'ref - -9 as a qualified ref myself, I apologize for his performance on behalf of the FA. Chris Powell was too polite to say anything but quite frankly he cost us at least 1 point and as he gave leeds two goals they shouldn't have had and stopped Charlton from having 2 pens arguably 3 points but he wasn't the full reason why we lost.0 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 6
Morrison 6
Dervite 5
Wiggins 7
Stewart 6
Cousins 6
Jackson 7.5
Stephens 6
Harriott 5
Church 7
Yann 4
T'ref 20 -
Hamer - 5
Wilson - 6
Morrison- 6
Dervite - 6
Wiggins -7.5
Stewart -6.5
Cousins - 7
Jackson - 7
Stephens - 6.5
Harriott - 5
Church - 7
Yann - 50 -
Hamer 6
Wilson 6
Wiggins 7.5
Morrison 6
Devite 5.5
Stewart 6
Jackson 7
Stephens 7
Cousins 6
Harriot 6
Church 6.5
Kermorgant 5
0 -
Hamer - 6
Wilson - 6.5
Morrison - 7
Dervite - 6
Wiggins - 8
Stewart - 7
Cousins - 5.5
Jackson - 7
Stephens - 7
Harriott - 6
Church - 8
Yann - 5
T'ref - ****!
0 - Sponsored links:
-
Hamer - 3 weak for the third, mess of the wall for the fourth.
Wilson - 7 busy and solid
Morrison - 5 poor for their first
Dervite - 6 bit slow but good bringing it out
Wiggins - 7 some class touches
Stewart - 6 stunning goal needs a bit more concentration
Cousins - 7 super, always available
Jackson - 7 back and better than ever
Stephens - 7 excellent, works well with Jordan
Harriott - 6.5 looked a threat. Head dropped after he was cheated
Church - 8.5 completely changed my opinion, excellent
T'ref - quite simply a cheat0 -
Hamer 5 - disappointing after 5 good games
Wilson 6.5 - still not missing Solly
Morrison 6.5
Dervite 5 - bring back Wood ASAP
Wiggins 8 - class act
Stewart 5.5 - all marks for the goal alone
Cousins 7 - gone be hard keeping him
Jackson 8 - mom
Stephens 7 - much improved
Harriott 6
Church 6.5
Yann 4 - not been fit all season
Ref minus 10 you northern monkey!!!
0 -
Hamer 4 - I just don't know about him. He has bags of confidence when he is slagging his back 4 off, not so much when it comes to doing anything in his own box.
Wilson 5 - Seen better days in a Charlton shirt
Morrison 5 - Was genuinely worried he might end up going off today, far too mouthy, that foul looked nasty too, possibly even malicious.
Dervite 6 - Could have been better but was a lot better than many are suggesting.
Wiggins 8.5 MOM - never stopped, played fantastically.
Stewart 5 - Awful apart from a scorcher of a goal.
Cousins 6 - Did Ok, nothing special, expect the general extra point from people because he is academy, but in reality didn't cover himself in too much glory.
Jackson 7.5 - Good to have him back, whatever people say about him, he pops up in the right places and scores goals.
Stephens 6.5 - At times good, at times poor.
Harriott 6 - Didn't do loads, haven't seen a replay of the penalty but at least he tried well
Church 8 - Our second goal was a fantastic effort from Church. The shot he had that was saved by Paddy Kenny, was one of the best connections of the ball I've seen and he did well to direct it goalward at all, other than that he worked very well.0 -
Hamer - 5 poor choices all game
Wilson- 6 a couple of lapses. Evident that Leeds kicked out every time, instead of trying to pass back to their keeper. Lawrie was nearly caught a couple of times.
Morrison - 6 not as sure as recent games. Slow in making decisions coming out of defence
Dervite - 5 usually a decent passer, not so yesterday
Wiggins - 7.5 Decent game, got forward well, great ball in for Church's volley
Stewart - 6 beautiful volley, has great feet but awful crossing yesterday
Cousins - 6 didn't really stand out as much as he has in some games. Up against some old pros, but will learn from that
Jackson - 6 took goal well, tried hard to push his teammates on
Stephens - 6 lower level than recent performances, still put himself about
Harriott - 5 a couple of decent attempts, but lacks defensively to support Wilson
Church - 7 unlucky with the great volley which, unfortunately, was straight at Kenny. Great play to beat his two markers twice before sliding across to JJ for the 2nd.
Yann - 4 not fit and didn't add anything when he came on
T'ref - t'wat
0 -
Hamer 5.5 Could have done better for third. Hesitant at times
Wilson 5.5 Not his best game today, but still had his moments. Seemed determined to execute the dodgy pass back on a wet pitch routine.
Morrison 6 Leave the ref alone Michael he wasn't worth arguing with. Mind you that booking pissed me off so I could see your point.
Dervite 5.5 OK seemed a bit lost at times
Wiggins 6.5 Getting back to his best
Stewart 6.5 Seems unsure whether he is crossing or shooting. Stick to the shooting your rather good at it, besides there is nobody in the middle to cross to anyway.
Cousins 6.5 Comfortable in the conditions, but never a dominate presence.
Jackson 7 A real Jacko performance. Works his nuts off and has that happy nack of being in the right place at the right time
Stephens 6 Tried hard not really his type of pitch. We may have seen the best of him at the valley until the pitch drys out in the spring
Harriott 5.5 Seemed very light weight
Church 7 His movement at times was superb, only a superb save from Kenny denied him the goal his performance deserved. One moment in first half his movement took out two defenders to open up a shot at goal for Harriott.
Yann 5 Can't bring myself to give him less, but did he really come on?
T'ref Dear Keith
I want you to study a video of the match you officiated last Saturday at the Valley between Charlton Athletic and Leeds United.
I applaud your booking of of the Leeds goal keeper for time wasting mid way through the first half and demanding that one of the northern cheats removed himself from the pitch to receive treatment for an injury he clearly didn't have.
Then it all went terrible wrong. You see Leeds weren't deterred, they persisted with the time wasting injury routine, the back injury to their number 5 in front of the East stand Lino just before we equalised was so blantent it was embarrassing. Loved the way you fell for the rolling around after a fair tackle from our Mr Morrisson. I think you will see why he was a tad upset with you.
Second half you really did up yor game, thought you did everything you could to help Leeds. Penalty? Probably, but let's be honest nobody could accuse you of been a homer, you are allowed to give penalties to the home side. The push in the back Mr Jackson received inside the box in the second half, would, in rugby union, have earned the culprit a 10 min spell in the sin bin, if not a straight red. Keith mate, it's dangerous and certainly a penalty to push someone like that when they are in the air.
Any way enough is enough just watch the video. Oh and by the way are you by any chance a mate of that nice Mr D'Urso? Thought so. You see it's obvious because like him you think it's all about you, even down to the late pitch inspection routine, nice touch, not quite in Andy's class though. He would have got us all in side then called it off, you need to work on this part of your game.
Please don't come back soon
Loads of Love
Disappointed of SE7
0 -
Hamer 5
Wilson 6
Morrison 6.5
Dervite 5
Wiggins 9
Stewart 7
Cousins 6
Jackson 6.5
Stephens 7
Harriott 5
Church 70 -
Kermorgant 40
-
Hamer 4 It really is feast or famine with Ben,sometimes I think he should be considered for England,other times like yesterday I think I'd like to see Alnwick given a game.
Wilson 5 Thought he struggled a bit
Morrison 5 Didn't look commanding for me yesterday.He lost the challenge which led to the first goal.
Dervite 5 Like Morrison lost the battle with Blackstock / Mccormack.Hope Wood returns soon.
Wiggins 8 Our best player
Stewart 7 an extra point for a special goal
Cousins 7 Tried hard
Jackson 7.5 Jacko looks a lot better in CM extra point for goal but loses his half point for not beating Mccormack for the 3rd goal.
Stephens 7 Looked bright at times I hope we can keep him.
Harriott 6 Loses a point for the penalty,seems to have been sussed out,but still showed moments of quality
Church 8 Extra point for the assist for the second,look busy all game
Kermorgant Good to see him back think it would be unfair to give him a mark as he does not look match fit.0 -
Hamer 4
Wilson 6
Morrison 5
Dervite 5
Wiggins 8
Stewart 5
Cousins 6
Jackson 7
Stephens 7
Harriott 6
Church 7
Yann 4
T'ref 00 -
o_Ogreenwichred68 said:
Church 3.5 enough said
0
