Hamer - 5 didnt do much apart from let in 4 goals Solly - 6 feel sorry for him, he is too good for this team Cort - 5 won a few headers but made too many mistakes Morrison -5 not good enough today, took too long when on the ball and gave it away for their 2nd goal Kerkar - 6 did well out of position Wilson - 6 did well shame he got injured Pritchard - 6 not great but i have seen him play worse Dervite - 5 didnt do much at all Jackson - he cant keep up with these championship teams, sorry jacko Hulse - 7 extra point for the goal, good finish, apart from that not great Wright Phillips - 4 and i might be being generous! completely anonymous, didnt do a thing. i know people will say to get off his back but he wasnt at the races at all today Stephens - 5 also needs to improve
Hamer 4 poor gaame, at fault for the third goal at least. Solly 5 his worst performance Cort 5 Morrison 4 what was that pass, who was supposed to mark Woodgate. Kerkar 6 gave them most trouble Wilson 5 Pritchard 5 Dervite 4 did he play Jackson 4 Hulse 5 Wright Phillips 5 Stephens 5
Hamer 5.5 Solly. 6 Cort. 6 Morrison 5.5 Kerkar 5.5 Wilson 5.5 Pritchard 4 Can't believe the high marks, looked out of his depth Dervite 5.5 Jackson 4.5 Hulse 6.5 Wright Phillips 5 Stephens 4.5
Hamer 5.5 Extra half point for a couple of good saves late on in no mans land for 3rd goal Solly 6 Usual steady self Cort 4.5 Partly at fault for 3 of the goals his worst performance in a Charlton shirt Morrison 5 Gave the vital second goal away to hand the momentum to Boro Kerkar 5 Kept going but didnt get to the deadball line and wasted cross after cross Wilson 6 Played well first half until the injury curse struck yet again Pritchard 5 Seemed to get weaker and brushed off the ball as the game went on not a RM Dervite 5 Looked very average today and asked to move to a 3rd CB when chasing the game Jackson 4 No way a LM in this league so off the pace again Hulse 7 MOM Put himself about all match and got us off to the perfect start to prove his doubters wrong about his confidence Wright Phillips 5 Tried hard but failed to establish himself in the game Stephens 5.5 Always tries to create something got stuck in but let himself down with couple of loose passes
Hamer 5.5 not his best, lots of ranting at the defence (fair enough I suppose) Solly 5.5 worked hard as usual but not up to his usual self Cort 5 Morrison 5 dreadful mistake for 2nd goal, unlike him, normally he's solid Kerkar 6 better in 1st half, was frustrated in 2nd half by his woeful crosses Wilson 6.5 showed passion and commitment, shame he was injured as the first half was even Pritchard 7 worked hard all game had a part in our goal, even though he was tired and shoved around at the end still my mom Dervite 6 some good touches but too anonymous in 2nd Jackson 5 would be lower but for his free kicks and corners Hulse 6.5 worked hard, took goal well Wright Phillips 5.5 would be higher if he'd got his studs right in the first place. Stephens 5 did OK but needed more than he showed
Hamer 5 - Not his best game although he pulled off a decent save at the end. He was left exposed and to be fair all Boro's goals were good goals, but could have been avoided. Solly 6 - Battled well Cort 5 - Not his best game. Morrison 6 - Made a bad pass, but i think it was his first off game for a long time. Kerkar 5 - Not sure why he was put in at LB. Did ok, but looks better going forward. Loan player for LB please. Wilson 7 - I'm gutted he went off. Played well and looked really dangerous then pulls up injured. Pritchard 5.5 - Would have been 7 had Powell left him in CM, but i thought he was uncomfortable in the second half when moved out wide. Dervite 6.5 - Looked good in that defensive midfield role. If he can play LB then maybe start him there on Tuesday. Jackson 5 - Did ok but pace severely lets him down as the game goes on. Hulse 6.5 - Extra .5 for the goal, but for a tall lad he doesn't jump for the ball which is odd. Wright Phillips 6 - Got pushed around a lot by their defenders and looked frustrated. Stephens 6 - Unbalanced the midfield for me. A couple of decent tackles and passes, but when he came on our midfield looked exposed.
Hamer - 6. No chance with the goals Solly - 6. The goals were no fault of his but looked less certain than usual Cort - 4. The worst performance I have seen him deliver. Let Woodgate free for their first and later missed a glorious chance to equalise. Very shaky Morrison - 4. Not just the pass but what were he and Cort doing for their third goal??? It was like they were strangers today. Kerkar - 6. For a player out of position he did quite well at left back. Oddly enough, for a winger, it was his crossing that let him down Wilson - 6. Was looking settled in right midfield until crocked. Pritchard - 5. Plenty of energy but outpaced and too easily brushed off the ball. Superb pass for the goal earns him an extra .5 Dervite -5.5. For a big guy I expected more ball-winning in our midfield but not a bad performance. Jackson - 3.5. This score hurts me as JJ is such a great guy BUT this reflects his performance today. He was anonymous and his lack of pace is being cruelly exposed. Hulse - 6.5. Took his goal well and battled hard Wright Phillips - 6. Gave everything but his first touch was unsure and he never looked like scoring Stephens - 4. Picked the ball up off the back four and then played it sideways!! Far too slow moving it forward and rarely got close enough to Hulse or BWP to provide support.
Hamer 6 Solly 6 Cort 5 Worst game for us. Morrison 5 Kerkar 4 Crap on the wing normally even worse at left back. Wilson 5 Pritchard 4 Dervite 5 Jackson 4 Not good enough for the wing not good enough for the middle. Hulse 6 Wright Phillips 5 Too light weight, looks out of his depth in this league. Stephens 3 Who ever it was that turned down 2m plus for him needs shooting.
Powell 1 more strange decisions, it's ok his still learning though.
Hamer - 6.5 at fault for one of the goals but was solid though he must improve his positioning for corners, still flaps alarmingly
Solly - 7.5 solid apart from a couple of errors
Cort - 7 again solid one of our more consistent players but is a bit slow for this division
Morrison - 6.5 uncharacteristic error
Kerkar - 7 flattered to deceive in 2nd half but to be fair out of position, some good crosses in, but has annoying fault of taking too many touches so easy to predict what he will do
Wilson - 6 not his finest game No 4 Friend deserved Red Card for crocking him
Pritchard - 4 yes has a great engine but sadly is now out of his depth in this league but in a better formation is better so may improve with a. midfield general alongside him and directing him
Dervite - 4 invisible, moans too much and made little impression and made many costly errors
Jackson - 5.5 midfield is the main problem and Jacko must be part of that problem, injury prone and slow
Hulse - 7.5 great goal showed why we need more class in the side
Wright Phillips - 4 poor game easy to mark unable to dominate defenders and out of his depth
Stephens - 7 came on and gave us a better shape but had little impact
Cook n/a Haynes n/a
Sir Chris Powell - 5 players out of position and 442 didn't work was strangely subdued throughout game. Why not blood some youngsters for a change
Hamer- 6 couple of good saves, let down by his defence again. Maybe should have done better with 3rd. Solly- 6.5 can't do it on his own Cort- 5 worst game for us Morrison- 5.5 ditto Kerkar- 4 not good enough for the Championship, sums us up at the moment- Lighweight. Can't cross to save his life, can see why no one else wanted him. Not a fan. Wilson- 6.5 his injury majorly disrupted us, hope he has back soon. Pritchard- 6 better in CM, should have scored. Least he doesn't hide and can't accuse him of not being committed. Dervite- 6 better in the first half, works hard. Jackson- 5 poor Hulse- 7 well taken goal. Probably our MOM. Wright Phillips- 5 anonymous. Stephens- 4 poor again, slows the game down. Some awful passes, Villa have had a lucky escape. We're a better side without Stephens. Was not always good enough for our CM in L1, certainly not good enough in the Championship. Has potential but needs more.
Wasn't the worst performance despite the scoreline. I've probably taken expectations into account with the marks hence why Jackson has lower than the other midfielders.
Hamer 6.5 couple of decent saves when we were chasing the game. No real chance with the goals Solly 6.5 Battled away as usual. Hope we don't lose him in January Cort 6 Not quite as dominant as usual Morrison 6 as Cort Kerkar 6.5 Probably 5 for attainment 7.5 for effort in an unfamiliar position Wilson 7 Shame we lost him. Hope and pray it's not too serious Pritchard 6.5 7.5 1st half 5.5 2nd half. he is not a right sided player! Dervite 6 Good to see some physical presence but went missing a bit in the 2nd half Jackson 6 Battled away but struggled. Should have scored in the 2nd half really Hulse 6.5 Excellent finish for his goal. Faded in the 2nd half. Wright Phillips 6 Not a lot of service. I think he tries but struggles at this level Stephens 5 His reluctance to compete for a 50:50 ball created the opportunity that led to their second goal. He didn't go missing like he usually does but equally there were no incisive passes which makes him an expensive and ineffectual luxury a struggling side cannot afford in my opinion.
Comments
Solly 6.5
Cort 6.5
Morrison 6
Kerkar 7
Wilson 7
Pritchard 7.5
Dervite 7
Jackson 5
Hulse 6.5
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 4.5
Solly - 6 feel sorry for him, he is too good for this team
Cort - 5 won a few headers but made too many mistakes
Morrison -5 not good enough today, took too long when on the ball and gave it away for their 2nd goal
Kerkar - 6 did well out of position
Wilson - 6 did well shame he got injured
Pritchard - 6 not great but i have seen him play worse
Dervite - 5 didnt do much at all
Jackson - he cant keep up with these championship teams, sorry jacko
Hulse - 7 extra point for the goal, good finish, apart from that not great
Wright Phillips - 4 and i might be being generous! completely anonymous, didnt do a thing. i know people will say to get off his back but he wasnt at the races at all today
Stephens - 5 also needs to improve
Bad day all round!
Hamer 5.5
Solly 6.5
Cort 4.5
Morrison 4.5
Kerkar 5.5
Wilson 6.0
Pritchard 7.5 mom
Dervite 5.0
Jackson 4.5
Hulse 6.5
Wright Phillips 6.0
Stephens 4.0 Should be at Aston Villa.
Cook n/a
Haynes n/a
Solly 6.5
Cort 6
Morrison 5.5
Kerkar 6.5
Wilson 6
Pritchard 5.5
Dervite 6.5
Jackson 5.5
Hulse 6.5
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 5.5
Solly 7
Cort 6
Morrison 6
Kerkar 5
Wilson 7
Pritchard 4
Dervite 5
Jackson 4
Hulse 5
Wright Phillips 4
Stephens 6
Solly 6.5
Cort 5.5
Morrison 4
Kerkar 4
Wilson 6
Pritchard 6
Dervite 5
Jackson 5
Hulse 6
BWP 5
Stephens 3
Solly 5 his worst performance
Cort 5
Morrison 4 what was that pass, who was supposed to mark Woodgate.
Kerkar 6 gave them most trouble
Wilson 5
Pritchard 5
Dervite 4 did he play
Jackson 4
Hulse 5
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 5
Solly. 6
Cort. 6
Morrison 5.5
Kerkar 5.5
Wilson 5.5
Pritchard 4 Can't believe the high marks, looked out of his depth
Dervite 5.5
Jackson 4.5
Hulse 6.5
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 4.5
Hamer 6
Solly. 6
Cort. 5
Morrison 5
Kerkar 4
Wilson 4
Pritchard 6.5 mom
Dervite 5
Jackson 4.5
Hulse 5
Wright Phillips 4
Stephens 6
Solly 6
Cort 6
Morrison 6
Kerkar 4
Wilson 6
Pritchard 5
Dervite 6
Jackson 5
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 6
Solly 6
Cort 5
Morrison 4
Kerkar 6
Wilson 6
Pritchard 5
Dervite 6
Jackson 4
Hulse 6
Wright-Phillips 4
Stephens 4
Solly 6
Cort 5
Morrison 5
Kerkar 4
Wilson 5
Pritchard 5
Dervite 4
Jackson 4
Hulse 6 (extra mark for the goal)
Wright Phillips 4
Stephens 4
Almost impossible to pick a MOM from such an abject 2nd half. Last season seems a lifetime ago!
Solly 7
Cort 6
Morrison 5
Kerkar 5
Wilson 6
Pritchard 6
Dervite 6
Jackson 6
Hulse 7 Just about MoM
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 5
Solly - 7
Cort - 6
Morrison - 6
Kerkar - 5 not a left back
Wilson - 7
Pritchard - 6
Dervite - 6
Jackson - 5
Hulse - 6
Wright Phillips - 6
Stephens - 5
Solly 6 Usual steady self
Cort 4.5 Partly at fault for 3 of the goals his worst performance in a Charlton shirt
Morrison 5 Gave the vital second goal away to hand the momentum to Boro
Kerkar 5 Kept going but didnt get to the deadball line and wasted cross after cross
Wilson 6 Played well first half until the injury curse struck yet again
Pritchard 5 Seemed to get weaker and brushed off the ball as the game went on not a RM
Dervite 5 Looked very average today and asked to move to a 3rd CB when chasing the game
Jackson 4 No way a LM in this league so off the pace again
Hulse 7 MOM Put himself about all match and got us off to the perfect start to prove his doubters wrong about his confidence
Wright Phillips 5 Tried hard but failed to establish himself in the game
Stephens 5.5 Always tries to create something got stuck in but let himself down with couple of loose passes
Solly 7 mom
Cort 5
Morrison 5
Kerkar 5
Wilson 6
Pritchard 6
Dervite 5
Jackson 5
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 7
Solly 5.5 worked hard as usual but not up to his usual self
Cort 5
Morrison 5 dreadful mistake for 2nd goal, unlike him, normally he's solid
Kerkar 6 better in 1st half, was frustrated in 2nd half by his woeful crosses
Wilson 6.5 showed passion and commitment, shame he was injured as the first half was even
Pritchard 7 worked hard all game had a part in our goal, even though he was tired and shoved around at the end still my mom
Dervite 6 some good touches but too anonymous in 2nd
Jackson 5 would be lower but for his free kicks and corners
Hulse 6.5 worked hard, took goal well
Wright Phillips 5.5 would be higher if he'd got his studs right in the first place.
Stephens 5 did OK but needed more than he showed
Solly 6 - Battled well
Cort 5 - Not his best game.
Morrison 6 - Made a bad pass, but i think it was his first off game for a long time.
Kerkar 5 - Not sure why he was put in at LB. Did ok, but looks better going forward. Loan player for LB please.
Wilson 7 - I'm gutted he went off. Played well and looked really dangerous then pulls up injured.
Pritchard 5.5 - Would have been 7 had Powell left him in CM, but i thought he was uncomfortable in the second half when moved out wide.
Dervite 6.5 - Looked good in that defensive midfield role. If he can play LB then maybe start him there on Tuesday.
Jackson 5 - Did ok but pace severely lets him down as the game goes on.
Hulse 6.5 - Extra .5 for the goal, but for a tall lad he doesn't jump for the ball which is odd.
Wright Phillips 6 - Got pushed around a lot by their defenders and looked frustrated.
Stephens 6 - Unbalanced the midfield for me. A couple of decent tackles and passes, but when he came on our midfield looked exposed.
Solly 6
Cort 6
Morrison 5
Kerkar 4
Wilson 6
Pritchard 5
Dervite 6
Jackson 4
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 4
Solly - 6. The goals were no fault of his but looked less certain than usual
Cort - 4. The worst performance I have seen him deliver. Let Woodgate free for their first and later missed a glorious chance to equalise. Very shaky
Morrison - 4. Not just the pass but what were he and Cort doing for their third goal??? It was like they were strangers today.
Kerkar - 6. For a player out of position he did quite well at left back. Oddly enough, for a winger, it was his crossing that let him down
Wilson - 6. Was looking settled in right midfield until crocked.
Pritchard - 5. Plenty of energy but outpaced and too easily brushed off the ball. Superb pass for the goal earns him an extra .5
Dervite -5.5. For a big guy I expected more ball-winning in our midfield but not a bad performance.
Jackson - 3.5. This score hurts me as JJ is such a great guy BUT this reflects his performance today. He was anonymous and his lack of pace is being cruelly exposed.
Hulse - 6.5. Took his goal well and battled hard
Wright Phillips - 6. Gave everything but his first touch was unsure and he never looked like scoring
Stephens - 4. Picked the ball up off the back four and then played it sideways!! Far too slow moving it forward and rarely got close enough to Hulse or BWP to provide support.
Solly 6.5
Cort 5.5
Morrison 5
Kerkar 6
Wilson 6.5
Pritchard 5.5
Dervite 6
Jackson 4.5
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 4
Cook n/a
Haynes n/a
Solly 7
Cort 4
Morrison 4.5
Kerkar 5
Wilson 6
Pritchard 4
Dervite 5
Jackson 4
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 6
Solly 6
Cort 5 Worst game for us.
Morrison 5
Kerkar 4 Crap on the wing normally even worse at left back.
Wilson 5
Pritchard 4
Dervite 5
Jackson 4 Not good enough for the wing not good enough for the middle.
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 5 Too light weight, looks out of his depth in this league.
Stephens 3 Who ever it was that turned down 2m plus for him needs shooting.
Powell 1 more strange decisions, it's ok his still learning though.
Solly - 7.5 solid apart from a couple of errors
Cort - 7 again solid one of our more consistent players but is a bit slow for this division
Morrison - 6.5 uncharacteristic error
Kerkar - 7 flattered to deceive in 2nd half but to be fair out of position, some good crosses in, but has annoying fault of taking too many touches so easy to predict what he will do
Wilson - 6 not his finest game No 4 Friend deserved Red Card for crocking him
Pritchard - 4 yes has a great engine but sadly is now out of his depth in this league but in a better formation is better so may improve with a. midfield general alongside him and directing him
Dervite - 4 invisible, moans too much and made little impression and made many costly errors
Jackson - 5.5 midfield is the main problem and Jacko must be part of that problem, injury prone and slow
Hulse - 7.5 great goal showed why we need more class in the side
Wright Phillips - 4 poor game easy to mark unable to dominate defenders and out of his depth
Stephens - 7 came on and gave us a better shape but had little impact
Cook n/a
Haynes n/a
Sir Chris Powell - 5 players out of position and 442 didn't work was strangely subdued throughout game. Why not blood some youngsters for a change
Solly- 6.5 can't do it on his own
Cort- 5 worst game for us
Morrison- 5.5 ditto
Kerkar- 4 not good enough for the Championship, sums us up at the moment- Lighweight. Can't cross to save his life, can see why no one else wanted him. Not a fan.
Wilson- 6.5 his injury majorly disrupted us, hope he has back soon.
Pritchard- 6 better in CM, should have scored. Least he doesn't hide and can't accuse him of not being committed.
Dervite- 6 better in the first half, works hard.
Jackson- 5 poor
Hulse- 7 well taken goal. Probably our MOM.
Wright Phillips- 5 anonymous.
Stephens- 4 poor again, slows the game down. Some awful passes, Villa have had a lucky escape. We're a better side without Stephens. Was not always good enough for our CM in L1, certainly not good enough in the Championship. Has potential but needs more.
Solly 6
Cort 6
Morrison 6
Kerkar 6
Wilson 6
Pritchard 6
Dervite 6
Jackson 5.5
Hulse 4.5
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 4
Wasn't the worst performance despite the scoreline. I've probably taken expectations into account with the marks hence why Jackson has lower than the other midfielders.
Solly 6
Cort 6
Morrison 6
Kerkar 6
Wilson 5
Pritchard 7 (8 first half; 6 second half)
Dervite 7
Jackson 4
Hulse 6
Wright Phillips 5
Stephens 6
Solly 6
Cort 6
Morrison 5
Kerkar 6.5
Wilson 6
Pritchard 6
Dervite 6
Jackson 4
Hulse 5.5
Wright Phillips 4
Stephens 5
Solly 6.5
Cort 6
Morrison 5.5
Kerkar 6
Wilson 7
Pritchard 6
Dervite 6
Jackson 5
Hulse 6.5
Wright Phillips 6
Stephens 5
Cook n/a
Haynes n/a
Solly 6.5 Battled away as usual. Hope we don't lose him in January
Cort 6 Not quite as dominant as usual
Morrison 6 as Cort
Kerkar 6.5 Probably 5 for attainment 7.5 for effort in an unfamiliar position
Wilson 7 Shame we lost him. Hope and pray it's not too serious
Pritchard 6.5 7.5 1st half 5.5 2nd half. he is not a right sided player!
Dervite 6 Good to see some physical presence but went missing a bit in the 2nd half
Jackson 6 Battled away but struggled. Should have scored in the 2nd half really
Hulse 6.5 Excellent finish for his goal. Faded in the 2nd half.
Wright Phillips 6 Not a lot of service. I think he tries but struggles at this level
Stephens 5 His reluctance to compete for a 50:50 ball created the opportunity that led to their second goal. He didn't go missing like he usually does but equally there were no incisive passes which makes him an expensive and ineffectual luxury a struggling side cannot afford in my opinion.