Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Sheff U 0 - 2 Charlton - Player Ratings

edited October 2011 in General Charlton
For those at the game, half marks allowed, copy and paste the below:

Hamer -
Solly -
Morrison -
Taylor -
Wiggins -
Wagstaff -
Hollands -
Stephens -
Jackson -
Hayes -
BWP -

Kermogant -
Green (n/a) -

«1

Comments

  • Hamer 8
    Solly 9
    Morrison 9
    Taylor 9
    Wiggins 8
    Wagstaff 8
    Hollands 8
    Stephens 8
    Jackson 8
    Hayes 8
    BWP 8.5

  • edited October 2011

  • edited October 2011
    Rugby Addick - Don't usually do the subs, however he did the job required of a sub, he had an impact on the game. So what's that worth compared to the players who sweated the full 90 mins...8 ? 8.5? Dunno.
  • Ahh okay - didn't go to this one but it sounded as if he is the definition of impact sub.
  • edited October 2011
    Hamer - 7 - decent shot stopping, looked dodgy from corners
    Solly - 8.5 - solid at the back, good going forward 
    Morrison - 8.5 - won nearly everything in the air, and made a handful of good tackles MOTM
    Taylor - 7 - did the job
    Wiggins - 7 - defensively was okay, decent going forward
    Wagstaff - 6 - kept it simple, could have attacked defenders more, one awful moment where he ran it out of play with no one around him
    Hollands - 8 - good defensively, effective short passing
    Stephens - 6.5 - not bad, but didn't really notice him 
    Jackson - 7 - not one of his best performances, but wasn't bad
    Hayes - 6.5 - some nice link-up play, but touch sometimes let him down 
    BWP - 8.5 - always looked threatening

    Kermogant - 8 - won every header, scored literally seconds after coming on, and assisted BWP
    Green (n/a) - 7 - looked to take players on, crossed when he could (other than one instance when he could have squared it)
  • Hamer - 7 - Some good stops but looked a bit dodgey when corners came in.
    Solly - 8 - Very good at the back and made some great forward runs.
    Morrison - 8.5 - He was a rock, claimed absolutely everything today.MOTM
    Taylor - 6.5 - A bit quite compared to Morrison.
    Wiggins - 7.5 - Doesn't seem to tackle to much just gets in the way of crosses. Made some good crosses as well.
    Wagstaff - 6 - Poor today seems to go down too easy sometimes , didn't put many crosses in and could easily have been sent of for dissent.
    Hollands - 7.5 - Made some good tackles , his long throws don't seem to get us anywhere.
    Stephens - 6.5 - Didn't see much of him today. Good corners put in.
    Jackson - 6.5 - Seemed to be out of position quite a lot today , not sure if planned.
    Hayes - 6.5 - Didn't have many chances today , when he went off play improved, coincidence?
    BWP - 8.5 - Always looks dangerous , good goal.

    Kermogant -8 - Looked dangerous when he came on , some good touches and goal.
    Green (n/a) - 7 - Didn;t have many chances to prove himself , thought he was a bit selfish to shoot in dying minutes.
  • Hamer 7
    Solly 8
    Morrison 8
    Taylor 8
    Wiggins 8
    Wagstaff 7
    Hollands 8
    Stephens 8
    Jackson 8.5
    Hayes 6
    Wright Phillips 8
    Kermorgant 8
  • Hamer 9

    Solly 9

    Morrison 9

    Taylor 7

    Wiggins 7

    Wagstaff 6

    Hollands 8

    Stephens 7

    Jackson 8

    BWP 8

    Hayes 7
  • Hamer - 7 (bit flappy, but one excellent save)
    Solly - 8.5
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8.5
    Wiggins - 9 MoTM, exceptional performance defensively and going forward
    Wagstaff - 6 - do me a favour Scott, stop moaning
    Hollands - 8.5
    Stephens - 8.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8

    Kermogant - 8.5 - Beast
    Green (n/a) -
  • Hamer - 7.5 - Made some good saves, bt a bit nervy from set pieces.
    Solly - 7.5 - Solid as usual
    Morrison - 9 - Fantastic performance. Won everything and made some key blocks/interceptions. MOTM.
    Taylor - 7.5 - Quiet but did his job.
    Wiggins - 8 - Really good game, best I've seen him play so far.
    Wagstaff - 6.5 - Pretty average.
    Hollands - 7.5 - Some great tackles and was comfortable in possession.
    Stephens - 7.5 - Comfortable with the ball and spread it well. Put in the corner also.
    Jackson - 7 - Played well, but can't remember much of him.
    Hayes - 7 - Normal Hayes style performance.
    BWP - 8 - Always looking for the ball, and his hard work led to our corner for first goal. Scored AGAIN.
    Kermogant - 8 - Possibly should start. Did really well holding up the ball and obviously scored with first touch I think.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hamer -  7.5
    Solly - 8.5
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 8.5
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 7
    Stephens - 8
    Jackson - 7.5
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8.5

    Kermogant - 8
    Green (n/a) - 7
  • Hamer - 7
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 9
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands
    - 8.5
    Stephens - 8.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 7.5
    BWP - 8.5

    Kermogant - 8
    Green
    (n/a) -
  • edited October 2011
    Hamer 8
    Solly 9
    Morrison 9
    Taylor 7
    Wiggins 8
    Wagstaff 6
    Stephens 7
    Hollands 8
    Jackson 7
    Hayes 7
    BWP 8

    KERMORGANT 9 MOTM
  • Hamer - 7.5
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 9
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 8
    Stephens - 7.5
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 6
    BWP - 8

    Kermogant - 8
    Green (n/a) - 7
  • Hamer -  7.5
    Solly - 8.5
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 8
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 7.5
    Stephens - 7.5
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 6
    BWP - 7.5

    Kermogant - 8
    Green (n/a) -
  • Hamer - 7.5
    Solly - 8.5
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 8.5
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 7.5
    Stephens - 7.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8

    Kermogant - 8.5
    Green (n/a) - looked lively

    I was pushed for MOM I'd say between Morrison and Wiggins
  • 11/10 to Sir Chris Powell for an inspired substitution
  • Hamer -  8
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 9
    Taylor - 9
    Wiggins - 9
    Wagstaff - 6
    Hollands - 8
    Stephens - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8

    Kermogant - 8
    Green (n/a) - 7
  • 11/10 to Sir Chris Powell for an inspired substitution
    two games in a row
  • Hamer - 8.5
    Solly - 8.0
    Morrison - 8.5
    Taylor - 8.0
    Wiggins - 9.0
    Wagstaff - 7.0
    Hollands - 7.0
    Stephens - 7.5
    Jackson - 8.0
    Hayes - 7.0
    BWP - 7.5

    Kermogant - 9.5
    Green (n/a) - 6.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • 11/10 to Sir Chris Powell for an inspired substitution
    two games in a row
    And some people reckon he's not tactically astute ......?
  • 9.5 rating for Kermorgan?

    That's only 0.5 less than a world class performance. By this reckoning, how will Kermit be rated when he's actually match fit .......?


    PS     Poor old Kermit. Rated 9.5 but can't be marked because he only played 25 minutes.
    No probs though ....he only scored 1 and set up the second - didn't really have any impact  on the match, did he?
    Bit like last Tuesday.

    ;o)
  • Hamer - 8
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 8
    Taylor - 7.5
    Wiggins - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 7
    Stephens - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 6.5
    BWP - 7.5

    Kermogant - 8.5 (MOTM)
    Green (n/a) - 7.5
  • Hamer - 7 Good shot stopper but looks vunerable at corners

    Solly 7.5 Another solid game, didn't get the chance to go forward as much this match.

    Morrison - 8.5 Man Mountain. Got in some very important tackles and dominant in the air.

    Taylor - 8.0 Solid. Compliments Morrison well.

    Wiggins 8.5 MOM. Exceptional performance. Good defensively and dangerous going forward. Unlucky not to score.

    Wagstaff - 7.0 Great effort as always but wasn't at his best with the ball today.

    Hollands - 8.0 Good performance in the middle. Doesn't look tired at all.

    Stephens - 7.0 Good use of the ball but the game passes him by sometimes.

    Jackson - 7.5 Some great distribution followed by some poor.

    Hayes - 7.0 Shows glimpses of brilliance with his flicks but then gives it away too often.

    BWP - 8.0 Always chasing the loose ball and ran the channels well. Deserved the goal.

     

    Kermorgant - 8.5 Very promising. He won every header and 50-50 ball against their centre halves in the last 30 mins. Takes a good free-kick too

    Green - 7.5 Very skillful player and unlucky not to score at the end.

     

  • Hamer - 7.5 made two important saves, but does have his weaknesses
    Solly - 8 another honest shift, made 2 poor forward passes in 1st half but otherwise faultless.
    Morrison - 8.5 he was everywhere
    Taylor - 7 no complaints
    Wiggins - 7.5 seems to be getting better every week
    Wagstaff - 6 a steady 1st half, but the kick into touch and subsequent yellow let him down
    Hollands -  7.5 no complaints
    Stephens - 9 made too many important contributions to list here (MOTM)
    Jackson - 8.5 a proper captain, was our 90 minute engine room
    Hayes - 7 looked good in patches but there is little link-up with BWP
    BWP - 8.5 top stuff to win the corner for our 1st goal - i'm sure he is feeling a knock in matches

    Kermogant - 8 first touch 1-0 and looks a lethal prospect
    Green (n/a) - 8 forced a great save from the keeper to deny 3-0 excellent sub.
  • I'm stunned that Wiggins is getting marks under 8, really am
  • edited October 2011
    Hamer - 7.5 Made one outstanding save in the second half and done well with what he had to do.
    Solly - 8.5 Another great display, he is really coming into his own and a vital part to our right side of the pitch.
    Morrison - 9 He won everything that came his way, dominant in the air and read the game well again. Brilliant.
    Taylor - 8.5 Similar to Morrison but wasn't as dominant in the centre, great performance nonetheless.
    Wiggins - 8.5 Fantastic game. He made challenges all game and got forward really well second half and could have scored.
    Wagstaff - 6.5 Wasn't his greatest game. First half was non-existent but the second half he was better but tried too hard in the end. 
    Hollands - 8 Box to box all game, helped the defence when needed to and supported the attack too. Done everything well.
    Stephens - 8.5 See above to Hollands, both compliment each other really well. Just slightly better than Hollands on the day.
    Jackson - 8.5 Cleared a certain goal off the line and went from there, performance to cover Wiggins and get forward into the box was brilliant.
    Hayes - 7 Played alright throughout the game, made some nice touches and movement. Kermorgant is keeping him on his toes.
    BWP - 9 Won the corner for our first and scored the second. He kept going and kept getting into those positions and his work rate was very good.

    Kermogant - 8 Changed the game when he came on and was always an option when we were defending. Played very well.
    Green - 7.5 Less than Kermorgant because he didn't score. However, he was very good when he came on and could have scored.
  • edited October 2011
    Hamer - 8
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 9
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 9
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 8
    Stephens - 8
    Jackson - 9
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8

    Kermogant - 9 (Ok he was only on for 25 minutes but well worth a 9)
    Green - 8
    Hughes - 7
  • Hamer - 8
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 9
    Taylor - 8
    Wiggins - 8
    Wagstaff - 7
    Hollands - 8
    Stephens - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 7
    BWP - 8

  • I'm stunned that Wiggins is getting marks under 8, really am
    This, I'm convinced people know nothing about the game.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!