Why bring in loan players who are no better than the players we have -and really are not here for Charlton.
Chris Powell has a great chance now to blood on some of the youngsters - rather Lose with Charlton Players of the Future in the team and getting experience than what we have now.
0
Comments
How do you know that Nouble is no better than we have... do we have that kind of striker at the right stage coming through? The last I heard we had two smaller players in Tuna and Perkins.
Bringing in youngsters on a mass-scale will shatter their confidence and suck us closer into the bottom, the way to do it is gradual and with an appropriate mix you can't just lump in half a dozen at once for their debuts.
Blood Some of the Youngsters -NOT mass -- and how good Nouble and Parrett are matters not as they will not be here next year...lets gear for 2011/12 --not help out other
How do you know they wont be? Perhaps powell seems them as potential summer signings and wants to get a good luck at them at the end of this season
Missing the point - Why not use are own Youth
cos they are not good enough/ready
We have blown it sadly ...no the new board blew it ..
Jenkinson has made a very good impact recently and is part of the team. Has proved in two positions he can do a job and is there on merit.
Solly will get opportunties before the season ends.
Waggy is already a regular
Are any others good enough or ready. Cousins and Harriot seem to have good ability and bright futures but Cousins himself has said he hopes to make more of an impact next season, maybe the same with Harriot.
Mambo, Tuna and Perkins who are young and on pro deals have barely been in any squads this season and I would guess are likely to be let go. None of them have played regularly above the BSS.
I'd like to think that Parkinson learned from this (or it could have been budget!) but last season we signed players on loan we had a realistic chance of signing on permanent deals, which we did with Sodje, Jackson and Reid. By and large they performed better, as they were playing to win a contract with us.
Looking at our current loanees, only Bessone is this sort of loan. I can't see any of Nouble, Parret, Ecclestone, Fry or Etheridge playing for us next season unless they are back here on loan. It seems a very short term policy & hope, like Parky, Powell(& the board) changes tack next season
I see it a little differently. The problem with the loans in Parky's spell in the Championship (and the end of Pardew's reign) was that most of them were terrible at football. It had nothing to do with whether we were going to sign them permanently or not.
In the coming years I can see some changes being made to the loan rules. It just seems ridiculous to me that a team can send out almost an entire mini-squad of loanees which can massively effect the outcome of several divisions. I think the other week Leicester had an entire back 5 of players they didn't own.
did you give Jonjo Shelvey your unswerving, unqualified support last season?
Nouble was brought in on loan because Anyinsah is injured and Benson is suspended for 4 matches and we needed a striker who can hold the ball up to play alonsgide BWP - as far as I know we do not have such a player in the "reserves". Fry was brought in to cover for Youga and Jackson and to allow Jackson to move into MF - again I have not heard of any young left backs at the club knocking on the door hence Jenkinson being asked to deputise recently. Parrett has been brought in because midfield is an area in which we are particularly crap - particularly on the creative side, Eheridge was brought in to cover for Worner whilst Elliott is injured - the only loan which doesn't really make sense is Esslestone but only becuase the subsequent signing of BWP has made it difficult to find a starting place for him - prior to the signing of BWP he would have slotted in well alongside Abbott or Anyinsah.
I just don't see the young players enough to be able to say whether they have any kind of a view on how they might fare in competitive games or how being thrown into competitive games too early might affect their development.